News
Barakeh justifies organs trafficking claims
Sharon Roffe Ofir
Published: 08.09.09, 19:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
1. it's beyond criticism
alex ,   tel-aviv   (09.08.09)
Israeli MP calls terrorists - "martyrs", talks like - ..."until proven otherwise" - maybe somebody can remind him that Israel was accused by his brethren of killing Arafat ( no need of proof). Is this a parliamentarian representing a chunk of our country? Then we are in a big trouble. But he has to know thing - he will incite Arab public to revolt some day and it'll end in a bloodshed, but would he care. This has gone too far, democracy will kill itself.
2. organ harvesting
observer   (09.08.09)
there have been repeated allegations of this practice ever since the '50's but of course the courts, police and hospitals have it all wrapped up together, so only the protesters against it are criminalised. This, together with unauthorised testing on vulnerable patients shows just how low medical ethics have sunk.
3. YOU DON'T TAKE ORGANS FROM CORPSES!
(09.08.09)
This man thinks he's found a new way to discredit Israel. You repeat a lie enough, soon more and more believe it. Everyone knows you cannot just go, find a bunch of deaqd bodies, carve out the parts you want and put them in a bag and go. They need special handling to be viable and placed immediately into special containers with in minutes of death. But, alas, enough ignorant people will believe this mans lies because they want to.
4. GET RID OF THIS MK AND HIS PARTY
stude ham   (09.08.09)
due to his demented bigotry he's clearly not competent to serve the interests of the people of israel.
5. #2 - Organ harvesting in 1950's? Who harvested your brain?
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (09.08.09)
I can't imagine putting it anywhere would do any good, since it doesn't serve you particularly well.
6. Barakeh
Ricardo Macher ,   KarneiShomron Israel   (09.08.09)
We are making a very big mistake! To keep this guy and his party in the Knesset is not a show of democracy, it's a mock of democracy! You are not supposed to sleep with your enemy, and if Barakeh is not an enemy of Israel nobody is. People like him and Tibi cannot be in the Knesset and should be kicked out.
7. Such intelligence!
The 11th Man ,   London   (09.08.09)
8. Organ transplant facts
David Israel ,   New York, USA   (09.08.09)
There are two type of donors 1. Living Donors. This is when a kidney is donated from a living person. 2. Deceased donor: These are not actually deceiced but declared brin dead. Oncd the body is totally dead(Not just brain dead) organs are no longer usable. Additionally, donated organs must be removed properly and stored in mediacally safe environments. It is not possible to bury a body and then harvest its organs. Finally; In modern democracies the accuser must provide supporting facts and evidence and the accused have no responsibiity to defend itself if thereis no credible evidence. Mr. Barakeh's accusations are similar to me calling him a lier.
9. the brain of Mr Barakei must have been harvested
ted   (09.08.09)
may be he never had one
10. Incitement?
SL ,   NY   (09.08.09)
Why isn't this MK charged with incitement? He has not presented a shred of evidence to support what amounts to a blood libel.
11. enforce law and jail him
stephane   (09.08.09)
12. Nip it in the bud
NYC Girl   (09.08.09)
Before this idiot, Barakat, goes any further with these incendiary accusations, the Israeli medical establishment and the media have got to put a stop to this nonsense once and for all by pointing out the facts regarding organ donation. The government can't continue to allow blatant lies that damage the country to go unchallenged.
13. Ridiculous on its face
Sarah B ,   New York City, USA   (09.08.09)
First of all, organs must be harvested while the donor is still alive or has been dead for a matter of seconds (organs) or minutes (corneas). Secondly, it would take a skilled surgeon to remove organs and corneas. Thirdly, organ/cornea removal must be done in a completely sterile setting. Fourthly, anyone killed in wartime has organs which are pretty much useless. Finally -- I believe the Knesset should give serious thought to censuring Barakeh (at a minimum) or, preferably, banning him and his party forever. This is nothing more than the old, old blood libel charges, with a Palestinian terrorist spin applied.
14. Why not just return the bodies? Is there something to hide?
Yishai Cohen   (09.09.09)
I see no reason to not return the bodies to their families. By holding the bodies it only invites more suspicion surrounding organ harvesting and trafficking at a time when Israel is already under the international spotlight regarding organ trafficking. I also find the part about marking the graves with numbers rather than names to be rather distasteful given our own history ans something that should be addressed.
15. #5 Andy: good one! LOL!
(09.09.09)
16. Small question
zach ,   US   (09.09.09)
Wouldn't it be hard to harvest the organs of suicide bombers?
17. when in rome...
tom ,   toronto, canada   (09.09.09)
israel must do what the arabs do - cynically exploit the dead bodies of her enemies for political benefit. like hezbollah, israel must negotiate the exchange of dead terrorists for israelis being held in arab captivity. if just two dead israeli soldiers were exchanged for 500 terrorists, at that "rate", imagine how many thousands of israeli soldiers, entire battalions even, could be ransomed in exchange for 275 dead terrorists' bodies! or even one or two, namely gilad shalit and ron arad, would be a good start.
18. irrefutable proof
observer   (09.09.09)
evidence of reaction of living body on the cellular level derived from the sutured edges of the cut wound from the abdomen to the chin. That will be in episode 2 of organ harvesting exposed.
19. Another voice against Israel
Norm ,   Rehovot, Israel   (09.09.09)
I do not normally agree with Avigdor Lieberman, but he is partially correct. I think it is somewhat like national suicide to allow people who do not accept the State of Israel in the Keenest. The Hadash party should not be allowed to have members of parliament, as they do not support the State of Israel
20. Organ Harvesting
USA ,   Duluth   (09.09.09)
Hadash Chairman MK Mohammad Barakeh is 100% correct. HE is the victim of organ harvesting. Somebody made off with his brains, his heart, and his ability to tell the truth about 1300 years ago. Silly little dufus. Keep up the good work chabibi. With "geniuses" like Barakeh the Arabs are doomed.
21. Barakeh
DR ,   Israek/Hebron   (09.09.09)
Barakeh has once again proven that all Arabs are brothers and that when confronted with an Arab Lie and a Jewish Truth, he will, in spite of the gift of Israeli citizenship, free speach, and a standard of living not even dreamed of by his Arab brothers living under Arab rule (GAZA and the West Bank) he will typically bite the hand that feeds him, defame the country that has given him the right to be heard, delibertly betray the country he has sworn to protect. There is a place for traitors and also there will be a time to put them in that place.
22. I HAVE SOLD ORGANS
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (09.09.09)
I have also sold guitars,pianos,harps,violins,cellos,flutes,lutes,clarinets,,,
23. "why Israel continues to hold their bodies"
William ,   Israel   (09.09.09)
I think a better question Barakeh is why do Arabs continue to hold the bodies of Israelis for decades? We're still waiting for the bodies of IDF soldiers not only taken and hidden away from their families, but used to taunt the families in despicable emotional ways in order to extract concessions....a true terror. Among them...Ron Arab and Eli Cohen, who the Syrians claim they placed roads and buildings over his grave and can't find it. Where are you and your outrage here, Barakeh? I trust you will support our claim that organs are harvested and bodies mutilated by Arabs, until proven otherwise.
24. "the burden of proof remains on Israel"
William ,   Israel   (09.09.09)
Actually Barakeh, you have that wrong. YOU are the accuser and the burden of proof remains on you. Since you have nothing but rumors and conspiracy fantasies to go by, it is clear you have NO proof. Even the Pals quoted in the Swedish article have claimed they have no proof, as well as the editor of the newspaper. So I will assume you are a 5th column working actively to undermine Israel and to destroy its Jewish citizens through espionage and treason...until proven otherwise.
25. Hadash- Arab MK-
Rich ,   Fort Lauderdale, USA   (09.09.09)
This is probably the most vile statement that has ever come from this man. Does he serve his constitutents by making such ridiculous and hateful statements? Does he have any humanity? It seems that he is evidence that it is impossible to accept Arabs living among Jews. People like him will always be a threat- that they will rise up to slaughter us at any opportunity because by their words they promote a future of hatred and intolerance and suffering for all people.
26. Foolish, Irresponsible Behavior
Margot ,   Texas   (09.09.09)
My mother always taught me that it is not enough to follow moral behavior, but also to AVOID THE APPEARANCE OF EVIL. Israel should never hold the bodies of Palestinians; kindness dictates that they be returned to their families. In most cases, there does not need to be an autopsy. As this issue has come up, the government should form an international committee to monitor this situation, and to verify that nothing terrible is happening. I believe that this is the old blood libel, surfacing again in the 21st century, and in the past, those who accused the Jews had no trouble murdering Jews and abusing them. After centuries of this, you would think that the government of Israel would make sure that all actions should be transparent without any doubt. I am Jewish, and I speak plainly that we must respect our enemies and work towards more cordial relationships with them by honest, careful and respectful behavior in all matters.
27. Its true, I have the "brains" of 21 "palestinians
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (09.09.09)
28. you mean terrorists who tried to
ghostq   (09.09.09)
kill innocent Israely, duhhhhhhh bargin he think it's something new, what the hell is he doing in parliament he doesn't know nothing about politics.
29. How many have Edi organ donor card
(09.09.09)
and in the past how many Jews died and had their organs transplanted into Israeli arabs? I might think twice now about signing such a card. I don't want any of my organs to go to such an asshole as Barakeh.
30. Barakeh a commie tool who spits on "human rights"
JPS ,   Efrat   (09.09.09)
Come on, folks, get real. Hadash is an old-style communist party where the members have no qualms about spreading propaganda in support of the "revolution". As commies, they have no respect for the concept of universal human rights or international law - unless, of course, it suits their propaganda purposes. That's why Hadash doesn't call on Hamas to allow the International Red Crescent/Cross to visit Gilad Shalit as required by international law. Barakeh is a tool, and the media should do its job and ask probing questions at a press conference and challenge these people who claim they support human rights, but only for themselves.
Next talkbacks
Back to article