News
PA to probe 'IDF organ harvesting'
Ali Waked
Published: 03.09.09, 17:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
1. PA to investigate organ theft
Df ,   Beer Sheva, Israel   (09.03.09)
While they are at it, they should investigate the reports that the the Jews are responsible for swine flu, the the Jews were responsible for the black plague, that the Israelis were responsible for the Tsunami that hit Muslim Indonesia. Another kangaroo court investigation with a predictable outcome.
2. Israeli leaders shake hands with munich massacre mastermind
Bernard Ross   (09.03.09)
Abbas
3. 'organ theft goes against all values and creeds"
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (09.03.09)
...as opposed to terror, racism, call to genocide and blood libel. And since the "organs harvesting" never happened, no true evidence will be found either and any "evidence" will as usual be another Paliwood and Paintshop extravaganza, Israel should pursue legal action against the PA even before it tries to make such fabrications.
4. Palestinian should investigate Elvis siting in Gaza City
JPS ,   Efrat   (09.03.09)
Why isn't the PA conducting an investigation into the reported sighting of Elvis in Gaza City? Could it be that they are so afraid of Hamas they simply won't show their faces on the streets of Gaza? Or is it a conspiracy in league with Hamas to coverup the news? Kidnapping of rock 'n roll stars is a crime against humanity, and unlike suicide bombings and other war crimes for which the Palestinians have immunity, the Palestinians are not exempt from the crime of hiding Elvis. The UN (or at least Rolling Stone Magazine) should immediately launch an international investigation.
5. HMMM - !!!.
ORAO STRANKA. ,   TSARIGRAD U SRBIA.   (09.03.09)
Secretary-General of the Palestinian Cabinet Hassan Abu Libda said the commission will be made up of the interior, health and foreign ministers. The PA will decide whether or not to pursue action against Israel in the international legal arena once the investigation's findings are revealed, he said. WHAT WILL YOU DO IF EVIDENCE IS NOT FIND - WILL YOU APOLOGIZE ??? This suspicion, the report said, may lead to an international war crimes investigation against Israel SHOTING ROCKET AGAINST ISRAELI CIVILIANS IN PEACE TIME, IS THAT NOT ALSO A WAR CRIME ???. I KNOW WHAT I WOULD DO IF I WAS TO DECIDE IN ISRAEL. YOU AND ALL THE YOURS WOULD HAVE TO PAY FOR ALL WARS AGAINST ISRAEL SINCE 1947. Orao.
6. sweet sweden
natan ,   J-M   (09.03.09)
I can't believe it! The Swedish reporter informed the PAL of this canard and now the PAL will investigate what goes. Are we guilty or is the Swede telling nasty lies about us ? Anyhow where is the gold from the teeth of the alleged victims?
7. False accusation - IDF organ harvesting
David Wolf ,   London, UK   (09.03.09)
When will the Government stand up in public forum of the UN, EU and loudly and publicly decray this latest "Blood Libel" against the Jewish People. This is beyond the pale and must be loudly voiced repeatedly and show up the P.A. as a blood-lusting defaming bunch of hypocrites once and for all.
8. PA is a banana republic that can never run a country
Cynic ,   USA   (09.03.09)
Let me see if I understand. The PA is going to investigate something that allegedly happened right under their noses, but they only learned of it from a foreign newspaper article. This is laughable.
9. I saw Elvis the other day!
alexander ,   tel-aviv   (09.03.09)
10. YOU CANNOT HARVEST FROM DEAD PEOPLE!
mea   (09.03.09)
As a former organ donor coordinator, take it from me, this is not possible!!!!
11. No. 2
NYC Girl   (09.03.09)
The Israeli authorities should make it perfectly clear that if the PA intends to carry on with this blood libel, then Israel is going to investigate, and make public, the role played by Mahmoud Abbas in the Munich massacre. Then let's see if the PA still wants to continue with these idiotic accusations of organ harvesting.
12. Clearly the PA has nothing better to do....
AJ ,   Washington, DC   (09.03.09)
like building a state they keep saying they want. No, they have all the time and energy in the world for this bullshit. If they want to investigate somebody, why don't they start with an audit of where Arafat's stolen millions went? Ooops, sorry. That's what they would do if they were Jews.
13. SUE the Swedes and Palestinians*
carlos ,   San Diego U.S.A.   (09.03.09)
14. Palestinian medical science
Raphael ,   Netanya   (09.03.09)
is presumably the most advanced in the world, as it is able to prove that organs extracted from snatched bodies can be used for transplants.
15. PA to probe 'IDF organ harvesting'
Jim Edwards ,   London, Canada   (09.03.09)
I remember how vociferous Israelis were in defending freedom of speech.during the Mohammed 'cartoons' 3 years ago. Now that the tables are turned do you still consider yourselves "defenders of free speech?"
16. Organ harvesting
Sharona ,   Jerusalem Israel   (09.03.09)
Since nothing of the sort happened let them waste European tax money. UN employees are also Pali liars. Suicide bombings are the biggest war crimes today. Where are the investigations into those atrocities????
17. Unbelievable!
(09.03.09)
"In his article, Aftonbladet reporter Donald Bostrom quoted Palestinians as saying that youths who were snatched from their villages in the middle of the night by Israeli soldiers were buried after being dismembered. Bostrom said he was informed of the alleged atrocities by UN employees while he was working on a book in the West Bank. " It is also quoted later, that he had NO real source of facts for his story. Yet this story will be repeated and repeated and repeated until it becomes "fact" in the minds of stupid people. And, the IDF also steal Pali children's blood in the middle of the night to make mazos.
18. To # 17
Michael ,   New York   (09.03.09)
so what makes you think that most of the people in the world AREN'T stupid? or hateful ? or antisemitic? or idiots? all of your points are well taken except that you assume that the rest of the world's people are anything but those things mentioned above.
19. Good use of donated funds! And while they're at it,
Global Citizen ,   Israel & USA   (09.03.09)
they should probe how many Israeli organs were transplanted by Israeli physicians in diseased Palestinan bodies FOR FREE.
20. World should probe theft of Billion$$$ of aid by PA instead
Alan ,   SA   (09.04.09)
21. "organ theft goes against all values and creeds"
William ,   Israel   (09.04.09)
Wait a second....aren't you the people who like to dip your hands in the blood of your victims and parade it around as a badge of honor? Don't you repeatedly show gore and mangled bodies of Pal terrorists in an effort to elicit world sympathy and enrage local emotions to incite violence against Israeli civilians?? You Pals have stepped across the "moral red line" a long, long time ago.
22. Send PA a DVD of "Young Frankenstein" labeled "EVIDENCE".
Dr. L. Brnd ,   San Diego, USA   (09.04.09)
23. Anytime you see the words 'PA & Probe', you can't help but
think of Arafat hey? ,   He he he.   (09.04.09)
24. MALISCIOUS COMMENTS ARAB /PALS PARTNERS FOR PEACE ??
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (09.04.09)
#5.... YOU MUST BE QUITE IRRATIONAL TO THINK THERE IS ANY VALIDITY IN THE COMPARISON THAT YOU ATTEMPT TO CREATE AS REGARDING FREE SPEECH AND TO PEOPLE DEFENDING FREE SPEECH HERE IN THIS MATTER. IT IS ABSOLUTE NONSENSE OF THE PAL/ARAB " INVESTIGATION " AND THEIR INVOLVEMENT IN, OR SPREADING AND CREATING " KNOWINGLY FALSE AND UNTRUE STATEMENTS " WHICH ARE REMINISCENT OF THE MIDDLE AGES. WE HAVE ALREADY BEEN DOWN THAT MIDIEVAL ROAD BEFORE AND THE ACCUSATIONS WERE ALWAYS FOUND TO BE CREATED BY ENVY AND HATRED AND WERE PATENTLY PROVEN FALSE AND UNTRUE. THIS PAL / ARAB "INVESTIGATION" PRESUMES THE WORST AND IT ALSO BRINGS OUT THE WORST IN MANKIND......... THE ARAB/ PALS " LEADERS " ARE SO READY TO EXPLOIT ANY FANTASY AS LONG AS IT SERVES THEIR ANTI-ISRAEL HATRED AND PREJUDICE, AND NOTHING IS SACRED TO THEM AND NO HUMANE VALUE SYSTEM EXISTS FOR THEM. THE PAL / ARABS RELISH CONFLICT AND HATRED.........HOW CAN THEY ESCAPE FROM THIS SOCIALLY AND NON- CIVILISED AND UN-ACCEPTABLE PART OF THEIR PAL / ARAB PERSONALITY ? IN DOING SUCH AN ODIOUS ACT LIKE THE INVESTIGATION " THE IMAGE OF ANY MODERATE PAL / ARAB "PARTNERS" IN PEACE WITH ISRAEL IS EXPOSED AS A FALLACY AS WE CAN SEE HERE. SUCH HATEFUL ACTS LIKE THE MALISCIOUS "INVESTIGATION " BY THE PAL / ARABS ARE NOT THE ACTS OF ANY MODERATE OR CIVILISED PEOPLE. THEY ARE NAZI LIKE, INQUISITION TPYE , LIBELOUS AND THEY REVEAL THE MINDS AND ATTITUDES OF THE PEOPLE WHO ARE BEHIND SUCH FALSE AND MALICIOUS PURSUITS. THE PAL / ARABS LEADERS EXPOSE THEIR OWN VILE AND UGLY NATURE YET AGAIN ! #5... YOU HAVE FAILED MISERABLY IN YOUR CASE, AND IN YOUR GLEEFUL EAGERNESS TO ATTACK ISRAEL, YOU HAVE EXPOSED YOUR OWN BIGOTED AND PERVERTED MINDSET.
25. obviously there is merit
edward ,   las vegas   (09.04.09)
the rabbi in new jersey was caught in a MASSIVE black market organ donor trade. jews are known for making money off of anything and everything. why would they let good money rot after killing 1400 pals in gaza? of course they harvest organs.
26. Thank you #10-Why hasn't Israel stated this
Andi ,   Israel   (09.04.09)
You can't take organs from people after the heart has stopped beating (except for corneas). The organs don't function and are useless. Why has nobody in the Israeli Foreign Office stated this? The whole idea is ludicrous, and the Swedes and Palestinians should be writhing in embarassment, never mind statements like "blood libel". As usual, we are failing in getting our message out, and being defensive.
27. I remember well the hanging
meg ,   israel   (09.04.09)
and drawing of israelis who took the wrong road. they pulled them apart and it was shown all to well on itliana news. Those evil barbarians torn outthre insides of those men while they were still breathing. But thats ok right...they are primative and its expected, so why not the fact that they are the actual organ takers, trying again to discredit israel
28. organ harvesting for suicide bombing; tit for tat
observer   (09.04.09)
29. Abu Mazen is responsible for the massacre of the Israeli...
Ron B. ,   Lod   (09.04.09)
Abu Mazen is responsible for the massacre of the Israeli athletes at the Munich Olympics. People who kill others or assist in planning murder should never be free of their crimes. When Mahmoud Abbas (aka Abu Mazen) was working for Arafat for 40 years as his top companion, assistant, financier, and collaborator he gathered the money to pay for the massacre of the Israeli athletes at the Munich Olympics. So doing made him a confirmed murderer – even if he didn’t pull a trigger or throw a bomb. As to an explanation of his hate : http://xrl.us/okrfa
30. Arab organs
JewBoy ,   Philadelphia, USA   (09.04.09)
Yes, and it is very important to get a good head shot.
Next talkbacks
Back to article