News
Russian report: Netanyahu may be planning attack
Olga Gouresky
Published: 10.09.09, 14:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
31. I ASSURE YOU ARABS,ISRAEL WANTS TO HIT IRAN AS YOUR WARNING
.......DACON9   (09.10.09)
OBSERVE THE POWER ISRAEL WILL UNLEASH THAT WILL BE FOR YOU ARABS
32. Just let Iran be. Mullah's rule is dying.
leo ,   usa   (09.10.09)
Once it is over Iran will become the biggest friend to Israel against common enemy. Just help it from within to fall apart. Hitting Iran will only prolong Ahmadinejad's agony and will create unnecessary resentment toward Israel. Personal message to Mahmood and Noir - guys, you really do not have much to show. Everybody knows that and laughs quietly. Save yourselves an embarrassment of looking like fools.
33. To: No. 19
Sarah B ,   New York City, USA   (09.10.09)
Well, contemplate the possibility (likelihood?) that Israel will dispense with a conventional war and bring something very unexpected to Iran. Still -- I've been to Iran -- as a glowing cinder, it will be much improved. Really.
34. RIght back at you Sarah
Yaron ,   USA   (09.10.09)
35. Mahmood, The Delusional
Robert ,   New Jersey, USA   (09.10.09)
I have used this title before. It seems to apply to you often. The Iran of today is a paper tiger, demoralized, dispirited and economically a corpse. It's military, similarly dispirited will not, nee cannot mount any defense against a superior, motivated western military machine. What they boast is pure empty propagandistic rhetoric. It is the blather of weakness Sorry to burst your nationalist bubble. You must be an expat. Your delusion is thus understandable. After the utter obliteration of Iran, you will witness a renewal of old Persia, but not before the so-called Islamic Republic is finally, deservedly reduced to ashes. Salam! Have a happy time until Nouruz!
36. Most likely trying to stop S-300 system and aircraft sales
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, USA   (09.10.09)
While bombing would destroy their reactor, I don't think it would destroy their centrafuges since they are deep underground but with the US bombs and a direct hit then maybe. I think Netanyahu is trying to stop Iran from building stronger defences before next spring when Israel may have to bomb. If Iran get the S-300 system up and running then Israel could lose 25-50% of it aircraft in a bombing raid. Dimona would most likely be one of Iran's main target for a counterattack.
37. Mahmood and Noor:
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (09.10.09)
We know from present and previous posts that you position yourselves as "military strategists" always threatening us (readers) of the dangers and risks to Israel. But have you considered the internal situation in Iran? The government is one thing but the majority of people are looking for a way to overthrow the government. An attack by Israel will open the floodgates. Iran will be severely damaged from within. In its weakened state, I think the current administration will be overthrown and the international risk which Iran currently exhibits will be significantly decreased. With that, Hizbollah and Hamas, both dependent on Iran for funding, will likewise be weakened. For mideast Arab and non-Arab states alike such as Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia as well as some of the Emirates, this denouement will come as a welcome turn of events. I don't say that Iran's demise will come without repercussions but I don't think they will be any where near as significant as you two seem to think (or want to believe). It's important to perceive this situation clearly and without prejudice and to separate your own desires of a damaged Israel with an objective look at the situation. In general, the Arab states have made war upon Israel because those in decision-making positions were unable to do that. When, on the other hand, to view one historic occurrence, the Egyptian officials realized Israel couldn't be beaten, a peace treaty with Israel was established, one that has served both countries well as compared to the militaristic situation before the war in 1972-73. Can you two not see how much better life would be for all parties concerned if Israel were to be recognized as a Jewish state in the midst of the other (Muslim) powers? The lack of recognition of the state of Israel is what keeps much of the misery and insecurity in that area of the world going. I realize that acceptance of Israel would result in an upheaval in the Arab world in terms of democratic expression and perhaps this is what the Arab and Muslim leaders fear as their own power might dwindle as a result. Nonetheless, can't you see that sooner or later it (democratic expression) will occur in Iran whether or not Israel attacks? The young people are insisting on it.
38. A chance to clear out the vipers' nest. It's about time!
Chaim ,   Israel   (09.10.09)
With Iran reportedly mere months away from producing functional nuclear bombs, why has Israel waited so long? Hopefully we will soon destroy Iran's nukes. When "Palestinian" terrorists rise up in defense of Iran, it will give Israel a golden opportunity to clear out the whole vipers' nest. Destroy Fatah, Hamas and Hizbullah and drive them from our land once and for all. It's about time!
39. #31
Nour ,   Palestine   (09.10.09)
First off, you lost the 2006 war and into the trash bin went the myth of the Israeli army's "invincibility". Yous is a totally immoral army whose sole purpose is to prevent the rightful natives to return to their homes. These are not my words by the words of your own criminal David GrĂ¼n. I only wish you engage the fanatical Ayatollah because quite frankly you both deserve each other! The Iranian and Israeli regimes are 2 faces of the same coin. In the name of religion, both are committing ugly crimes against humanity and human rights. My prayers go to the innocent civlians who will die in vain, victims of yet another Israeli aggression which WILL NOT go unpunished.
40. Netanyahu's visit to Russia
Miri ,   israel   (09.10.09)
My intuition tells me that the reason for this visit was to dissuade the Russians from supplying Syria with planes &/or similar matters having to do with our Arab neighbors. This propaganda - our attacking Iran's nuclear facilities - is terribly harmful and it is not for us alone to make such decision. The rest of the world is at risk - let them band together and react.
41. iran deserves to get her butt kicked and hard
(09.10.09)
for one reason , when the US and the israel attacked iraq , iran stood by and watched instead of helping its brother neighbor . so now its your turn IRAN ......
42. #37
Nour ,   Palestine   (09.10.09)
You're right, I'm biased against the current Israeli "establishment" - NOT the Jewish people. I also wish Iranians all the freedom they serve, away from the clutches of the evil ayatollah who crush and rape dissidents. But make no mistake, the end of Israel is approaching and it will be from within, and hopefully peaceful means. Muslims, Christians, and Jews ought to live in peace together in the land of Jerusalem. However, it will not be based on our marginalisation or humiliation and rememeber, violence breeds violence. All Mahmood is saying is be very, very careful about the box you're opening as it might very well be pandora's. Works for me, as i want to see the end of the Apatheid establishment.
43. To: No. 39
Sarah B ,   New York City, USA   (09.10.09)
The 2006 war in Lebanon was fought with 5% of Israel's mobilizable forces. And it was fought with a delicacy towards collateral damage. Don't count on that happening with Iran. You are a rightful native of either the Balkans or Arabia. You are an unwanted interloper in the Jewish State of Israel, and you will eventually have to leave. Totally immoral army, you say? As distinct from who -- the "moral" armies of both Hizbollah and Hamas who hide behind women and children? (I use the word "armies" advisedly .....they are terrorist rabbles, not armies.) Who is going to "punish" Israel, Nour? The Palestinian fractious assorted terrorist rabbles? Oh yeah. Please just shut up -- you sound like a broken record.
44. TO SARA
osma   (09.10.09)
you are really optimistic for that ! 1- what about to come here while that happen 2- I really want to see if israel could attack iran and then see what will happen 3- you tells a story as the israeli's are friends to the iranian's ppl ( the goverment in one side and the majority in the other side ?? offcourse they will stand beside you ? 4- ynet once published one of the iranian's leaders said the attack on the iranian facilities will consider as nuclear war ,would you explain what that's mean ? no one knows what the other hide and their tactics
45. #31 totally agree with you nour
saher   (09.10.09)
lets them settle each other
46. re#33 Oh Sara please...........
Cali Cal ,   Los Angeles, USA   (09.10.09)
the chances of Israel using nukes on Iran are about as much a chance as you becoming an islamic suicide jihadi or me getting circumcised at the age of 34 :), Irans facilities might glow but so will your precious Dimona :)
47. Let him be
Alan D. ,   Denver, CO   (09.10.09)
Why does everyone have to know everything that the PM does? I understand the press' desire to know, and their job is to try to pry it out. But really, there are times when the PM must have space to conduct serious, existential business without the press complicating things by speculation and reliance on people who really don't know.
48. #46: Get circumcised...it is never too late
Israeli 2   (09.10.09)
49. 47
Rosie   (09.10.09)
You are absolutely right.
50. TALKBACK NUMBER 11.
Arn. ,   Sweden.   (09.11.09)
MMM - !!!. Arn.
51. israel
db ,   us   (09.11.09)
God is on Israel's side. Who is on Iran's side?
52. Israel and God
Rich ,   California   (09.11.09)
The question is-- is God on Israel's side or is Israel on God's side. Yahweh Bless Israel
53. For #24
Rickos ,   Palatine   (09.12.09)
Hey man, cool your jets a little. Next thing you'll say is that the Israeli jets aren't American. Yes, Israel has pilots among the best in the world. Unfortunately, you forget one class of pilots against which NOONE but NOONE can compare. United States Navy. Aircraft Carrier pilots. Israeli pilots don't even know what it looks like.
54. Visit to Moscow....
Harv ,   Bastrop, Texas USA   (09.12.09)
Such a totally stupid article. Are we supposed to believe this? Everybody in the WORLD knows why the hasty visit was made. Such idiotic propaganda attempt.
55. god
hell ,   toshina   (09.12.09)
that's biblical god, do they believe in that?
56. Middle East
Ken Gourley ,   Surrey-Canada   (09.13.09)
Israel has proven to be a Criminal Government, never answering or taking honest opinions, criminal acts by the thousands mostly in a country that they are guests in. If they attack Iran, who by the way is lawfully entitled to produce nuclear what ever as has Israel. Should Israel attack I forsee many assaults world wide of Jews not just the ruling criminals but all Jews. I also see many western countries and Russia siding with Iran and also Palestine. My heart goes out to the innocent they are many, the guilty few!!
57. Censorship
Ken Gourley ,   Surrey-Canada   (09.13.09)
I realize that almost all press or broadcast medium is controlled by a group sympathetic to Israel and have hated all others forever, so I expect that my previous article will be censored! I had to write to show that your guilty in my eyes and everyone I know feel the same, even Jews that are my friends.!!
58. God
Ged ,   Liverpool England   (09.14.09)
Is not the God of Israel also the God of Iran, and the God of Abraham? Oh and by the way, how can everyone be so sure that Iran hasn`t already got the Bomb. Check with the neighbours, Russia, China, and Pakistan. Not exactly eco-friendly.
59. Real SHOCK and AWE~~~~~~~
Magend ,   Little Israel, USA   (09.15.09)
Here's a prediction for ALL supporters of Palestine/Iran and the rest of the worlds TERRORIST!!!! Especially those that speak of some Arab/Iranian Retaliation?!!!! Eloheme has always been behind Israel ~~~ but only enough to sustain them through the past Arab-Israeli conflicts. I predict that, for one, the "SHOCK and AWE" from Israels coming pre-emptive strike will resound across the planet and that YOUR arms will go limp, your tounges will go numb and your thoughts will evaporate where you sit ~~~~ you, and ALL the Hordes of Israel's sworn enemies will soon be confounded. Israel will not only put an end to Irans TERRORISTIC Nuclear Dream, but will break the WILL of the Arab/Islamic JIHAD. Your calls for "Retaliation" and "JIHAD" will become screams of "Holy Terror" and "RETREAT. Iran will soon CEASE to exist as a threat, and you can here-bye get a head start on coming Geographical changes by "Erasing" Damascus Syria from your maps. Israel is soon to expand her borders and become "an exceding great army"!!! The Holy Sovereign of Israel is soon to speak and WILL NOT BE MOCKED!!!! G-d BLESS ISRAEL!!!!
60. iran attack
fred ,   phoenix, USA   (09.21.09)
#59 AMEN to that! All just read the BIBLE ... it tells you all that will happen in the last days ... about to happen .. and the BIBLE was never wrong!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article