News
Israeli patient: We'll sue Romania for damages
Daniel Edelson
Published: 21.07.09, 13:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. How very very sad
(07.21.09)
These women will go to any lengths to have a child. The Haredim will go to any lengths, it seems, to get rid of them.
2. Its the Romanian victims...
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (07.21.09)
that should be suing your a$$ for exploitation.
3. romanian clinic
dan guina ,   jerusalem,IL   (07.21.09)
Sure,sue them,how could they dare to aplly their law in their country.To us ?
4. Romanians complaining of Israelis being like in Auschwitzhtt
DS ,   KA   (07.21.09)
Ironic that of all people and of all places, ROMANIA should complain of JEWISH doctors being like the Nazis in Auschwitz. Please go to my blog, ISRAEL TRUTH TIMES, and read the entry DID YOU HEAR ABOUT THIS LATEST ATROCITY, at : http://israeltruthtimes.blogspot.com/2009/06/did-you-hear-about-this-latest-atrocity.html You will see that the ROMANIAN doctors are the ones benefiting from Auschwitz and other death camps. Passing the blame to the Jews, how easy!
5. #1
DS ,   KA   (07.21.09)
That is pure slander. Do you have any idea how much Chareidim love their children? SHAME ON YOU.
6. to #5 really so what kind of financial back
ghostq   (07.21.09)
round do they have in order to bring up so many children, in very warm shelltered inviorment, they don't rais their own children they r counting on their other children that grow up since then to rais them.
7. what ??
xolv ,   buc, romania   (07.21.09)
Btw, how are criminals (especially palestinians) treated in israel ?? They are invited to tea ?? "We didn't know we were doing something illegal," " What ??? Really? You're playing the victim for 2 ths years now. Start being responsible for once! You are using human beings for your own personal gain and you didn't know you were doing something wrong ??
8. Romania
Moe ,   USA   (07.21.09)
Why this clinic was not doing this service in Israel?l
9. criminals
Ilana   (07.21.09)
come in various degrees of crime severity. Innocent women, on a table with her legs open deserves privacy and not a bunch of bullies coming in to look and laugh. Disgusting behaviour. No excuses will make it any better. And in any case, the argument that "you do it too" does not make a wrong a right. Even though the assumption to begin with is incorrect. It is good to know that we need to keep this country of ours very carefully as NOTHING has changed since WW11. It is a good reminderand the reactions are as well a good reminder.
10. #9 Ilana: Playing the victim again are we?
(07.21.09)
You should be ashamed of yourself and of your people. Exploitation of poor women is lower than scum. May be that army commander should have whipped your a$$ and taught you some manners.
11. I was there you were not!!!
Grateful Father ,   Israel   (07.21.09)
# 1, If you are not a parent you have no idea how valuable it is to have one. Indeed, some people LIKE MYSELF, have gone to great lengths to experience the joy of parenthood. I have nothing but praise for the SABYC Medical Center in Bucharest and for the Israeli doctors who helped me and my spouse become parents. If it was not for their work we would not have experienced the joy of our beautiful baby. How dare you #1 pass judgment on people who you do not know and their life burdens and sacrifices which you ignore. You are a top notch fool. By the way, most couples I saw there were not Haredi at all but secular. Please, if you do not know what you are talking about; keep your opinions to yourself. #2 You are also a fool Sarah as you seem to ignore the fact that your great New York City, has a large number of fertility clinics who are definitely more a cash making business than the SABYC ever has been. #7 You have no idea how your economy has benefited by the operation of clinics like this one. Air fare, hotel stays, restaurants, etc. you take responsibility for your actions and admit that your police acted with abusive force. To all, I find it very suspicious that well reputed Israeli reproduction doctors would be operating in Romania, a country with a history of anti-Semitism, without having their clinic completely legal and properly licensed. I am more prone to believe that they were set up by some change in Romanian, legal loophole. More criminal here is the police’s treatment of the people they arrested. I am truly saddened by these events as this means other couples who were hoping to become parents will probably continue being childless until they find another such clinic. I am even more saddened, if all the allegations are true, that the Israeli government allows its citizens, to be in harm’s way but not legalizing egg donations within Israel. In a children loving culture such as the Israeli, couples with fertility problems should be allowed to have these options within Israel to avoid being under anyone else’s law’s and possible anti-Semitic brutality. I know many beautiful children have come to the world and brought much joy to their parents thanks to these doctors and others like them in Israel, New York City and many other places in the world.
12. Ilana
Elisabetha   (07.21.09)
You are so right. Many people in many countries are criminals. Israel included. Claiming Israel does it too is stupid for a few reasons: 1. It does NOT 2. As you said, if it did, why do people think it is wrong when Israel does it, but right when others do it back? Stupid illogical logic. The criminal in court says, "but he did it too, so let me free!" I don't think so. Ilana, thanks for your logic!! I love your talkbacks. Especially when backed by all sorts of proof and info. I now love Israel. Romania is backwards and full of bullies from the farm! (red necks) Usually a silent voice, Betty
13. romanian police
joseph ,   nj usa   (07.21.09)
Its the same as the police do to the haredim in Israel
14. YOU KNOW CHAREIDIM SO WELL?
DS ,   KA   (07.21.09)
15. XOLV is a Victim
Andrei ,   Romania   (07.21.09)
XOLV - let me tell you something: for 2000 years we dont "play" being the victim. Let me tell you something else... 2000 years ago Romanians did NOT exist. Nor were the people living in today Romania Christian! Even Christianity is a Jewish product. Not a Romanian one. Go down a tuica down your fat a..s!
16. Exploition of Romanian women?
Amber ,   USA   (07.22.09)
There have been suggestions of “exploitation of Romanian young, poor woman.” Well then I have to ask, why are these woman becoming egg donors; what is the Romanian government doing to help their poor and needy citizens? Very little it would seem. Of course, another option for them is to become call girls (prostitutes,) which runs ramped in Romania. At least in Bucharest (where the clinic in mention is located) all one has to do is look up and see the many billboards advertising call girls, which pictures young woman. It is obvious these woman are in dire need of money, i.e., poor. Is that not exploitation, not to mention being a prostitute puts someone at high risk health wise.
17. Antisemitism ?
nicolas ,   Tg mures , Romania   (07.22.09)
"children loving culture such as the Israeli," ? How about palestinian children killed this winter with phosphorus bomb ?.As about romanian antisemitism take time and go better deeper in history of Romanian communism and discover the fact that majority of communist elites were jew people They killed in early stages of communism dozens thousand of my own people , especially intellectuality unaligned to communist party.
18. Ugly Betty
nicolas ,   Tg mures , Romania   (07.22.09)
Usually a silent voice, Betty ? in fact a stupid one Your "superior" attitude reflect in fact your inherit attitude regarding other races and cultures
19. nicolas
Timothy   (07.22.09)
I just cannot understand what you are saying! I don't get your message. I realize it is against Betty though ,but your point is either incomprehensible or really far out in space and disconnected. ???
20. nic
Judah   (07.22.09)
She seems very nice and intelligent. She has a great attitude towards some cultures and races. Your sentences are hard to understand but to use arguments like "your stupid voice" is childish and just proves Betty's point exactly, which should not be what you wanted, but is what you got!! lol.
21. re
nicolas ,   Tg mures , Romania   (07.22.09)
Maybe she is nice and intelligent but I used stupid arguments like "your stupid voice" in response to stupid arguments like : Romania is backwards and full of bullies from the farm! (red necks)
22. I see
Judah   (07.22.09)
so then because you got insulted or mad at what she said you reverted to the same type of low response. You should have said something like, generalizing is not right, while there may be some red necks or even many red necks in Romania there are also many who are not. Just as there may be some criminals in Israels, there are many who are not. It is more convincing. Generalizing is not nice. FOr anyone.
23. way too much
Noah ,   Haifa Israel   (07.27.09)
helloooo people! dont u think its way too much comparing Auswitz with all of its horoors to a bunch of israeli grabbers whom happen to be doctos in this case? so what? the romanian ladies needed the money, and for the israelies it was conveniable it happens all around the world ! it just came to sunlight now with romanians and israelies.... for how long was this clinic functioning? and noone said a word till now????
Back to article