News
Iranian reporter: Swedish article on IDF organ harvesting 'credible'
Dudi Cohen
Published: 01.09.09, 13:25
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. OF COURSE! ALL OF SUDDEN AFTER THIS ARTICLE
The Dude   (09.01.09)
It's just a coincidence that after the Swedish report does this come out...
2. iran -sweden
av ,   london.uk   (09.01.09)
well done sweden now you have the support of iran thats is very important for human rights
3. CURB REPORTER
(09.01.09)
DEMONIC PROPOGANDIST
4. Yellow Journalist
(09.01.09)
if you had your facts why did you have to wait that long time before publishing.You must be a mundane reporter with pervasive or pernicious intent. Just go to hell.
5. stealing organs at the cemetery?
Lisa   (09.01.09)
O for crying out loud- what kind of morons are those people..in Iran? it is quite clear they have no idea what they are talking about- harvesting organs from corpses ready to be buried? The Iranians must be even more gullible than some of the Swedes.. do they believe in UFO's and aliens too?
6. Gagged Reporter
(09.01.09)
Who knows Iran in objective reporting . How well did you Aslam report the case of your fellow women raped because they protested your June 12 rigged election.
7. Well Then It Must Be True
NYC Girl   (09.01.09)
So now we have an Iranian reporter, stationed in the West Bank and Gaza, coming forward to claim that IDF soldiers have removed organs from thousands of Palestinians by raiding hospitals and digging up graves. Certainly sounds credible to me. NOT!!!!!
8. iranian claims
mohson   (09.01.09)
iranian reporter along with ahmadinejad are full of crap. Leading iranian ayatollahs condemn him along with kameinei. The army is now plottiing to put the shah's son in power. The end will come and ahaminejad will wish he was never born.
9. Congrats Sweden
Yaniv ,   Israel   (09.01.09)
Sweden will now go down in history as the country who started the new blood libel against Jews in modern times, which will be used by other anti-Semites around the world. Just as Sweden invented race biology in 1922 and declared themselves, the Nordics, top of the Aryan master race, another piece of Swedish propaganda that was to be later used by the Nazis.
10. Even Hamas, Al Jazeera, Al Manar, Al Arabyia know nothing
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (09.01.09)
about this. If there was the slightest rumor about this all these Jew haters would have used it for their propaganda long ago How in hell is the far away Iranian able to know so much more?
11. hilarious
gliker ,   TX/IL   (09.01.09)
12. Muslims are very good
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (09.01.09)
at having millions nursed by fantasies, hypocrisies, and conspiracies to explain away their own failures.
13. Of course! Iranian reporters are "credible"!
(09.01.09)
14. aslam...you been in a coma for 22 years???
meg ,   israel   (09.01.09)
you best look to whats going on inyour own country and stop jumping on bandwagons for your own filthy fame. Aslam you have proved by your report (only now) that it is lies, or where have you been these past 22 years when you say you witnessed this. You have proved yourself a liar eaten up with hate . By the way organs from the dead are useless
15. You are confusing the concept of fact with...
Truth Hertz ,   UK   (09.01.09)
Islamic Truth. This is a typical western response. You assume that Islamic Truth has to bear some relation to fact. It does not. It merely has to contain details that would be convenient to the Islamic World View (or wish list) to be an Islamic Truth. The Swedes have either made this simple mistake or they want to believe it anyway, or a combination of both.
16. IGNORANTS
Gabriel ,   Dallas, USA   (09.01.09)
The Iranian reporter and the newspaper she works for, are so ignorant! It takes a live organ to do a transplant. You can not snatch a body from a morgue or a cemetery as it is useless, the organs have to be removed from a body that was prepped in the hospital and the organs have to be removed immediately after the death occurs if not they are useless. The hate of the Jews is limitless so why not lie a bit as stoke the fires of anti semitism.
17. Iranian Journalism
Miranda Rose Smith   (09.01.09)
Why do you dignify this stuff by reporting on it?
18. Swedish article "credible"
DT ,   TA Israel   (09.01.09)
As credible as any Iranian reporter. That should ridicule and bury anything that is endorsed by an "Iranian Ahmadinejads" not that the Swedish report had a vestige of fact or seldom ever does
19. Interesting that this is the on same day as Hadassah's
(09.01.09)
malpractice where an innocent parent is once again accused. For more details see talkback #12 http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3770379,00.html
20. Interesting that this is the on same day as Hadassah's
(09.01.09)
malpractice where an innocent parent is once again accused. For more details see talkback #12 http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3770379,00.html
21. The Swedes began with the Blood Libel and the Muslims...
Svetlana ,   Vilnius, Lithuania   (09.01.09)
...continues with it. The dead Jews that will result from this case will be totally on Sweden's government hands. The Swedish government could have used its cherished "free speech" and spoken against such blood libels and anti-Semitism in general. But the Swedish government instead has chosen to scold its own ambassdor to Israel who rejected the story. This is the face of Sweden; this is the face of anti-Semitism today. Shame on you!
22. 22 YRS TO REVEAL MISSING THOUSANDS OF ARABS
.....DACON9   (09.01.09)
I SAW ELVIS IN A GROCERY STORE I SAW SUPERMAN FLY I SAW SPIDERMAN CLIMB THE EIFEL TOWER AND LASTLY I SAW DUDI COHEN WRITE A SILLY NONSESE STORY THAT DIDNT USE ANY COMMON SENSE TO RETORT SUCH INSANITY, LEAVING some readers to think there may be some credibilty..unless dudi cohen believes body parts can be taken from dead people with a army scout knife in dirty enviorments. #1 AGREED #7 THE MOSSAD STOLE PARTS #12 BECAUSE ISRAEL DOESNT RESPOND IMMEDIATLY TO KNOCK DOWN LIES. THE HIGH BROW DOESNT WORK IN THIS DAY AND AGE #16 UNLESSTHEY ARE MAKING SHIASH KA BOB #17 MAKES JEWS LOOK BAD FOR SUCH REPORTING, UNLESS THEY ADDED COMMENTARY to disclaim obvious lies of aslam.
23. I'm glad this so called witness did her home work...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem Israel   (09.01.09)
You can't get organs from dead bodies ready for burial. What a horrible and malicious lie. The really sad thing is people will believe this crap. If we're so bad why do they have to lie? I hope one day she realizes what she is and never lives down the guilt.
24. This sounds like something from TT "news agency"
Ulrika Ringholm ,   Stockholm   (09.01.09)
The Swedish "news agency" TT (Tidningarnas Telegrambyrå), whose dispacthes about Israel was for 30 years written by a defender of a Holocaust-denier's theories, and a member of North Korea's Friendship Association in Sweden, is long-standing Israelhating institution in Sweden. It is capable of printing stories like the above, and distorts international news dispatches daily from AFP and Reuters, through dishonest re-editing in order to demonize Israel and cut out anything in the original dispatch that gives a balanced view. TT should NOT be granted press cards in Israel, since it is MUCH worse than Aftonbladet !!
25. "body snatching israeli ALIENS"
les ,   canada   (09.01.09)
now i really believe the sweeds!! if that totally unbiased, very talented iranian "jurnalist" say so, it must be true...LMAO. i am sure out of the thousands of cases she vitnessed, she took a whole bunch of pics. too. can hardly wait to see them... a deserving follower of ahmadinutcase
26. Iranian "reporter"
Alex ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.01.09)
Since organ snatching from dead bodies is medically useless, this "reporter" with "22 years of experience" and "personal accounts" obviously did not see a thing. I wonder whether this "reporter" is blatantly lying, or the did the hate that she feels toward Jews create hallucinations in her head where she actually "saw" these organ snatchings take place? She knows that what she says is blatant lies. How can she go on with this??
27. Here is a true story about Israeli organ harvesting
Besalel ,   Kew Gardens, NY   (09.01.09)
I am an Israeli American. I love the land of Israel and am often proud of the State of Israel. Nonetheless, here is a true story about Zionist organ harvesting: when my father (born and raised in Israel) was in his 30s in the 1970s, his father lay dying in a Jerusalem hospital. At that time, the Israeli doctors would take organs without informing the family unless the family explicitly filled out certain forms prohibitting organ harvesting. A woman sat next to her dying father in the bed next to my grandfather's. My father told the woman, who looked observant, that if she did not want her father's organs harvested she should take affirmative action by filling out specific forms, otherwise, they will be harvested. A doctor overheard my father giving this advice to the woman, became enraged at the fact that he was losing organs and in cruel and abusive language, threatened to throw my grieving father out of the hosptial so that my grandfather would die alone. This is a true story. Is it then such a stretch that these same secular doctors who see themselves as little gods will take organs from the enemy? I do not believe a word that comes from the Anti-Semites but the reality is that there are many Israelis very capable of such behavior.
28. Typical Islam
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.01.09)
When things start getting tough - blame the Jews. The Iranian theocracy is in real danger, so they invent a new blood libel just in an attempt to divert attention away from their actions.
29. #s19+20 without a name:
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (09.01.09)
Are you some kind of Edah Haredi who uses this article as a means of defending a Haredi child beater found guilty in a court of law who shook and killed an infant after a period in which the child was a victim of abuse? And what evidence do you have that this man was innocent? And why is it that when a Haredi is found to commit a crime, he/she is always defended by the Haredi crowd? Can you Haredit commit no wrong? Is it not possible? The Edah Haredi are so closed to the outside world that they resemblea cult (see Jim Jones in British Guyana) and the people who make up such cults, in their isolation, are so psychologically abused and unaware that dysfunctionality and lack of moral responsibility become the norm. At least you (the writer) could have had the courtesy to state your name, who you are and how you "know" that the convicted Haredi was innocent. I, for one, believe that many more stories of physical (and sexual as well) abuse will come forward out of the ranks of these most secretive Haredit. It's inevitable, just like the stories that filtered out, then poured out, from the Catholic church regarding its priests and brothers. As a retired psychologist with plenty of experience in these areas, it's my prediction that there are many other instances which have not seen the light of day yet.
30. If the Swedish blood libel leads to any physical harm
Yaniv ,   Israel   (09.01.09)
on Jews, do we have a right to counter-attack Swedish leftists with physical violence?
Next talkbacks
Back to article