News
White House urges Israel, Palestinians to resume negotiations
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 22.10.09, 23:13
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
20 Talkbacks for this article
1. In 9 short months,BHO has made a mess of the US. He will do
the same to Israel ,   if he gets a chance.   (10.22.09)
2. same old same old from the Yanks
JPS ,   Efrat   (10.23.09)
You can pick up 30 white house press releases from over the past 20 years. Each one says the exact same thing. Only this time, the Israelis are really supposed to stop construction. And pray tell us... are the Pals really going to stop incitement and shooting rockets at us? Even if we totally stop construction? Not likely. So it's more of the same old same old.
3. "BLA BLA BLA " FROM HILARIOUS
LAWRENCE RAP ARTISTE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (10.23.09)
Clinton and her boss the saviour..
4. Stop the occupation and oppression, give peace a chance
Post Liberal ,   Israel   (10.23.09)
USA occupies lands stolen* from Native Americans. Freedom to Native Americans Freedom to Native Australians Freedom to Basques Freedom to Kurdistan Freedom to Chechnya Stop oppressing Arab refugees labeled as Palestinians and kept in ghettos all around the Arab world for PR. 3rd generation of refugees, maybe time to resettle them instead of imprisonment in camps? Do Germans keep Germans in refugee camps since WW2? No. So why do Arabs keep Arabs in camps? * Can I use the word stolen or it's reserved to Israel bashers? It seems that while other nations "conquer" land, Israel always "steals" land.
5. Talking to those who want to kill you is stupid
David Middlemiss ,   Rhode Island   (10.23.09)
Ehud Barak offered Arafat just about everything he wanted and got war in return. Israel gave the Gazans all of Gaza and the Gazans voted for war. You have to be naive to believe that talking to people who want to kill you will accomplish anything.
6. o-BUM-a sez, "Israel, lay down, roll over, play dead."
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (10.23.09)
He says the same thing to his wife and she does it, so what is wrong with Israel?
7. I'm willing to bet his Nobel prize - it won't happen!
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (10.23.09)
Obama gan go in dreard arain..
8. israel should never fight the one who feeds her...
american observer ,   dc   (10.23.09)
fighting and continually disagreeing with the US is a huge strategic mistake for israel. where are the wise and rational leaders within israel??
9. Before There Can Be Talks
emanon ,   USA   (10.23.09)
The terrorstinians must recognize Israel's right to exist. Without that, the talks are meaningless.
10. America...
Eliezer ,   Jerusalem   (10.23.09)
America is getting to big for their own britches. They should keep their mouth shut. Let them give back the land that they took from the indians, the mexicans and the french.
11. Asking us, Jews, only because we are Jewish, not to reside
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (10.23.09)
in certain neighborhoods - be it of cities or of the country - amounts to pure and simple racism, anti-Jewish racism. Are Afghans who live in the US asked not to reside in North West Washington, DC? Are Iraqis requested to vacate their homes from Arlington, VA? Are black people from coast to coast told by the US government, by their black President, to remain living in their designated neighborhoods? But the "liberal" and "progressive" President of the US and his right-hand-woman, Clinton, do ask Jews, for no other reason but their Jewishness, to limit their living space in the country to certain designated areas and neighborhoods. This is nothing short of a manifestation of racism, anti-Jewish racism, and it must cease. You want to help bring peace about, you are welcome, by us at least, Jews. But ensuring that parts of the country are Jew-free, that areas are "cleansed" of their Jewish residents is not a form of peace but racism and we can't accept that.
12. White House urges Israel,
Yonatan ,   Jerusalem   (10.23.09)
what a grate leader of the so called free world cannot see passed his nose how ever did he get in the white house? a democratic novelty perhaps it should be clear by now to the whole world by now that Israel has done more than enough for a peaceful settlement with the palestinians in the end we are branded war criminals we began the peace process in good faith and what did we get in return? ill tell you mr big shot sitting in the white house we were bombed in the buses in the coffee house and in the market place and the world stood by and did nothing so mr big shot stop patronizing us get your finger out of the grate american pie and put a stop the iranian threat or do you speak persian by chance?
13. Is Obama naïve?
Ron B. ,   Lod   (10.23.09)
Obama's reference to "settlements" as "illegitimate" and an "obstacle to peace," ignores the September 2005 uprooting of all Jewish settlements from Gaza, which severely exacerbated Palestinian terrorism, triggered the December war in Gaza, paved the road to the Hamas takeover of Gaza and further eroded Israel's posture of deterrence, thus enticing Arab aggression. Life of the civilian population in the Jewish communities around Gaza became a nightmare : http://xrl.us/bfq9oi
14. Settlements in Judea, Samaria, Gaza and the whole of ...
Ron B. ,   Lod   (10.23.09)
Settlements in Judea, Samaria, Gaza and the whole of Jerusalem are legal. The “Mandate for Palestine” granted Jews the IRREVOCABLE right to settle anywhere in Palestine, the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, a right unaltered in international law and valid to this day. Settlements in Judea, Samaria (i.e., the West Bank), Gaza and the whole of Jerusalem are legal. The international community and the arabs should respect the original legitimity as described at : http://xrl.us/bjch4
15. Israel has taken the following risky steps:
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (10.23.09)
1. It enabled the PLO to send its leaders from Tunis and set up its autonomy, the Palestinian Authority (PA). 2. It enabled the PA to set up its security "police" forces and armed these forces. 3. It vacated the entire Gaza Strip of both civilians and Israel Defense Forces (IDF). 4. Shall I go on...? And what did Israel received in return so far? As early as the 1990s a wave of suicide bombings hit the Jewish civilian population of the country, not in Jenin, not in Shchem (Nablus) but in Tel-Aviv. And in 1996 the Palestinian Arab armed forces attacked and killed Israeli police forces in Jerusalem, using the arms provided with Israel's authorization. And finally, the Gaza Strip has become a launching ground for the Arabs there to relentlessly attack the civilian population of the Jewish state with weapons of terror, rockets, while enabling Iran to turn the territory and Hamas there into an Iranian advanced position in its long term goal of wiping the Jewish state of Israel off the face of earth. How many more risks should Israel take without getting a simple matter in return: Arab recognition of Israel's right to be, to exist as the nation-state of the Jewish people...??
16. Dear Mrs. Clinton,
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (10.23.09)
I urge you and Mr. Obama to resume negotiations with Al Qaeda and the Taliban. Put down your weapons and talk politely with them. Surely, they will agree to change their ways and be nice. Please show us how to be kind with terrorists....
17. re 14: A Mandates gave Jews rights but not land
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (10.23.09)
Israel agreed to honor all Ottoman/British land titles when it became a state and "A" Mandates disolved. Even under Mandates which gives RoR to Jews they still had to buy land. Israel sidestepped this by declaring refugee's lands abandon and then claim them for the state. Any new settlements since 95 are illegal under 1995 agreement which overrides Israel's laws, land can only be taken for temporary military use.
18. Israel just hailed& saluted his Emperor Obama's hat but no
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (10.23.09)
help A few days ago a ceremony, historical repetition of William Tell story in Jarusalem took place, and this time William Tell were not there! You cannot expect a brave Israeli to come out and refuse to salute video message of Obama, just like saluting Emperor's hat in absentia. Instead Jewish leader pretended as if his emperor Obama was there with them and even supporting them Now and later it is better understood it was an empty hat saluted. Who would guess William Tell story will be experienced again hundreds years later?
19. It ain't rocket science.
Holly D'Souza ,   San Francisco - USA   (10.23.09)
If the tables were turned would the Israelis endure "encroachment" and illegal settling? This isn't rocket science. The USA must put their foot down with Israel. In light of its own failing economy, the USA can not afford to continue supporting Israel. The USA has HUGE debt, karmic and otherwise. We have tormented other peoples and nations and now our own suffer. If Israel is going to continue encroaching I consider this a waste of my tax dollars in support - even in light of the illegal settlements - US support should cease. BB Netanyahu knows the settlements are illegal. There is no honesty in his voice when he talks on this subject.
20. #8: With friends like Obama Israel needs no enemies.
Jacob ,   Montreal, Canada   (10.26.09)
Back to article