News
Israeli lecturer endorses international boycott of state
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 22.08.09, 21:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
89 Talkbacks for this article
31. #22 it dont only tak guts it takes chutzpah
(08.23.09)
32. #7, Ricardo: Why not just transfer him to . . .
Stewart ,   U.S.A.   (08.23.09)
an American University? Professors here can say almost anything they want about any topic even if the have marginal proof to support their "scholarly" opinions. It doesn't matter what subject the professor teaches, he or she can hold his or her students hostage to political indoctrination whenever they wish. Gordon would feel right at home at an American university. :-)
33. Now if he was teaching this in the States, he'd be hailed as
a hero and given ,   full tenure.   (08.23.09)
34. Hmmm, wonder if the professor was being probed the same time
arafat was? ,   Israel   (08.23.09)
35. But who will save Israel from people like Dr. Gordon?
William ,   Israel   (08.23.09)
The last thing Israel needs is another self-righteous academic or Liberal Jew-hater telling Israel to destroy itself so some violent Arabs can be given legitimacy for their hate. Sitting in his yard watching his boys play, I wonder if Dr. Gordon has given any thought to what it would be like if Pals had a State and fired rockets on his home from the Hebron Hills. Certainly he doesn't give any thought to the kids who CANNOT sit freely in their yards in Sderot and Ashkelon because of Hamas rocket attacks...the very same that came BEFORE any Gaza siege. Infact, being an academic....one would think he'd actually know the definition of the word "apartheid" before using it. Because Pals are NOT Israeli citizens nor even at peace with Israel, IDF troops in WB and a wall between territories is more than legal...it's a necessity. I wonder if Dr. Gordon gave any thought to what life was like in 1999 BEFORE his best friend, Arafat, who's hand he shakes, launched a terror war to kill children in a pizza shop or families sitting at Pesach dinner because the generous offer by Israel didn't include a 10-year supply of falafel and Israelis still insisted on living.
36. #22 - Shoot the messenger
William ,   Israel   (08.23.09)
Angela, it's people like this that make the peace agreements harder for both sides. Calling for Intl pressure on Israel takes it off of the Palestinians. Both sides need pressure but with the growing calls against Israel, the Palestinians have pulled back from their own obligations - namely, renouncing terror, working against internal violence, and developing infrastructure. Now everytime they are asked to advance, they turn the topic over to Israel and settlements or water or a number of side-issues that help avoid condemnation of their own ineptness. They're the only country in the world who gets so much Intl aid and is not required to account for even $1 of it. It's a walking corruption entity and the more the world accepts this and blames Israel, the longer it will continue to the detriment of Palestinian citizens. All analysts and Intl researchers of credible value agree on this point. And myopic Leftists like yourself and Dr. Gordon insists on blaming Israel because it's easier and you can sleep at night. Can you sleep at night when Hamas guns down a Fatah member and his family? How's your bed feel when a family must travel to another town for water because the PA pocketed the money for infrastructure instead of building a well, despite having approval for more than 2 years??
37. See attached link: "Boycott the Arabs! Boycott Rverybody"!
TERRA ,   LOS ANGELES   (08.23.09)
Rob Eshman, editor of The Los Angeles Jewish Journal, replies to Dr. Gordon: http://www.jewishjournal.com/bloggish/item/boycott_israel_nope_boycott_the_arabs_20090820/
38. Neve Gordon - like most of his kind - is a hypocrite
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (08.23.09)
Let him, if he is true to his own call, boycott his own university. Let him resign, and cease cooperating with any of his colleagues. Let him cease procuring Israeli grown foods, Israeli made medicines and technology. In short, let him get the he** out of the country he so despises. (I'd say worse, but terms of use require otherwise.)
39. Ben Gurion University- Strip it of all Jewish Philanthropy
Jae ,   Lynn US   (08.23.09)
unti; they kick this dog out. How does a university have such a simple minded , but dangerous fool, as its teacher of you jewish minds. Shame on you Ben Gurion
40. boycott people like this!
Golan ,   Israel   (08.23.09)
his students should boycott his class and other students should not take his classes. Their is no "peace camp" only anarchists and communists who want to destroy their country out of self hatred.
41. Glorification of self hate
Thomas ,   USA   (08.23.09)
The avalanche of hurtful incitements against Israel by a large segment of Jews - in and outside Israel - begets a simple question for us non Israelis: If you hate your country so much why should we, non Jews support Israel? Americans and Europeans a good advise: let them rot in their own moral swamp; do we want to support them against their own wishes? These self haters are all over in the media and inculcated most people that Israel MUST GO! If you are unable or unwilling to purge you society or reign in these scumbags, you will be erased from the ranks of nations. Have a nice trip to oblivion.
42. GORDON, THE MESSENGER SHOOTS HIMSELF AND HIS COUNTRY !
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (08.23.09)
BY SPREADING FALSE MESSAGES, CONDEMNING YOUR OWN COUNTRY IN FOREIGN PAPERS AND SPOUTING HIDEOUS ANTI-ISRAEL PROPOGANDA, THIS MAN IS NOTHING BUT A TRAITOR. HIS GROTESQUE ACCUSATIONS AND ANTI-ISRAEL BEHAVIOUR ARE NOT THE WAYS AND ACTIONS OF A PATRIOT. #22 ANGELA ...... IF YOU REALLY BELIEVE IN WHAT YOU YOURSELF WROTE, LIKE ..... " Free Palestine, Free Gaza and let's grow up and get past all this racism and apartheid/separation. " ........ YOU ANGELA ARE ON ANOTHER PLANET IF YOU BELIEVE THAT ISRAEL IS A RASCIST AND APARTHEID COUNTRY ! GORDON HAS AN EXCUSE FOR HIS IDIOCY AND TREACHEROUS ACCUSATIONS...................HE IS AN INTELECTUAL WHO HAS GONE WAY "OVERBOARD", AND HIS IDEAS OF A " FREE UNPREJUDICED COUNTRY " EXISTS IN NO COUNTRY ON EARTH. GORDON'S IDEAS AND STATEMENTS MAY BE A LOFTY GOAL BUT ONLY FOR THE IMAGINATION, BUT NOT ANYWHERE ON EARTH WHERE WE ALL LIVE. IT DOES NOT EXIST ANYWHERE EXCEPT IN THE IMAGINATION. GORDON BELIEVES HE IS DOING THE CORRECT THING BY SPEAKING VILE AND DECEPTIVE ANTI-ISRAEL SLOGANS. DOES GORDON TRUELLY BELIEVES THAT HIS VILE ANTI-ISRAEL ACCUSATIONS WILL SOMEHOW "HELP" ISRAEL ? I FIND HIS " LOGIC " IMMATURE AND CHILD-LIKE AND NOT THAT OF AN EDUCATED PERSON. AND IF # 22 ANGELA AGREES WITH HIM, THAT BY ACCUSING ISRAEL ABROAD AS BEING RASCIST AND APARTHEID-LIKE IS SOMEHOW GOING TO HELP ISRAEL .... WOW ....... WHAT PLANET ARE YOU PEOPLE LIVING ON ? AND THIS GUY IS TEACHING AT A UNIVERSITY ?
43. GORDON - A SCHOLAR AND AN IDIOT !
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (08.23.09)
WHEN A SCHOLAR ASSUMES THE ROLE OF A PROPHET , IT IS A SURE SIGN OF A MENTAL DEFECT,.
44. TO #22
Ron ,   L.A., USA   (08.23.09)
Angela, I'm sorry, but the prof. and you are both very misinformed and blind as to what reality is. The Palestinians, as a whole, do no wish for peace with the Jews being in 'control'. They would have this land be in their control with us as their slaves. That's the cold hard reality. Don't believe me? Look at every other arab/muslim land. Jews are not allowed to have positions in governments or be a sufficient number. If they do exist, they're not even the minority. Minority is too big a number for jews who live in arab countries. Please stop being deceived by all this israeli apartheid garbage. wake up. smell the humus and realize that out of the arab world of some 360 million, want more land? And the tiny population of 7.5 million in Israel is supposed to be giving up more??? Does this sound fair to you???
45. He is both right and wrong,Israel Arabs dont have equalright
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, USA   (08.23.09)
Palestian have lost most rights because of past terror attacks but Israeli Arabs is another matter. Israel is trying to be both a democractic and a Jewish state. While Israeli Arab citizens have many rights, in some ways they are second class citizens. With non-Jews at around 35% in the under 20 age group, hard choices will have to be made soon.
46. HE"S TALKING ABOUT SWEDEN ISN"T HE?
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (08.23.09)
47. Dear Moron Gordon!
Yehudit ,   London   (08.23.09)
1) Do stick your anti-semite / anti-israel ideas up your...it is a worry you work in education! 2) Israel does not need Israelis to encourage its boycott, there are enough anti-semites / anti-israel creatures out there. If you ae unhappy wth Israel right to defend itself then leave it. 3) Israel is not obliged to agree to a 2 state solutions with Fakestinians terrorist swho never had a state to start with, hence could not have occupied it!
48. What gives him the right to take the law into his own hands?
VERED ,   ISRAEL   (08.23.09)
Was he elected? Did he approach the Knesset? Has he organized protests? Has he done anything besides going outside of the country and making unauthorized policy? Apartheid? He is a professor here? What, did he pay someone off to receive his degree?
49. Dorothy Naor
Gábor Fränkl   (08.23.09)
1. Ynet censored my previous comment in which I used the "R"-word in connection with Neve Gordon, and surmised that he is an anti-Semite in my view. It's clear to me that deep in his heart he wishes the demise of his own country, so this moniker is warranted I believe.(It seems one is not allowed to criticize this man.) 2. I also told that the LA Times (3rd biggest papaer in circulation in the US, or 4th after NYT, WP and USA Today) is a dangerous far-far left irresponsible rag which very often offers platform for radical "R" anti-Semitic tendencies. So birds of a feather flock together I asked rhetorically. 3. In the meantime dear "Dorothy Naor", I'm afraid that you represent, let's say 0.00001 per cent of the Israeli society, RIGHTLY, so this position is comforting to know. Cheers! (Please don't cancel my comment this time.)
50. And the leftists dared to slam Bogi Yaalon?
Tahl ,   Ashdod, Israel   (08.23.09)
This nutty professor proves Yaalon was 100% right. Citizens who write in foreign media inciting propaganda about their country, asking the nations of the world to boycott it - are indeed traitors.
51. #22 rubbish
Tahl ,   Ashdod, Israel   (08.23.09)
Your post is so utterly naive and silly, I wouldn't even know where to start... Have you been living in Mars in the past 15 years or so?
52. I would like Gordon to Boycott his zionist salary first
dmgold ,   Pardes Channa Israel   (08.23.09)
Its all very well to make sensationalist declarations against his own dirty zionist employer, I would expect such a principaled person as gordon to not accept dirty zionist blood money from the evil colonial racist and aparthied empire. Gordon is like all principalled left wingers a hypocrite.
53. Treason/ Strip him of citizenship
Larry Lamb ,   UK   (08.23.09)
He should be convicted of treason and imprisoned, and then upon release stripped of citizenship and deported.
54. To the misinformed about apartheid.
Norman Gellman ,   Rehovot, israel   (08.23.09)
The term “apartheid” is used incorrectly, as there are no separate statues for Jews & Non-Jews, a basic requirement of “apartheid”. Everybody is entitled to his or her own opinion but one collecting state supported funds should be more circumspect in publishing their opinions I recommend a boycott of Prof. Gordon.
55. hey ANGELA, our cousins would slice your throat open
Ella ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.23.09)
as you try to stop shooting anything! Deep down, you know you are not from here, and don't belong here, as you have no grasp on the reality of this place, ANGELA. now in Jerusalem.
56. #17, #22, Why is there no Palestinian state?
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (08.23.09)
The Palestinians could have had a state of their own by declaring one at any time during the past 15 years. But they have not done so. The reason is very clear, as they have said many times, their goal is not to have a state side by side with Israel, their goal is to have a state IN PLACE OF Israel. They define their "rights" as your extermination.
57. Academic Freedom
atmleb ,   NYC   (08.23.09)
academians must be free to hold opinions of their own without political interferance. Academians must be challenged and debated. slandering or criminelising professors will harm the Israeli society in the long run.
58. 22# Living in that safe little bubble will be a big
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (08.23.09)
surprise...once they kick down your door and pop it. The Muslims have plans for the Jews...and they aren't going to be peaceful in nature. The United States is now going to help Morocco and Saudi Arabia with nuclear power. Between my screwed up country and Russia....what do you really believe will be the fate of the Jews? The United States might as well be opening an abortion clinic for Israel, if they proceed with nuclear plans for Muslim States. If the United States gives these clowns the technology....then they are your enemy...plain and simple. There isn't a threat to your existance though. The Jews thought the very same thing during WWII. Look where it got them.
59. to #22 palestinian is British invention.
ghostq   (08.23.09)
the palis r not race and has no joined history that goes 100 years back. he is wrong cause no jew is allowed to live in the teritory while Israel let arabs live freely in hers, it is quit posible that the riots of arab population against jews in the future will return, you know purfectly well they don't care if the jews near by r innocents or not you sould learn from your own history, and I recomand you to hear the spanish jews stories of the arab riots in jerusalem in 1948 one famous Israely artist described how the arabs killed his grandfather. mmm your lack of history will return and hit you like a bumerang.
60. The Mad Professor !!
miri ,   israel   (08.23.09)
Can you believe this man ? Please do us all a favor and leave our beautiful, wonderful country.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article