Jewish Scene
Poland's Catholic Church publishes book co-authored by rabbi, priest
Ynetnews
Published: 12.10.09, 08:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
6 Talkbacks for this article
1. You trying HARD to strike a CONNECTION between
Benjamin ,   singapore   (10.12.09)
Xtianity- Catholic and JUDAISM ? Sorry, Orthodox Judaism's Teaching just will NEVER EVER mix with you Xtian- Catholics ! Water and Oil dont mix ! I am sorry, YOU XTIAN and CATHOLICS have gone very FAR FROM THE TORAH and the Hashem....PERIOD! We can only discuss history of MY PEOPLE- Religion , NO, We will not....please leave us Jews alone to keep the law. We have taught you enough, given the whole bundle long ago, But YOU HAVE BEEN SWAYED AWAY THROUGHOUT AGES. YOU MADE GODS, DOCTRINE, DOGMA, MAGISTARIUM THAT YOU DONT UNDERSTAND! WE JEW TAKE THE TORAH AND WE MOVE IN TIME. YOU XTIANS & CATHOLICS GO YOUR WAYS. WE WONT MIX. WE CANT EVEN DINE WITH YOU - WE ARE KOSHER AND WANT TO STAY KOSHER. YOU HAVE NEVER LEARNED TO UNDERSTAND OUR JEWISH LIFE, AN DYOU WANT TO GEL WITH US? SORRY, IT WONT WORK. MICHA INJUNCTION APPLIES. YOU TAKE YOUR GODS WE FOLLOW OUR SINGULAR G-D. THE LRD G_D OF YISRAEL- THE HOUSE OF JACOB. I HAVE SEEN ENOUGH OF THE CATHOLIC HIPPOCRACY IN MY YEARS LIVING HERE IN SINGAPORE AND MALAYSIA ! BUT I AHVE ALSO MET MANY GOOD FELLOW S WHO ARE MODEL OF CHARACTER- i WILL NOT SHUT THE DOOR ON YOU BUT I WILL NOT INVITE YOU ALSO. I HAVE THE TORAH, YOU FOLLOW ME. CROSS OVER THIS SIDE, FOR I HAVE THE WORD OF THE HASHEM WITH ME. WE HAVE KEPT IT ALL THIS YEARS INTACK- WE WILL PASS IT TO YOU WITH DUE DILIGENCE. BUT YOU XTAINS AND CATHOLICS HAS NEVER MADE IT EASIER FOR US JEWS EVER THROUGH OUT THE AGES. BEN SINGAPORE benjamin singapore
2. What will counter anti semitism is knowing that Jesus NEVER
JMK ,   NYC   (10.12.09)
existed. No Jesus, no life, no perfiious Jews, no death. No nothing. No special reason to hate Jew, The New Testament being fiction, its 450 anti semitic pericopes are fiction as well. Six million Jews were murdered because of human stupidity to know fact from fairytale.
3. Exegesis and Hermeneutics
benjamin ,   singapore   (10.12.09)
Exegesis is a greek concept to thought created as matter of political repercussion during the greek conquest to subjudicate Judaism. Exegesis is an immediate invention of the Greeks to make justifications to folk lore ideas to be transplanted into uncertain exegesis of the Greeks, Well the greek for ages have struggled to explains abstract notion and religious doctrine which is self –created UNLIKE THE JUDAISM. Most of the Greek exegesis are hear say doctrine, without facts , evidences of substance. The Doctrine of Faith was created to create a notion of acceptance of many unfounded ideas. Comparatively Judaism need not follow the exegesis of the Greek. We Jew have the torah, and we need not apply exegesis theories to make justification and acceptance. We jews believe in one G-d and the truth in these believe system is original and sufficient to keep us moving and to go forth. Our Father Avraham understood this, he passed it to us to date we pass the truth of Judaism in sucession. We jew don’t need the traditional and exegesis of the hermeneutics of interpretation theory which the catholic and protestant used widely to the point they have created anti-Semitism idea in the society at large. They have penetrated a wide range of disciplines. The concept of exegesis explores into the text interpretation to establish, greek traditions, philosophy and biblical idea which are alien to Judaism. Jew have great history, the hallmark of heritage that it starts from day one of creation. Greek, Catholic- protestants and xtian don’t have such historical heritage so intimately connected to the Lrd G-d the Creator of everything that is tangible and Intangible. We jews have EinSof !What do they (xtian) have ? Well, they only have mere human logics and reasoning created by the human political and historical establishments of the renaissances magus.They created Judea from Judah, they took our land and divided the same among the conquest alien who have committed theft on our promised land. To date Israel is divided! It is all exegesis of frame work, and inter-relative process that manipulates the human mind. But we Orthodox Jew will NEVER EVER FALL FOR THE GREEK-CATHOLIC – Xtian exegesis.Water and Oil dosent mix! We Jews know our sources, we know our origin, we know our creator, we are the beloved of the Lrd. Everything that belongs to the Lrd belongs to me. Greek exegesis is never part of Judaism and we jews will stay out of the Greek no matter how many bundles of books you Polish Rabbis and Catholic try to write to strike a compromise. You Gentiles stop that adultery of the sacred book. You rabbis in Poland stop this compromise !
4. 2 - then neither did moses, abraham, jacob, or akiva
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (10.12.09)
how can you say jesus didn't exist and those mentioned in tanakh did? how does that work?
5. #4 Mike, What makes you think that they did exist? Where is
JMK ,   NYC   (10.12.09)
the proof for anything as it is written, if there is a kernal of truth that can be teased out of it, it is the desire for Jews to create a mythical story to parallel their development to a larger political entity. Anyway Moses is an Egyptian name and so is much of Exodus, Genesis being so much Caananite and Bablylonian myth, never heard of Gilgamesh or the find at Ugarit. Since you are probably an ex-Jew Christian have you never read about the various problems with the New Testament and its thousands of supporting examples of its fiction and forgery. Since you speak english read The Case of the Nazarene Reopened by Rabbi Hyman Goldin 1948. Just the examples critical of the New Testament's few uses of hebrew and aramaic will leave you in stitches for the many errors that are so tranparent.
6. Poland's Catholic Church publishes book co-authored by rabbi
R C ,   USA   (10.13.09)
I wish more Christians would read and understand Romans chapter 11 in the Bible. If they understood this chapter they would realize that G-D has used the Israelites for our salvation. I wish the Roman Catholic Pope and all other Christian Faith Leaders would help Israel restore the Temple in Jerusalem, and follow G-D’s plan. They are our spiritual brethren. Quite trying to proselyte them. Bless Israel.
Back to article