News
Noam Shalit: Concerned by images of Gilad
Hagai Einav
Published: 02.10.09, 20:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
120 Talkbacks for this article
1. Look at the difference in health of Gilad and Arab prisoners
Time to hurt Arab ,   prisoners!   (10.02.09)
in Israeli jails! Gilad looks like he's in a Nazi concentration camp and the Arab prisoners look like they just finished eating at a 5 star restaurant. Time to treat Arab prisoners harshly! Time for the DEATH PENALTY in Israel!
2. And why, may I ask, the International Red Cross has done...
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (10.02.09)
...nothing for over three years to visit with Gilad Shalit, having been abducted while on Israeli soil? And why for all this time neither the UN Human Rights Council nor Mr. Goldstone have called to investigate this lack of adherance to basic human rights by the thugs of Hamas? Is the fact that Gilad is a Jew a factor? Don't Jews have human rights?
3. Gilad.....
Abir ,   Chicago, IL   (10.02.09)
He has paid and continues to pay a terrible price. Hopefully this act of releasing a video clip will lead to his quick release.
4. Staged video. Gilad hasnt seen the light of day in 3 years,
Jae ,   Lynn US   (10.02.09)
looks gaunt, skinny, emaciated. Time to stop hamas terrorists conjugal visits. It is nauseating how think headed and foolish those in charge in Israel really are. Get a clue people!
5. Hamas: proud to be blackmailers
john   (10.02.09)
6. I TOLD YOU HE WAS ALIVE!
John ,   London, England   (10.02.09)
I never lost hope Gilad. Not once. We will not abandon you. We will bring you home.
7. one message to Hamas
Natan   (10.02.09)
SCUM BAGS!!!!!!!!!!!
8. Respons to #1
Mameluken ,   Sweden   (10.02.09)
I think Gilad Shalit looks very healty. What now for the 10 000 + palestinians prisoners?
9. courage gilad we will save you
gil ,   city of david israel   (10.02.09)
why the red cross is taking care pf palestinians killers and not taking care of israeli young soldiers |????? Barabarians cannot do nothing against you because tsahal knows the name of each of your captors they knows that if you are hurt , they will be finished , and their gangs
10. Time for a change...
Jose D ,   Netanya, Israel   (10.02.09)
We have been shown that the jewish people, and particulary Israelis are civilize. We do mistakes, yes; we abused sometimes of others, yes; but in general we are more civilize than the rest. I agree that the time for a change has come. We have to start treating arab prisioners taugher than we do now. No Human Rights, they are not human, they are not even animals and deserve no rights at all. Free Shalit!! We want u back home 'achi'!!
11. Pray for CURSES on Hamas captors & their families!!!
shuebydoo ,   USA   (10.02.09)
As in the days of Moses when God tormented the Egyptians with curse after curse until they let the Israelites go free, pray for CURSES on the Hamas captors and their families, and may they all be so tormented that they realize it is because of holding Gilad...and that they let Gilad go free.
12. one messeage to #7
(10.02.09)
you are the real SCUM !!!!
13. to #1
Eric   (10.02.09)
Gazans don't have basic food, you want them to put Gilad in 5 star hotel. At least he looks better than majority of Gazans
14. Time to start bombing the Gaza Strip again.
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (10.02.09)
If he is alive....Go in and get him. I wouldn't trade these terrorist scum bags a plug nickel for him.
15. Another solution
Siul ,   Madrid Spain   (10.02.09)
Unfortunately the posture of Israel is weak and crazy. I propose the next(very easy): No water and electricity for Gaza, put all the prisioners in isolated cages till Shalit be free.Wake up Holy NationĀ”. The Best for you is the worst for your enemies. Allmighty, give strengh to your peopleĀ”
16. I'm appalled...
sunshine2010   (10.02.09)
about the strength of this young man being in captivity for more than 3 years. The most important thing is: he is alive and he seems at least being good condition. I'm glad for his family that they at least received a sign of life from their son and I very much hope that this long story will coming to a good end - that the Shalit family will be reunited soon.
17. to #1 please take pal terrorists to sweden
gil ,   city of david   (10.02.09)
18. Where has the International Red Cross been all this time?!
Galit ,   Nahariah   (10.02.09)
19. I Publically Apologize
emanon ,   USA   (10.02.09)
It looks like Shalit is alive. I said I would admit it if I was wrong. I admit it, I was wrong. I still do not trust the terrostinians.
20. gilad
jj ,   montreal canada   (10.02.09)
I'm not so sure this video is real or has it been photoshopped and poor Gilad is no longer alive. This could be only a rouse by the Palis to release thousands for a dead body again like with the Hezzies
21. At first glance at your comment
Richard Trank ,   Bellingham, WA   (10.02.09)
After my first glance at your comment I became ashamed to be a Swede...until I saw the name you chose for your email address.
22. Gilad
Piccolo ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.02.09)
GET HIM HOME!! STOP WASTING TIME AND GET THIS YOUNG MAN HOME.
23. disgusting...
Golan ,   SL   (10.02.09)
so what #10 you had information he was alive? You hoped. Gilad should have been rescued back in 2006 and aging in 2009 war. We PAID for this propaganda and that is all it is. Now all I can say is thank God he is alive. Lets turn Gaza upside down till we find him or not leave a mashtin bakir.
24. So relieved You are alive
Nevena ,   Paris, France   (10.02.09)
I'm glad Gilad's family had an opportunity to have a glimpse at their beloved son and brother. I hope he goes home soon. I agree with No 1 he does not look his best, but then at the moment the most important is to bring him home.
25. Ynet perhaps consider a bit more responsible editing?
do we really need 2 ,   read silly TBs?   (10.02.09)
26. Gilad
sharon ,   Israel   (10.02.09)
I agree with you but...if he were your son you might feel differently....
27. Happy Sukkot Gilad ! Stay strong, we pray for your return
Zionist ,   Zion   (10.02.09)
28. 3 Years
Resistor   (10.02.09)
Mossad can't get him out? Shin Bet can't get him out? What is really going on? Does Israel need an unlikely hero for the masses? Come on, the truth now.
29. Number 1 is right on the mark!!! View pictures of Gazans in
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (10.02.09)
the streets. Take a look at their officials. They appear to have nothing missing in their diets. But Shalit does look like a Nazi death camp prisoner. View in particular his left hand before the end of the tape. But of course, neither the International Red Cross, nor Richard Goldstone and the UN Council that sent him to Gaza care. Why should they. Gilad Shalit, after all, is only a Jew...
30. Huriyahs from paradise riding camels
zeroing ,   Germany   (10.02.09)
The health of Gilad Shalit is not a quarter as good as those of the potential killers who were released from Jails in Israel. They looked as if they had been staying at one of the tourist resorts in Eilat port for the past ten years. By their face values there were zero traces of punishment; they looked like the fabulous Huriyahs from paradise riding camels to meet their Hamas Shahidis - the Killers of innocent people. The only positive thing in this: Gilad Shalit is alive and hopefully he will soon be released and meet his people in the Land of Israel.
Next talkbacks
Back to article