News
Hebrew U bans 'cursed Zionist war' conference
Yaheli Moran Zelikovich
Published: 28.12.09, 22:09
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
30 Talkbacks for this article
1. So, essetially Hadash lies to the University
William ,   Israel   (12.28.09)
That's really grounds for having the student group censored but putting that aside... the university did the right thing in cancelling this event. The even was nothing more than an attempt to divide the State along sectarian lines, mostly Arab and Jew, with specific mention of "Zionist". Hadash isn't an Israeli Arab party - it's a "palestinian" party and should be censored as such.
2. :: Free speech in Israel??
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (12.28.09)
Another nail in the coffin of free speech in Israel. I guess that Operation Cast Lead is still too much of an embarrassment within Israel to discuss the matter openly. Best sweep it all under the carpet eh?
3. #2
Ellen ,   Israel/USA   (12.28.09)
Guess what--Jews aren't allowed to incite either. Try holding a conference in the US calling for the destruction of the US--you might be surprised at the results!! AND take a look at Iran if you have any doubt about the results of anti-government statements in Arab nations.
4. #2 - Matty's upset Arabs can't voice racist hate?
William ,   Israel   (12.28.09)
No matter how you define it, no group has the right within a democracy to incite violence and cause sedition - against the State or any othe group. No where is this more enshrined than in the West which, if not checked, results in Neo-Nazi groups and militias spewing racist hate. The minute the Arabs mentioned "Zionist" and not "Israeli" or "IDF", they attempted to create incitement against a group of people (non-Arabs) and exploit a racial divide.... an act that is outlawed in every democracy...even Fairport, NY
5. Matty - make yourself crfedible, use UR name
William ,   Israel   (12.28.09)
Like most israel bashers and self-righteous hatemongers, you use a pseudonym to hide your identity. Do you feel powerful hiding behind the computer screen spewing hate, the same way hamas hides behind children as they fire on civilians? Taking the name of a singer and record label is not honest, but how can I expect you to be honest with us....when you're not even honest with yourself.
6. Willima, make yourself credible, use your real name...
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (12.29.09)
...here's a clue putz. I don't see your full name anywhere, or your email address either. My name is Michael Hess and I am a Cherokee near Charlotte, North Carolina. And I have seen you lie several times, that's about it. That being said, I have never seen Matty write anything of a hateful nature, just facts and reality, so I can safely assume you are freaking insane. And according to the Goldstone Report, it was not Hamas hiding behind civilians, it was the IDF. Even the Israeli High Court had stopped them from doing so what back in 2005-2006. They went back to it though. And you'll never be able to explain away the IDF shooting Palestinians carrying white flags. Nope, you just keep making things up and keep helping Israel slide into an abyss it may never get out of.
7. :: William - #5
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (12.29.09)
Firstly to answer your question: I do not feel ‘powerful’ in any way shape or form. I am simply stating facts and my own personal opinion. Secondly, it is interesting that you mention Hamas using human shields. Let me argue that Hamas *do* use civilians as human shields. I am sure that you will agree that this is a cowardly act and can be classed as a War Crime. Now that we are in agreement let me ask you a question as you have asked me many questions today. William: Do you agree that the IDF have committed a War Crime by using Palestinian Civilians as Human Shields? William you can easily Google this subject and you will see that the Israeli court ruled that this IDF procedure and policy of using Palestinians as human shields was illegal. William the question is: have the IDF committed a war crime by using civilians as human shields. I await your answer.
8. #2 go tell the arab/muslim countries about the freedom
rachel ,   usa   (12.29.09)
of speech ....also mention "honor killings" , "female circumcision " and how about slavery and the disappearance of Christians in the Muslim world .There are so many crimes against humanity
9. #6 so How about fighting for the rights of the 1million jew
rachel ,   usa   (12.29.09)
jewish refugees kicked out of Arab countries ? a lot more than arabs who left when they were told the jews would be massacred ...Why can't jews live in Arab countries they were there first before the muslims .....
10. that dreadful war STOPPED THE DAMNED ROCKETS THOUGH
...DACON9   (12.29.09)
11. Good!
Christy ,   Boston, US   (12.29.09)
12. Free speech, "Matty Groves":
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (12.29.09)
They let you publish in an Israeli website.
13. BBSNews: So you finally identify
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (12.29.09)
yourself, Michael, after all the sleuthing already done on you. Now that let's your ex, Kandy Ringer, off the hook. I'm sure she didn't want to be associated with you, your insipidness nor your ignorance, any longer. As to your being a Cherokee, while there may be some Cherokee blood left in you, we all know that after the "Trail of Tears" and the exile of the Cherokees to the western plains left only a thin blood remnant in North Carolina. Might I suggest, however, given that you say you identify with the Cherokee people, that you read "The Education of Little Tree", the true story of a boy who grew up to become a famous storyteller in the tradition of the Cherokee people. His name is Forrest Carter. Understanding him might humanize you, Michael, save you from yourself and might even help you comprehend the endless exiles of the Jewish people, the ones you are so bent antagonizing in each and every commentary you write on Ynet and The Huffington Post as well as what you (and Kandy) used to write on your now defunct website, BBSNews and on Haaretz before you were barred.
14. BBSNews finally admits
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (12.29.09)
that he's Michael Hess and, for the first time (after he was outed, mind you) gives an email address and then tries to make a virtue out of it. At least your colleague, "Matty Groves", shows some character in refusing to admit where he resides and certainly refuses to leave an email address. But you show no character at all unless we consider your constant bullying something like "character". Is that why Kandy Ringer (formerly associated with BBSNews) left you, Michael? Come on, Mike, come clean, now that you've started the process.
15. #6 - Michael Hess....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon, IL   (12.29.09)
Citing the fictional account known as the Goldstone report. Now there's credibility. If one missle landed in Texas, there'd be a giant hole where Mexico used to be. And nobody would say a f'in thing about it. Our government had every right to do what it did to stop the thousands of missles on our civilian population. You may think killing Israelis is OK, but we don't.
16. since 1967, israel is no longer a free & democratic nation!
shmuel feigin ,   los angeles, CA   (12.29.09)
it is sad, but unfortunately true. there is no freedom and democracy in israel anymore. the illegal occupation of the palestinian west bank and palestinian east jerusalem doesn't help either!
17. You should go to Saudia Arabia
kativa ,   Canada   (12.29.09)
See how much freedom of speech is practised in the country, which is originator of Islam. There are 1000s of mosques but not a single church, temple, or any other religious place of worship. Israel is much-1000 better than any Muslim country.
18. Yes ,Free Speech in Israel
Danial ,   DC   (12.29.09)
Matty, I hope you live in a democracy. Free speech is fine, as long as you don't incite for hatred. Imagine if you were a dad and you kids walked around inciting against you, instead of respectful complaints. There is much propaganda around the world, but many of those propagandists are fools. Luckily, most people in the Israeli government and around the world are smarter than to listen to comments like yours.
19. Thank you michael
Roy Galutia ,   Selah Wa   (12.29.09)
20. GREAT POST # 6 and Matty too
USA ,   USA   (12.29.09)
tell it like it is !!!
21. to #16 if I was a mexican will USA
ghostq   (12.29.09)
except me? let me be free in the USA or that it will try to shoot me at the border.
22. LOUSY POST # 6 and Matthias too
US of Islam ,   US of Islam   (12.29.09)
tell it like it isn't !!!
23. GUYS ! YOUR ( ISRAELIS & THE ARABS) MENTALITIES ARE CURSED..
.. LIKE JERUSALEM ,   ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (12.29.09)
IN THE BEGINNING, ONLY THE JEWS HAD HONOR WITH THE CURSE. than A MAGIC HAPPENED, AND THE JEWS TOOK THE ARABS TO JOIN UNITY OF THE CURSE. JERUSALEM IS CURSED TOO. LOOK NO PEACE THERE. THE PRAYER HOUSE HAS ONLY THE WALLS LEFT. ps: The Arabs also closed their books. they become blind and idiot. THIS CALLED CURSE.
24. ONLY ME IS OKAY, AROUND.
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (12.29.09)
25. Please IGNORE THEM
Mary Beth   (12.29.09)
Matty and others like him use these tbs to vent their hatred and spread their twisted versions of the situation. Ignoring them will be beneficial. Sometimes no response is MUCH stronger. Don't let them have the opportunity to write more and more nonsense. Ignore them, frustrate them and don't even open their tbs. It works. We love Israel!!!!
26. "Free speech" #2? Walk into iran or saudi arabia with a
Bunnie Meyer ,   Los Angeles, CA USA   (12.29.09)
bible and get your head cut off. At least ynet believes in free speech but if it had to have at least the hope of a glimmer of truth, you wouldn't be posted again.
27. Don'
Kim ,   Australiar   (12.29.09)
28. No more complaints about BDS suppressing freeom of speech
Kim ,   Australia   (12.29.09)
Israeli critics of the Boycott Divestment and Sanctions campaign spuriously complain that BDS stifles "free speech", but they conveniently leave out the fact that Israeli universities and the Israeli state regularly stifle dissent on their own campus (with this incident being just one example) and regularly repress Palestinian universities and Palestinian students preventing them from getting a proper education at their own institutes and stifling their freedom of speech. Israeli hypocrisy on show once again...
29. #28 Incitement is not "free speech"
Cynthia ,   USA   (12.29.09)
Universities and colleges have the autonomy and responsibility to decide what classes and conferences are appropriate to sponsor. This was deemed inappropriate. Boycott Divestment and Sanction campaigns discriminate only against Israelis. Singling people out based on religion and country of origin is a form of racism. Israel does not control Palestinian universities or prevent Palestinians from getting an education. In fact, many attend Israeli universities.
30. This is Great
Leon ,   Ottawa, Canada   (12.29.09)
The only 'democracy' in the Middle East shutting down criticism on the 'principles' of incitement against Israel. Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Jordan will soon be ready to welcome Israel to the club.
Back to article