Opinion  Nahum Barnea
What went wrong in Gaza?
Nahum Barnea
Published: 20.10.09, 09:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
31. #26 The war appair easy from ar away goggles
George ,   Canada   (10.20.09)
"Israel dropped a million leaflets,"maybe true but the question is to run and leave their target homes to where? to sea? they have no where to run from the crazy Israeli military machines didn't you think about it? 2 millions civilians locked up in an aria maybe less than the district you live.
32. naive israel is always wrong because it exists
avrom ,   bet shemesh   (10.21.09)
thus it is always and will always be condemned the facts are irrelevant
33. What you've seen there is not what we saw here
Leonardo Levinas ,   Uruguay   (10.21.09)
In most of the countries outside Israel and US, TV stations download reports from reuters, AP FP and other "famous" agencies. The 99% of what we saw in TV and press from the operation was the IDF bombing and shooting inocent people most of them small kids and using chemical wheapons. Believe me: Arab media was less antisemitic than europeans. If you compare the Israeli press against local or european press in any day during the operation you couldn't believe that it was about the same conflict. Israel Gov should understand how press network works, who pay them and should coordinate efforts with local communities in order to show the facts and not lies. This is a must for us.
34. What, went wrong? In gaza?
paul kersey ,   Kufrland, Earth   (10.21.09)
Media values went wrong. World MSM helped create the Hamas War Machine (HWM). Hamas taylors its tactics for the MSM. The MSM shows the vision the HWM wants shown. These media cretins owe Israel, the Jewish people, and the arabs, deep apologies. Showing obvious fake deaths, obvious staged events as real. Created a demand for more from the MSM, and the HWM produced, its extravagant , audio/video aid. No bunkers for noncombatant to go for safety in Gaza. Noncombatants force at gunpoint to remain in line of fire. Combatants not wearing uniforms, to distinguish them from noncombatants. Firing on the village of Sderot, where no hostilities were initiated from, to kill noncombatants, egg-on the IDF to retaliate against the HWM. The MSM helped bring this monster to life. That's what went wrong and is wrong!
35. no moral justification for Israel casualities
Ilan ,   Ariel   (10.21.09)
I think that Israel waited showed enough restraint before acting. The rocket attacks on Sderot had become intolerable long before Israel acted. Given that Hamas had mined all the main entrances the only way to proceed was to assume that all Gaza was one big booby trap. Massive fire to suppress anti-tank units was therefore justified. If the cost of world approval is Israeli acquiescence to constant attack or a high number of Israeli casualties then the world can go screw itself.
36. to 34
jojo   (10.21.09)
the wrong thqat you do not believe that there is a god .and many are like you not on gaza only but on earth
37. What went right in lebanon??
T.I.P. ,   Beirut   (10.21.09)
We kidnaped 2 of ur soldiers, gave them back as dead as ron arad, and celebrated as a nation at ur stupidity. You are supposed to have the best intelligence in the world, u got fooled! you gave us back our brave men, you got punk'd!!
38. Who Cares
prahuty ,   Salabinda, Kafnoito   (10.21.09)
The sillyness of this artlcle and all like it is beyond belief. A goy that picks up his hand has no place in this world. A goy (or a Jew foir that matter) that opens his mouth to spout false and malicious canards about the Yidden, should have it filled with the various products of human metabolism, preferably from the area between the donor's knees and the his/her navel . Have a nice day.
39. to 36 jojo
paul kersey ,   kufrland, Earth   (10.22.09)
jojo, what you said was very hateful to me. Being a Kufr, I know I am lucky to be aloud to live on your god's planet. I try to make friends with apostates and hypocrities. For they do not see me as your god does - booty- or the most vile of creatures. Truly, if gaza is populated with Kufr still, then Kufr has not been forsaken.
40. this article...
Rafi ,   US   (10.23.09)
... is as dumb as it is rambling. It is full of contradictions and inaccuracies. Bottom line: a) Given the chaotic urban guerrila warfare situation it faced, the outcome of Cast Lead was unequivocally one of Israel's major military successes. b) there are NO diplomatic victories for Israel relative to its wars... There never have been. The assumption that "shorter wars" on cue would achieve significant "diplomatic success" for Israel is illusory. In all events, I would take an effective Operation Cast Lead over a sweeter Goldstone Report anyday. c) While Israel's response in 2006 Lebanon War was disorganized, it was by no means a total failure. Hizbollah (& Lebanon due to its hosting role) paid a very heavy price.
41. Israel
rperry ,   US   (01.22.10)
Have to study Israel past, present and future. The Israelies are interesting people. Any suggestions for reading material along with the bible?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article