News
Shas condemns attack on gay center
Amnon Meranda
Published: 02.08.09, 08:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
34 Talkbacks for this article
1. Nissim Ze`ev has blood on his hands
Avi ,   Israel   (08.02.09)
Nissim Ze`ev ; In June 2007 he compared homosexuals to drug addicts and suggested that rehabiliation centers be set up for them throughout Israel, saying: The government should initiate this; these people are dangerous and we must keep an eye on them... I am not speaking of a closed institution, but of a center that will accept anyone who walks through its doors... We must set up special teams of psychologists, psychiatrists and social workers who will help them return to a normal life, just like in a drug rehabilitation center. He also claimed that gay people must be made aware of "how their lifestyle is destroying our existence" and that MKs "propose numerous bills to help barren women become more fertile, but on the other hand we allow this immorality.
2. The only life style we need to fear is the one by SHAS
Steve ,   Tel Aviv   (08.02.09)
3. talking of life styles
Zohar ,   Ramat Gan   (08.02.09)
seven SHAS mks convicted of serious crimes agains the state including, theft, corruption , lieing and preventing the course of justice. So thank you Mr Ze`ev but when it comes to morals you are the last person on earth to be quoting to others.
4. Too little too late
(08.02.09)
5. they r irrelivent to this situation,
ghostq   (08.02.09)
and their opinion doesn't realy count anyway.
6. to #1 blaaaaaaaaa
ghostq   (08.02.09)
get over yourself you give any sagnificant meaning to nobody, gees y people from your comunity r so sensitive.
7. While I don't condone this..
J ,   Tel Aviv   (08.02.09)
and am certainly shocked and feel for the families who have lost loved ones, I think that it is ill-advised to blame a political party who does not agree with homosexual behaviour. Minister Ze'ev's previous statements never called for violence of any kind. In fact, I can only think of one religion which executes gays in modern times (no need to mention which religion, as I am sure it is quite clear). The fact is, that any individual who on a psychological or physical level which differs from the norm, is considered as having a disability or sickness. This cannot be disputed, as any depressed, schizophrenic, or socially challenged individual will tell you - these people need treatment (although even available treatment has not yet progressed to a level of 100% effectiveness). Thus, I would not place blame of any kind at the feet of anybody who merely sees a problem and wishes to actually find treatment for it. Had these people (GLBT community) invested all of the funds raised in support of strengthening this illness, towards actually curing this illness, we wouldn't see so many lost souls and broken families.
8. #6 show some respect to the victims
Avi ,   Israel   (08.02.09)
Sorry if i dont come down to your usual level but my friends son is in hospital with a bullet in his chest. His only crime was being born gay, ill pass on your message - thanks
9. Incitement?
Paul ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.02.09)
It's apparent that the Gay community is not in mourning, but they are on a political crusade to infiltrate social institutions and promote leftist agendas using this tragedy as a springboard. The religious community has an obligation to protect their children from unhealthy public influence from any corner of the society, and cannot be blamed for a murderers actions. Blaming a religious institution Shas is incitement. The true agenda of the Gay community is very revealing by their reaction to this tragedy.
10. #7 j Are you for real ?
Avi ,   Israel   (08.02.09)
Tell me you are joking? Illness ? i am a gay man , born gay will die gay, being gay is someones genetic makeup it is not a disease or a disability. We are decent people working , paying taxes and defening our country, The only person that needs a cure is you my friend, for homophobia. Such comments and people like you are what caused this murderous act in the first place. Inciting hatred and violence leads to acts of violence . MK zeev has been inciting hatred towards us for a long timeit was only a matter of time before someone acted on his words, my friends son sits in hospital with a bullet in his chest i hope you are happy.
11. Hardei
Phillip ,   Brooklyn   (08.02.09)
All the Arab states and Iran need do is NOTHING.... Israel is destroying herself from within. This fool of a MK did his best to deflect the issue away from the crazy religious of Israel. When the guilty are found and if they are part of a religious group. The government should do put th rabbi and his devils in prison as well as the shooter. The founders of modern Israel must be turning over in their graves.
12. to #8 mmm first of all send speedy recovery
ghostq   (08.02.09)
to your friends. second, the lack of respect is not to the gay, but to people like you, duh. you not so smart to relize it, again duh. hint next time read it carefully, you know what giving a meaning to Nobody means. gees you r hot headed.
13. Avi
Sagi   (08.02.09)
I offer my support.
14. #13 sagi thank you for your support
AVI ,   Israel   (08.02.09)
thanks dear :-) you are a beautiful soul
15. Wait a minute please
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.02.09)
We all , me too , presume that it was an anti Gay attack . But are we right ? Is'nt there a possibility that there can be another reason for this murder ? So before pointing a finger to someone , let's wait .
16. # 15 Charles
Sagi   (08.02.09)
Aiding a crime and perpetrating one are equal in the eyes of the law. The Haredim and especially Shas are guilty of incitement. This is just as serious as the crime itself.
17. Nissim Zeev
Michael ,   Haifa   (08.02.09)
Nissim Zeev will rapidly recover from the trauma of this incident and will return to the more important things on his agenda such as printing "I believe in the Creator" on our currency notes
18. to #16 it's not orthodox related, gays were
ghostq   (08.02.09)
since the bigining of time and only now you think it's inciting, they r more inciting against general secular than gay, there was no special inciting latly over the media against gays, try secular who use parking lot on saturday, Chales is right before you jump the gun wait most of hate crimes r not by religious people, try secular ones, and usually I don't agree with orthodox, but need a lil statistic and reality check.
19. #1 Many counsellors of GLBT also say it is a treatable ...
Yitzchak Micha'el ,   Melburne Australia   (08.02.09)
#1 Many counsellors of GLBT also say it is a treatable. If something is therefore treatable to comparision to any other ailment is totally fare. I am sure you will disagre, but the studies and testimony of many who were previously living GL lifestyles show that it a serious change of heart called T'Shuva in Judaism can and has made a difference to those once trapped in compulsive sexual disorders.
20. just found something great here
oferdesade ,   israel   (08.02.09)
... and i really and truly am sorry for sounding like i'm gloating - anyone who knows my history knows i am physically weeping for the kids and their families. but you gotta read this one: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/08/01/jonathan-campos-sailor-ch_n_249356.html it's about a hate murder in the navy where the murderer committed suicide by stuffing toilet paper down his throat. what's the point, you ask. it would seem to me that anyone who will take ideology so far as to murder someone is a loser by definition. suicide bombers are mostly so; just take a quick look at pixes & life-story of our pm murdering hero and his lovely wife and child. and this turd in black. big hero. machine-gunning the defenseless. probably dovening his heart out waiting for a sign. waiting for a comforting word from gos or some mindgy politico spreading hate with every gaseous bodily expulsion, wording his message of aversion as he counts the bucks. i say - let the police bumble on - they'll probably find some victim sooner or later; and meanwhile, may the real perpetrators all choke on their own toilet paper...
21. Is Homosexuality Treatable?
NYC Girl   (08.02.09)
If those people who are opposed to homosexuality feel better believing it's an illness that can be treated, then so be it. However, the American Psychiatric Association refuses to classify homosexuality as a mental illness. And, in addition, there have been enough scientific studies to indicate that homosexuality is determined in utero, and is more than likely linked to certain hormonal changes in the mother during pregnancy.
22. Politics first. nothing changes.
Ilan ,   Ariel   (08.02.09)
23. #7 A very dangerous sentence...
Soeren ,   Cologne/Germany   (08.02.09)
"The fact is, that any individual who on a psychological or physical level which differs from the norm, is considered as having a disability or sickness." But then, what about Jews in Arab countries who obviously lived a bit different than the Muslim majority? Has Judaism then to be defined as a sickness which needs treatment (conversion to Islam)? Following your ideas I understand that you think that the haredim are a sick population ("any individual who on a psychological or physical level which differs from the norm") as obviously they don't work or serve in the army (what is the norm in Israel). Any proposals for treatment? The problem is that such ideas about a monolithic society without differences between the individuals or groups opens the doors to totalitarianism... Finally, while both lifestyles are not mine, one shouldn't forget that the haredim are chasing and attacking the homosexuals – and not vice versa... A last word: As you are referring to the "statistical norm" (what is not totally wrong) – one should rely more on a "functional norm" for medical purposes. And as I see, the most homosexuals are quite well integrated, can fulfill their duties and live a normal life as citizens...
24. Really, does anyone believe him?
Talula ,   Israel   (08.02.09)
They riot on Shabbat, defend a warped mother who starved her child, protected a Yeshiva student who bit and beat his infant baby son until he died, they form modesty squads that beat women, threaten to kill gay participants in the yearly gay parade, thieves, liars, low-lives ALL of them. And those assholes insist it’s against God Law to do all these vile despicable things. Who the hell believes them? Killing young kids, taking their lives because they are gay – it’s simply beyond comprehension. It surpasses the boundaries of humanity – and whoever is responsible should be injected with something lethal. Scum like that need to be gotten rid off.
25. 7 You need urgent help, can't you see that?
israel   (08.02.09)
26. #19 stop talking nonsense
Avi ,   Israel   (08.02.09)
Thanks for your diagnoses but being gay is someones genetic makeup and not a disease and neither a life style choice. The words "finding a cure" i find insulting not only to me a gay man but as a human being ,to think that there are such ignorant people out there who spread such ridiculous stories. A straight man can never understand what it is to be gay. You will find that these so called people who now claim to be straight just go on to cheat on there wifes and familys while having affairs with men on the side, Trust me i could provide a list ! . Were these two young people cured last night? hope your happy now
27. Unfair accusations
Besalel ,   Kew Gardens, NY   (08.02.09)
To say that Shas is guilty of murder because it does not support GLBT is the same as saying that leftists are guilty of murder after every terror attack because they support a Palestinian state. Niether accusation is fair. Niether Leftists nor Shas believe that violence is the way btu they each have their own convictions which they promote non-violently. (In the case of Shas it is always very far from violence).
28. #1 inciting hatred, anti semitism
eddie ,   london   (08.02.09)
a) the murderer or motive has not yet been apprehended. b) it was most certainly not carried out at instruction of Shas or any other relgiious party or rabbi. c) scientifically MSM and IV drug users have the highest rates of HIV/AIDS. In that case, they are dangerous lifestyles. d) If you are talkign about "blood on hands" then sadly, the gay commuinty worlwide has spread a virus that has killed millions, infected 10s of millions, and destroyed the lives of so many. The minister from Shas has killed noone. d) The mass hysteria is similar to that after the Rabin murder. Suddenly all religous/right wing were murderers. But now it is not right wing, since Bibi never uttered any anti gay sentiment. e) It looks too professional a hit for it to be a a Shas or haredi. Look at the messy rioters in Jerusalem, who throw stones and burn garbage bins.. These characters dont even watch TV, or know what guns are. f) Forensics should decipher at least the circumstances of the killing. Those who already accuse Shas or whomeever are the real prejudiced people.
29. It's not so simple
John ,   Houston, TX   (08.02.09)
Of course Shas politicians don't want people being shot. But... if you talk a lot about how bad a certain group of people is, some unhinged person will eventually take it a step further. That's doesn't make you directly responsible, but if you don't stop and think about the consequences of what you're saying, and insist there are none, you're kidding yourself. Light enough matches, one will start a fire.
30. #27 sorry but words lead to violence
Avi ,   Israel   (08.02.09)
im sorry to disagree with you but as a gay man we have been the vicious target of a hate campaign lead by Shas. We all knew it was just a matter of time before someone carried out their words. It started with vicious homophobic slander which has now turned to violence, You do not live here in Israel and neither can you possibly understand what it is like being the target of such a campaign, In europe i was attacked for being a jew in israel i am attacked for being gay. Two young people were murdered in cold blood , what would you say if someone blaimed the jews for swine flu, earthquakes , refered to you as filth and mentally sick? Come on even you can see the connection here, Shas must stop the hate campaign before more people are murdered. We blaim Shas for what has happened and we shall never forget this. These two fine young people were jewish as well as gay.
Next talkbacks
Back to article