News
'Taliban mom' appeals confinement conditions
Aviad Glickman
Published: 22.10.09, 15:37
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
15 Talkbacks for this article
1. If her cell "reeks"...
Malone ,   Hfx   (10.22.09)
...it's no doubt her own "BO" causing it... She should try taking a shower with her clothes off,like normal people do. Why do these nut cases keep on making the headlines?
2. Sorry, no sympathy
Sarah B ,   New York / Saviyon   (10.22.09)
for this one. Maybe she can share a cell with Marie-Charlotte Renault. Neither of them will have much of a shelf life in general population. Maybe that's not such a bad thing, either.
3. She belongs in a psychiatric ward
Shalom   (10.22.09)
Meshugganah - nowhere does Judaism say to wear multiple layers of clothes; to shower with clothes on; not to speak and that she should spend her time fasting.
4. This woman belongs in a psych ward
Joe ,   Ohio, USA   (10.22.09)
not jail, Multiple layers of clothes, a vow of silence, fasting, showering with your cloths on?! Can you spell CRAZY?
5. We have to thank the secular education system
Smith   (10.22.09)
for producing such wackoes in their public schools. These fanatics become baalei tshuvot causing the bad mouthing and stigma of all hareidim in general.
6.  Sarah B., there was an abuse case from one of YOUR kinds
(10.22.09)
here: http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3793602,00.html How come we didn’t hear from you: “Maybe she can share a cell with Marie-Charlotte Renault. Neither of them will have much of a shelf life in general population.” I get it! It is because there are so many secular parents abusing their children that you don’t even bother reading those reports. Most of the time Ynet doesn’t report it. They only reported this one because it is the least abusive from the common abuse cases in secular homes.
7. Child abusers should suffer like their children
Truthteller   (10.22.09)
This bitch is getting what she deserves. Anybody who would harm a childhood deserves to be uncomfortable and even miserable every single day. Her modestly be damned, her laundry be damned, her social needs be damned--THAT is what she handed her own children and she can go to hell!
8. No Kidding
Rav Elkohen ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.22.09)
Of course the system isn't equipped to handle her situation. The reason is abundantly clear, its because she is not following normative Judaism. She is not even following the most strict standards of Chareidi Judasim. She is in a world of her own. If there is any cause for complaint it is probably that she is not recieving adequate(if any) treatment for here severe mental ailments.
9. Her conditions better than her kids'
R   (10.22.09)
1) What has this got to do with haredi/secular? Taking every article and making it into a haredi/secular issue is the same as the TBers that take every article and make it into an Israeli/Palestinian issue. 2) Her conditions are better than the ones she gave to her own kids. She sleeps inside, has (access to) regular meals, and no one beats her. And if she doesn't want to speak, why should she be with other inmates?
10. To Sarah B.
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (10.22.09)
Since #6 brought it up, could you, please, explain what, exactly, "kind" you are?? I thought I was one of a kind and I want to check out the competition, hahahaha
11. #2
observer   (10.22.09)
You seem to be obsessed with this sort of problem. perhaps you suffer from something similar yourself? Even the worst criminal has a right to certain basic amenities.
12. Observer , no sympathy at all with child abusers
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.22.09)
If children can't rely on their parents , on whom should they ? They are defenseless , and abusing them is a crime . Did they have some pity on their children ? Did they listen to their crying ? Basic amenities ? they have it : a bed , food . But not more .
13. # 1- 12
Birdi ,   Israel   (10.22.09)
Is today Sarah bashing day ????
14. To 13
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (10.23.09)
I suggest you read #10 again, if you even read it in the first place. "Hahaha" usually connotes laughing. I'd venture to guess that Sarah understood my post and did not feel "bashed."
15. Birdi # 13 ???????
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.23.09)
Can you , or did you read ?
Back to article