News
Netanyahu: Settlers are our brothers
Roni Sofer
Published: 06.12.09, 17:48
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. Settlers are our brothers...
Nili   (12.06.09)
Bibi says settlers are his / our brothers--sadly I am reminded that Qayin killed his brother Hevel. Is this what our PM is referring to? I once thought that Bibi was the right man to lead Israel into the future, sadly he is fast proving that he may well be the one to lead us to destruction.
2. bothers ?
Michael ,   Haifa   (12.06.09)
with brothers like that, i'm probably better off with cousins
3. They are not our brothers
Ussishkin ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (12.06.09)
They live in another world, in another country, believe in another faith, none of which bears any resemblance to us. To continue seeing them as "Hem Shelanu" - they are like us or they're ours - is to give them our legitimacy which they abuse and distort. They reject our laws, believe in their own version of God and see most of us as apostates. We have nothing in common with therm and its time to wake up and see that truth. Then perhaps we can act on it and against them. There;'s no nice way to deal with the devil we've nurtured.
4. Braverman is an MK? With MK's like that who needs enemies?
bezalel ,   tl aviv   (12.06.09)
Braverman said "......will be RETURNED to the PALESTINIANS" --well, firstly the so-called Palestinians never owned any land ever, so how can we "return" land to them? Secondly, the word 'Palestinian' was invesnted by the Romans after they destroyed the 2nd Temple on the Temple Mount and wanted to disconnect Jews from Israel. It remained Palestine until 1948 when the modern Stae of Israel was born. Then in 1064 Arafat reinvented the name to once again try to claim a disconnect between Jews and the land of Israel. So please, dont use the word 'Palestinian' because it means our destruction as a Jewish nation in every way. Refer to them as Arabs.
5. Netanyahu´s peace offer
Haider ,   Gothenburg, Sweden   (12.06.09)
What a joke, why then the freeze? Why don´t Israel want to live in peace with its neighbours? There are tens of millions Arabs around it and hundreds of millons Moslims too. No one is denying the existence of the State of Israel not even the Arab countries. WAKE UP ISRAEL. Leave the occupied territories. The Moslem Moores had to leave parts Spain after more that 500 years occupation. The Crusaders had to leave the Holy Land after more than 200 years. They did not belong. Most of the Jews in Israel today do not belong either. Please, don´t believe in what you have been taught about the Jews being God´s chosen people. Radical Moslims think that they are the ones chosen. Christians have a similar belief about themselves. God would not create peolpe to favour some and ignore others.
6. great!!!
Yafa ,   Palestine   (12.06.09)
so Mr biby please take your brothers to live next to you and not in the state of Palestine with many thankfull to you!!!
7. Not my brothers thankyou very much
Avi ,   Israel   (12.06.09)
Heaven forbid settler thugs in our family !
8. Where is sense in 10 months freeze ?
Roland Seener ,   London England   (12.06.09)
9. nonsense from all sides
eddie ,   london UK   (12.06.09)
Bibi has already set a precedent. Each act of submission and apepasement sets a further one for Israel to be carved up and its eventual demise. This began with Oslo. Whilst Bibi did then criticise oslo, he is now doing things which would have made rabin blush. Next, Bibi may nto be in power in 10 months from now, and his successor can only be to his left. so the freeze may well continue. As for those who hate the settlers, they are to be reminded several things. As far as the Palestinains are concerned, all Israelis are settlers. Tel aviv and Haifa were just settlement which were built before 67. After the west bank , they will as for the Galillee. And peopel like Beillin and Mofaz will peddle the idea that Galil is a virtual arab enclave anyway,so just give it up for peace. Then the Israelis inthe Galil will be the new enemeies of peace, like the settlers of today. Also, Israelis have very short term memory. Gaza was a proof of and a scientific sample of Palestinian statehood. A westbank state will be a hamas state within 3 days of independence. In fact, the IDf themselves have said there will be a takeover there if they pull out, even without a statehood. The security fence cannot protect against missiles. And the final sting: Israel's so called right to self defence. the gaza war and the Goldstoen report show that the world will not accept Israel defending itself against a west bank state. Amoz Oz used to say it is easier to break the back of a young palestinian army than of a tenager. Gaza proved him wrong. For those Israelis who stil think they are strong, think again. They will not be able to defend themselves agianst hamas, just liek they coudlnt in gaza. they will be war criminals, even in tel aviv and haifa.
10. Bibi, you have been going against the voters until now and
Shalom   (12.06.09)
suddenly you expect the citizens to believe you and trust you "that nine months and 20 days remain until the end of the temporary suspension, and this does not depend on anything other elements will do, including Abu Mazen"?
11. Jews In Yosh Are Our courageous Brothers
Roy Chweidan ,   Netanya   (12.06.09)
The Jews who live in Yehuda and Shomron are our courageous brothers. They live on, and with the IDF, protect the Heartland of Eretz Yisrael. All patriotic Jews salute them. I would always have lived there if not for my wife:s refusal. Instead I served until age 68 in the Unit of Volunteers Over the green line. My brothers in Yehuda andShomron I salute you and support you. Roy Chweidan, Netanya
12. Braverman - Know your facts first!
David ,   Shilo Israel   (12.06.09)
'Returned to the Palestinians' Since when and where is it even remotely recorded that any area in Israel including the disputed areas, belonged to a nation called Palestine that was run by indigenous Arabs i.e not Ottamon Turks etc.? The answer is absolutely never! This is an essential point as any negotiation needs to be built upon factual reality, and each side presents their own version of facts. Sadly, Braverman has seen fit to lie on behalf of the other side. That alone makes him unfit to serve Israel. Otherwise...Bibi why do we have to serve out a full term like a convicted people? Your tactics, if honorable, could be better received by 'your' voters should you seek an earlier end to this episode. You would have made your point whilst also showing that you serve your nation, Israel.
13. Settlers are your Brothers? Would never have guessed!
Shalom   (12.06.09)
Expelling YOUR BROTHERS from their rightful home, ousting YOUR BROTHERS from their rightful homes, destroying the homes of YOUR BROTHERS? And you still have the chutzpah to say with a full mouth that these are YOUR BROTHERS?
14. Terminology
Gideon Reader   (12.06.09)
braverman, Barak and numerous others have a snarky, smarmy way of using "wording" that would in my little part of this ball, get them a smack in the chops. "Break bones" "Drive from the tent", "Whip into line". there spirited comments are better suited toward a true enemy; not members of one's nation, blood and situation. Maybe it's just bad toilet training, or socialist immersion of the kibbutz kind, but certainly off putting and vastly improper and inappropriate.
15. :: Brothers?
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (12.06.09)
If this is the case I look forward to the day when the illegal settlers are removed from the Palestinian WB and reintegrated into Israeli society. For to long now these illegal settlers have lived separately from mainstream Israeli society, once they are removed to make way for the state of Palestine I’m sure Bibi and the rest of Israel will welcome them home with open arms.
16. was braverman educated?
bernard   (12.06.09)
i thought he is a university man? we cannot return the land to the pals. it never belonged to them in the first place. b4 israel controlled the land it wascontrolled by jordan! jordan waged war on israel. the pals fought for jordan. israel won period!! we may have to relinquish territort for the pals for peace. but this is not a return. it is a gift to receive a gift in return. hopefully land for peace will work. history shows that it does not, but we will try one more time.
17. Is this the way Jews treat their brothers?
Nour ,   Palestine   (12.06.09)
This evil man must be joking! Would a jew expel a fellow jew from the land of the jews? Why is Bibi and the Israeli govt. tagging them as "settlers"!? This is racist and self-hating! One state now! Don't stop building - "baby".
18. braverman-i'd like to see what you do when they come after
Randi ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (12.06.09)
hey braverman - I'd like to see what you would do if they came after your neighborhood. don't think it's so impossible. it won't be your fellow Jews, but it will be the international community that you try so hard tom please. they don't want us here, and it doesn't matter if we live in tel aviv or jerusalem or efrat or shilo.
19. NOT MY BROTHER !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
DAVID ,   JUDEA   (12.06.09)
Brothers do not sell each other out and do not interfere with the building of their homes, but help and support each other to achieve this. Bibi mentions the interest of the State of Israel, most of us know by now that the state is a separate entity that goes against its citizens to follow its own failed and sick ideology. Bibi and the state are not to be trusted and will use any trick in the book to deceive and harm is citizens, only to satisfy their own sinister agenda's. While Iran is working hard towards the A bomb Bibi and his fellow irresponsible users, focus all their energy, on division and destruction of their own “brothers” homes and communities. This sell out mentality exists in every sector of our society. The Haredi sell out their national religious brothers, the left sells out to any highest bidder, the right sells out due to their convoluted ideas and so the list goes on and on. This lack of unity will come with an enormous price tag, for which we will all pay together as usual. History has shown us this many times over, sadly we are own worst enemy, with no end in sight.
20. THIS IS A SHAME TO BROTHERHOOD .
Benjamin   (12.06.09)
21. "as it will be returned to the Palestinians eventually" what
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (12.06.09)
chutzpah, Bibi is establishing borders before negotiations? NO Bibi, NO, just plain NO. Build, Build, Build and create facts on the ground.
22. To quote a famous Congressman: "YOU LIE!!"
Debbie ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (12.06.09)
You didn't fool me, Bibi Netanyahu. I recognized your duplicitous behavior during your first go at being PM. You're as honest as a used car salesman which is what you remind me of, every time I see you. Shame on every Jew who voted for you the second time. I didn't! You and the whole gang of oligarchic thieves are on your way OUT! Better pack an emergency bag for your quick get away. The only way out of this mess is a revolution. And, I would suggest to Avi that he get out, too. Avi, YOU are the one who doesn't belong here in G-d's Land. And just you remember your whole miserable life that it was YOU who said we weren't your brothers. Truer words were never spoken. The "settlers" will be here when the rest of you, including the murderous Arabs, are long gone. There will NEVER be a State of Palestine. It's a still-born. Completely non-viable. LONG LIVE GREATER ISRAEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
23. settlers do not want brothers like bibi
zionist forever   (12.06.09)
He has sold them out and asked nothing in return from the arabs. The whole point of what will turn out to be a permament freeze not a 10 month one is being put in place to appease Obama and is a stunt to try and make Abbas look like the man who doesn't want peace. No other PM on the left or right has ever implimented a full freeze before not even Olmert, but now the right wing Bibi is. This is not only betraying the right but settlement building is one of Israels most valuable political playing cards and a freeze could be used to demand alot of concessions from the arabs but Bibi is wasting it. The right wing PM is now breaking election promise after election promise and getting away with it.
24. Yehuda ans Shomron...the last firewall protecting Israel
BJL ,   us   (12.06.09)
Israel is surrounded by Hizbollah in the North, with 50,000 missiles and Hamas in the South. And those in TA scoff at those resettling Yehuda and Shomron? The last firewall that protects Israel from the hords to the East? Those resettling Yosh are the heart and soul of Israel.
25. #15: What this PM needs to know about Mr. Obama
Steve   (12.06.09)
President B. Hussein wants to steal Jewish land in order to give it to Israel's enemies. He wants to establish yet another Muslim-killer state in the region; this one in Israel's Biblical and historic heartland. US President Hussein's brethren are Israel's enemies. PM Netanyahu is falling into Hussein's hands.
26. My BROTHER would not tell me to stop...
yeiel   (12.06.09)
building. He would support me.
27. A failure twice in one lifetime
Paul ,   J''M, Israel   (12.06.09)
How many people get to prove their are morons twice. The whole nation is disappointed in Bibi. Somewhere in our dreams we wanted to believe that a second chance would inspire this man to overcome his shameful wimpy leadership, everyone including those he is trying to impress is disappointed. Go home Bibi, you had your chances.
28. #4
Shlomo Kamra   (12.06.09)
"So please, dont use the word 'Palestinian' because it means our destruction as a Jewish nation in every way. " Good! Then I will use the word "Pallestinian" as much as I can! Destroy israel eh?
29. Israel exudes perfidy, even gleefully...
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (12.06.09)
"'Even if Abu Mazen (Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas) will come in eight months and say, 'Peace now,' we will begin building as we did before. The cabinet decision is time-limited,' the prime minister said." So lying to the American President, the American public, Abu Mazen, the Arab Street, the EU, all this helps Israel how exactly? Why even bother at all with a sham freeze, that is nothing more than an admitted lie, a freeze that does not include the most important item of all East Jerusalem, so it was never going to be enough to bring the American or Abbas fully on board, it was simply an act of perfidy. Here's how it helps. It helps the EU come to the decision that Israel must have a fair and just settlement imposed on it, and President Obama will have numerous instances of Israeli perfidy, and the Goldstone Report, with which to beat recalcitrant Congresscritters about the head and shoulders with as they try and shield Israel's impunity to the Rule of Law.
30. To @3 No they do not live in another World,BUT OURS
Kate ,   ISRAEL   (12.06.09)
You whoever you are may think of the so-called settlers(which i loath the appelation)But without them who practice faithfully what our EARLY PIONEERS have done and continue in their way by creating beautiful cities and turning the desert into a GREEN pleasant LAND. And incidently,in the majority they are secular and not all fundementalists rightist. They are of a diverse nature,and without them there would not be an ISRAEL. You are in Tel Aviv,thanks to the early pioneers who made it possible when they came in the 1800's long before the Balfour declaration was even dreamed of. This settlers are the same as those who came long before the RE-BIRTH OF ISRAEL.Or have you forgotten it. Some of you are so hurtful toward them,methinks you are behaving same as the Arabs,rather than applaud their hard working endeavour to establish the rest of Eretz Yisrael where we all Jews belong.(in case you think otherwise I live in Karkur) Duh! If you have nothing in common,then just leave them alone.Who is asking you to participate in joining them. LASTLY ALL JEWS ARE OUR BROTHERS. Together we "stand" divided we "fall". Think about it,.
Next talkbacks
Back to article