News
Report: Israel planned to strike Iran during riots
Roee Nahmias
Published: 07.08.09, 15:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
1. proof why we cant wait for US permission just do the job now
zionist forever   (08.07.09)
If Iran had launched a nuke at Israel and we phoned Obama for permission to shoot the thing down whilst its in flight Obama would probably say dont you dare we will use diplomacy here and shooting down that missle before it hits you will be bad for the peace process. Assuming there is any truth in this report then it shows that the government cannot ask the US for permission in advance and if there is a plan in place do what must be done tell the US later and accept the politcal fallout when Obama thorws a temper tantrum later at least that way we can let Obama play his diplomatic games without the same urgency. In 1981 the world US included who were not informed in advance condemned Israel at the UN and drafeted a General Assembly resolution. Ten years later when they went to war in Iraq and their soldiers lives were at risk they were saying to themselves its a good thing for us Israel stopped Saddam getting nukes in 1981 otherwise this war might nuclear. Considering Obama wants to cancel the US missile defense system then they have even more reason to want to stop Iran gettiong nukes especially because Irans missile program is getting better and having longer ranges so one day the US will be in range of those missiles with nuclear warheads. I wonder how that would affect Obamas legacy that he is so desperate to create?
2. The nation of slaves are ignored
Marcel ,   Florida   (08.07.09)
Maybe if hte Jewish slaves of America Babylon had crawled on their hands and knees their Plantaion Master might have responded ? This is what happens to a faithless people who forget the Holy One of Israel and run to Idols for help.
3. Avoid mistake
Brod ,   USA   (08.07.09)
Israel MUST NEVER ask for permission from the Obama administration to defend themselves from external threats and aggressions. It is like asking Hitler for permission. The Obama administration is NOT a friend and ally of Israel!
4. WE SHALL HAVE MORE
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (08.07.09)
Of these dates coming.We started with wishing to do this and that on the 14th.June?15th.June...................next,please!!!
5. Obama hides
NoraTel Aviv ,   Tel Aviv   (08.07.09)
behind Israel and "some " Arab countries presumably pressuring him (Sic) not to recognize Ahmadinejad`s electoral victory. Good boy Obama, good boy.
6. #3
Syrian ,   USA   (08.07.09)
As long as the US keeps feeding Israel money to stay alive, Israel will and must ask for permission.
7. since when!!!!!!!
Robert Higgins ,   Orangevale Calif.   (08.07.09)
Since when does the most powerful state in the middle east have to ASK for permission to defend themselves from a maniac.Dont you have the will to survive? I am shocked that Israel would risk another American miscalculation. Obama is a talker. He will try to talk till the cows come home. No matter if you ask or not, once the cat is out of the bag we will have to handle the situation, and will do it together. Sooner the better. That big mouth little rodent, and the towel wrapped pshcho's that run Iran, will be the next ones to be dragged out of a hole and swung. More than likely it will be by his own downtrodden citizens Again, the sooner the better. I dont know whether you are puppets or puppies. Which is it!!? How many Israeli's will roast under the weapons of Iran? Too damn many!
8. Second chance
Sarah, USA ,   New York City, USA   (08.07.09)
... is coming up real soon. The EU and the United States are expanding the already considerable sanctions in place against Iran; the Iranian economy is in shambles, unemployment is rife and the people are unhappy. They continue to grumble against Ahmedinejad and they don't care that much for the mullahs. It won't take much to set rebellion off again, and it isn't too far down the road. Israel should take advantage of the opportunity when it next presents itself. What is the United States going to do about it, anyway? And who cares what anyone says or thinks? The documentation of threats to Israel's existence made by the Islamic Republic is extensive. Israel has every right to act pre-emptively to assure its survival.
9. #2 Ah, you have demonstrated MANY times that you walk not in
the LOVE, or WISDOM ,   of the Holy One.   (08.07.09)
10. Israel should not act like wiggers to obaama.We are the
chosen nation&need ,   to act lke it.   (08.07.09)
11. If there was no reply it was yes go ahead
Rod ,   Fargo N.Dakota   (08.07.09)
12. STOP ASKING FOR PERMISSION FROM HUSSEIN!
THE US HAS BEEN ,   HIJACKED BY ISLAM   (08.07.09)
13. IF THIS IS TRUE -
ORAO STRANKA. ,   TSARIGRAD U SRBIA.   (08.07.09)
DO THE JOB, AND IF THE US STANDS IN THE WAY, WHIPE ITS AS. US THE IDIOT, SHALL GO TO HELL,. Orao.
14. Kuwaiti paper say lie
sm ,   Tehran,Iran   (08.07.09)
Kuwaiti paper say lie . . . . . . . .
15. Do you believe everything you read in the arab press?
Daniel ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (08.07.09)
16. Obama is a pascifist who will disarm Israel
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (08.07.09)
and the United States before protecting both countries. He is a sell out.
17. PLEASE MR.OBAMA
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (08.07.09)
Can I have permission to go to the Toilet?
18. NEVER AGAIN
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (08.07.09)
Will jews go like sheep to the slaughter....but only if Obama gives his permission..
19. Israel asks US permission
Betty ,   Daleville,Al USA   (08.07.09)
I have asked before and I ask again WHY should the CHOSEN people ask the US for permission to do anything??Pray to your G-d and listen to HIM and when you pray please pray for America! I pray for Israel every day. I love you!!!
20. STRIKE
LIZZY ,   SOUTH AFRICA   (08.07.09)
FOR HOW LONG WOULD ZIONISTS NATION CONTINUE TO DECEIVE THEMSELVES. SO YOU SEE THAT IRAN CANNOT BE EASILY STRIKE WITHOUT THE HELP OF THE GIANT USA. IRAN IS INDEED GREAT. IT IS ABOUT TIME ISREAL STOP DISTURBING THE WORLD OF STRIKING. IF ISREAL IS WAITING FOR USA BEFORE STRIKING, THEN THEY SHOULD FORGET IT. ISREAL COULD NOT CONQUER A UNIT LIKE HAMAS, AND IS TALKING ABOUT A WHOLE NATION. INFACT SOME OF US CANNOT WAIT FOR THE WAR SO WE COULD SIT ON OUR SOFA, WATCH AND ENJOY OUR POPCORN. ISREAL, NOTE THAT YOUR CONSTANT NOISE ON STRIKING IS EMPOWERING IRAN DAY IN DAY OUT. BCOS THEY WILL MAKE SURE THAT THEY TEACH YOU A GOOD LESSON OF YOUR LIFE AND NEVER AGAIN WILL THREATEN A NATION OF WAR OR MINI WAR.
21. Failure to Act when Opportunity arises.....
The Archives ,   Kuala Lumpur   (08.07.09)
This is the US failure to support a viable Israeli objective when everything is black and white. This speaks more that IDF and intelligence cannot afford to just drop and let down their guards/weapons when 'PEACE' (PISS) is achieved. Yet peace doesn't mean war in the near future but more problems especially when borders are opened and integration of smiling enemies in Israel. War? Not so fast but one way or another.
22. Israel planned to strike Iran during riots
Mary Pollock ,   Skokie, IL USA   (08.07.09)
I do not believe that this report is credible. It sounds like something that the Arab press made up. Bibi has said before that he would not ask permission to do this. He will act in Israel's not US interests. What is the point of asking permission if you know that the answer is going to be no?
23. if you believe this story then you are
dan   (08.07.09)
a victim of the constant misinformation from foreign intelligence services.
24. #3
Psalms 83 ,   Selah   (08.07.09)
I agree but in this case the world got to see the mullah for what they are....makin any future israei strike less of a issue to the world....
25. when did the Arab sources start telling the truth?
Frank ,   USA   (08.07.09)
26. #9 anon
Marcel ,   Florida   (08.07.09)
I don't usually pay much attention to cowards afraid to leave their names but with you I shall respond. ISRAEL has demonstrated many times that they ignore God and chase after idols for no peace. Now that their latest fasle god wants them to follow the holocaust extermination method of not fighting back and going quietly you would think that the slaves of Israel would wake up and revolt ? Who really hate's their God so much that you always find them lying prostrate at the Temple in Washington ?
27. NO.......THEY DON'T..................#15
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (08.07.09)
But the Iran and the plans to bomb it has become so boring since 2004,that the slightest opportunity was picked up to revive the otherwise a stale issue.You may,I believe soon read yet another date that the IAF was supposedly to carry out the bombing but the weather turned bad and lot of desrt storm in iran prevented it.:)
28. NOTHING LIKE PRE-EMPTIVE.........#8
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (08.07.09)
Strike any more.forget the days of Osirak raid in the 80's.Here, the moment Israeli planes take off,monitors will pick them up and you might see retaliation before your pilots have chance to kiss the breeze of iranian sky.I do give you the credit for good thoughts,however, but the IAF will not be able to do what you desire.Don't upset them,please.
29. We stand alone !!!
Eyal ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.07.09)
It has been prophesized... we will stand against the rest of the world... so be it. we have Hashem. Theres no way we could have won any of the last 6 or 8 wars without his direct hand. theres nothing to worry about. Lets get it over with already !!!!!!!
30. The story is probably not true
Sarah B ,   New York City, USA   (08.07.09)
Israel knows full well that the first thing that Obama would do were Israel to make such a request would be to pick up the phone and dial Ahmedinejad. If Israel does decide to attack Iran, they won't bother to clear it with the United States. Israel did not inform the United States prior to destroying the Osirac reactor in Iraq, and they did not inform the United States prior to destroying the early-stages nuclear facility in Syria. Nor did they inform the United States in advance of the raid on Entebbe; or the attack on the caravan in the Sudan; or the torpedoing of the arms-laden Iranian container ship. Given the political bent of the current U.S. administration, Israel is not likely to ask permission, or even inform the United States. The U.S. will figure it out soon enough.
Next talkbacks
Back to article