Opinion
Only Jews deserve dignity?
Shulamit Aloni
Published: 26.10.09, 18:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
31. to 16
jadda ,   jerusalem   (10.27.09)
yes iam look like red indian but my grandson is white with blue eyes andgolden hair but sure both are palastiniaaaaaaaan
32. to 17
zeinab ,   sahara   (10.27.09)
for what they stole the za3tar .. tibi said it 3 times in their keneset
33. to 29
lian ,   cairo   (10.27.09)
copt are egyptians kurds are iraqi maronites are lebaneese but jews are only jews . they do not like only to be jews in america they are jews in france or germany or london or in china .. do you think about the reason ... simply they thought they have no dignity only to be jew hahaha
34. You're all missing the point...
Ron ,   L.A., USA   (10.27.09)
Forget about Left or Right in this case. This should not be able Jew, Muslim or Christian. Rather it is about humanity. Yes, Muslims start a lot of problems, but it does not justify how we Jews should descend to that kind of level. If we are indeed the "chosen" people, then we better start acting like it. Stop acting like we're entitled and start setting the example of how people ought to treat each other. These guards are a blemish to all of us!
35. A moral tragedy for the Jews
Marcos ,   Massachusetts, USA   (10.27.09)
This old Jew finds it difficult to think of anything more dishonorable than defending vicious acts by Israelis against the dignity of other human beings on the grounds that some other countries are worse. If such behavior is common among Israelis (I hope not), then it is hard to avoid the conclusion that Israel has become a moral tragedy for the Jews. The Torah says that Sodom and Gomorrah would have been saved if their population had included five just men. If Israel deserves to be saved it is because of decent human beings like Shulamit Aloni.
36. Aloni
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (10.27.09)
I disagree with Aloni's agenda too. But judge a post by its content, not the messenger. Judging the content is the act of an intelligent and reasoning person. Judging the messenger is the mark of a bigot--and we have way to many of 'em.
37. When I Hear Someone Like Marcos I Know There Is Still Hope
World Citizen ,   the world   (10.28.09)
If more righteous people of all races and creeds will stand for justice and human dignity this world can be saved.
38. To #25 Nothing to admire
Babushka ,   USA   (10.28.09)
I have followed Shulamit Baloni's career for many years. She is a hardcore Stalinist. I believe she fought in the 1948 War for Independence, not for a Jewish State, but for a Marxist Communist state. She used the word "kulaks" to describe Jewish settlers. "Kulaks" was the word used by Stalinists to dehumanize the people of Ukraine who were mass slaughtered by Communists in the 1930's. Apparently Shulamit approved of that genocide. I do not find anything to admire about this angry, bitter old hag.
39. Only Jews deserve dignity? No Way
ahyar ,   jakarta Indonesia   (10.28.09)
Frankly, In Islam Someone's Dignity is not related with his/her wealths or races or faiths/religion or skin colour but according to his/her good deeds and his/her piety to Allah,God of this universe. all people are equal before God. its funny if jews said “dignity and liberty” in the Jewish state are only reserved for Jews, this kind of narrow view must be hold by a pathetic person. so Only Jews deserve dignity? No Way
40. Wicked and evil
Yehudi ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.28.09)
All people are created in the image of God.
41. To 10 and 11
(10.30.09)
Na nanana na !!!!!!! Na nanana na !!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article