Jewish Scene
Chinese descendants of ancient Jewish community make aliyah
Itamar Eichner
Published: 22.10.09, 15:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
35 Talkbacks for this article
1. funny, they don't look jewish
Jean   (10.22.09)
2. they will all do that
MOhammad ,   Jerusalem   (10.22.09)
it is in our holy book ,i wish they know ...the rest of the story ...good day .
3. is there a place on this plannet
ghostq   (10.22.09)
there isn't a jewish population. just when I thought I have seen everything. so what r they sephared jews? right? they r not ashkenaz for sure. (scraching my head) someone tell me please.
4. #1 Intermarriage does that.
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (10.22.09)
The Kaifeng community observed a patriarchal rather than matriarchal line for Jewish lineage, and took local wives quite often. Further assimilation meant that, while they did observe certain of the old traditions and beliefs, they were more mainstream Chinese than Jewish by this point. Some are coming back to the old ways of their community, though, and their claim to a Jewish past is pretty solid - hence their conversion to cement their return to Jews and Judaism.
5. to # 1 Jean
blackman ,   Amsterdam   (10.22.09)
You mean Judaism is a white right? silly rabbit!
6. the woman in the pic is hot, mmm jewish women
ghostq   (10.22.09)
usually r. hey I don't descriminate.
7. Chinese Jews???
Phoenix ,   Israel   (10.22.09)
Yeah right! Even I would not mind some Japanese Women Jewish converts cause they are inteligent and hot.
8. Kaifeng
Mark ,   raanana   (10.22.09)
No 1, obviously #'s 4&5 don't know the joke.
9. To #1
cas reader   (10.22.09)
That is such a racist remark. Is there like a Jewish ' look ' ?. The fact is that most Jews of today are themselves a product of mixed ethnicities.
10. To #4
Sarah Mohammed ,   Jordan   (10.22.09)
"... and took local wives quite often..." I thought one cosidered jewish if his mother is jewish! So they're NOT really jews, are they?! and if they're jewish, then arabs are, as they're Abraham's descendants also! Isn't Ishmael his son?!
11. Nothing new - remember Eliezer Marom?
David Isarel ,   New York   (10.22.09)
The chief of Staff of the Israeli Navy in 2003 Eliezer Marom was a Chinese from his mother's side. Later he also served in other high positions until ealy this year when he resigned from his post.
12. G-d bless them and G-d bless the Jewish state of Israel
Frank ,   USA   (10.22.09)
13. Mark # 8 . You are right
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.22.09)
It's a great joke
14. Some mixed Jewish outcomes
shuebydoo ,   USA   (10.22.09)
Nina Brosh - model, Jewish-Chinese Craig David - singer, Carribean-English-Jewish Sophie Okonedo - actress, Nigerian-Jewish Ehud Olmert's parents were from China. China was a haven for the Jews fleeing persecution. javascript: save()
15. #10
Matt   (10.22.09)
They are not Jewish. The article states they are "Chinese descendants of ancient Jewish community." That is why they must go through the conversion process. They have some Jewish ancestors, but they themselves must first convert in order to become Jewish. As for Arabs, probably many of them also have Jewish ancestors. After all, when the horde of Muslim Arabs swept through the land and decimated local populations they often forced many to convert to Islam. That, and Muslim's on-going fondness for forcefully taking the daughters of minority people for their wives, means many Palestinian Arabs probably are of some Jewish descent. If they wish to renounce Islam, convert to Judaism, and embrace the Jewish state as the Chinese are doing then they are welcome to do so.
16. #15 they are not going to because
Steve ,   USA   (10.22.09)
by killing the man and taking his daughter or a wife he is demonstrating the superiority of his faith. Why do you think they burn down the Jewish synagogues or build the mosques on top of the Jewish temples? As for these Chinese joining the Jewish people, it is great.
17. the guy on the top right...
Ariel ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.23.09)
... still has very strong jewish features! Waaw! ;)
18. Matt #15
Mo ,   jerusalem   (10.23.09)
convert ??? this is a colt ,not a religion .
20. If they are Jewish descendants, why convert??
Israeli 2   (10.23.09)
21. It's really hard...
Adam Glantz ,   Herndon, VA, USA   (10.23.09)
...not to feel inspired by this story. G-D bless and protect the Chinese part of K'lal Yisrael.
22. Chinese Jews
David Levy   (10.23.09)
They are required to go through conversion because ion Kaifeng they based their Jewish lineage through the father, and not through the mother as practiced in the wider Jewish community. As such they are not recognized under the Law of Return as being Jewish, and must go through formal conversion if they wish to reside in Israel. It also gives them an opportunity to study Judaism and better understand their new home. Shavei Israel isn't the only organization who is helping them, and were assisted by another less known organization called the Association of Kaifeng Jews, which has been operating since 2004, and whose members have been working with the community long before that.
23. #17 wh? because he is on the top? or he is on the Right?
observer   (10.23.09)
24. Funny
Mikesailor ,   Miami, FL   (10.23.09)
So, Chinese 'Jews' make aliyah and are therefore immediately granted more rights and privileges thjan the Palestinians who have been living on the land for centuries. Yet, Reform and Conservative Jews are not considered to be real 'Jews' by Yishai and many other Israelis. I wonder if the Chinese will receive the same Jewish 'treatment' as the Ethiopians?
25. Racism of Chosen Jew & LDS Mormon
observer   (10.23.09)
both believe that G-d curses the black race. But, do they believe that G-d curses the Yellow race. Is it according to Halacha that Jewish lineage is not enough and formal conversion is still needed for them to be just Torah observants? I don't think the LDS Mormons would even request a born Mormon to be baptized before visiting Utah.
26. China is important for Israel
cas reader   (10.23.09)
It seems that some readers are skeptical about the Jewishness of the Kaifeng Jews. I suggest that you first read up on Kaifeng Jews on the Internet before making racist and / or stupid remarks. Secondly, it does not help to ridicule the Chinese people. China will become the 2nd largest economy in the world by end of this year, and holds the largest foreign exchange reserves in the world. China has become a true superpower. China is also a permanent member of the Security Council. Israel and diaspora Jews need to build up good relations with China, and it certainly does not help by making inappropriate jokes about the Chinese people.
27. I wish there was 70,000 and hot just 7
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (10.23.09)
28. but can they drive ?
alan ,   toronto   (10.23.09)
if not, thats ok. They will feel home with all the crazy drivers in Israel
29. All I can say....
Eli Freedman ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (10.24.09)
Is WELCOME HOME ....欢迎 欢迎 huan ying huan ying!!!! P.S. And to all the negative talkback here..GIVE IT A REST!!!
30. Jews of Kaifeng
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (10.24.09)
The Jews of Kaifeng were discovered in the 1850s by a christian missionary,who was aproched by a Jew, who took him for A Jew,because of the missionary's believe in one God,the Kaifeng Jews never met christians or Muslims before,The Chinese people called the Jews," the people who don't eat the muscle that shrank",That is in remembrance when the angel injured the socket of Jacob's hip,and changed his name from Jacob to Israel.
Next talkbacks
Back to article