News
Barakeh justifies organs trafficking claims
Sharon Roffe Ofir
Published: 08.09.09, 19:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
31. TOO MANY ARABS THINK SUICIDE BOMBERS ARE MARTYRS, & WORSHIP
(09.09.09)
THEIR ACTIONS, THEIR FAMILIES, NONE THE LESS THEIR REMAINS, THUS CREATE A NEW WAVE OF SUICIDE BOMBINGS.
32. barakeh organs to go on sick pigs
michael ,   jerusalem   (09.09.09)
then die
33. #26 Margot
Cynthia ,   USA   (09.09.09)
I hope your mother also taught you to seek the truth. And I hope she taught you that repeating a lie doesn't make it true. To capitalize on a lie to push your own agenda is evil.
34. Barakeh
Yaron ,   USA   (09.09.09)
Isn't this pitiful excuse for a Knesset member the one appointed by that idiot of a defense minister that could not figure out how to look thru a pair of binoculars? If so, Peretz should go on trial along with his coolie for aiding and abetting treason and slander against the state
35. it doesnt even mke sense logically or politically
zionist forever   (09.09.09)
If your going to give somebody a transplant it involves a battery of tests of both donor and host. If tests show that the donors organs are not compatible then they are not used because the doctors know the body will reject them. As soon as a person dies the organs start dying so you can't put them on ice in a hospital forever. You need specialist facilities for removing organs which the army doesn't have & not all civilian hospital do. You need specialist suregeons not military doctors who usually just carry out minor medical treatments. You certainly can't do it in some non sterile mourge Israel cannot keep a storage facility of live palestinians waiting to be executed to have their organs removed as soon as somebody needs them. Unlike Gilad Shalit prisoners in Israeli jails are allowed Red Cross visists so we all know they are alive and well/. If prisoners started disappearing the Red Cross would be carrying out investigations. Barakeh is either an idiot who doesn't understand the first thing about how the body works or he is just trouble making trying to keep this piece of shoddy journalism alive. He should be expelled from the Knesset especially when he starts calling terrorists OUR MARTYRS. Israels martyrs are its soldiers who he is trying to destroy the reputation of. This man wants his Israeli citizenship so why does he speak this way about Israeli martyrs?
36. Every Jewish life is precious
Ron ,   Europe   (09.09.09)
If we can use some organs of an Arab prisoner before terminating him, we are morally obliged to do so.
37. who win???
ale ,   Italia   (09.09.09)
is a race. a race against peace. winners are not creators of apartheid.....not south africa win! winners are heroes of israel.... you are winners because no media in EU wrote somethings about israeli bodies(of goim of course) strategies..... TAKE ORGANS FROM CORPSES! TAKE LAND FROM PALESTINE israel win the race against peace with fantastic and MORAL strategies ISRAEL YOU WIN!!!!!! KILL ALL THAT YOU WON, TAKE ORGANS AND LAND, BUILD SETTLEMENT AND HESDER.... GOD WON'T congratulation for bibi', dobermann, baracc....and all actors of this HORROR comics.
38. The MK should have pointed out...
seth ,   deering, us   (09.09.09)
...that at the time the Abu Kabir facility was illegally harvesting organs from the bodies of Israeli soldiers, some families of whom got compensation. This despicable crime occurs in the UK & the US too. Medical professionals can be very arrogant everywhere. In the 19th century manydoctors were convicted of grave robbing for skeletons. This charge is not a blood libel, which is a ploy by the govt to avoid coming clean. The story is old and tawdry. The Swedish article was remiss in not putting it in the context of other harvesting at the Israeli morgue. Arab victims deserve the same treatment as Jewsih victims. To do otherwise would once again expose to the world in the most unsavory way the racist nature of Israeli society. It is inconceiveable that at Abu Kabir in the early 1990s , where Jewish bodies were not respected, that a higher standard was held to for Arab bodies. A rigorous investigation is needed and the UN should be called in to do it. The government has no credibility given its silly blood libel charge.
39. Why corpses...?
LeChinois ,   Shanghai China   (09.09.09)
Who says they were corpses when taken away. Most probably the kids were alive!!!!
40. Yeah..sure man...
leChinois ,   Shanghai China   (09.09.09)
>>>>Finally; In modern democracies the accuser must provide supporting facts and evidence and the accused have no responsibiity to defend itself if thereis no credible evidence. Mr. Barakeh's accusations are similar to me calling him a lier.>>>> Not true. Israel just has to give the corpses back (in one piece). The rest is literature. The onus is on Israel....
41. to Ron #36
Jon ,   St. Louis, USA   (03.01.10)
You are obviously not jewish my friend. Very transparent attempt, not sure who you think you are fooling.
42. Yishai u r an idiot
Alon   (07.21.17)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article