just wondering how their bible book looks like, is it in Hebrew? I think Menashe tribe were very decent people very famouse in the Bible indeed. they should go back home to Israel were they belong.

Unfortunately, the Indian government refuses to allow them to emigrate to israel! However, should they arrive, they should not be allowed to be victimized by the Haredim who will use them as fodder for their Yeshivot! They should be free to observe Judaism as they see fit like all other Israelis!

They are strangers of non jewish race and blood that want to convert in order to scape their third wold countries. Dont be impressed!

HERITAGE ......TEIR EXISTENCE HAS A BIG CONNECTION WITH BANKING LAW AND BILL OF EXCHANGE....THE JEWSIH TRADE ROUTE...INTERMARRIAGE... SILK ROUTE TO CHINA.....VERY FEW OF THEM LEFT.....I HAVE BEEN THERE TO SEE FOR MY SELF...NOW THERE IS METHODIST MISSION ACTIVE THERE, IF YOU DONT RESCUE THEM THEY WILL ASSIMILATE INTO XTIANS. IDIOTS--- RESCUE THEM !

They are lovely Jewish people. Bring them home to Israel.

I am definitely more impressed by people converting to Judaism in remote indian mountains than by Jews from Israel calling themselves by a greek godly name... Torah is always brighter than avoda zara !

My poor knowledge is that the indian governement does not forbide them to emigrate to israel but only to convert to Judaism in India, because indian law forbides proselytism. My understanding is that it is the israeli government which does not allow them to immigrate... because they are still not jewish. Israeli governement does also refuse to give them temporary visa to study and convert in Israel.

You can't judge but G-d does. Who opens the hears of Rabbis to accept. There must be a reason or reasons.