News
Global ranking: Only 3 countries more dangerous than Israel
Ynet
Published: 03.06.09, 10:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
31. Outrageous
Steve ,   Brooklyn, USA   (06.03.09)
This is so outrageous. The fact that Israel ranks worse then many African nations shows an anti-Israel bias. Life is so cheap in so many African nations. Murders and atrocities take place on a daily basis in some African nations, yet Isreal ranks worse than they do? That's completely laughable. I mean take a look at day to day life in Israel... do they really think it compares to Somalia, Iraq and Afghanistan? Give me a break!
32. Israel - dangerous???
Alan ,   New Jersey USA   (06.03.09)
What a surprise! The ECONOMIST thinks Israel is more dangerous than Sudan and the Congo. Old-fashioned British anti-semitism.
33. That "Light Unto Nations'..isn't so bright!
Edithann ,   USA   (06.03.09)
Hahahahaha Denial, thy name is Israel ! TATA
34. Immigrants From All Over The World Feel Safer In Israel
Ari ,   Beit Shemesh, Israel   (06.03.09)
The fact is, #6, that thousands of immigrants from all over the world feel safer in Israel than where they came from. You cant argue with the facts. Tel Aviv has a lower crime rate and murder rate than Wellington. Israel's overall crime rate is lower than New Zealand. Israeli youth could literally walk the streets of Jerusalem or Tel Aviv at any time at night, without any adult supervision, without fear of being harmed. Judging by your comment the report is based on Israel's treatment of the Palestinians ("shocking" human rights violations) which really doesnt measure how safe Israel really is. But the facts speak for themselves. How can you seriously trust a report that places Colombia and Venezuela, two countries with the highest murder rate per capita, higher than Israel.
35. #6 The Maoris do not practice the 'Religion of Peace'
Jake   (06.03.09)
And that is why New Zealand is so much safer than Israel. And another thing, Peter don't forget. The Jews are the Maoris of the Land of Israel; they are not the Pahekas. The Jews are the indigenous people who were expelled by the Romans and returned to their native homeland. With your lambasting of Israel, you are trying to distract from the real issue, which is the fact that your ancestors from the British Isles, with no prior claim, forcibly took over and colonized New Zealand and 1000s of islands of the Pacific inhabited by the Polynesians since time immemorial.
36. Believe 'The Guardian' at your risk.
Jake   (06.03.09)
37. israel
(06.03.09)
if the arab countries surrounding israel gave up their annihilistic wars and terrorism, israel would be amongst the safest countries to live in. it is unfirtunatelly the maniac neighbors of the middle east that are the most dangerous ones to peace and stability and life in israel.
38. 8
zionist forever   (06.03.09)
I agree with you completely. I am an olleh from the UK moved to Israel nearly 10 years ago now and although Israelis at times can be some of the most annoying people in the world short of an accident or a terror attack, which doesn't happen as often as the left wing media make out then Israel is a safer place. Whenever I go back to visit relatives I can see it all around. The elderly are treated with respect, here and its safe for children to go out and play with their friends in the streets or parks. One of my good friends is also an olleh from the UK and they have a 12 year old boy who they used to drive to and from school here they let him walk home with his friends. The country its problems but I feel safer here than many western states where you would expect it to be safer.
39. Ranking by opinion
Avishai ,   USA/Israel   (06.03.09)
It really seems there are no metrics for this report. The only metric I can see is who has more stories of violence on the front page of CNN...
40. UK paper judging Israel?
Roscio ,   Rome, Italy   (06.03.09)
Please read www.thereligionofpeace.com - each day there are reports of Muslims (oh, excuse me, the Guardian would say "unknown Asian youths") who are raping, assaulting and killing Brits. Latest reports, e.g.: a 19-year-old cricket ref bludgeoned by an entire Muslim team, and another man kicked to death by a Muslim gang. Over 50% of all Christian priests and ministers in London admit to having been assaulted or beaten by Muslims. They print these ridiculous lies about Israel in order to distract their readers from the rapid decline and surrender of their own country.... in great part due to the Quisling erosion of their own society by media such as the Guardian.
41. Could it be Talmud ?
Student of history ,   Toronto   (06.03.09)
Instead of blaming it on Islam could it be attitude inculcated by Talmudic teachings?
42. A load of BS...
Proud Secular Jew ,   haaretz   (06.03.09)
I wonder what Lebanon got in the rankings...or China?...Iran?...Saudi Arabia?...Pakistan?...SRI LANKA??... Placing Israel at the bottom end of such a ranking is absolutely ridiculous. Just another sign of the world's selective morality.
43. Thieves Are Never Safe
J. Abramoff ,   Zion   (06.03.09)
Very amusing this drivel about the "native" Ashkenazim (hehehe) The undisputed facts show clearly that the zionists CAME (as in from elsewhere) to colonize and murder the native Palestinian people. That bloody campaign remains active to this day. There can never be peace without addressing this grave injustice. faced.
44. Does S.A. fit into this list!?
Gidon ,   Modiin   (06.03.09)
45. missing the point
Lisa   (06.03.09)
I think some Tbs are missing the point here- this has nothing to do with anti-semitism..... look at the reality instead. How many countries in the world need a roadblock and security checks every few hundred meters to keep their people safe- and a wall around the country? IF all the security in Israel was discontinued would you still believe you live in a safe country? A safe country is where you can be outside any time of day or night, go anywhere you choose, and be safe from attacks, terrorists, bombs- I would like to believe you when you say you feel safe and dispute this rating- good for your state of mind- but unfortunately this is not the truth. Probably some countries ended up in the wrong rank, give or take a few numbers- but it does not change the overall picture of Israel being a dangerous place to live. Nobody is saying it is Israel's fault- in case some Tbs are starting to accuse me of being anti-semitic... (been there, heard it all) this ranking does not look at who's fault it is- it is just the facts....also- what difference does it make which place Israel is at the moment? 102 , 120 or 121- it is still WAY behind the safe countries.
46. Given the list -- clear attempt to kill our tourist industry
5th generation ,   Israel   (06.03.09)
47. Perfectly safe 4 women, children in the streets after dark
CrockOv Shite ,   Modiin Israel   (06.03.09)
Never heard of anyone I know being murdered here. Back in South Africa , I do not know of anyone who does not know someone who was killed assaulted, or raped. This total BS, but what more do you expect from the Guardian
48. The article on "Dangerous Nations"
Aric Fisher ,   Chehalis, WA   (06.03.09)
This article is biased, off-base, and based completely on a false premise. It is written with the implication that Israel is dangerous because it is an "aggressor" or "trouble-making" nation! Israel has never sought to be an conqueror, or ruler of the region. All of Israel's acts have been in defensive measures, in order to protect itself from hostile nations that surround and threaten it constantly, with quotes of desiring nothing except to destroy Israel, wipe the Israelis and Jewish people off the Earth. Israel does not seek to makes itself dangerous. The source of danger is from those who would see Israel destroyed... those who actively and passively work to see Israel harassed, bombed, and terrorized into non-existence.
49. Israel safe? Says who?
Beau ,   Amarillo, TX, US   (06.03.09)
Interesting that only Israelis find Israel safe. I would call that a good example to define "bias".
50. # 7 - Peter
Eyes Wide Open ,   Australia   (06.03.09)
"It's not Israels fault" No, never is Peter. is it? Always the muslims, who you have systematically terrorised and displaced for 60yrs, no Peter it is not Israels fault at all. Reap as you sow Peter, reap as you bloody sow. Actually I'm surprised that Israel is not below Iraq, at least in Iraq someone is trying to do something about making it a better place for ALL it's people?
51. # 48 - Aric says
Eyes Wide Open ,   Australia   (06.03.09)
"Israel does not seek to make itself dangerous" WHAT? You do not think it is dangerous to threaten war with Iran?? Have you no idea what the world thinks will become of Israel should it attack Iran?? Of course Israel is a dangerous place, in fact it is the no1 threat to world peace at this time and has been for many years. Do you not think people the world over would avoid Israel like the plague because they dont want to get caught up in a nuclear strike counter strike scenario?? The fact is that more jews are leaving Israel than coming to Israel for those very reasons, the Iranian jews wont even accept $50,000 each to emigrate to Israel, now that tells you something about Israel doesnt it?? You sir are deluded beyond any measure of reason, the last paragraph of your comment is glaring evidence of this.
52. #6 Grab what land?
Zohan ,   Tel Aviv   (06.04.09)
I suggest you go back to school, learn some history before you open your gap. http://www.middleeastfacts.com/middle-east-facts.php
53. Global ranking bull
Peter ,   Montreal Canada   (06.04.09)
one word for that pile of garbage: Biased
54. "Eyes wide open", Australia
Tahl ,   Ashdod, Israel   (06.04.09)
A few minor corrections to your points, if I may. "You do not think it is dangerous to threaten war with Iran??" - Who threatens war? Israel only calls for the peaceful divestment of Iran from its nuclear capabilities. If anything, it is Iran which calls for the destruction and "wiping off the map" of Israel. "Of course Israel is a dangerous place, in fact it is the no1 threat to world peace" - No, Iran is. It is Iran and the Arabs who do not accept Israel, not the other way around. Only senseless Israel-haters believe this nonsense. "Do you not think people the world over would avoid Israel like the plague because they dont want to get caught up in a nuclear strike counter strike scenario?" - No, such people do so simply because they hate Israel. "more jews are leaving Israel than coming to Israel for those very reasons" - The world is big and open. Those who leave Israel do so for the very same reasons you or your ancestors left their home country for Australia. "the Iranian jews wont even accept $50,000 each to emigrate to Israel" - The Iranian Jews CAN'T emigrate to Israel, Iran won't let them, or threaten their families. Do you really think they can voice their own opinion freely there? "You sir are deluded beyond any measure of reason" - An exact assessment of yourself.
55. North Korea?
Robert M. Stockmann ,   Oosterhout, NL   (06.04.09)
I would say the most dangerous country is the one doing some serious nuke stuff. the article should have been titled "the most iniquitous countries", with two category's : - the iniquity meter for governments - the iniquity meter for citizenry
56. Israel is the Most Dangerous Country
Novus Ordo Seclorum ,   Gandwanaland   (06.04.09)
The last colonial master on Earth can only be the most dangerous country. Look around the planet, there are no more colonies or apartheid except in Israel.
57. My children small children can walk to school by themselves
L ,   Israel   (06.04.09)
here whereas in the US (yes, we are olim) I wouldn't DREAM of it. When I tell my family and friends back in the States that everyone here sends their littles out (mine are 6 yrs, 8 yrs) to school to walk by themselves, they just don't comprehend it. The rule in this town is that children under 9 wait at the crosswalks and any adult coming along will hold the child's hand to take them across. Many adults will even go out of their way if there aren't so many parents about to cross a late child especially. My children are wonderfully safe here, thank G-d. I feel safe here. I leave my front door open for fresh air and don't worry about leaving it open when I'm not in the room. It was definitely NOT like that in the US. What a nonsense report!
58. Of course the occupier is safe!
Steve ,   Australia   (06.04.09)
That's because it's your soldiers making life unsafe for others. Just because you're safe, we knew that all along, but your victims the Palestinians are far from safe.
59. Ash-dod is a Dud
Eyes Wide Open ,   Australia   (06.04.09)
In Iran today, the country’s Jewish minority unanimously rejected cash offers from supporters of the state of Israel to leave Iran and move to Israel. The Israeli government promised to provide a package of housing and jobs for the twenty-five-thousand Iranian Jews. A special fund created by Israel supporters promised a ten-thousand-dollar cash award for any Iranian Jew who moved to Israel. The Society of Iranian Jews dismissed this move as a bribe. Iran's sole Jewish member of parliament, Morris Motamed, said the offer was insulting to Jewish Iranians. Instead of taking the pro-Israel group up on its offer, the community of Iranian Jews instead took a loyalty pledge to their home country of Iran. Iran's Jewish population has dwindled from around eighty-thousand at the time of the 1979 Islamic revolution. But, it remains the largest of any Middle Eastern country apart from Israel. Jews have lived in Iran since at least 700 B-C
60. 50 "eyes open wide" can't read
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (06.04.09)
the name is MIKE, not peter. and i speak as the husband of an israeli arab christian, who holds the same assment i wrote about, that it is the MUSLIMS that wreak misery upon everyone in israel, arab and jew alike. as an arab, realizing the freedom and liberty provided by the jewish state sort of makes one understand the contrast between real bigoted terrorists who have genocidal aims with the blessing of civilized humanity that is provided here. you should wean yourself from propaganda and go with the truth (unless you are happy in your self-deceptive ignorance, which seems entirely likely).
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article