News
Ada Yonath: Release all terrorists
Ynet
Published: 10.10.09, 18:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
98 Talkbacks for this article
61. mapping shmapping
Hen   (10.11.09)
first let's make a map of the bus routes available, then we can look at genomes
62. She has it the wrong way round
Danny   (10.11.09)
It is the fact Israel DOES release prisoners that motivates abductions not the other way round
63. Too much time in the lab.
Ynot   (10.11.09)
Listen, Genius, let's see you lose your kid to terrorist and see how long you believe that person should be free. Like many overly educated idiots you are lacking common sense.
64. # 58 I FIND YNET FAR MORE
LAWRENCE RAP ARTISTE ,   Safed Israel   (10.11.09)
Stimulating and interesting than learning some Torah thank you.Could care less what happened to Moses and Abraham thousands of years ago.My comments are only idiotic because you are too dumb to comprehend them.Go play with your toys.By the way...hard luck losing out on the olympics but the best city (Rio De Janeiro) won.Tell your community organiser Obummer to stick that in his pipe .
65. #58 LARRY CHICAGO
LAWRENCE RAP ARTISTE ,   Safed Israel   (10.11.09)
Bollocks to you.I will post as many comments as I like,idiotic or otherwise.It is my life and my business,if you do not like them do not read them. TA TA .
66. This has to be a joke
Steve   (10.11.09)
Does this woman not realize what 10,000 terrorists are capable of? 10,000 terrorists could carry out a lot of suicide bombings and shootings. They would kill thousands of Israelis. I understand her logic, that if we have no terrorists to release, Hamas won't kidnap soldiers to trade. However, there is a better way. If we introduce the death penalty for convicted terrorists, then there will be no prisoner exchanges, and we won't have to worry about 10,000 dangerous scum running around the streets.
67. Yonath
J.K. ,   Brookllyn USA   (10.11.09)
If the Antisemite,Marco the Spaniard,is praising yonath,that means she said somthing very stupid.
68. Ada
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (10.11.09)
Ada Yonat ! Halanu at, o Letsarenu ?.
69. Ada Yonath: Release all terrorists
R C ,   USA   (10.11.09)
WOW! Her lab should be checked to see what kind of fumes she has been inhaling, then send some to Ahmadinejad and the Ayatollas, maybe they will release their prisoners too after a couple of inhalations.
70. Alan you crack me up it wasn't me
Palestine dove ,   afula   (10.11.09)
it was my evil twin but you should have went down a little and read the rest
71. To: No. 50
Sarah B ,   New York / Saviyon   (10.11.09)
Trials in Israel are always before a judge. There are no jury trials in Israel. The concept of administrative detention is not limited to Israel -- look at the detainess in Guantanamo, for example -- and I can tell you that the administrative detainees -- whether in Guantanamo or Israel -- are scarcely innocent babes in the woods. Israel has an excellent network of informants and excellent internal security apparatus, but the fact of the matter is that Israel has released many of these detainees time and again, only to see them resort to bad acts. Here you go: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Administrative_detention The Israeli government knows full well why these administrative detainees are under detention. For you to suggest otherwise is ludicrous. The only organization that has ever leveled that charge is B'Tselem, and they may as well be a part of Hamas or Hizbollah or Islamic Jihad. Your accusation -- stupidly parroted from B'Tselem's claim -- which was exhaustively investigated and determined to be wholly without substance -- makes you appear quite foolish, by the way. You are the LAST person in the world to talk about "ignorantly relying on meaningless assumptions." Or is it that you have become a past master at the art? I read most of your posts, so I'd have to say that is probably the case. Poor, poor, pitiful, gullible you. Broaden yor horizons!
72. Ah, did I neglect to include the link?
Sarah B ,   New York / Saviyon   (10.11.09)
Here it is. Sorry .... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Administrative_detention
73. Season Your Dreams with History Lessons
Robert ,   Kentucky, USA   (10.11.09)
Yonath must learn to study history as well as chemistry. Time has proven that to release all prisoners would solve nothing. To the terrorists, capitulation only means weakness which gives them cause to celebrate and then move on to their next demand such as more land etc. I must at the same time commend this woman for having a good dream, however unrealistic, at heart and just as importantly the courage to express it. Perhaps if more people did the same then at least some of those good dreams could become a reality. After all don't we all have some good dreams about our own futures? Do all of your dreams make good common sense?
74. Sounds more like an Idiot
Brod ,   USA   (10.11.09)
She must be out of her mind.
75. Release of prisoners
Robert Barzilli ,   Los Angles, Ca   (10.11.09)
After reading the comments of Prof.Ada Yonath I came to the conclusion that she is a marvelous scientist and makes me proud that she is Jewish but that at the same time she does not have her feet on the ground, that she is so naive that she, even with such marvelous brain, does not understand what goes around her. It reminded me of another person after 9/11 attack who said "We should shower them with candies and not fight them". This man was unable to understand the arabs. If we follow his advise the arabs would say "let's attack more cities, we get more candies". In the case of Prof.Yonath what she calls "prisoners" are murderers with blood on ther hands and as soon they are released will go on killing other innocent people including women and childrens,and if they have the chance, also such lovely person as Prof. Yonath!
76. Miss Teen South Carolina Has Nothing Over You, Lady!
Heather Czerniak ,   Milwaukee, USA   (10.11.09)
Politics isn't for you, sweetheart. Back to the lab.
77. hahaha
(10.11.09)
right wingers are perplexed again at the words of a highly intelligent person. Ada Yonath was only good for them when she stroked their nationalistic ego by winning the Nobel prize.
78. Yonath and Arab Terrorists
Jack Law ,   Belgium   (10.11.09)
This woman is as crazy and out of touch with reality as most of your intellectuals, namely Oz, Yehoshua, etc. Those people do not deserve the country they live in and should go live elsewhere. Nobel and other prizes are worthless for Israel who needs security, strength and determination to face their enemies
79. Exchange her for Shalit
Lila ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.11.09)
We need Gilad Shalit back here - let's just give Hamas this nut case in exchange!! She's certainly a much bigger prize.
80. The Nobel Prize winner is obviously an idiot savant! (end)
Bartley Kulp ,   Haifa, Israel   (10.11.09)
81. Read
(10.11.09)
82. since when someone in chimestry knows
ghostq   (10.11.09)
about politiks mmm this lady got ego boost and acting like she knows what she is doing well she doesn't in matter of fact if these r Nobel Prize winner way of thought I can get one.
83. Ada, stick to science for you know nothing of life.
leo ,   usa   (10.11.09)
Israel, do you want stop kidnappings? Stop taking prisoners.
84. to #50 lol dungeons and dragons maybe
ghostq   (10.11.09)
stop the Drama, well at least you didn't gave the women and children speach. you palis watch too many soaps.
85. LAWRENCE RAP
LAWRENCE RAP ,   Chicago   (10.11.09)
why does the Ynet put idiotic comments on their site? is there no one of any seriousness out there?
86. does no body listen anymore
AY_Lamb ,   Globestan   (10.11.09)
She didn't say release all the prisoners; she said "that the words used to defend their detention have ambiguous meaning to her" it is logical that she'd have that perspective since her life’s pursuit is one of mathematical precision, harmony and beauty. The language of the universe is math and the quotient for hate, fear, prejudice and contempt is erratic and variable, to a person of Ada’s acumen this would seem obtuse and irreconcilable. and HaShem coalesced the luminance, and the name, and into being emerged 4 base pairs
87. Ways to ensure that people would not be motivated to kill?
S.   (10.11.09)
That would mean to erase islamic death cult. How would that be solved? She should better stick to ribosomes then politics.
88. maam .. your heart is big as your mind
Jalal ,   Gaza   (10.11.09)
89. I bet even the terrorists are laughing at this one.
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.11.09)
90. Hey YNET, where is my comment?
Rich ,   Toronto, Canada   (10.11.09)
If I was talking ignorance and lies, like so many of the comments I see here, you would post that immediately. But when someone says something so profound as to get Jews thinking differently, you don't want to post that. Where is the free speech for Jews?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article