News
Neturei Karta spend Shabbat in Gaza
Associated Press
Published: 02.01.10, 22:02
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
31. I....I...Rrr!!...OH I AM SO MAD I'M SPEECHLESS!!!!!
(01.03.10)
32. Chilul Hashem! To stand with those who kill their brothers?!
L ,   Elad, Israel   (01.03.10)
As an "Ultra Orthodox" (If that idiotic pigeonholing descriptive must be used) person myself, I am glad that the AP at least had the decency to include the disclaimer that they are "mostly shunned by mainstream Judaism" -- they are also dismissed as total nudniks by most of non-mainstream Judaism as well, so no rants about "all those Haredim" please!
33. they dont even care about philistine cause
zionist forever   (01.03.10)
They have latched onto the philistine cause and used it as an excuse to try an delegitimize Israel and its right to exist in any shape or form. If China said that Israel was historically theirs and that the Chinese were there long before the jews came then this bunch would have been spending Shabbat in China saying how they support the Chinese cause to liberate what was their home before the zionists came along. There is nothing they would have loved to see more than in 1973 to have seen Israel defeated and the arabs killing people. Then they could have said look on Yom Kippur of all days Israel was invaded and the zionist soldiers were being killed doesn't this prove that we are right & G-D just not want jews living in this land until the messiah comes. If Iran said that if the jews stay in this land we will nuke Israel but if the jews leave then we won't NK would be saying leave now this is a sign but if you choose to ignore it then I hope G-D forgives you for getting yourselves nuked. If somebody has an excuse why jews should not be living in Israel and says they must be driven out then these NK leaches will grasp onto it because its good for their cause. They are the lowest of the low when it comes to judaism because they call themselves righteous but they spend their Shabbat organizing political protests based on hate, Abroad they are out in the streets carrying banners even on Shabbats even though its forbidden. They don't have Israeli citizenship so we are not obligated to let them back so leave them in Hamastan with their philistine friends where they will be much happier.
34. @5 "...he yaanee god....."
er der   (01.03.10)
I think you meant to say 'allah', right rashid, my friend? ;^)
35. Even Satmar are against NK
Shalom Hartman   (01.03.10)
There is no-one worse than a self-hating Jew. A "secular-lefty" can be forgiven to a certain extent, because he was raised with non-Torah values. A "NK" cannot be forgiven because they are total "rasha'im!
36. there is no real jew, only a
m&m   (01.03.10)
divised and lost jewish people.
37. Are they bringing back Shalit? ... oh I forgot.
(01.03.10)
38. These attention queens always get media space
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (01.03.10)
What is it with this tiny clique of attention queens? They always get the spotlight! Maybe "Code Pink" and PETA should wear streimels. I'd like to see a hot PETA babe wearing nothing but a streimel. The saggy bags of Code Pink, not so much.
39. #3: Real Jews
David ,   Austin, Texas   (01.03.10)
Neturei Karta might be "Jews", but that doesn't disqualify all others as fake Jews. I think I am more proud to be Jewish than those whiny anti-Zionists. And, if you really think that NK are the real Jews, then what are you doing, Moshe, in Israel? Aren't you supposed to be waiting on the Messiah? Or, are you one of those whiny Hassidic Jews who live off the state, and then denounce it in every possible way, making other Haredi Jews look bad.
40. Neturei Karta in Gaza-Leave them there(end)
DT ,   TA Israel   (01.03.10)
41. Traitors
(01.03.10)
betraying the Jewish people and the Jewish homeland. Let them stay there.
42. don't let any of them into Israel ...
rachel ,   usa   (01.03.10)
43. Don't let them back into Eretz Yisroel.
Wise Saba ,   Netivot   (01.03.10)
44. ( LOL#38 Good point! Except the PETA folk wouldn't wear fur)
(01.03.10)
45. Sick'Os
israel   (01.03.10)
Why are they let back in the country?
46. #7 is Gaza occupied?
observer   (01.03.10)
47. nk spend shabbat in gaza
debbie ,   israel   (01.03.10)
These are the same crazy people who went to Iran to sympathize with Ahmadinajad and hold his hand. I say once they cross into Gaza to spend Shabbat with their cronies, they should not be allowed back into Israel. Let them live there for a while and soak in what it's like to live under Hamas rulers. Perhaps then they won't be such Israel bashers, and so Hamas loving. And also, isn't this against the law?
48. to #46 nop Hamas controll Gaza ence she isn't.
ghostq   (01.03.10)
49. Neturei Karta in Iran and Gaza
Max Schick ,   Sion-Switzerland   (01.03.10)
These guys are called in The Gemara "Rodef" and are in fact liable to death penalty. Since we are not in the times of the Beth hamikdash, the only thing I could suggest to Israel, is, not to let them in again ever. Let them stay in Gaza, until one day they'll find out how it is to live among Arabs...
50. naturei karta: look as idiots, speak as idiots
black sabbath   (01.03.10)
should be idiots.
51. NK in Gaza
Max Schick ,   Sion-Switzerland   (01.03.10)
Israel is unfortunately a country in constant state of war. In every country in the world, even in peace time, there are unthinkable things that no government or population can or would accept. It's about time that MK's who hate and bash Israel, or disguised Jew-haters like NK should be punishable by law.
52. Betrayal
Yakov   (01.03.10)
I'ts really sorry to see these people there. It's bad enough that they go to Gaza with an enemy as Hamas. Seeing a picture of a man during Shabbat prayers and also wearing a Pali flag is revolting. Not only that, it is a slap in the face to those who give of their life and time towards the development of Israel and Jewish people within it.
53. NK
poppy   (01.03.10)
DONT THEY HAVE TO GO THROUGH A CHECK POINT TO GET TO GAZA???? IF SO DONT LET THEM BACK INTO ISRAEL THE LAND THEY SAY DOES NOT EXCIST
54. Neturei Karta
LOLLY   (01.03.10)
A QUESTION FOR THE PM IF YOU DONT ALLOW TERRORISTS INTO ISRAEL HOW DO YOU ALLOW MEMBERS OF THE NK TO COME BACK FROM GAZA?????
55. I wonder how they got Kosher food - or is that also unnecess
rebecca ,   Modiin   (01.03.10)
or is that also unnecessary until the Meshiach comes.
56. #1 & #3
Daniel ,   Cleveland   (01.03.10)
Let your fate be equal to theirs you traitors of the Jewish People sicken any true lover of Torah and Eretz Israel, may your names be erased for eternity"
57. NK: Israeli Seculars' Ally
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (01.03.10)
Most of you seem not to have given much thought to why NK receives so much media attention… and where. Outside of the Arab & Muslim world, foreign media make only a passing, mostly disinterested (yawn), mention. But in Israel, the secular media heralds it to the rooftops. The Arab & M8uslim interest is obvious, but what explains this the Israeli secular media's obsession with heralding it to the rooftops with maximum coverage? Orthodox and secular Israelis alike are repulsed by NK's treasonous consorting with Israel's enemy. What can be gained by giving NT this maximum platform? And by whom? Clearly, the product of the media attention is smearing all Orthodox Jews as fanatics tending to identify with Israel's enemies. The result is that most Orthodox furiously try to distance themselves from the NK while the secular Israelis view it as more evidence that "the religious" are the enemy. This is the most compelling and illuminating reason for the predominantly Israeli secular political and media insistence on heralding the infamy of NK. Otherwise, they would have no significant impact. Misojudaic seculars who publicize their prized example of "religious fanatics" to the rooftops are mindless hypocrites for then throwing rocks at them. If they were serious about combating NK they would, first of all, limit coverage of them to about 2 informative sentences--like most of the foreign media does--and then ignore them… instead of publicizing them with glaring headlines. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer (& Orthodox Jew) Advocate for Logic as Hermeneutic Halakhic Authority Welcoming All Torah-reverers (Jews & non-Jews) www.netzarim.co.il
58. Traitors
Ashamed ,   Israel   (01.03.10)
Do not allow them to enter Israel. Let them stay in Gaza with their wonderful friends.
59. leave them there
Duchess   (01.03.10)
perfect solution. They don't recognize Israel so why should they live here? Let them live in Gaza. We don't want them back!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article