Jewish Scene
Neturei Karta: Returning Shalit not a commandment
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 19.10.09, 17:47
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
64 Talkbacks for this article
1. Ignore them
Chaim ,   Pittsburgh USA   (10.19.09)
Assuming they actually do not break the law and free speech is allowed - I can not see why the media and everyone just ignores them. They are idiots and just look for publicity. Every single Israeli soldier risks their life for all Jews everywhere - I thank each and every one of you very much.
2. OK, Neturei Karta, lets talk about Mitzvoth
Besalel ,   Great Neck, NY   (10.19.09)
How about the Mitzvah to live in Israel? The Mtzva to conqur it? And what about the commandments concerning Rodef, Neturei Karta? What about Rodef?
3. SOD THEM!
No wonder   (10.19.09)
4. naturei my ass
Alex ,   Montreal   (10.19.09)
5. and if shalit kept "mitzvoth" would THEY come to rescue him?
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (10.19.09)
of course not. they would continue doing absolutely nothing.
6. Why on earth does ynet print their garbage?
who cares   (10.19.09)
No one who reads ynet from the most secular to the religious, care what these creatures think eat smell or do. Why do you always print the stuff from these skunks when none of your readers can stand the stench. If some inhabitant of their pigsty read these columns he's a huge hypocrite( which we already know). Even Ahmajinidad, their very own dreamboat, refuses to meet with them lol
7. Throw these F**king anti Zionists out!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (10.19.09)
The leech on the land, give nothing and are just a bunch of parasites!
8. WTF
Ariel ,   São Paulo   (10.19.09)
Herem on Naturei Karta will be the solution for them
9. What world do they live in?
Miransky ,   Alabama   (10.19.09)
Gilad Shalit "eats in non-kosher restaurants"? What warped world do these Neturei Karta people live in? Who do they think protects them? Who do they think supports them?
10. ***Move all Neturei to Gaza NOW***
Yonah ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (10.19.09)
They are more their brothers than ours, and they hate living in Israel anyway. Let them all live in Gaza where they can hate us all they want.
11. NK is an Islamic cult, not a Jewish one
eddie ,   london   (10.19.09)
NK are not jews or Israelites. They are Mohameddans for Talmud. Their predecessors collaborated with the Nazis, to prevent Jews from leaving Europe, and to be killed there. They are not of any significance, and they also denied the Holocaust side by side with their sponsor, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Haredim generally dismiss them, but they dont do so publicly, as they dont wish to give a victory to secular or religious zionists. In Tehran, they sat with white supremacists, neo Nazis, and Islamic terrorists, to denounce Israel. They denied that 6 million were killed in the Shoah, claiming this was a zionist myth. There is a yiddish saying " they can go to hell".
12. i am haredi and these people make me want to puke
(10.19.09)
13. It is Wrong to Give These Fools Publicity
Aryeh ,   NY, USA   (10.19.09)
This small fringe of insane idiots deserves no publiciciy.
14. Ignore
SL ,   NY   (10.19.09)
It seems like the secular media likes to print ridiculous comments by supposed Neturei Karta members (even if there is no evidence whatsoever that these were in fact sent by NK--maybe they were sent out by a provocateur!) ... to make haredi Jews look bad, by association. However, nearly everyone realizes that these paid lackeys of Iran have no connection whatsoever with Judaism. They are at best a cult.
15. why quote these criminaly insane savages?
chaim ,   brooklyn ny   (10.19.09)
hey,YNET,would you quote a drunken wino passed out and wallowing in his own vomit on the gutter ?of course you wouldn't,so why quote these criminally insane traitorous pieces of human garbage?
16. everyone has their loonies
david ,   new york   (10.19.09)
this is a small, nutty group far outnumbered by the people who sniff glue on a daily basis. covering them detracts from the hundreds of thousands of mentally stable religious people who don't do nutty stuff. their craziness stands in oppositions to hundreds of thousands of good people
17. What a bunch of disgusting little parasites!
Etoile ,   Montreal, Canada   (10.19.09)
18. muhammad wrote their "torah" and their inbreeding
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.19.09)
has resulted in continued idiocy.
19. #11 Haredi newspapers aren't at all forgiving toward NK.
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (10.19.09)
The Haredi approach to them ranges from dismissing them as loonies to open hostility. They've long ago stopped to amaze me, as they've went beyond the lowest point they could have when they openly cooperated with those seeking to annihilate us.
20. LOONEY TUNES DANCE AT AHMENIJADS NAZI
Jae ,   Lynn US   (10.19.09)
CONFERENCE OF HOLOCAUST DENIAL. You are sick in the head. You represent the Ethics of the Jewish sages statement that Torah scholars beware of their words- because they can be life giving and affirming or poisonous and fatal. These people are poison.
21. Ship Them To Iran!
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville USA   (10.19.09)
Let the Mad Mullahs have all the Neturei Karta. They are a disgrace and an embarrassment to Jews everywhere.
22. BUT BUT WE ARE NOT LIVING IN IRAN ! RIGHT?
David Fakheri ,   Los angles   (10.19.09)
Im an Israeli with Iranian back round & I know the following comment that I'm going to give might make some of you laugh or perhaps angry but any ways I'll say it : If Israel like Iran HAD dead penalty , NOT only the Haredim would dare to do or to say or to act against the interests of the state of Israel " as they usually do ", also the other Israeli citizens like the Arab Israelis would think twice to do what they are doing daily to shake the security of our beloved country!. BUT WE ARE NOT LIVING IN IRAN ! RIGHT? David L.A
23. Netura Karta and others like them
Df ,   Beer Sheva, Israel   (10.19.09)
To My knowledge, Netura Karta followers are not citizens of Israel. At most they are permanent residents in a country that they don't recognize. There is no block in Israeli law against removing their permanent residency status and this should be done. And if they have not accepted even permanent residency status, which may be the case since they don't recognize Israel in any way, shape or form, then they are here illegally and should be deported. Pray tell why is the Interior Ministry not moving against them as they are against the foreign workers and their children ? At least the foreign workers contribute something to the country.
24. Expel them from Am Yisrael
Proud Jew ,   Israel   (10.19.09)
25. Lets have a vote to kick them out of Judaism and Israel
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.19.09)
I wonder if any lefties would vote for them just because ;)
26. these neturei rodeo clowns also do not keep any mitzvot
eli ,   haifa   (10.19.09)
They are collaborators with Nazis and circus clowns. The are not Jews, but Minim. They are worse than the secular anti-Zionist leftist traitors.
27. NK ARE NOT MY BROTHERS!!
Chaya ,   Bat Yam   (10.19.09)
Maybe they aren't even Jews!
28. Lets trade these arab loving traitors for Gilad.
Wise Saba ,   Netivot   (10.19.09)
29. A Mitzvah to Hate
Paul ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.19.09)
Trading all of the G-dless and poisonous Neturei Karta for the Holy Jewish brother Gilad would be a great contribution to the whole world. It's a great Mitzvah for anyone of decency to loathe this cult.
30. Are they kidding?
Astonished Christian ,   Germany   (10.19.09)
There's no obligation to rescue Gilad Shalit , because he has (once) eaten in a Druze restaurant? Incredible. I've never heard of something like that.
Next talkbacks
Back to article