News
Halutz: Sometimes you just have to 'go crazy'
Tal Rabinovsky
Published: 12.07.09, 13:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
7 Talkbacks for this article
1. there is no point to cry over spiled milk
ghostq   (07.12.09)
you did much better in Cast Lead.
2. I have another theory for ur failure in 2006
Marco ,   Spain   (07.12.09)
How about Hezbollah's Guts and the lack of it in the IDF!
3. #2 ,you are right ,I think the same.All these crap analysis
George ,   Canada   (07.12.09)
is just like pouring water from one backet to another back and forth.
4. Israel
Johnny   (07.12.09)
Either quietly or not so quietly, has won every war. Israel is a light to other nations. One of Israel's heroes is worth thousands of her enemies. Muslems' thirst for revenge to give them back their lost pride, will only bring about more war, more hatred, and the crumbling of their nations. Israel, you are loved by many many christians. We know the truth.
5. The “detterence” of Hezbollah
Ron B. ,   Lod   (07.12.09)
In the wake of the 2006 war, the following facts have become clear: First, Hezbollah, which represented itself as the “defender of Lebanon,” turned out to be its destroyer, due to the extensive devastation it brought down on the heads of the Lebanese people in the course of the war. Second, Hezbollah’s deterrent charm was dispelled. The war made it clear that the organization could no longer carry out military operations against Israel along the Lebanese-Israeli border and expect Israel to refrain from retaliating. Third, Hezbollah was perceived more and more as a Shi‘i organization serving Iranian interests. More at : http://xrl.us/beee8c
6. eiland's comments
alexi   (07.12.09)
Eiland comments are quite accurate. Olmert had no idea on what he was doing and what he wanted, he is into illusions and deceptions and can never ever be a part of a security team.He was a sick joke and israelis including the peace surrender team at haaretz should realize it. The real surprise is halutz. People say he was an excellent pilot and air force man. Well he is absolutely lousy general with little understanding of ground forces and because of him and air force general will never again be appointed chief of staff. Barak was right, absolutely right that the ground soldier made up for the generals sitting on their asses and letting olmert and halutz screw it up with no operation goals and no stomach for war.halutz was incompetent as judged by winograd by not introducing a massive ground action instead of an olmert led 8000 troop insertion which got chewed up at bint jbeil. What shmucks!And Kaplinsly, he was paralysed. He was brought in like sharon to counter. he sat there and took orders from our awol gutless crook olmert. The whole group-olmert, peretz, halutz, kaplinsky stink to high heaven. No one wants to hear from this idiot halutz. He says go crazy.... you have to think clearly and have a plan and not go crazy. He's a moron like sholmert and sharon was almost senile when he appointed him.
7. Going to war wasnt the problem it was handling it
zionist forever   (07.13.09)
Deciding to go to war was never the problem it was the decissions made by Olmert, Pretz & Halutz to try micromange the war from their offices and ignore the commanders in the field. Halutz was convinced he could win the thing by air alone despite the fact the infantry kept saying give us more men. It wasn't until the final days that Halutrz admitted air power wasn't going to win it and gave them more men. Everything the air & ground forces did the politicians tried to dictate and told them all we know better so you just be good boys and girls and follow orders we give you. There was also lack of coordintion so supplies were not getting through and thanks to over a decade of anual budget cuts the military they were not ready for anything other than running around the streets of Gaza. Training for reserves was virtually non existent and so they got out of shape and forgot skills that they are supposed to keep fresh through regular training. The army hadn't bought enough body armour .. why waste money on protection for reserves who won't need it unless there is a major call up? The army would buy a tank but to save money they wouldn't buy systems to go on those shiny new tanks which protect from anti tank rockets. Then Livni proudly sogned 1701 just when the army was starting to get their act together. The thing was a disaster in every possible way. To make it worse neither Olmert, Livni, Peretz, Halutz or even the new president elect Peres all snubbed the one year memorial service for the dead soldiers.
Back to article