News
Firefighters refuse to put out blaze in Palestinian field
Efrat Weiss
Published: 01.06.09, 18:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
36 Talkbacks for this article
1. PA has money
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim,   (06.01.09)
B"H PA has money by the truckload to buy fire engines, instead maybe of SUVs, latest Mercedeses and illegal superluxus villas with multiple terraces, why don't they put out their fires themselves? Why Israel keeps on giving them free water, electricity, and now it turns out, fire fighting service, is beyond me.
2. And why should they? Ambulances have been attacked
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (06.01.09)
by arabs in the past when they were tending to injured.
3. israeli rescue and illegal sistem
ale ,   Italia   (06.01.09)
congratulation to israeli settlment world, congratulation for illegal racial sistem in west bank, congratulation to UN that don't say anything.....
4. # 1
Dee ,   haifa   (06.01.09)
isnt it enough that you steal and burn there land , and on top of that you dont wanna put the fires that you caused ????? unbeleivable arrogance ......
5. Rotten psyche
Philbert ,   Canada   (06.01.09)
As an Israeli living abroad, this idea of firefighters not doing their duty really bothers and disgusts me. I have been seeing it for a long time now but this is more evidence of Israeli society getting more and more rotten from within. The loss of basic morality and decency is a terrible thing and we have allowed ourselves to lose it. The situation is tough and for the sake of ourselves and our children we need to find a way out of this mess with the Palestinians. If we continue as is we lose ourselves completely. It shows itself in our delusion of electing an insane government (unfortunately we do not have any 'good' options) and hoping that things will get better and our perpetual individualism and corrupt society. We are in serious societal decline and have been for decades. We need to wake up, grow up and get out of our teenage years as a nation.
6. here is why!!
palestinian ,   Jerusalem   (06.01.09)
read the first 49 pages of the Quran ... it can't be more accurate ...and God made no exceptions.
7. Jewish Settlers are SCUM
David ,   IL   (06.01.09)
"Settlers are seeking to 'exact' a price on innocent Palestinians whenever the government dismantles their illegal settlements." What disgusting human beings. The World would be a better place without this fanatic settler scum.
8. Yellow Journalism, Taurine Excreta
Yoni   (06.01.09)
Settlers started the blaze? Where did this theory come from, except in a left wing, pro-arab mindset. We have seen for centuries that arabs a perfectly capable of starting fires and blaming everyone else. No sources, just conjecture. This story would not make a high school news paper in a normal society.
9. what an idiot
to # 1 ,   ben   (06.01.09)
so its ok to burn trees and fields because they are owned by Palestinians. what an idiot, i thought its the land and trees of greater Israel.
10. UNBELEIVABLE - WAR CRIME
USA   (06.01.09)
This is truly a dispicable act . God help you jews. really. god help you.
11. Re: #4 "Arrogance"
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim,   (06.01.09)
B"H Even if I stole and burned the land as you say, it would be their responsibility to put the fire out. But I didn't steal it as it was never theirs, they pretend it was, but it wasn't. It is my G-d given Holy Land. This is one. Two, we are in presence of incredible government pogroms against the Jews living on this Land in huts and mobile structures and this aspect you overlook. Why? Is destruction of Jewish homes and deportation of Jews on the Holy Land is allowed? Isn’t this racism? Fighting racism is "arrogance"?
12. I live in this area and
Israeli   (06.01.09)
I am tired of the harsh anti-"settler" rhetoric from talkbackers who live safely in distant lands, with a left wing personal agenda. They are not subject to the regular Arab attacks on innocent travellers on our roads, do not have their agricultural equipment and produce stolen by "palestinian" Arabs out of Jewish fields, and accuse us of stealing land which we have purchased years ago with good Dollars from the original Arab owners.
13. How do we know that the Pals did not set fire
Debbie ,   Toronto   (06.01.09)
to this field and then blame the residents of Judah and Samaria. It's their usual old trick,but I see from some of the talkbacks it still works
14. Re: # 9
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim,   (06.01.09)
B"H In fact I ignored this aspect because I don't believe the story as it is given. Many times in the past ynet reported so called settlers, read Jews, doing things the Torah specifically prohibits us to do, so basically I don't buy the story as it is. Looks more like a propaganda piece.
15. To all the Haters
Shu ,   Ariel ISRAEL   (06.01.09)
To all Haters of the "settlements" in the "West Bank" Do you think for a second that if Israel gave in to Arabs and gave up Judea and Samaria, the Old City, half of Jerusalem and everything else that demand for their State, that they will be satisfied???? Arabs have made no secrect that they don't want to negotiate they want all of Israel, that includes you in Haifa and Tel Aviv. If you got your wish and the West Bank was free of Jews, it wouldn't take long for them to decide that they need the Ports of Haifa for trade, why should they suffer. And if you don't give up your house then they'll start start bombing you, until the World starts to feel bad for them and you get kicked out. You don't have to look to far in History to see that giving up land to the Arabs didn't work out to well for Israel.
16. Doesn't the PA have its own fire trucks??
usa   (06.01.09)
How can there be "2 states for 2 people" if one side has to rely on the other to take care of something as basic as putting out a fire? And another thing: WHY are settlers taking out their angst on the Arabs? They should take up their grievances with the Israeli gov't and not act like vigilantes. Maybe they need to create 3 states for 3 people: the regular Jews, the Palestinians, and the fanatics?
17. #10 RE: "God help you jews:" ...He does. He will.
ur a jerk USA ,   usa   (06.01.09)
18. #15 While your argument may be true, it doesn't give settler
(06.01.09)
s the right to set fires. That is and MUST be against the law.
19. #2 - there are instances responding to Israeli-Arab towns
William ,   Israel   (06.01.09)
Nevermind in PA territories, firefighters and utility workers were attacked in some Arab towns in Israel when they responded to a call...usually faked in order to drawn the services into the town.
20. #3- Congratulations to Ale for blindly cursing others
William ,   Israel   (06.01.09)
Why do you call Israel a racist system when they single out the very groups that publicly attack and call for the death of Israel? That's not racism. Racism is what YOU exhibit in Italy when Albanian refugees arrive on your shores in makeshift boats. Racism is what Arabs exhibit when they called for exterminated Israel and the JEWS (not ALL Israelis, just the Jews). Arabs made themselves a separate group from the beginning, and exhorted their supremacy over others, including Christians. The fact that Israeli Arabs enjoy the State's benefits, including telephone, water, electrical, police, and fire services negates your tirade entirely.
21. #10 - Hahaha - now the Leftists show up
William ,   Israel   (06.01.09)
"This is truly a dispicable act " Yes, burning an unused field of thistle is truly a despicable act while rockets on civilians, or bombings at settlement gas stations are perfectly ok. I believe you are the one who truly needs help, if you can remain silent at Arab violence and racism. BTW - farmers routinely burn their fields to help rejuvenate the soil and remove over-growth.
22. THIS WILL HAPPEN UNDER TWO STATE SOLUTION ON A MORE REGULAR
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (06.01.09)
NO HELP WILL BE PROVIDED IN ANY SIMILAR CIRCUMSTANCES, EITHER BY THE ARAB SERVICES OR JEWISH ONES. THAT"S WHAT HANDING LAND TO THE ARABS MEANS .IT"S A SHAME,BUT THERE YOU ARE!
23. So? Pals steal Israeli cars with no legal follow-up.
Global Citizen ,   Israel & USA   (06.01.09)
Pals are always screaming for justice - there it is.
24. #16 - "2 States for 2 people"
William ,   Israel   (06.01.09)
Well, what the Arabs are asking for right now is a lot like this situation.... They want complete autonomy to collect taxes, make intl trips, import weapons, and decide who to arrest...but they want Israeli utilities, intl donor money, and the right to kill whomever they want. Ergo, they want Israel to put out the fires and handle issues as if they are an occupying power, but not to arrest anyone for breaking the law or terrorism.
25. Jewish Land burns under arabs!!!
Atar BenHorin ,   Kedumim, Judea   (06.01.09)
Arabs will not squat on Jewish Land. No arab can own, work, or use Jewish Land in any way. Land will burn under arabs. Firefighters' trucks will burn too, IDF escort or not. Nobody shall put out fires from under arabs!!!
26. number 18
Shu ,   Ariel   (06.01.09)
I don't condone starting fires at all. If they did, those individuals should be punished
27. IF THE PALESTINIANS WANT A STATE LET THEM PUT OUT THEIR FIRE
zionist forever   (06.02.09)
PUT OUT OUR FIRES GIVE US JOBS GIVE US ELECTRICITY GIVE US ANYTHING WE WANT LET US FIRE ROCKETS AT ISRAEL LET US SEND SUICIDE BOMBERS INTO ISRAEL LET US KIDNAP SOILDERS The palestinians want us to give them everything to make them happy but they only want to create misery for Israelis. Time to stand up to Obama, the left and the arab world in general and say the two state idea is failed and lets look at other possibilities and if the arabs want anything at all from Israel then they will have to play by our rules. Also we need to start demanding loyalty from the arabs living in Israel if they want citizenship they are going to have to choose between Israel and the arab world.
28. 7...you make a fool of yourself
(06.02.09)
29. 7 & 10 are the same person...both morons
(06.02.09)
any excuse will do to point your ugly fingers of hate and lies.
30. Another Reason The Settlers Must be Removed.
Moshe ,   TA, Israel   (06.02.09)
It is a sad day for all Israelis when even those whose very job is to save lives and protect property have been polluted with such prejudice and hatred. The settlements simply come at too high a cost to the moral fabric of our society to justify their continuation.
Next talkbacks
Back to article