Jewish Scene
Vatican defends move on wartime pope
Associated Press
Published: 23.12.09, 14:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
13 Talkbacks for this article
1. Not this one again!
Invicta   (12.23.09)
Not this one again! The Pope is responisible for the holocaust? What exactly did the US or the British or the Russians do to help? And they, unlike the vatican, had planes that could have bombed the train lines and the marshalling centres. And what did the victims actually do to help themselves? They trudged meekly to their fate, their tormentors aided and abetted by their own kind.
2. sad state of affairs
mordechai taub ,   jerusalem   (12.23.09)
One would think that the Vatican would have the decency to wait another 30 years for this unholy act. Turning Pius into a saint only adds to the suffering of many holocaust survivors in their declining years.
3. Interesting...
Mikesailor ,   Miami, FL   (12.23.09)
I suppose the purpose of the article is to fan the embers of hatred toward Christianity in general. So the Pope wishes to beatify Pius. I don't care about the merits of Pius but I do believe it is a Catholic internal deliberation. Funny, but when a rabbi advocated killing children because they might be future threats to Istael, I don't hear the same criticism from Jews or Catholics. As to the idea that the West failed the Jews, get over it. The West was involved in WWII, not for the Jews, but for the future of humanity in general. I am always curious about that argument. Did Israel help the Cambodians when their genocide occurred? Rwanda? Darfur? If not, then stop whining.
4. POPE AN CATHOLIC- MURDER IS MURDER
BENJAMIN ,   singapore   (12.23.09)
.... YOU MURDER JEWS, YOU CANT JUSTIFY WITH SAINTHOOD ! YOUR POPE WAS ONLY INTERESTED WITH ESTABLISHING THE CATHOLIC CHURCH BUT NOT AT ALL BOTHERED WITH INJUSTICE DONE TO JEWS. SIMILARLY THE SAME WITH THE CATHOLIC ARCHBISHOP OF SINGAPORE AND THE CATHOLIC WELFARE SOCIETY AT THE WATERLOO STREET. THEY SUPPRESS THE VOICE OF TEH POOR AND NEEDY. i KNOW OF ONE CASE. STINKY !!!!!
5. mikesailor
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (12.23.09)
The difference between pius and Israel is that the murders of Jews occured in Christian states , He did'nt say anything when Jews were deported from the town where he lived ! The West was involved in a war , yes . But the murder of the Jews was a part of this war , so they could fight it too . And a Rabbi advocating the murder of children ? where ? in your head probably .
6. Pius XII
Luiz Felipe Haddad ,   Rio, Brazil   (12.24.09)
Mr. Taub, your comment was unfair. Pius XII did what he could for helping Jews from Nazist criminals. Past prejudices are harmful. A Brazilian Christian salutes you. Luiz Felipe Haddad.
7. Papism
Brod ,   USA   (12.24.09)
Papism is not Christian. It is Paganism in Christian garb. It is the Antichrist. It is "Babylon the great the mother of harlots (false churches) and the abominations of the Earth." Revelation 17:5
8. Money Talks, Vatican promoting Hitlers pope
Jorge ,   Tegucigalpa   (12.24.09)
And Ynetnews has big advertisement for Jesus in the same page, the so called free press of Israel has no limit to corrupt the nature of Israel and its people, could you imagine Corriere de la Sera advertising for Judaism or Al Hayat for Christians
9. The only way to "defend" the wartime pope
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (12.24.09)
is to open the archives . Nothing else . To 8 in Tegucigalpa , why should the corriere della sera not publish pro Jewish adds ? do you know that when you buy a newspaper , you pay only for the paper , ALL the other expenses are covered by publicity .
10. Mr. Haddad
mordechai taub ,   jerusalem   (12.24.09)
I believe that you are misinformed. Pope Pius, perhaps out of a legitimate fear of communism, was an early supporter of the nazi regime in Germany. Statements mildly condemning the mass murder of Jews were too little too late. Please read the material available on this issue on the internet. You will find that many in the Catolic leadership supported the nazi regime while quite a number of clergy, especially in France, risked their lives in order to save Jews. My late grandfather, for nearly half a century following the war, carried a picture in his pocket every day of the French priest who saved him and my grandmother.
11. Intolerance
Luiz Felipe Haddad ,   Rio, Brazil   (12.24.09)
Mr. Brod, please, respect our Catholic church, so we respect the Evangelical ones. Fundamentalism and radicalism only provoke more evil. I recommend you to read the II Vatican Council documents. I wish you a happy Christmas. Luiz Felipe Haddad.
12. Judaism, Christianity, Islam = 3 x evil nonsense
Miss Piggy ,   USA   (11.22.10)
declare the Pope ''Kermit the Frog'' for all I care...
13. "Pius' faith and Christian virtues"
tom ,   toronto, canada   (11.22.10)
pope pius stole thousands of jewish children and forcibly converted them to catholicism, under the pretence of protecting them form the nazis. that makes him a saint of the catholic church. if that is not the case, why has the vatican not yet released the documents which would identify those children and allow them to freely choose to return to their jewish origins? and "stealing jewish souls" is a very legitimate "obstacle to dialogue between jews and the catholic church"!!!
Back to article