News
PA to probe 'IDF organ harvesting'
Ali Waked
Published: 03.09.09, 17:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
48 Talkbacks for this article
31. Jim, come on
Jared ,   orlando   (09.04.09)
The mohammed cartoons were a depiction in principle of terror driven and sanctioned by islamic extremism in the name of mohammed, for which there is an inoordinate amount of evidence to substantiate. The opposite is true of this alleged organ thievery by the IDF, for which the article and since, no substantive evidence has been provided whatsoever. Second, the cartoons were a depiction in principle of a powerful facet of islam today with no specific accusations of crime with criminal implications for anyone or any islamic state per se, while the swedish story is an accusation of a crime without basis (otherwise known as slander/libel) for which there are numerous criminal/political implications for the state of israel Third, islam has not faced a mass extermination preceded by abundant anti-islamism, however the jews and israel have (multiple times) and still do and preceded by much anti-semitism. Thus, an article of this sort better damn well have plenty of evidence behind it before adding fuel to a fire which has been used to justify the slaughter of millions
32. Free Speech ( note to # 15)
Ellen ,   Israel/USA   (09.04.09)
Jim--it would help if you understood what free speech was. In the incident of the Mohammed Cartoons these were examples of what some people thought were accurate descriptions of the values of the Moslem religion. Political cartoons arecommentaries on something happening in politics. It was AN OPINION of the religion! In this issue lies and fabrications of facts are being stated. It is NOT OPINION!! Free speech does NOT give you the right to shout "fire" in a crowded movie theatre! Free Speech does not give you the right to make something up and report it as fact!!
33. Israel - let it be known to the Palestinians...
William ,   Israel   (09.04.09)
let them investigate to their hearts delight, but they better come to the table with 100%, unadulterated, verifiable evidence and not just rumors and convoluted "evidence" or be subjected to the largest counter-investigation and litigation in Intl court with the final purpose to bankrupt the entire PA.
34. #15 - An opinion and a false blood-libel are different thing
William ,   Israel   (09.04.09)
I believe in your Canada it is also illegal to make a false accusation against another party, especially with no proof to back it up. Apparently you are more concerned with nailing Jews than with protecting the real purpose of freedom of speech.
35. Jim Edwards you hoser, take off, eh? And while you're at it-
JPS ,   Efrat   (09.04.09)
while you're at it go learn some basic ABCs of what freedom is all about. Go ask a lawyer what the differece is between freedom of speech and libel or hate crimes. It's ignorant hosers like you who give Canucks a bad name.
36. organ harvesting; an improvement from dismembering practice
observer   (09.04.09)
37. #3 the diffrence is
observer   (09.04.09)
They'll have proof for the first, but you have not been able to have evidence for the second.
38. away from the norm
observer   (09.04.09)
usually the IDF probes itself. Other party probing is completely non-acceptable.
39. against IDF grandise;
observer   (09.04.09)
IDF has not set the least inquiry into the case.
40. #10 and who said they were dead during the harvest?
observer   (09.04.09)
41. #..ACCUSES OTHERS OF WHAT HE HIMSELF WOULD DO !!
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (09.04.09)
THIS MAN IS AN OBVIOUS ANTI-SEMITE. HE ACCUSES JEWS OF MAKING MONEY OUT OF ANYTHING AND EVRYTHING. THERE IS ALSO SOMETHING VERY POSITIVE IN THE IDEA THAT SOME SMART PEOPLE CAN SEE A OPPORTUNITY AND MAKE MONEY . CONSIDER THE SCRAP METAL DEALERS, BUYING OTHER PEOPLE'S SCRAP AND CONVERTING IT INTO SOMETHING USEFUL AND MAKING MONEY AT THE SAME TIME, THIS IS CALLED ENTREPRENEURSHIP, AND IT IS A POSITIVE ADDITION TO THE COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE. WHAT THE HATE MONGER #25 IS ACCUSING JEWS OF IS QUITE " OBVIOUSLY WITHOUT ANY MERIT " AND IT IS QUITE HATEFUL AND BIZARRE AND REVEALS THIS PERSON'S PERSONALITY............ HE IS A WIERD, BIZARRE AND HATEFILLED LITTLE MAN.
42. #28 - So suicide bombers are organ donors?
William ,   Israel   (09.05.09)
Rather than wait for the IDF, they are so kind-hearted they wanted to throw their organs into other innocent bodies nearby. How touching.
43. #40 - Read the article, pseudo Observer
William ,   Israel   (09.05.09)
"who said they were dead during the harvest?" - Observer The article did before that line was taken it. It read that the PA also "heard" rumors from people that the IDF followed Pals into a cemetery during funerals and would take the body before they had a chance to bury it, in order to harvest organs. Perhaps even that tripe was too hard to believe so the PA rescinded it. Which is hard to believe because it's benign compared to the whole "Palestinian" narrative that been faked.
44. #40..AGREE, "NON-OBSERVER" LIKES TO STIR UP THE POT
ABRHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (09.05.09)
THE NON-OBSERVER DOES NOT NEED TO READ ANY FACTS, AS THE COWARD CANNOT FACE THE TRUTH. THE REALITY AND THE TRUTH WOULD MAKE HIS COMMENTS UTTERLY USELESS, SO HE DOES NOT NEED TO READ THE STORY OR GET THE FACTS STRAIGHT.. HE MAKES THE FACTS UP AS HE GOES ALONG, AND THE NON-OBSERVER LIKES TO STIR UP THE POT, THAT'S ALL. THE NON-OBSERVER GETS FLATTERED BY APPEARING IN YNET AN ISRAELI NEWSPAPER PUBLISHED IN ISRAEL. THIS ATTENTION ON YNET BUILDS UP THE IMAGE OF HIMSELF WHICH NON -OBSERVER DESPARATELY NEEDS, OR HE WOULD HAVE A COMPLETE MELTDOWN.
45. MAFIA PROBES INTO ORGANISED CRIME !!
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (09.05.09)
THE PAL / ARABS PROBING FOR THE TRUTH MUST BE VERY DIFFICULT IF NOT IMPOSSIBLE FOR THEM. PAL / ARABS PROBING FOR TRUTH IS LIKE SIT IS THE SAME AS THE MAFIA PROBING INTO ORGANISED CRIME.. IF THE PAL / ARAB LEADERS EVER REALLY FACED THE TRUTH, THEY WOULD JUST BE SHOOTING THEMSELVES IN THE FOOT AND THEY WOULD NO LONGER HAVE A JOB. #25... IS ONE REAL ANTI-SEMITE BASTARD WHO WOULD TAKE ANY AND EVERY OPPORTUNITY TO BAD MOUTH JEWS OR ISRAEL.
46. #43,44 what are not in the article
observer   (09.05.09)
France was among the countries that ceased organ collaboration with Israel in the nineties. Jerusalem Post wrote that ”the rest of the European countries are expected to follow France’s example shortly.” Half of the kidneys transplanted to Israelis since the beginning of the 2000s have been bought illegally from Turkey, Eastern Europe or Latin America. At a conference in 2003 it was shown that Israel is the only western country with a medical profession that doesn’t condemn the illegal organ trade. Israel has a great need for organs, that there is a vast and illegal trade of organs which has been running for many years now, that the authorities are aware of it and that doctors in managing positions at the big hospitals participate, as well as civil servants at various levels. Young Palestinian men disappeared,and they were brought back after five days, at night, under tremendous secrecy, stitched back together after having been cut from abdomen to chin.
47. #42 suicide bombing NOT bomber
observer   (09.05.09)
it's the act of suicide bombing which Israel swaps with the act of harvesting organs!
48. NO DOUBT ABOUT IT ..... THE "NON OBSERVER "
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (09.06.09)
IS ONLY HERE TO STIR UP THE POT AND TO EVOKE RESPONSES FROM YNET READERS. HE IS THE " ENEMY " , THE " NON OBSERVER " GUY ............... THAT WE SPAR WITH AND PRACTICE WITH, TO HONE OUR TALKBACK ABILITY AND KNOWLEDGE SKILLS. IT'S LIKE HE THROWS OUT " GARBAGE " AS HIS FACTS AND WAITS TO SEE HOW WE RESPOND. "NON-OBSERVER".......... PLEASE GIVE US YNET READERS, A HIGHER LEVEL OF COMPETITIVE WRITING, AS YOUR OLD STUFF IS WEARING THIN. HOWEVER HE IS GETTING A LOT OF POSTINGS HERE ON YNET...........TOO MANY FOR SOMEONE WHO DOES NOT KNOW OR SAY TOO MUCH IN TERMS OF RELEVENCE TO ANY SUBJECT AT HAND.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article