News
Israeli lecturer endorses international boycott of state
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 22.08.09, 21:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
89 Talkbacks for this article
1. what a hypocrite...
leah ,   beersheva, israel   (08.22.09)
i can't imagine this guy can boycott israel while living here... what, he imports his own fruits and vegetables, doesn't pay income taxes and rides his bike everywhere? yet another academic lunatic!
2. With this man 100%
(08.22.09)
3. wonder what would happen if a student disagrees with him.
Rebecca ,   Modiin   (08.22.09)
4. Enemies who encourage boycotts on Israel deserve...
Bernard Ross ,   St anns bay, jamaica   (08.22.09)
...to be treated the same as the terrorists.
5. A lunatic indeed
David ,   Switzerland   (08.22.09)
There are a few of them in every country, I guess. Just ignore him, maybe he'll go away.
6. He has the same article in the British newspaper
R Yaron ,   TA Israel   (08.22.09)
The Guardian,a nasty antisemitic and nasty anti Israeli newspaper.A paper that constantly writes anti Israeli articles.He isn't the only Israeli.They have a few, others, one that is much nastier than all the others,put to gather. We should name and shame them.They cause a great danger to Israel.
7. Dr. Gordon
Ricardo Macher ,   KarneiShomron-Israel   (08.22.09)
He should be kicked out of the university! He has the right to believe whatever he wants, but not to receive a salary from the government or the university if he attacks his own country.
8. traitor
Lisa   (08.22.09)
take away his citizenship- he is a traitor- .And he DARES accepting a salary from Israel.
9. #6 -- re theGuardian
Radka ,   Athens, Greece   (08.22.09)
1. The Guardian is certainly anti-Israel but not anti-Semitic. And you should really check the talkback forum responses to articles written on Islam. They'll make your day. 2. Been hearing "Boykott Israel" all my life. Yet to see it happening, and I'm 33. Quite the opposite, in fact. Chillax.
10. What!!!!
BF ,   Asia   (08.22.09)
What is this guy on? Aparthaid State.... so, who was using recreational drugs when that line was penned I wonder????? Universal soffrage, civil rights, free eduacation for all, free health care for all and equality under the law were not characteristics of the Apartheid State. Really, the middle class in Israel need to wake up, face reality and start participating in serious politics. Maybe then weak, guilt ridden lecturers would not get their soft middle class egos massaged so often (and their wallets made heavier by article fees). Please, give us a break.
11. sraeli lecturer endorses international boycott of state
Bob ,   Yerushalayim   (08.22.09)
This is the kind of virus that Minister Moshe Ya'alon was talking about. Is there any doubt that viruses of this type bring great danger to the State?
12. Arrest him for incitment
Eric ,   Tel Aviv   (08.22.09)
13. Shame!
Vladimir ,   Jerusalem   (08.22.09)
This person should be stripped of his citizenship immediately, but this Israeli government will never do such a thing. They are afraid of their own shadow.
14. Will The Univ. Break All Ties With Him ?
Dan ,   USA   (08.22.09)
Probably not .
15. Radka, misinformed
Gábor Fränkl ,   Budapest, Hungary   (08.22.09)
But perhaps the Guardian is really not anti-Semic. It would be more correct to call it collectively Judeophobic. You are right.
16. 4
Rosie   (08.22.09)
With you 100%
17. Neve Gordon
Dorothy Naor ,   Herzliah, Israel   (08.22.09)
2 comments 1. Neve Gordon is absolutely right in calling for boycott (to which one could also add divestment and sanctions). Israel needs outside pressure to make it change its ways destructive to itself no less than to Palestinians. 2. Apparently the spokespersons for Ben Gurion University believe in academic freedom only when they agree with the opinion expressed. More the pity. Universities should encourage the free expression of ideas and opinions, whatever these may be, so long as they are not racist or intended to harm anyone.
18. Problem of Two State Solution
emanon ,   USA   (08.22.09)
The basic problem of the so called Two State Solution is the arab world does not want it. The arab world wants a one state solution, one that does not include Israel. If there was arab backing for a two state solution, such an idea could be discussed, but tehre is no backing so it can't. Proof the arabs want a one state solution? Look to Gaza. Israel capitulated against all reason, evicted Jews from their home on Jewish soil and look what happened. "Just give us this land for a home land and we wil live inpeace with you", Israel was promised. Did this move bring peace? Not just no, but HELL NO! Ask Hamas, ask Fatah, ask Iran, ask Iraq, ask any arab. All they want is all of Israel.
19. 6
Rosie   (08.22.09)
Name them, shame them, jail them.
20. 7
Rosie   (08.22.09)
I do hope he will be fired, but I doubt it. In my humble opinion, he MUST be kicked out of the country, not only from the university.
21. appartheid is a word that sounds good but they dont understa
zionist forever   (08.22.09)
Apartehid is a term thats applied to citizens of the same state but one group has different laws that apply to them on the grounds of things like race. South Africa had one rules for blacks another for the white minority. The palestinians are not Israeli citizens so they are not entitled to any of the rights that Israelis are. As for the boycott calls who cares this is just another one of many academics who likes to think that they have all the answers and know solve the problem. This idiot isn't the first to call for boycotts over Israels so called apartheid policies with the palestinians and won't be the last. Best to just ignore him rather than highlight his calls through the media. Without media attention nobody will take any notice of him.
22. DON'T SHOOT THE MESSENGER
Angela ,   Jerusalem   (08.22.09)
Palestine should be free so that Israel can be. Without closure, without acknowledging our cousins as our equals, we have no future as a country either. Takes guts to write what Neve Gordon did. Free Palestine, Free Gaza and let's grow up and get past all this racism and apartheid/separation. Who wants to stay in the ghetto? Don't shoot the messenger trying to save Israel's soul. Deep down, you know he's right. He just cares more.
23. Gordon: Proof having Phd doesnt mean you're smart
(08.23.09)
24. #22 "Deep down you know he's right" YOU ARE KIDDING?
(08.23.09)
This person whose thoughts you obviously ascribe to, is an arrant moron. Israel is not an "apartheid state". Far from it. It certainly is surrounded by them though.
25. When I hear: "boycott Israel" ...
riki ,   LF   (08.23.09)
I make sure to go out of my way to order Israeli products.
26. #22 You're crazy
riki ,   LF   (08.23.09)
Worry about your own soul, or lack of one.
27. He should be the first to get fired then.
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (08.23.09)
Let him set around in squalor without a job, if he wishes this for the entire population of Israel. Will his children be happily playing then Maybe this is the only way to wake him up. The Muslims want the Jews gone.....like it's so hard to figure out.
28. 17# People losing their jobs...that's not hurting anyone?
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (08.23.09)
Give us all a break.....He is trying to start a trade war. Let him be the first to be unemployed.
29. Israeli lecturer
wael ,   Hebron < palestine   (08.23.09)
He speaks the truth . why you dont want to hear the the truth and wisdome from the mouth of its owners.
30. Embracing those obsessed with your destruction, Angela?
Cameron ,   USA   (08.23.09)
You & Gordon certainly have a mindset suitable for a ghetto. There is an irrationality to the Left that absolutely staggers. Self-destructive creepy ye are.
Next talkbacks
Back to article