Jewish Scene
Rabbi: Nazareth Illit must be Judaized
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 27.07.09, 09:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
31 Talkbacks for this article
1. not arab but muslims, they got no bussiness
ghostq   (07.27.09)
to be in the city of Nazarath only chritians and jews r allowed.
2. What a moron, Palestine is Arab
Nour ,   Palestine   (07.27.09)
3. It all starts with Prayer
Galut ,   Selah   (07.27.09)
With out Gods Help ... you will have only a shell that will fall apart....
4. the entire biblical israel needs to be taken back!
(07.27.09)
5. Waste of resources to settle territories; we need Jews
Reb L. Yell ,   Carmiel, Israel   (07.27.09)
in the Galilee, where we are losing ground, yet there is no opposition or limit to settling.
6. ...""Judaize"....
ale ,   Italia   (07.27.09)
moral word in settlers world.... fantastic for theese moral orthodox heroes of modern apartheid.... medias give space and visibility to rabbi "the judaizer" and kfar tapuah and kiryat arba heroes... HESDER YESHIVA AND STUDENTS in danger for judaize..... congratulations for yuor moral community...with settlers , heroes, rabbis, hesder and medias...all in same direction... to judaize....... moral word in moral rabbi mouth, on moral newspapers....
7. this is no way to peace
marko ,   Tel Aviv   (07.27.09)
this is nt the way there to be peace only more blood shed and hatred
8. to #2 worng palestin is Jorden,
ghostq   (07.27.09)
80% of jorden r palis anyway so go joine your brothers there.
9. to #6 he isn't a setler he is orthodox big difference,
ghostq   (07.27.09)
and nazerath should be Chritian and not controll by muslims that have no historical reason for being there in the first place.
10. Nice...after 61 years..and still no success
Indigenous ,   Nablus, Palestine   (07.27.09)
I mean...if you cannot fill the area that you conquered in 1948..what will you do with all of us..we learned the lesson..we will not leave our land..and we will make our best to live on..and not to die in it! Be logical..and pragmatic..the partition plan is what you based your declaration of independence, and what the PLO used in 1988 to declare its peace initiative..so do not waste your money on Nazareth, it is on the Palestinian side.
11. Judaizing Nazareth
Joe ,   Israel   (07.27.09)
To what audience is Rabbi Lior addressing his call to "Judaize" Nazareth? Only Religious Jews? Shame on him! What kind of an example is Hebron that after thirty years has barely 1000 Jews.
12. to ale, Italia
Michael ,   Jerusalem   (07.27.09)
don't interfere with matters that are stranger to you. Stay in Italia and don't speak about things you don't maybe cannot understand. Israel has a 3000 years history that is far far from you.
13. to #2: If 'Palestine' is Arab...
Racoon ,   Switzerland   (07.27.09)
...then Israel is Jewish. And so all Arabs must go. Understood?
14. It does not need 'judaization'...
Racoon ,   Switzerland   (07.27.09)
...since the Land of Israel, including Yehuda, Shomron and Aza, are the God-given land to the Jews and therefore has been Jewish for more than 3'000 years. Israel IS Jewish!!
15. #13 Clarification
Nour ,   Palestine   (07.27.09)
No buddy, you're not catching. Palestine from Sea to Sea (original uncolonized Palestine) is Arab. Meaning Yafa, Haifa, Aka, Led, Nasra, Bir El Sabe, Asqalan, Tarsheeha, etc. It's all Arab. Denying this is denying history. The Nakba doesn't change a thing. Palestine is Arab. Now shut that Rabi of yours' mouth before it gets real ugly in Nazareth (Nasra).
16. #15 lol nazarath belomg to Chritians and jews
ghostq   (07.27.09)
arab muslems have no place there, since 90% of the palis r muslims than, nop, funny but the UN already declared it as Israel teritory in 1947 that would mean you will break international law. and thats is the true palis way, if you can break international law and have no respect for it or any other law, than so can Israel witch leads to more setelments. truth hurts. doesn't it.
17. to Michael , Jerusalem an hero
ale ,   Italia   (07.27.09)
dear hero michael...are u 3000old?... are u stronger than me....i suppose, are u so...old....
18. Upper Nazareth is Jewish as is
Avraham   (07.27.09)
There are no Jews living in Nazareth (original city), why should Arabs live in the Upper Nazareth?
19. #14 - myths
P ,   Philadelphia   (07.27.09)
"God gave it to me" is about as meaningful as "The Tooth Fairy gave it to me". Relying on these ridiculous myths makes you ridiculous as well.
20. JESUSALEN
cristian ,   bs as arg   (07.27.09)
I know jewish people were chasing and murdered by jesusĀ“name after his cruxifiction but I was born in 1980 and I read that jesus taught the truth and love .I recognized the dark past but I think my generation has nothing to be with others generations a long time ago so I love you jewish people as christ had done it,shalom alejem.
21. don't listen to that uneducated nour
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (07.27.09)
she lives in her fantasy world where islamic men ruin the lives and land of everything they touch. no wonder nobody likes them. which is why there are plenty of arabs who love israel and despise the rubbish this nour eats for breakfast.
22. All believers of Abraham's G_D should have aright
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, USA   (07.27.09)
2000 years ago there was no Muslims or Christian and even some Jewish ways have changed. The Jews from that time and before have many decedents, most may be Jewish but some are now Muslims or Christians.
23. as if Hebron wasn't enough
charicleia ,   USA   (07.28.09)
aha: now we go after Christian communities after fooling ourselves that Jewish 'settlement' in hostile Hebron is a viable lifelong achievement. wake up. wake up. and please, send these rabbis to common sense school, and esp on tact and diplomacy. they just embarrass us all.
24. rabbi is rightist, standing right to G-d
observer   (07.28.09)
but G-d told him you can't Judaize what has been already Judaized. The rabbi is right, but Liar.
25. Another Kobi Nahshoni special
Shlomo Silverstein ,   Maale Adumim, Israel   (07.28.09)
Well done. Another YNET "special" by Kobi Nahshoni - chief self hating Jew journalist. Incitement is his greatest weapon.
26. To P and ale (and Nour) here are some facts
Daniel ,   Formerly Israel   (07.28.09)
You guys ar right, that whole "God gave me the land five thousand (not three thousand) years ago"' argument is pathetic; I mean seriously pathetic. But so by the way is Nour's "I live here so it's mine" argument. Here are the facts: According to the earliest records we can trust, the Romans' the land belonged to the Jews about 100 B.C., that's why they called it Judea. Then they came and conquered it became their's. Two ceturies later they had a nasty disagreement with the Jews and kicked them out and, in a psychological attack renamed it after the Jews worst historical enemies; Except their scholars misread the hebrew F for a P (an easy mistake) and misread the vowel sounds (another easy mistake since vowels aren't written out in semitic scripts) So instead of naming it after the Philistines they named it after the "Palistines", thus we get Palestina, which the Romans pased to their decendants the Byzantines three hundred years later. The Byzantines lost it to the Arabs five hundred years after that and it became theirs They fixed the little Roman naming mistake, ahd they moved a lot of their people there, but that didn't make it any more (or less) theirs. They lost it briefly to the crusaders in the twelfth century, regained it, then lost it to the turks four hundred years later. After WWI the Turks lost it to trhe British (who stubbornly reinstituted the Roman screwup of nomenclature) . The Jews then purchased it from the British but Britain, after Arab Pressure, de to leave ninety percent of it to the Arabs anyway and leave the jews with ten percent, but that ten perl icent (partition Palestine) belonged to the Jews. The Jews then proceeded to conquer another fifteen percent (incidentally all in defensive wars) so under international law, and I mean reality-based law, not the intelectual B.S. they cook up in the Hague, all the territory currently occupied by Israel belongs to Israel regardless of who lives there, who used to live there, ohom God promised it and when. Any questions?
27. to #26 that's what I am saying all along it's the
ghostq   (07.28.09)
British fault. even in crussaid times in the year 1189 the British king Richard the lion heart slaughterd so many jews in jerusalem many fled, so it's the Brits fault, Israel sould sue the Brits for Historical assults.
28. msg of hate - no comparison between Nazareth and Hebron
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (07.28.09)
Just like his conterparts in Hamas, he is spreading a msg of hate, intolerence and racial descrimination. Unless you have to be a yeshiva student to be counted Jewish, Nazareth Illit is by far predominantly Jewish and its jewish identity is unshakable... It has an Israeli-Arab minority that lives in peace and harmony with their Jewish nieghbors. Moreover, excellent relations exists between upper Nazareth and biblical (lower)nazareth. If anything this should be the model for the rest of the country to follow.
29. dear Daniel , Formerly Israel ..
ale ,   Italia   (07.28.09)
are u right...i understand... well prof can u halp me to explain to my turkish friend that istambul (was costantinopoli&bisantium...) IS ROMAN!!! could u help me dear, Daniel , Formerly Israel ....strictly professor. life is tomorrow....in legality...wake up prof!
30. to #28 so how come muslims pray infront
ghostq   (07.28.09)
of the saint Maria Church and how come Chritians leave the City, hint it's not cause the jews.
Next talkbacks
Back to article