News
Gilo outraged at US demands to halt construction
Naama Lanir
Published: 17.11.09, 14:38
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
15 Talkbacks for this article
1. Obama has got to go
Charles ,   Cleveland   (11.17.09)
2012 can't come soon enough as Obama makes the world a much more dangerous place.
2. Any attempt to limit the living space of Jews, only because
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (11.17.09)
they are Jewish, anywhere on earth, let alone in the Jewish people's ancestral homeland and its capital city is purely racism, anti-Jewish racism. The fact that the "liberal" and "progressive" trio Obama-Clinton-Mitchelle is the promoter of this form of racism doesn't cleanse it. It is still a form of racism!!!
3. Ohana, I agree with you! Middle Finger should be extended
Nour ,   Palestine   (11.17.09)
to the arrogant Americans. Who said that Palestinian Arabs cant return to their lands in 1948 Palestine? Who said Jews cant live in Hebron or Schem? What arrogance! ONE STATE NOW!!!!!!!!!!! :)
4. Obamas appeasment policy caused these problems
zionist forever   (11.17.09)
Obamas arab appease the arabs attitude and hurt Israel is whats brought about all these problems. In the past the US would ask Israel for realistic concessions. Freeze settlements in certain not so politically sensetive areas of Judea & samaria. Uproot all illegal settlements etc. They have certainlu never asked Israel to stop building in Jerusalem before. Obama in his attempts to show the muslims he is on there side has been asking Israel to make concessions that Bibi couldn't deliver even if he wanted to. As a result the PA are starting to talk tough because they think they have the US on their side now and Obama will do as he is told by them. Abbas is saying full freeze of settlements including Jerusalem or there are no talks. Under Clinton or Bush he wouldn't have dared said that he would have sat down and talked and tried to get some realistic concessions out of Israel. This is also why Iran is talking so tough to the US now, they just don't have any respect or fear for America because they know they have a muslim appeaser in the White House who will never use force. If the man was presidential material he would be saying to Iran this is how its going to be you accept that or else. He would say to Abbas your going to sit down and your going to talk with Bibi no strings attached. I will try and help get you some realistic concessions bu thats all I will promise you now do as your told or I will not push Israel into anything.
5. All Americans DO NOT Agree
Christy ,   Boston, MA   (11.17.09)
The Americans who are demanding a halt to construction are the same ones who have condemned the US itself for many things. They do not reflect the views or opinions of all Americans. As an American, I say go ahead with anything Israel deems necessary to secure itself. Do what you need to do to secure Israel. Don't trust in the USA, or any man, trust in G-d alone and do what you believe He wants you to do.
6. I love you Giloites!!!!
Golan ,   Ashdod   (11.17.09)
Obama has no political capital, not internationally and not in the US.
7. Jews can live anywhere in Jerusalem. Obama, just shut up!
avraham ,   nyc   (11.17.09)
8. Nour
zionist forever   (11.17.09)
ONE STATE NOW I agree with you 100% one palestinian state its called Jordan. Its also long term the only viable option because a palestinian state will never be able to practically support itself. Its not even going to be allowed an army to defend itself.
9. NO DIFFERENCE!!
VOTING U.S. CITIZEN ,   Florence, ITALY   (11.17.09)
ALL American Presidents, not only this one, have been AGAINST Jewish sovereignty on the Land of Israel except when THEY see fit to it and when it doesn't trouble their relationship with the OPEC countries, first of all Saudi Arabia! THAT'S WHY since 1995 they ALL "waved" the implementation of the Jerusalem Embassy Act passed by 95/100 US Senators and 4/5 of the US Congress (Bush the LIAR did it 16 times in spite of his explicit and REPEATED electoral promise not to!!!). For the State Department and the White House, Saudi Arabia and Egypt are more important than Israel, and it has been so for Egypt since the '50s, and for Saudi Arabia since ARAMCO in the '20s! Jerusalem for them is occupied, just as Hebron: they want it split or internationalized just like the Vatican end the rest of the world.
10. Racism argument doesn't work at all
Basil ,   Morgantown, USA   (11.18.09)
This isn't about Jews being prevented from building because are Palestinians, Christian or Muslim, allowed to build in West or East Jerusalem? No! Are settlements built for Jews only or also the Christians and Muslims who are citizens of Israel? Is not the land also ancestrally for the Palestinians? Who is really being more anti-human and anti-Semitic? Israel or America? The Palestinians are Semites. Even if they are citizens in some cases, they can't build. Don't talk to me about this B.S. racism.
11. BUILDING IN SETTLEMENTS
Loraine ,   Monterey, CA   (11.18.09)
The amount of money the U.S. provides Israel should give it some say-so in matters regarding Israel-Palestine peace matters. The horrors of The Goldstone Report(or whatever the name) make it clear that Israel cannot be trusted regarding Palestine--bombing schools, killing 1400 people, including whole families and children. Someone has to stop Israel from being a bully (Yes, we have our own bullies in the U.S., namely the last Administration!
12. the ethnic cleansing must stop
KMansfield ,   San Francisco, CA   (11.18.09)
The palestinians have said they would not force jews out, they can become full citizens. You have got to stop letting these extremists abuse them. The US has been coddling you, and you have been coddling them for so long none of you know the difference between right and wrong anymore.
13. #11..Loraine,CA .. HIPPOCRATE, LIAR, RACSIST !!
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (11.22.09)
LORAINE, AFTER YOU GUYS MASSACRED THE NATIVE INDIANS AND STOLE THEIR LAND. YOU CREATED SETTLEMENTS ON LAND THAT WAS WON BY FORCE , MURDER, AND DISPLACING NATIVE POPULATIONS FORCING THEM ONTO " RESERVES "........ LORAINE ........ THE AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT THE U.S. " GIVES " TO ISRAEL IS SO MINISCULE COMPARED TO WHAT THEY DO AROUND THE WORLD. THE U.S SAVED GERMANY, BRITAIN, FRANCE,, KUWAIT ..ETC. U.S TROOPS PROTECT S. KOREA, THEY ARE IN IRAQ , GERMANY AND AFGHANISTAN TO MENTION A FEW. THE IRAQ WAR HAS COST THE U.S. OVER $500 BILLION IF NOT MORE. KEEPING TROOPS IN EUROPE AND OTHER PLACES COSTS BIG MONEY. COMPARE THE " AID " ISRAEL RECEIVES FROM THE U.S. TO THE VAST MONEY SPENT IN THE ABOVE COUNTRIES I MENTIONED HERE. IT IS EXTREMELY SMALL IN COMPARISON, BUT IT IS APPRECIATED. THE U.S. AND ISRAEL HAVE SOMETHING IN COMMON -- A SHARED FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY. . IT IS THE U.S . TAXPAYERS WHO HAVE SHELLED OUT $500 TO $700 BILLION FOR IRAQ, AFGHANISTAN, EUROPE, AND SO ON. I AM NOT ANTI-AMERICAN AT ALL......... I AM AGAINST ANY RASCIST LYING HIPPOCRATES LIKE YOU.
14. Building in Jerusalem
Carole63 ,   Colwyn Bay, Nth Wale   (11.25.09)
As far as I`m concerned the Israelis can build anywhere in Israel and Jerusalem has been the Jews capital since Bible times as God gave them the land of Israel(which was vastly bigger than it is now) If the wrath of God is not to be invoked they must not interfere in Jerusalem!
15. Basil 10 & Loraine 11
Pamela   (11.26.09)
Basil and Loraine There was NEVER a country called Arab palestine nor was the Land of Israel ever a Arab country for your information The Jewish people have lived contiually in the Land of Israel for over 3,000 years There was only 600,000 Arabs that left Israel in 1948 when told to by the invading Arab amies not thrown out by Israel What is completely ignored is that there was 1 Million Jewish refugees who WERE THROWN out penniless from the Arab countries The Arab refugees are the sole rsponsiblity of the Arab countries who should take them all in.
Back to article