News
Shulamit Aloni: We are a nefarious people
Naama Lanir
Published: 29.11.09, 16:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
75 Talkbacks for this article
1. granny is melodramatic and wrong
ghostq   (11.29.09)
this isn't angry mob that use violance on innocent people, and the palis r no innocents, the sucide bombing can prove that, is she forget those events time don't make people come alive, and most of the sucide came from the west bank.
2. Miss Aloni
Seth   (11.29.09)
We in Israel clearly do not want you. Your group is a small fringe group that is worthless in our society. If you don't like it, please leave. We will not miss you! I am sure eastern Europe will greet you with open arms.
3. I wonder, if Shulamit Aloni were prime minister would there
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (11.29.09)
be an Israel today that is the nation-state of the Jewish people, or rather she would have given away the state peacefully to those eager to annihilate it and erase any trace of Jewish civilization in it, and all for the sake of "peace"...??
4. Not like wine...
(11.29.09)
I suppose when some people get older they don't necessarily become refined. This women is a loony.
5. Have a happy 81st and shut up!
Dave ,   Canada   (11.29.09)
I once voted for her when she stood for womens rights. Now for many years I cringe at that memory. She was senile when she was young and become worse with age.
6. that's why the "West Bank"
bob ,   potomac md usa   (11.29.09)
that's why the "West Bank" and Gaza have lower infant mortality than most Arab countries--It's sad to see a Jewish person siding with the forces of jihad.
7. Thank you Shulamit
Micha ,   A FORMER leftist   (11.29.09)
You once again have explained to me why I was right to move to the centre and away from your Antisemitic extreme left wing. You accuse us of "murdering thousands" yet do not condemn the terrorists of Hamas for forcing Tzahal's hands after Barak...the one you condemn so....refused to defend the Negev for so long allowing Hamas to turn the lives of the Negev residents in to a living hell. YOUR left wing has already offered the PA almost everything they demanded (over 98% by even Abbas' own accounting!) and they refused! YOUR beloved PA still refuses to change its charter calling for our destruction, but to the left that is acceptable! The Left is dead for good reason: Israelis are sick and tired of our enemies within excusing every murderous attack against us. There comes a time when we must say enough is enough. As for you, perhaps you should move to a State where your Anti-Israel Antisemitic foundation would be more acceptable - perhaps Saudi, or Iran, or Switzerland, or Venezuela, or even Sweden!
8. Worse than Kristallnacht and all the others? She's deranged
Zvi   (11.29.09)
9. Wow.
J K ,   NYC, USA   (11.29.09)
I guess she summarizes the left's policies. What a fruitcake! "Surrender now" is not much of a policy as is not defending youself. She's sad about all those dead Arabs...me too...Hamas and the PA shouldn't have launched those pesky intifadas or shot thousands of missiles into Israel. If this is the cream of the left, it's no wonder Netanyahu won.
10. Aloni, please find a nice quiet retirement home
Besalel ,   Great Neck, NY   (11.29.09)
and just die.
11. too ealy to have dementia
mike1947 ,   Raanana   (11.29.09)
It's sad to see that Shulamit has such an early-onset case of severe dementia, but its true.
12. Shulamit K Aloni will you please go now
Marvin ,   Rehovot   (11.29.09)
If you think our nation is nefarious please accept my hearty and cordial invitation to leave it! In fact you can even leave this part of the world
13. Shulamit Aloni, the nefarious king, condemns her people
Bob   (11.29.09)
14. amazing aren't they the rantings of brain diseased leftists
ralph   (11.29.09)
15. Is she still around?
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.29.09)
Ship her off to Gaza to be with the people she loves so dearly and who wish us so much harm. How about a one-on-one exchange for Gilad Shalit? Hamas could appoint her Propaganda Minister. There is no one alive who better fits the role.
16. Naama Lanir, thank you for being honest with yourself...
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (11.29.09)
...and sharing that honesty and your well-written truths. Those that write with disdain for you and the facts you write about are guilty of a human failing hardest to overcome. Looking in the mirror and realizing that in all honesty, there is no righteous way to defend the indefensible. These are the same people who deny the information contained in the Goldstone Report, B'TSelem's 20th anniversary report, the wild disparity in civilians deaths inflicted upon Palestinians when compared to violence inflicted by Palestinians on Israelis. Even with incontrovertible proof, the layers of extreme denial are many and run deep. Thank you for cutting through some of them.
17. hahahahaha hee hee
martin ,   stevenage - uk   (11.29.09)
crazy? not at all. she is just another member of the looney left. perhaps she might wish to emigrate to the uk. they welcome dross like her. now repeat after me... "asylum - benefits"
18. senile old bag
janice cohen ,   jerusalem israel   (11.29.09)
the arabs deserve something better?
19. Why the extreme left is REALLY upset
Israeli ,   Haifa   (11.29.09)
Israeli banks are not affected by the usual Islamonazi excess! By tomorrow, she and her allies in Ramallah will be demanding that the Knesset divert funds from Tzahal to help bail out the Arabs. http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3811965,00.html
20. This Old bag should be tested for Dementia.
M. Duvduvani ,   Yokneam   (11.29.09)
This old bag is getting more and more senile. She should be checked for Dementia ....seriously!
21. so now what?! u're gonna call her an antisemite?! lol
Marwan ,   Amman, Jordan   (11.29.09)
she's too old to go after any political or earthly gains and she's just telling it as it is! but her people are too dumb to listen before they pay big time for their nefarious crimes.
22. Mrs Aloni, get your facts right
eddie ,   london   (11.29.09)
The Cossack pogroms was a ssytematic genocide and rape of the Jews in Easter Europe, with perhaps half a million civilian Jews having been murdered, and women systematically raped. How many settlers have raped palestinian women? I haven't heard of 1 single case. Mrs Aloni - you are entitled to your political opinion, but do not create fiction, otherwise you will grouped with Ahmadinejad et al, and they will not tolerate your kind in their society.
23. What an idiot
Rafael ,   Yerushalayim israel   (11.29.09)
24. No Excuses
Peninah ,   Israel   (11.29.09)
Aloni does not have the excuse of senile dementia. She was every bit as bad many years back, especially during the struggle for and against the wicked Oslo Accords. Passionately for them of course. I recall once during that same period she was in Germany on Yom Kippur and sent out announcements to the press to come photograph her eating lunch in a particular restaurant. No, not demented. Vile.
25. Where does she live in Israel ?
Yoni ,   Ashkelon   (11.29.09)
Does she even know where Sderot is located and how the life was for those "nefarious" resident living there ? Perhaps does she want to speak about Jerusalem jewish resident which lived in fear of bus explosion It may be ok for her selective moral.
26. The Israeli Left is crazier than the regular Left.
Etoile ,   Montreal, Canada   (11.29.09)
27. Sedition and treason
shuebydoo ,   USA   (11.29.09)
If she is found sane, does Israel have laws to try people for sedition and treason?
28. Complicity.
Ron B. ,   Lod   (11.29.09)
Those who defend the Palestinians uncritically are enablers of murder. Not just the murder of Israelis, about whom they clearly could hardly care less, but the murder of the Palestinian victims of the Palestinian terrorists. The uncritical Palestinian partisans also share responsibility for the blood of the Palestinians who die in Israeli strikes intended to stop the aggression against Israelis and Israeli cities. The Israelis living in Judea and Samaria cannot tolerate the stabbing of Jewish boys by Palestinians (Israel cannot let this go on, while the Palestinians fire more powerful rockets deeper into its territory.) These attacks are the only reason for the Israeli strikes. Those who support the Palestinian “resistance” are aiding the provocation that makes the Israeli strikes necessary. Unless they temper their support with strong and unequivocal criticism of Palestinian aggression, all their sympathy for the Palestinian people is nothing more than crocodile tears as explained at : http://xrl.us/bi5da
29. #21 So, by definition, anything that isn't based on politics
Roman ,   Lod, Israel   (11.29.09)
or self-interest is the truth? Not everything that a person says or believes, regardless of how earnest he is about what he says or believes, is worthy of consideration or respect. Karl Marx believed in his Communist Manifesto. Osama bin Laden believes in his great Jihad. Some people earnestly claim to have been abducted by aliens, and others still think that tinfoil hats protect them from secret mind control devices. I'll take a politician with a clear, sane head on his shoulders over Shulamit Aloni any day of the week. Like many of her type, she is part of a Cause, and honestly believes that she is utterly correct, and that those she is against are utterly wrong. She will never, ever let the facts confuse her. Neither will you, I suspect. Being constantly bombarded by news reports of Palestinians as victims and Israelis as evil oppressors made certain of that, didn't it, along with the great benefits pan-Arab Nationalism brought to our region?
30. :: Shulamit Aloni speaks the truth
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (11.29.09)
Shulamit Aloni speaks her mind and the truth and all that the shrill pro-Israeli posters here can do is try and belittle her and call her names. Seriously guys this got old a long time ago. Such juvenile posts only demonstrate how insecure you all are. Anyone who offers an opinion or fact that contradicts your rose-tinted woolly cocoon is subjected to a barrage of childish insults. This is beyond sad, this is pathetic.
Next talkbacks
Back to article