News
Soldiers won't eat in front of Palestinians
Efrat Weiss
Published: 21.08.09, 00:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
83 Talkbacks for this article
31. Kids may carry gun-shaped toys?
Ypip ,   Canada   (08.21.09)
So much for the 'fabric of life'. Care for a Wolfgang Puck with cream cheese?
32. This is how you make peace
Sam ,   ME   (08.21.09)
33. THANK YOU ISRAEL.
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (08.21.09)
34. That's what 5 year olds act like....
Jens ,   TA   (08.21.09)
Maybe acting your age would be a reason to be polite. Not like: "They don't respect our holidays so we wont respect theirs!" Maybe just be sane. Not like "We should behave just like them." Thanks yael for as far as I see the only reasonable comment. To all others: If you are a kid: ask your parents to talk about racism with you...
35. Park Hotel.. Passover...
Avi ,   Tel Aviv   (08.21.09)
Need I say more?
36. lol, what an outrage
real observer ,   asia   (08.21.09)
dont worry jews, no israeli soldier in 60 years has been polite to palestinians, let alone in a checkpoint, you have nothing to worry about jews barak is just saying it for good international pr but most people including the soldiers know they wont follow it save your outrage
37. What do you mean "Prophet" Mohammed??
Scott ,   USA   (08.21.09)
Mohammed is the Muslim prophet. If you believe he was a prophet at all, you're a Muslim, not a Jew.
38. Are you respecting Christian Arabs by doing this?
(08.21.09)
39. WHAT IS NEXT ????????
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (08.21.09)
Having IDF soldiers kneel down towards Mecca 5 times a day, have them eat ham and cheese sandwiches, when the pope visits us next time. These people are insane with their moronic defeatist gestures. As long as it is against anything Jewish they will grovel down in the dust for anyone to walk all over us. The media and our secular Zionist are the real enemies of the people of Israel and will do anything to to harm and destroy us. We have just seen on this same Ynet internet page how suicidal these people trully are, when they are faced with their own BS. They take the easy way out, because they can not handle the truth and the reality, they so desperatly try to manipulate into their own failed corrupt Hellenist ways.
40. They riot on Yom Kippur and we must respect their fast?
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (08.21.09)
Crap!
41. DISCRIMINATION!!!! What about GESTURES to JEWS
Shalom   (08.21.09)
to stop desecrating Shabbat at least “refrain from doing so in public, in order to ‘demonstrate a high level of respect and understanding’ ” TO JEWS and G-D. Wouldn’t that make sense in a Jewish country? It’s only because the Torah says that it belongs to the Jews that you have the right to live here. But if Israel is embarrassed to claim that they’re a Jewish country, what right do you have to it? Typical Galut mentality to bow down to anything that smells non-Jewish. SHAME ON ISRAEL!!!
42. to all of you
Jewish mother   (08.21.09)
come on guys.......we should be the light onto other nations and this is just another human, nice side of the IDF. Let´s keep being human and nice regardless of what others do or don´t do.....
43. I only observe my religion, NOT other peoples.
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem Israel   (08.21.09)
Shabbat Shalom
44. Stupid and wrong.
Eliyahu ,   Yrushalayim   (08.21.09)
45. Some Pals can't eat
(08.21.09)
Because jews force them to live under siege in poverty. So IDF, go stuff your face in a bunker!
46. to # 29
Ellen ,   Netanya/NYC   (08.21.09)
It has nothing to do with respect. It has everything to do with OUR army not being forced to observe THEIR religion. Hey, I've worked in NYC public schools. There is a large number of Moslim students. Many fast during Ramadan. Should we eliminate lunch during that time period. After all the kids have to watch the non-Moslims eat. If we live in a mult-cultural society then we deal with multiple cultures--it isn't disrespect it is reality. Not eating is the first step toward dhimmihood. The Moslems make no secret of wanting world domination. Israel should not be helping!
47. Stop arabization of Israel
Tomy ,   Serbia   (08.21.09)
Arabic is alreaady an offitial language."Palestinian"" flags are freely wawed in all arab towns but in Yaffo Acre Haifa also.The Arabs have zero respect for six milion Jewish majority here seeing us as temporary problem here. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!!!!
48. to give and to take
Daniel   (08.21.09)
Respect for other people's religion and culture is the foundation of a civilizated nation. Israel's policies toward Palestinians and Arabs should be actually: if you want peace and prosperity, you will become this; if you want war and suffering, you will become that in retourn. Israel has chosen her moral standarts already and must stick to her values. Palestinians should become their chance, on the condition that they do the right choice too and deserve the trust which is granted them.
49. Religious Jews should bribe Muslim leaders
Shalom   (08.21.09)
to demand that Israel add Gestures to ‘demonstrate a high level of respect and understanding’ and refrain from any work on the Jewish 7th day, the Shabbat. Hopefully the Secular Jews who respect Muslim (more than G-d) will agree to their demand.
50. #40
jj   (08.21.09)
It was the jews rioting on yom kippur for a guy driving his car. call the whaaaambulance.
51. The same mentality that gave them control of Temple Mount
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (08.21.09)
This "request" was also publicized last year. I didn't agree with it then, and I still don't. But this is hardly a new trend in Israel. It comes out of the same mentality that gave control of the Temple Mount back to the Waqf after Israel won it back. The irony is that though Islam has no tradition of respecting other faiths - quite the opposite - non-Muslim majorities are expected to respect and be sensitive to Muslims and their practices. Consider: Muslim-only prayer rooms and "foot baths" at publicly funded universities in the US; amplified calls to prayer from minarets put up in majority Christian neighborhoods; toilets in UK prisons reoriented so as not to point to Mecca; Muslim "modesty" standards proposed for some UK public pools (cancelled due to public outrage); and much more. Enough already. Such sensitivity is taken to be "submission" and a sign of weakness.
52. Bibi should not forget
Barry Soetoro ,   Jakarta Indonesia   (08.21.09)
not to eat or drink in front of Obama when he visits him during Ramadan!
53. PC multiculturism has no place in Israeli society.
dmgold ,   Pardes Channa Israel   (08.21.09)
After reading this ridiculous policy of the IDF I am going to personally ensure that I eat and drink next a muslim as often as I can during Ramadan
54. #29 - Yael - Peace is reciprocal, enslavement is one-way
William ,   Israel   (08.21.09)
Yael, get off of your ivory tower in Tel Aviv. The points made here are extremely valid....why do for them when they don't even respect us as humans, let alone respect our holidays? You want to push peace by doing one-sided gestures....begin by honoring both Jews and Arabs and go live with them in Ramallah. Peace is a condition when BOTH sides are involved, and we have that only with Jordan and Egypt. We tried to unilateral peace moves before and they blew up in our faces. There are Muslims who consider just the existence of Israel as an insult and never accept peace. Besides - Ramadan is a time for person introspection, which must be against all outside influences. It's an act of personal intention and power to keep Ramadan vows despite watching people eat in front of you....just like Jews must do on Shabbat, Pesach, and Yom Kippur. In Arabs countries, you get thrown in jail for not acting Muslim. So, how far would you like us to go to appease Muslims for peace? Still believe giving everything will get you accepted?
55. #36 - RO - Then you'd never been to a roadblock
William ,   Israel   (08.21.09)
If you had and watch the tedious daily actions you'd see a lot of respect by soldiers to Palestinians....until the occasional woman brings out a 10 inch knife or a kid is caught with weapons in his backpack or a Pal driver decides to ignore soldier demands to stop his car. Let's see how respectful the police are to you - in Asia, the US, the EU, when you act disrepectfully or even threatening to them.
56. #45 - Is that because they eat viagra, not hummus?
William ,   Israel   (08.21.09)
We hear lots of claims of starving Palestinians but not one picture of a thin one. Not even a direct story but one through 3 degrees of separation. So, IDF stuff your faces without remorse. And feel good the Gazans have viagra, qassams, and and a car fender to snack on.
57. Another Failed PR Stunt
CaptAhab   (08.21.09)
This is the most disgusting publicity stunt by the Israeli PR machine. The troops, of course, will continue their nightly raids that scare the hell out of innocent children, arrest their fathers and brothers, humiliate Palestinians at checkpoints and kill those who don't obey orders, but, hey, they won't be eating or drinking while they're doing it. Disgusting!
58. If we behave like them, then what makes us better than them?
Yael ,   TA   (08.21.09)
59. What is wrong with you people?
Adam ,   Israel   (08.21.09)
The level of hatred and vitriol over ANYTHING having to do with the Palestinians is shocking. I'm starting to believe that when it comes to dealing with our Palestinian/Arab neighbors, it seems the only course of action any of you would support is their outright extermination in gas chambers! Shame.
60. STOP THIS B.S.! THE SOLDIERS ARE JEWISH, NOT MUSLIM! RIDICUL
jae ,   Lynn Ma   (08.21.09)
OUS Do muslims stop driving on shabbat or yom kippur? no1 In fact a couple ran their atv over a 9 year old jewish gilrs head on yom kippur. Israel is bleeding itself with governments that capitulate to foolishness. Is the water of the knesset spiked??!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article