Business
Israelis to clear mines in Turkey?
Doron Peskin
Published: 03.06.09, 12:26
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
21 Talkbacks for this article
1. we do anything for money
doda   (06.03.09)
why would israelis clean up turkeys mess? the are not our friends, they are openly antisemite, jews have been threatened in their country, ... let them pay their friends to this cleaning up. we should not be their whore
2. just prove that turks need Israelies for money only
ghostq   (06.03.09)
they don't realy like Israelies.
3. We should replant them in turkish
jason white ,   afula,israel   (06.03.09)
population areas. We do not need the turkeys!
4. Israeli companies, but who will the workers be?
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (06.03.09)
Chinese? Thais? Will the managers be Israeli but the workers from elsewhere?
5. A clear test
Arie ,   BaGolan   (06.03.09)
If the Turks cancel this agreement, they will only be following the Obama lead - whereby he declared he is not obligated to any agreements he did not personally sign! Our tourists should begin looking at this and see if Turkey is really an Islamist state they want to visit and spend their money? Israel spends more money in Turkey and on Turkish goods than the reverse. It is a clear test
6. Why would Turkey use an Israeli company when it has NATO?
Berk ,   Istanbul   (06.03.09)
The NATO Maintenance and Supply Agency (NAMSA) is specialised in large scale mine clearance. Turkey is going to contract NAMSA to do the job as stated by the Turkish Chief of the General Staff. Which begs me to ask...where does Ynet get its news from in Turkey? Official channels or speculators?
7. #3 Jason White where does all this hatred come from?
Berk ,   Istanbul   (06.03.09)
Turkey and Israel are still officially allies the last time I checked. So why would you suggest the mass murder of Turks? Are you perhaps armenian or greek? But then again even they have forgotten the past and are after reconciliation! Grow up and educate yourself. Perhaps start by learning the true dictates of juidaism. And remember he Torah orders you not to prejudge people!
8. #4 Dorothy You Hit Nail On The Head
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (06.03.09)
The mine-clearers will be Thai or african Slaves,oops I mean "workers" and the managers sitting behind Plasma screens drinking coffee will be Israelis.Me a Freier ? Anyhow,let the Turks clear up their own mess.
9. # 4Dorothy Is No Fool
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (06.03.09)
10. This is not going to take place.
(06.03.09)
It was a proposition by Erdogan as he apparently made a deal with an Israeli firm behind close doors. There is nothing that Erdogan could not do for money and he has 19 files for fraud and corruption waiting in court. However, the area which will be cleaned off mines is Syrian-Turkish border, and most Turkish people and opposition parties fiercely oppose to the idea that this job would be done by a foreign company. Furthermore, Erdogan also proposed that after cleaning this area it will be hired to another Israeli company to do organic farming. The area is about twice as large as whole of Cyprus meaning it's huge, tens of times of Israel. And, the whole battle between Erdogan and Turkish opposition over this is the hottest debate in Turkey now. See, Erdogan is a friend of money, it looks like he made a secret deal and got his own share through a bribe, that's why he is pressing so hard to make Turkish people and Turkish secular left wing opposition party(they are very patriotic too), and nationalist oppostion to accept this deal. It seems far too unlikely though, millions of Turks are against the idea that the land, especially border land, to be hired to a foreign company. The job to clean the mines for Israel is not going to happen for sure. Under pressure by opposition, Erdogan's party removed that option from the proposition.
11. To talkbackers
(06.03.09)
If you love Israel and if you want Israel to earn money you should be backing this proposition made by Erdogan. Israeli companies could earn billions from this job. And, it is all thanks to Erdogan whom yoy hate to your guts. I too dislike Erdogan and his policies very much. And, I am very much against this proposition. I do not agree with the idea that my dear wonderful country Turkiye's border land to be worked by a foreign company. This is Turkish land, it belongs to Turks and should be worked by the Turks. It will eventually be that way. It is just Erdogan trying to make money in secret deals but this time he really got it wrong by proposing the border land to be hired to foreign company, this will never happen. Turkish people will never let that.
12. Moving a single mine from Turkish Borders is High Treason
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (06.03.09)
13. #7, Berk, not to worry
Jake   (06.04.09)
Turkey, Turks, and Turkic peoples have been and can be good friends to Israel and the Jewish people. Just remember to vaccinate yourselves against whatever illness Erdogan and his Party caught the last time they toured around Arabia.
14. #11 The land lease is probably ...
Zvi   (06.04.09)
... intended to make sure that the mine-clearing company has a very strong incentive to completely clear out the mines, because it will be using the land itself for 44 years afterward. In Europe, for decades after World War II, people were still getting killed by old WWII mines and bombs. The Israeli company will (one hopes) have the incentive and the ability to handle any mines that are discovered after the initial mine-clearing effort is completed. So in other words, I think that the 44-year lease was probably something offered by the Turkish government as an incentive to whichever company won the bid, rather than something requested by the Israeli company.
15. To #7 The turks are not our friends!
jason white ,   afula,israel   (06.04.09)
Read what your p.m. said during Operation Cast Lead. They are tilting towards the syrians politically. You should grow up and remember judging people based on current events is not prejudging. The armenians,greeks and kurds have not forgotten the past.
16. to #12 funny I thought you like your neighbour Syria.
ghostq   (06.04.09)
17. AKP of Erdogan and Freemasons in Turkey frieds of Israel!
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (06.04.09)
But Turkish nation is NOT a FRIED of ISRAEL, Israel is enemy of All nations including Jews except for Zionists. Zionism is not a simple ideology of Nationalism(I would respect, despite I may be in opposite side, to Israeli nationalism) Zionism is a RELIGION(and also an ideology as any religious belief) different than common Jewish belief Zionism is behind almost all conspirarcies,including latest mine removing attempt. This is first step of a plan with further stages to INVADE TURKEY buy enemy forces including US and EUROPEAN forces. Turkey should plant more mines along IRAQ_TURKEY borderline instead of removing mines. That is cheapest defence precaution, despite not a percet solution. Removing a single mine from Turkish borders is A HIGH TREASON and anyone who removed, signed a decree or take part any propoganda which was initiated by civilian agents of CIA and Mossad in Turkey, shall be, one day tried before Turkish courts and will be HANGED for high treason. That is inevitable fate of them.
18. TO #17 TAYFUN
DAVID ,   HERZLIA,ISRAEL   (06.04.09)
WOW !!!!, WHAT ARE YOU TAKING? , ARE YOU DRINKING THE STUFF, SMOKING IT ?, INHALING IT? , INJECTING IT?, SNIFFING...... YOU NEED TO BE EXAMINED BY A QUALIFIED DOCTOR... WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU, DO YOU SUFFER FROM PARANOIA????
19. #14
(06.04.09)
Zvi, I understand your point. But, one has to double check deals if Erdogan is involved. Erdogan is the guy who supported Iraqi war, thanks to Turkish left wing opposition and nationalist opposition Turkey refused to collaborate with the US on Iraqi invasion in 2003. Then a few years back, Erdogan did some secret talks and unofficial deals with Sami Ofer while Ofer was already under corruption isues in Israel. There are far too many examples of Erdogan's way of dealing things. There are many huge corruption scandals which involves Erdogan himself, his party members, his family and his businesses. He is a man of money and would not hesitate to do anything to get more cash. Olmert may look like an angl next to him in terms of corrution. He wouldn't arrange a bid without already speaking with possible winners for his own gain.
20. #7 Jason White
Berk ,   Istanbul   (06.05.09)
Alot of people said alot of things during operation cast lead. Your closest ally such as the US said negative things about Cast Lead. Famous jewish people also criticized Israel about Cast Lead...Are they all enemies of the State of Israel? Can't friends voice different opinions? Can't two individuals who belong to two different faiths be friends? You are prejudging and it is people like you who cause more comotion than peace.
21. To #17- Tayfun where have you been educated? La La land?
Ibrahim ,   Istanbul   (06.05.09)
Turkey and Israel are allies by Bilateral treaty. Go and research the meaning of the term "ally". We have no space for conspiracy theories and/or rhetoric which is border line antisemetism. It is people like you that cause harm to Turkey's international relations. Your counterparts in Israel do just the same on the other side. Us Turks and the Jewish peoples have had cordial relations for in excess of 600 years. I don't think we will have any problems today due to afew fundamentalists on both sides. Go read the Turkish Governments White Paper on International Relations, especially the section on Israeli-Turkish relations. And observe how close the ties are between the two states.
Back to article