News
Minister Katz: Fatah's draft platform a declaration of war
Roni Sofer
Published: 02.08.09, 13:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
47 Talkbacks for this article
31. FATAH = TERRORISTS WITH SUITS!
(08.02.09)
32. #29: You say the Jews are tired of fighting.
Steve   (08.02.09)
Your point is, most (the majority of) Jews are tired of fighting and you are right. Polls demonstrate that the Palestinians (the entire Muslim world) would like to get rid of the Jewish state, whether we Jews surrender a portion of our land or not. If we are to believe the polls, you are correct, the majority of Jews will accept a Muslim-enemy state in the West Bank and Gaza; perhaps east Jerusalem. Sadly. Might I suggest, there are times where there is no choice but to fight and to stay the course? Is there any doubt in your mind, the Allies (Churchill) did the right thing in the midst of terrible loses against the Nazis? The Allies fought until they were victorious. In a 1941 speech, Churchill said: "Never give in--never, never, never, never, in nothing great or small, large or petty, never give in except to convictions of honour and good sense. Never yield to force; never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy." Same holds true with Israel. I understand it is discouraging but there is no other choice for the Jews but to fight for our land. Either that or we will see a huge slaughter of Jews, quite unlike we've seen heretofore. Surely that is not what you want. I hope this is not what you want.
33. #32Jews will go on fighting because"Ein breirah" - no choice
Sam ,   Canada   (08.02.09)
If Palestinians won't accept Israel as the predominantly Jewish country it is then Jews will defend themselves and some of them will insist on settling.
34. Arabs, Jews and Rights
Allen ,   Tel Aviv   (08.02.09)
Who the h.... cares what Fatah or any other Arabs say? We should NOT react to their declarations. We should just make our own. We are a sovereign, Jewish state with ancient, valid historical rights to our own land. These rights have even been internationally recognized by both the League of Nations after WWI and by the UN after WWII. And we will do whatever necessary to remain sovereign and protect our interests. And if our PM can't do the job, throw him out and vote someone else in!
35. lydia, you mispelled something
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (08.02.09)
you should have correctly said: 1400 offensive militant Fakestinians died while shelling defenseless Jewish towns and villages not to mention the hundreds of thousand of defenseless Aborigines that you viciously murdered in the Outback
36. #1, Palestine EAST of Jordan Will you free from Jordanian?
David ,   Boston, USA   (08.02.09)
Afterall, thats about 80% of the historic land., If you are talking West of the Jordan, thats mordern day Israel and it has nothing to do with modern day Jordan Palestine. There never was a land west of the Jordan called Palestine with the exception of 1922 to 1947, thats it in History. I assume you know that, right? Do you also know that Jersualem has always been a Jewish city, E jerusalem is traditionally Jewish until British and Arabs purged the NATIVE Jewish population. Palestine is a lie. Facts are Facts. cancel Palestine. Create peace for all.
37. #20 Neighborhood thug?
Cynthia ,   USA   (08.03.09)
How does that work Lydia when the Arabs have started every war with Israel? By your definition is Israel a thug because Israel defends herself? Normal relations between Israel and various Arab countries are long overdue and should not be influenced by parties intent on perpetuating the conflict for profit and power.
38. #37 Israel started the '67, 2009 gaza, wars and many others
Nour ,   Palestine   (08.03.09)
39. 35You can't spin Israel turkey shoot into a defense act
lydia ,   Brisbane   (08.03.09)
It is nothing but cold blooded murder. Hamas is a legal resistance to Israel occupation and slaughter of the Palestinians. No one is defending colonialism in any shape of form but Australia, unlike Israel, doesn't coral Aboriginals on overcrowded tiny strip of land then shoot them down at point blank range or from helicopter gunships nor do Australians drop white phosphorus and du on unarmed civilians.
40. Minister Kats Fateh declaration........
yousef shamari ,   Hebron ,Palestine   (08.03.09)
Look , Fateh and Hammas will not do any thing to Israel Existence, cause the jews come here with the God promise and i am sure they will be sent back to exil again, and the problem when it will happen.i think its not long so enough.
41. #1 - huh, before 1967 Jews couldn't live in peace...
William ,   Israel   (08.03.09)
So can the "Palestine must be free for peace" crap! There was no peace for Jews in the region for a long time...and the racist attacks began as soon as the Turks were defeated and the Arabs gained control...looking for an enemy. Truth is - areas under Israeli control saw more peace than when they reverted to PA control, especially the Gaza Strip. No peace for Pals until Pals learn peace between themselves and with each other....I assure you of that.
42. #4 - Not true, Muslims don't like Muslims either
William ,   Israel   (08.03.09)
The sectarian violence throughout the Middle East proves that.
43. #14 - Got your timeline backwards, huh Nour?
William ,   Israel   (08.03.09)
In 1994 when Israel signed the Oslo Accords which called for a 2 State solution, it began pulling back troops and handing cities over to the PA, which brought terrorists from Tunisia back to the region. While Israel publicly recognize the Pals and the 2 State solution, Pals refused to change their charter and schoolbooks which calls for the destruction of Israel. The PLO and PA have never recognized Israel officially, and a Fatah member stated so recently...again it was stated in the Convention. They were required to accept Israel in BOTH English and Arabic! (something they always refused). Arafat was caught telling people the Oslo Accords were part of a step solution to undermine Israel. Arafat was caught aiding and paying terrorists to act on Israel while pretending to know nothing (proof taken from Mukata when IDF broke in). And PA leaders went on record saying that deception is part of war. All Israel is guilty of being naive...which our Left is still, but the rest of us know who YOU are now.
44. #18 - Lydia - Not even Hamas claimed they were defenseless
William ,   Israel   (08.03.09)
Stop trying to be a bigger propaganda agent than the experts in Hamas. You're just making a fool of yourself.
45. The Truth
(08.03.09)
The truth is that Israelis want all the land they have now, plus Gaza, the West Bank, Golan, and whatever else they can grab. This new Israel is for jews only, and any non-jews wanting to live there, must do so as 2nd class citizens and work as servants with little or no rights. In the meantime, Gaza serves as a practice range for young IDF recruits to sharpen their skills, before invading Iran and Syria. Am I right?
46. #38 Nour
Cynthia ,   USA   (08.03.09)
In '67, Egypt, Jordan and Syria prepared in advance for war against Israel. With knowledge of an imminent attack, Israel performed a pre-emptive strike. Syria was bombing Israeli farms and villages from the Golan Heights long before '67. You can thank your bloodthirsty Hamas brothers for the War in Gaza. 9000 kassams landed in Israel since 2001 before Israel went to war. But the kassams increased to 45-50 per day and this provocation kicked off the war Hamas was begging for.
47. Minister Katz
Henry Weil ,   Jeruslem   (08.04.09)
As usual unoriginal LIKUD cliches Build a railroad from Jerusalem to Tel Aviv, that's your job, leave the classical BS to the relevant Ministers, or better still go home
Previous talkbacks
Back to article