News
Arabs: Nakba bill means war
Sharon Roffe-Ofir
Published: 30.05.09, 20:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
66 Talkbacks for this article
31. Zeidan: Foback to sch. & learn some basic ME history
Zohan ,   Tel Aviv   (05.31.09)
http://www.middleeastfacts.com/middle-east-facts.php
32. As usual, threats of violence - sigh.
Zvi   (05.31.09)
The appropriate response here is to reach out to the many, many Israelis who value freedom of speech and democracy over this right-wing drivel. Doing so, they could EASILY defeat the stupid Naqba bill. Instead, the Higher Arab Monitoring Committee is (as usual) resorting to mindless hyperbole and threats of violence. So stupid. So typical of the HAMC.
33. #23: Dont be upset; it's "democracy," remember?
Noor ,   Palestine   (05.31.09)
34. Make Arabs confront their fake history
GZLives   (05.31.09)
And make sure people understand they mourn the failure of exterminating us. Let it be understood that had they murdered all of us, their "nakba" would be a garnd celebration of slaughtering the Jews. This is unacceptable for us and for anyone. Force these Arabs to confront their real history. That which included their lying brethren who led them into their miserable lives for 60 years ... enough of all of this PC crap from our Jewish hearts. It was plan and simple, black and white, their nakba is their failure to exterminate us.
35. The hell with the moon whoreshippers
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (05.31.09)
followers of a bloodthirsty Pedophile, Psychopath, Highway Robber, Murdering Lying Thief
36. Really Sarah....OK then...
Bob ,   NYC, USA   (05.31.09)
I say that Americans should be able to do that to all American Jews and deport them all back to Israel. That would include you. Still feel the same way now? 1.7% of the population isn't very large..so yes, we could, we really, really could.
37. To: No. 23
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (05.31.09)
Oh, amen, amen, amen. You can have them. Israeli Arabs: Can I help you pack?
38. Fine. . .then war it is. Christians in the US back the Jews
John ,   Houston, USA   (05.31.09)
Go ahead.. . .have your war. The Lord's chosen people will prevail.
39. "Tex-speak..."
Roy ,   USA   (05.31.09)
A colloquial Texas phrase comes to mind here: "You are either fer us, or you're agin' us!" If Arabs don't like Israel, or Jews, or Zionism, they are more than welcome to "git the hell outa Dodge!" There are plenty of so-called "Arab countries" who just "Dyin'" to abuse them!
40. #14 You are hardly a student US Civics
usa   (05.31.09)
In the USA, students are never REQUIRED to recite the pledge of allegiance. There have been many cases that have ended up in front of the United States Supreme Court, and the Court invariably decides that it is unconstitutional to mandate that any native-born citizen must recite a pledge of loyalty. (This is not, however, true for foreign-born aliens who want to become citizens. They ARE required to recite a loyalty oath.) Personally, as a US citizen, I have never been required to "demonstrate my loyalty'," aside from eating the occassional hot dog on the 4th of July and singing The Star Spangled Banner at a baseball game. So, to answer your question: No. The US is NOT fascist because our consitution protects the rights of ALL its citizens. Can the same be said for Israel if it adopts this ill-advised bill?
41. #23 Ha ha! Yes, Arabs, leave NOW, the sooner the better!
(05.31.09)
42. we are right in passing this law. i said they were not loyal
ralph   (05.31.09)
and we were leading to this by sweeping it under the carpet. either loyal israeli-arabs in a jewish land or get out of my country. no inbetween!
43. this will not become a wimar republic. leftist wrong. choose
ralph   (05.31.09)
between loyal citizens or get out.
44. This would hurt Israel.
Ron ,   L.A., USA   (05.31.09)
I understand that Israel wants uniformity. Every citizen should swear loyalty to it's country. However, these bills would hurt Israel in short/long term. These Arabs have no loyalty, love or desire to be apart of Israel. They call for Israel's destruction. The idea of a two state solution is disgusting to them. So, how is a piece of paper requiring them to say a few meaningless words going to change their minds? We jews forget that our own culture has survived tumultuous times before. For a culture to survive, all that has to happen is the believed perception of persecution. Let us not do this. Instead, let them go back to where they came from. Let them return to Syria, Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, Saudia Arabia, and all the other arab nations.
45. #23 Excellent idea!
Tahl ,   Ashdod, Israel   (05.31.09)
I agree with you. The hell with Israel. let all Israeli Arabs live in your wonderful, oil-rich Saudi Arabia. We'll even help them pack and give them sandwiches to go. Excellent idea Mohammed.
46. There is no such thing as Arab citizen of Israel: you are an
Moshe   (05.31.09)
Israeli believing in a Jewish Zionist and Democratic state or you are not an Israeli.
47. 23
zionist forever   (05.31.09)
WHAT A WONDERFUL IDEA YOU HAVE HAD Let them leave Israel go to Arabia its the ideal place for palestinians also. You have more land than people & more money than you know what to do with so take in the palestinians and Israeli arabs we can finally have peace between Israel & the arabs. That would be the ideal saudi plan and praised worldwide.
48. Nakba
Jim ,   USA   (05.31.09)
G-d says "Deuteronomy 32:35 Vengeance and retribution belong to Me; in due time their foot will slip; for the day of their calamity is near, and the things prepared are hurrying for them." and for those who celebrate Nakba, HaShem has something special for them... Ez 25:6 For thus said the Lord GOD; Because you have clapped your hands, and stamped with the feet, and rejoiced in heart with all your despite against the land of Israel; 7 Behold, therefore I will stretch out my hand on you, and will deliver you for a spoil to the heathen; and I will cut you off from the people, and I will cause you to perish out of the countries: I will destroy you; and you shall know that I am the LORD. Blessings
49. The Quran
David ,   USA   (05.31.09)
The Quran says that Israel is for the Jews. There are arabs that are denied citizenship in the countries they are born in because they are "palestinian", even though they never set foot in palestine. And their children are also denied citizenship because the country they are born in also calls them "palestinian". Arafat said his greatest weapon was the palestinian woman's womb. The arabs love the palestinians so much they want them to be refugees forever. The UN & PLO loves them so much they wouldn't let Israel build them better housing. You're only deluding yourselves by blaming Israel for the attack by Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Iraq & Yemen 60 years ago that denied you a state.
50. Saudia wants us to die, they will not allow...
Fahad Assawi ,   Palestine   (05.31.09)
All muslim countries just want us to die and kill Jews. We are not invited to any muslim country. They only supply us with arms, some money to exist.
51. You left,you lost the war...blame your ancestors
Maria ,   MD   (05.31.09)
And besides,it's not your land,Palestinians.Calling yourself,Palestinians,you should have kept your identity,Arabs.No Arab countries want you now.Celebrating Nakba means add more fuel in the fire.
52. Arabs: Nakba bill means war
Michael ,   Idaho, USA   (05.31.09)
Pass all three to honor what G-D promised Israel with HIS word to Abraham, Issac, Jacob and Moses for the glory of HIS name's sake...
53. To all the Arabs living on the Land of Israel !
Dave Ronen ,   Haifa   (05.31.09)
'This is OUR COUNTRY, OUR LAND, : We are the legitimate owner of this land. Once you are done complaining, whining, and griping about Our Flag, Our Pledge, Our Anthem, or Our Way of Life, I highly encourage you take advantage of one other great Israeli freedom :'THE RIGHT TO LEAVE'. If you aren't happy here then LEAVE. The Arab occupation has lasted long enough. We didn't force you to come here. The Land of Israel is the land of the Jews as explained at: http://xrl.us/bi5c6
54. Now is a good time for an academic research project
William ,   Israel   (05.31.09)
funded by a few anonymous benefactors to research the real land records between 1917 and 1948, to uncover Turkish and British census records showing a multitude of languages spoken in the region by Arabs (besides Arabic), and the records of illegal Arab immigration during the 1930s. If we have time and money, add research on family name origins. Arafat was from Egypt, others for sure originated elsewhere in the Middle East. Present this research to the UN and the world as proof of Pals false claims of history and land ownership. They want to play hardball...be prepared.
55. Palestinian Freudian slip
William ,   Israel   (05.31.09)
I met a woman in a children's playgroup the other day who identified herself as "Palestinian" from Hebron. Then she said she was Jordanian. Then she said Palestinian, then she said she had a "Pal....Jordanian passport". So which is it, honey? Freudian slip....you know what we already know...you're Jordanian, not Palestinian.... Tough to become another nationality simply because your leader says so...and he's a homo from Egypt, not the pedophile from Medina.
56. # 23 G-d bless you
Art Schwartz ,   IRVINE, CA.   (05.31.09)
57. Bob @ 36; I do not understand your logic.
leo ,   usa   (05.31.09)
Why do you concentrate solely on Jews? Are you implying that American Jews are disloyal and even hostile USA? If this is not what you wanted to say then do you even understand what is being discussed here?
58. #50 you're so right ! but we're not so much better
avi   (05.31.09)
I'd explain if I thought my post would not be blocked but believe me, we're not in better hands even if it looks otherwise ...
59. to #50 you right,
ghostq   (05.31.09)
if it was just Israelies and palestinians all this conflict was long gone by now but international entities r medeling without knowing that they make the situation much worse.
60. Some Arab enemies of of Israel are so easy
Frank ,   USA   (05.31.09)
You poke them and their venom just keeps coming out.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article