News
Iraq to sue Israel over destroyed reactor
Roee Nahmias
Published: 05.01.10, 15:51
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
68 Talkbacks for this article
1. What a stupid idiot. This guy deserves Saddam
Scott ,   Australia   (01.05.10)
...and what about the Scuds actually fired upon Israeli civilians during the Gulf war 9 years later? No mention of that.
2. We have a counter suit just waiting for this
Yuval ,   Panama City, Panama   (01.05.10)
Enough scuds rained in Israel in 91 without any provocation
3. this again it's not the first time
ghostq   (01.05.10)
they tried it before about 5 or 6 years ago, but the dumb dumbs always forgets that they will have to admit they had illegal nuclear program and in the end sadam prosecution was in the right place. lol when arab look for pointless scap goat revang they do the most idiotic things. mmm
4. Sorry, but
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.05.10)
the statute of limitations has expired. On the other hand, the statute of limitations for murder continues in perpetuity. In 1969, nine Iraqi Jews were hanged in public, supposedly for espionage, although the real reason was Israel's victory in the Six Day War. For more about Jewish claims against Iraq, please read here: http://www.jewishfederations.org/page.aspx?id=43353
5. Sue 'em
PW ,   Virginia USA   (01.05.10)
simple sue Iraq for supporting terrorism. The evidence, $25,000 given to families of terrorists. One count for each attack, one for each attempt and many for each individual and property loss. Should be a tidy sum
6. Can we sue Iraq for forcing Jews to leave?
Historical Observer ,   USA   (01.05.10)
This is wonderful news if they clear the way for a lawsuit over the reactor. The amount of compensation for families that left Baghdad in the 1950's will be enormous!
7. sure
Dude ,   USA   (01.05.10)
as Israel sues for Iraq invasion of Israel in 1948 and missiles etc in 2000, and property and loss of earnings from evicting its Jews.
8. Would it be value at the time or current cost to rebuild?
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (01.05.10)
Even if Israel lost this case it would take years to go thought the courts. The question is if they build another reactor will Israel bomb it too?
9. IRAK DOES NOT DENIE ITSELF !!!.
Arn-Orao. ,   Sweden-Srbia.   (01.05.10)
IT WILL GO TO DESTRUCTION , WITH SYRIA AND TURKEY, IN THE GREAT AND TERRIBLE DAY OF JEHOVAH. GO TO HELL IRAK. An-Orao.
10. to #8 they will have to sue your country
ghostq   (01.05.10)
first, USA got direct link to Iraq situation, so start paying your money for lawyers, cause in the Gulf war the americans were the first to reaport for duty be carefull what you imagin.
11. To: No. 8
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.05.10)
It isn't going to be rebuilt. Iraq remains formally at war with Israel, and Israel has existential issues with its neighbors and sworn foes developing nuclear capacity. However, if Iraq does sue, there is nothing to stop Israel for suing Iraq for damage to property incurred when Saddam launched all those SCUDs at Israel in 1991/1992. Not to mention suing Iraq on behalf of the Jewish people who were forced to flee and not permitted to take their property or bank accounts. There are always two sides to every coin. What do you want to bet that Israel and Jewish interests would come out ahead in any lawsuits, purely on the basis of the damages incurred? Even if Iraq abandons the suit, there is nothing to keep Israel and Iraqi Jews from pursuing their very valid claims, now is there? Al-Maliki may discover, much to his dismay, that he has opened a Pandora's Box that cannot now be closed; very much to the detriment of Iraq. Oh well.
12. How Israel should respond
Eitan ,   Chicago, USA   (01.05.10)
First, Israel should bring forth a civil suit seeking damages for the millions of Iraqi Jews forced, or compelled via economic strangulation, to flee that country in the 1940s and 1950s, with claims per family based on anti-Semitic firings, property confiscation, and the attendant requirement that emigres sell any remaining property in Iraq at fire-sale prices. Secondly, Israel should launch criminal proceedings against still-alive terrorists and their financiers in Iraq who aided in perpetrating such abominable attacks as the Misgav Am nursery massacre. If the Iraqis want to play this game, it will cost them every penny, until they can no longer afford the educated foreigners that run their energy sector. Their newly rediscovered, Arab trust-fund kid lifestyle will be over as soon as it has started.
13. As valid as Egypt's claim against the Jews of the Exodus
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (01.05.10)
A few years ago, some Egyptian proposed to sue the world's Jews for the "wealth of Egypt" they took with them as they left the land in the time of Moses. There appears to be a form of congenital madness among the Arabs that emerges where Jews and Israel are concerned. We owe Iraq nothing. It is *they* who owe both the former Jewish residents of Iraq for despoiling and driving them out of the country, and Israel against whom they've waged war over the decades.
14. Israel should sue them back for being involved in the wars
Wonderer   (01.05.10)
meant to destroy Israel
15. Dead proposal
sam   (01.05.10)
It will not even attract pity from reasonable people rather hate from those countries helping you now.
16. Yeah Right...
Gershon ,   London UK   (01.05.10)
Israel should also sue for all the damage - to buildings and to people (physical and psychological)- by the unprovoked scud attacks in 1991 Gulf War. I think the difference would mean many millions to Israel.
17. FOR THAT THEY GOT RID OF SADDAM?
stude ham   (01.05.10)
don't these babylonians have more important things to do?? like preventing homicide bombers from killing off their population?
18. Lebnan must also sue for 6B USD destruction Israel caused
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (01.05.10)
Goldstone to Lebonan please your reports are wanted there Lebonan should immediately start a suit on the basis of excesive force used against Lebonan and unnecessary destruction of Civillian facilities, and civilian life Mediterenian Countries should sue Israel for Environmental destruction cause by Israeli bombing fuel depot and leakage to Mediterenian! Do not stop go ahead!
19. Next Iraq will sue US for Capturing Saddam
(01.05.10)
20. Sue Iraq for 39 Scuds!
Tovia ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (01.05.10)
Sue Iraq for Saddam's 39 scud missiles which were deliberately launched against Israel, and for the suicide bombing for which Saddam paid $25,000 each. We are talking big $$$
21. perhaps we should sue because Saddam...
(01.05.10)
supported and aided in terror by giving the families of terrorists $20,000 each
22. Ok then...
Lior ,   Israel   (01.05.10)
This is what the blood and money of the U.S went to support: YET ANOTHER MONSTER Jew hating, Israel bashing leader with no appreciation. Make no mistake, Iraq is a phony democracy for no democratic leader would turn around and bite the hand which feeds them. This is not only a slap to the U.S but a huge wake up call to Israel that we have little if any friends.
23. What does Israel owe Egypt Syria RIGHT ???
M. S. ,   mpls america   (01.05.10)
I realize by the same token Egypt and so Syria may sue Israel for damages done to their own military systems respectively during and so from the 1973 middle east war RIGHT legal logic to Arabs is some thing else again and so I would pay what $ 130 million dollars but I am not Israel I doubt they would pay would the United Nations use utilize military force to make Israel pay RIGHT ??? Thank You... M. S.
24. Counter sue them
Sagi   (01.05.10)
for the interminable damage done to Israel and The Jewish People perpetrated by a notorious Iraqi called Salah A Din Yusuf Ibn Ayub and his hordes.
25. UN will agree !
DT ,   TA Israel   (01.05.10)
Things have well passed the absurd ! Should sue the US for invading Iraq
26. Small change
Uzziel   (01.05.10)
Irak and Israel were technically in state of war but even if by today´s standards when everything is valid to harass Israel regardless of laws and justice the reparation would be small change compared to what the Irakis stole to the Iraki jews in the 50s and 60s. The jews owned 80% of Bagdad´s real state, that alone would worth more than 10 billion dollars. Go! Open the Pandora Box...
27. Lets ALL use Arab Logic
Bob ,   Canada   (01.05.10)
Israel should sue Iraq for the cost of the fuel and the bombs that Israel used to destroy that reactor in 1981. In addition Israel should submit the time and hours and salaries wasted and dedicated to plan out the attack. Last but not least sue Iraq for all the wasted Newspapers space dedicated for the criticism of Sadam Hussein and his cohorts.
28. #18- Tayfun_in the glass house.
Uzziel   (01.05.10)
Just wait for those legal precedents and then prepare to sell your country in order to pay for the Armenian genocide + the unlawful northern cyprus invasion + the summary executions of the 80s and 90s in the Turkish occupied kurdish cities to begin with...
29. I hope this is merely for domestic Iraqi political purposes
AlexB ,   Toronto, Canada   (01.05.10)
...because on the international stage it will make Maliki look like a doofus. It's just so damn stupid!
30. Take out insurance policy
eddie ,   london UK   (01.05.10)
Israel could get a comprehensive Insurance policy, for such claims, valid all countries, including Iran!
Next talkbacks
Back to article