Jewish Scene
German Jews want Mein Kampf reprinted
Ynet
Published: 11.08.09, 13:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
16 Talkbacks for this article
1. Would they like the concentration camps
jason white ,   afula,israel   (08.11.09)
reopened and running?
2. Why when there is Obama's fav book, "Rules for Radicals"?
Rivkah   (08.11.09)
3. #1
(08.11.09)
Yes please.
4. Forbidden
Andy ,   Dortmund/Germany   (08.11.09)
In germany it is forbidden to print this book. You have to alter the law before republishing this pamphlet
5. wrong
Lisa   (08.11.09)
it is forbidden to print it- why would they want to reverse this? So the wrong people can read it and get organized again? Some things are better left - what is the purpose of this? To reopen old wounds, encourage more anti-semitism? You ask for it- you'll get it- and the blame will lie entirely on the Central Council's shoulders.
6. I agree it should be reprinted
zionist forever   (08.11.09)
You can't pretend history and its good for Germans to be able to see what Hitler wrote. They know what he did let them see the things he wrote. Allowing Germans to read Mein Kampf won't turn them all into neo Nazis but they are learning a little bit about the man who played such a big role in their countries history. Let the next generation of Germans read in their own language what Hitler had to say for himself they can already buy the thing online in english. Neither knowladge or history are things to fear.
7. Go ahead and reprint but it won't do any good
AY_Lamb ,   USA   (08.12.09)
The Turner diaries, "Left Behind" and "tribulation force" etc etc these series are the "next generation" multimedia, multifaceted, sensory extravagant replacements. Much to peoples chagrin these concepts we call "Fascist" "Totalitarian" "Bigoted" "Intolerant " etc etc are firmly ingrained in christian supersession dogma and dictates, the physicality of their deity in the entity they refer to as the "christ" serves as a exculpatory, expunging device that expurgates acts of violence, and immorality. In short there is an unavoidable and inexorable link between the cruelty, homicide and perversion we attribute to hitler Y"SH"V and perfectly normal/predictable adherence to the tenets of christianity.
8. to #3 And you can be the first and only
jason white ,   afula,israel   (08.12.09)
victim!
9. NEVER!
Josh   (08.12.09)
10. Sad
Choni Davidowitz ,   Omer Israel   (08.12.09)
It makes one sick to the stomach that Jews still choose to live and thrive in this murderous country.
11. to #3 you idiot this time there r also mulim turks
ghostq   (08.12.09)
to add, sigh shooting your foot and cry, don't say I didn't warn you. as for Mine Campf, well they still print stallin and Mau(chineses leader) books, y not right wing book, if you forbid one you forbid all.
12. Please read the article
Jens ,   Germany   (08.12.09)
To print it is not forbidden by law. It the state of Bavaria that has the right to print it and isn't giving it to anybody. The Problem: the copyright protection is going to end. So a professor wants to do a critical edition of the book, so people who are interested in the myth will read an academic edition and not when within the next 5 years the copyright ends some editions that probably will be published by neo-nazi groups. (BTW: if you want to read it cause you are neo-nazi, there are tons of ways to get the book (the states, download form the internet etc.)). So I guess you wont encourage to more antisemitism if it will be published in a commented version first.
13. #10, the Germans learned, you didnt!!
German in Israel ,   Tel Aviv   (08.12.09)
14. #10
Ilan ,   The Netherlands   (08.12.09)
Well one thing is clear ... you have never been to Germany and you have no idea what you are talking about. No, I might be from The Netherlands and my grandparents and parents fled from Europe. Most of my family died in concentration camps. I feel more at home, safe and secure in The Netherlands and Germany as a Jew than in Israel or America. Europe has learnt from the past and admit to the human traits that need to be kept in check. Don't for one minute think that this is a German trait .... we Jews are also capable of hate, racism and killiing. No group of people are above the others. You should open your mind and heart to non-Jews .... they tend to love us more than our own group mostly.
15. to #13 he was brain washed. he is clueless.
ghostq   (08.12.09)
16. it is good in spite of the events of early 20th
AY_Lamb ,   USA   (08.12.09)
century europe and america, Jews do continue to thrive in these inherently antisemitic places.
Back to article