News
Israeli hospital in Haiti ends operations
Noam Barkan
Published: 26.01.10, 00:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
50 Talkbacks for this article
31. Cameron -Tell us how much you donated.Be honest for a change
Alan ,   SA   (01.26.10)
32. to #26 :)
ghostq   (01.26.10)
I tought you well lil grasshoper(giggle Duh :P), now back to the subject, Technical issues r just excuses cause Mexico was there saving lives and trust me some Arab counties r stinking rich, if you have enough money to build the most tall tower in the world you surly have enough money for rescue aquipment that usually is generator simple building driller elastic ropes and concrete hammer, you don't need high teck for saving human lives, stop making excusses, and thanks I will try my best to enjoy the rest of the day. you should do the same.
33. :: PR exercise
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (01.26.10)
"We can sum up by saying that we had three missions: Saving lives, providing medical services, and representing the State of Israel honorably" I think this sums it up quite well. Israel’s third agenda was to use the Haiti disaster as PR to try and repair Israel’s tattered international image. Can anyone give me an example of another country that has produced something like this: idfspokesperson.com Can anyone name one other country that is using the devastation in Haiti to try and highlight its ‘good will to its fellow man’ as much as Israel? In truth I have not come across one other country that is using crisis in Haiti as ‘Good PR’. I fully thank the Israeli mission in Haiti for all the good work that they have done and the lives that they have saved. Credit where credit is due they did a fine job and were one of the first on the scene. I also fully condemn Saudi Arabia/Egypt for not lifting a finger; I think that their Government’s indifference is appalling. However I will not abide by Israel or any other nation using a travesty like the disaster in Haiti for its own benefit. I would give credit to the Israel spin doctors as they succeeded in Israel’s third agenda (to get mention of Israel’s mission in Haiti in as many media releases as possible) but as none of the other nations involved in this Humanitarian Relief effort were trying to use Haiti as a PR stunt the Israeli spin doctors didn’t have a hard time. The really sad part of this saga is that the Israeli mission in Haiti will be returning soon and not one of them will be asked to go to the Gaza Strip and help the 1.5m people (half of whom are children) who are injured/maimed/made homeless/etc after last years attack. If Israel wants to win this PR battle it must first deal with the brutalized/occupied and oppressed people on its own doorstep ie: the Palestinians.
34. to #27 do you even listen to yourself
ghostq   (01.26.10)
if USA realy cared about that country it would have helped them before any quake, the only reason you do that cause you don't want them at your back yard, and since president nobama took care of his family from Kenya but not willing to really help these people, stop accusing others of ego cause you r not super power anymore, you manneged to screw up around the world in so many ways including dealing with NATO in the last 5 years. you r not all mighty ant the last friends around the would you push away, europ or other places don't like it when the USA act as if the europ is USA territory. so get reall.
35. cameron 27
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.26.10)
For you , even if we stayed there for years, it would not be enouigh . If EVERY country had contributed as MUCH as Israel has done , and proportionally to their wealth or populations , then you could say something . WE have done MUCH more than any other country , proportionally to our population and wealth . Has your country's mission gave surgery to 12,000 Haitians ? Delivered 600+ babies ? Saved 40,000 lives ? Not at all . So SHUT up .
36. # 35
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.26.10)
Charles, 16 babies were delivered by the Israel medical team in Haiti, not 600. 314 surgeries were performed not 1,200. The IDF's hospital treated 1,102 Haitians.
37. Why Alan, I donated exactly the same amount you did
Cameron ,   USA   (01.26.10)
If I were a prosperous state with an awful, international image, and reputation that badly needed a PR boost, I would've contributed a great deal more. Can I pat myself on the back too as a citizen of nation that will assume the burden of aiding & rebuilding a collapsed basketcase for the long years ahead, when other states out there made a symbolic contribution, and then pissed off into the horizon as quickly as possile?
38. In and out, like a thunderbolt, eh Charles?
Cameron ,   USA   (01.26.10)
Like a flash in the pan! The emergency hospital that mysteriously disappeared as quickly as it was erected. The Hatians will doubtless puzzle over this one The Yanks will prove a bit more long-term, and consistent, methinks.
39. to #37 you don't know exactly how much
ghostq   (01.26.10)
nice one, anyway as for PR yours went down the drain when Nobama send more and more troops to Afganistan without checking what's really going on there, as we alll know Nobama favorite way of doing things is by remote controll. and news flash USA didn't have field hospital, go check it up. the realy bad cases they send to the Israeli team, most of the staff were army man but no civilians. Israel team combined CSI team as well(sad to say it but it's true. go cheack it.
40. Birdi ???
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.26.10)
I asked if HIS country hospital had delivered 40 times more babies [ as US pop is approx 40 X greater ] as the IDF one .
41. Cameron , a thunderbolt that saved
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.26.10)
More than 1000 Haitian's lives , operated more than 300 of them , and delivered 16 Babies . Remember that the USA rescue team brought people they saved to the IDF field hospital , because their's was not functioning or incapable to provide the necessary medical care . POOR LOSER !
42. 33 , matty grovel
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.26.10)
The IDF hospital was there first of all to SAVE people in NEED . And indeed , they represented what the Israeli can do as NO other can [ with the possibilities we have ] : To help people when they are in need . Your last sentence : We can't help people who refuse it or who's only goal is to destroy us .
43. # 40
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.26.10)
Pardon me Charles.
44. Pathetic
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.26.10)
Haiti is all about many nations extending whatever aid they could/can provide to the devastated Haitian people. Does it really matter which nation did what, did more, provided less, provided more? Why all the mud slinging here? The fact of the matter was/is that each nation helped in their own way. Lets not behave like little kids here.
45. Hey Cameron, you live in the USA&so close to Haiti.Please
tell all of us.Did ,   YOU go to help out??   (01.26.10)
46. What About the FIRST First Responders?
JoeP ,   Usa   (01.27.10)
Both Cuba and Venezuela were in Haiti standing up hospitals before the Israelis ---- and also kind of importantly, these 2 countries will continue to foot their own bills, where I as an American will pay taxes for Israelis to have been there.
47. Leaving so soon?
Mega ,   Tel Aviv   (01.27.10)
"The cameras are going, and so are we."
48. so the media is gone...
freedomforllife ,   australia   (01.27.10)
.....and so is Israel. What a suprise.
49. Israelis checking out?
robertsgt40 ,   san antonio tx usa   (01.28.10)
Even a Japanese whaling ship has to go home when the boat's full. Probably have more organs than they know what to do with. The international market will be flooded.
50. Isreal verses US
pam ,   USA   (02.02.10)
How dare we Americans say anything about the timing of the Isreali team leaving. No matter what, they were there first, ready with all that they had. They worked hard during the days of "waiting for others to showup" and when relief came, they can now rest. Please USA, compare the land mass of the USA to the land mass of Isreal, compare the number of American states/citites/hospitals/physicians/nurses, etc to Israel. Pound for pound, ounce for ounce, Israel is truely GREAT. As the Christian Holy Bible says, G-d loves those who give greatly from all that they dont have than the crumbs from all that they do (paraphrasing). G-d Bless Israel and pray that G-d bless the USA as we honor G-ds people. pam
Previous talkbacks
Back to article