News
FM: Assad's regime will collapse if he provokes Israel
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 04.02.10, 10:50
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
58 Talkbacks for this article
1. Lieberman wishes to scold Moallem's like DA did Celikkol
lydia ,   Bribane   (02.04.10)
2. Calling for the bombing of Israeli civilian population by...
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (02.04.10)
...the foreign minister of Syria, for the commitment of crimes against humanity by a UN member state against the civilian population of another UN member state should have brought the UN and its various agencies to sound a major protest. But the UN of course is silent, as is the UN Human Rights Council, the one that sent Goldstone to find Israel guilty before an investigation even took place. The reason: Israel is the national home of a singled out people, of the Jewish people, and the mass murder of Jews in the eyes of some appear to be acceptable... still.
3. A thug turned minister, only in the zionist entity
Pat ,   United states   (02.04.10)
4. No Return of Golan = No peace
David ,   USA   (02.04.10)
Simple as that. If Israel is unwilling to return the Golan, then there is nothing to talk about with Syria.
5. Lieberman
Tom ,   US   (02.04.10)
is a plain speaker . Good for him. He does not take crap from Syria . He makes a good point about oil prices when -IF Iran goes nuke under the current regime.
6. Imbecile people elect imbecile governament
Sami ,   Lebanon   (02.04.10)
Lieberman is a clear example how much the political system in Israel is irrational and sick! .It is the case when political oriental bazaar, with its bargain and discount deal replace the democratic election of the better people representative bringing a discount politician to the power to complete the quota.
7. Lieberman Tells It As It Is
Avraham ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (02.04.10)
Why are we on the Golan Heights at all? Because in 1967 Syria attacked us, together with Jordan and Egypt. They did it again (without Jordan) in 1973. Syria has never expressed regret about starting 2 wars with us, has never expressed a deep desire for peace, only a demand to return what they lost in wars they started. In addition, Syria is fuelling all the fires in Lebanon. Only a fool would relinquish the Golan Heights under such circumstances.
8. ...and as for the Golan, please note the pattern:
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (02.04.10)
Syria used the Golan in 1948 from which to launch its war of annihilation against the just proclaimed state of Israel. It did so as part of a much larger coalition of Arab states, and failed. Syria used the Golan in 1967 from which to initiate the Six-Day War whose goal was to accomplish that which the coalition of Arab states failed to do 19 years earlier: wipe Israel off the face of earth and with it its Jewish population and all traces of Jewish civilization of which Israel has been its cradle and sustainer. Syria, together with Egypt, attempted in 1973 to do what they failed twice before, doing it once again by launching the Yom Kippur war from the Syrian part of the Golan. Syria, for some time now, has been part of the Iran-Hizballah-IslamicJihad-Hamas-Syria coalition whose declared goal is to wipe Israel off the map, while the Golan should provide it with the means from which to launch such an act of aggression. Therefore, only a fool would expect Israel to provide Syria with the means with which to attack it. If the Syrians want peace, they should talk with us, Israeli directly, and through talk and negotiation should reach an accommodation of peaceful coexistence: peace for peace. We, Israelis, are eager to reach such an accommodation. Are the Syrians...??
9. 4#, Does America have peace with Mexico?
Judah ,   Golan Heights,ISRAEL   (02.04.10)
10. Lieberman is 100% right - No return of Golan!!!
Israeli   (02.04.10)
& Syrians should immediately stop threatening Israel. Do not forget, Mualem, you are not dealing with a stupid sheep like Olmert anymore... Hopefully soon ynet will translate Dr. Guy Behor's article about Asad's intentions for the Golan if Israel is stupid enough to give it to them for false arab type "peace".
11. Only in Israel
Observer   (02.04.10)
A bouncer of a night club and from Moldavia becomes a Foreign Minister of a zionist entity! Root of the problem indeed
12. Why on earth would we return the Golan?
Vered, Israel   (02.04.10)
It was won fair and square in a defensive war. If nations that start wars have no fear that they will lose the land from which the attack was started, what is their motivation for maintaining peace?
13. Thank you Mr Liberman.
Arthur ,   SF, CA   (02.04.10)
Finally there is a minister in the government that has a spine and speaks his mind. Of course - Golan will stay as a part of Israel. And of course - if there is a war - Damascus could be leveled faster that Assad will blink. To all of you who never visited Golan - make a point of going there while in Israel. Beautiful place. It's a joy to see Syria somewhere down below... An on a clear day you can see Damascus indeed..
14. Israel provoking Syria
Robert ,   Brisbane, Australia   (02.04.10)
"The Syrian minister was responding to remarks made by Defense Minister Ehud Barak earlier this week. Speaking at a forum of senior IDF commanders, Barak said a full-blown war with Syria was possible in case a peace agreement is not reached". So Israel is allowed to provoke but don't provoke Israel. Huh. Seems to be an Israeli malady that.
15. #7 #10 #12
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (02.04.10)
The Golan is part of Israel and always has been. The British illegally transferred the Golan to the French in Syria. So you can't return your own property to a thief who stole it just because he wants it. The best you can say is that some Israelis want to surrender the Golan to a tin-pot dictator who illegally occupies Lebanon and murders it leaders because they think Israel doesn't need water and Jews don't need land to live.
16. what did he do wrong?
larry   (02.04.10)
Lieberman did NOT do anything wrong! The world can spew hate against Israel but that is ok? iT IS TIME FOR OUR BUMBLING LIBERAL POLITICIANS TO LEAFN THAT WE CANNOT IGNORE THREATS & SAY IT LIKE IT IS! WE HAVE TO BE DIPLOMATIC BUT NOT WITH THOSE WHO WANT TO ANNIHILATE US. LEARN FROM HISTORY!!!!!!!
17. what if all neighboring countries attacked us !!!!?????
Idont know ,   may   (02.04.10)
lebanon war and gaza war showed that our army is no longer capable of winning wars. so we have to be more carefulllllllll if palestinians revolt, hizbullah attacked, syria attacked, jordan attack, egypt attacked ......what would we do Mr minister????? be realistic and wake up
18. Mr. Cabel, may I remind you, that Israel there is no peace
israeli   (02.04.10)
with syria, only a ceasefire.
19. # 8 nothing else would work
Egyptian   (02.04.10)
In 1967 Israel launched the war and attacked Egypt ( our air planes were grounded) we on our happy day 6 of October 1973, got our land back. Syria will have to do the same if it wants its land back. You know that very well.
20. To #8 Eitan, #12 Vered and #13 Arthur
George ,   Antwerp   (02.04.10)
Thank you for all the truthfull words. Actually speaking about conquered land, there's some land in the West Bank that should also be annexated... Israel should not give back any land to its neighbours. In English it means: spoils of war.Israel had to fight for that after having being attacked in so many wars. We actually deserve it.
21. to#17 may
Marcelo ,   Frankfurt   (02.04.10)
simple, we go back to the '48 where syria, egypt, jordan and other arabs countries attacked Israel. Hizballah and Hammas weren't actually wars. If there should be a new war against hammas and hizballah, I wouldn't expect so much care about syrian/lebanese civileans as Israel did....arabs "think", with a war they would be able to get the proud they have ALWAYS lost....
22. TO 21
to 21 ,   j   (02.04.10)
whats your defition to war? almost 2 millions of our state were targeted by hizbullah missiles, we couldnt move an inch in the north (south lebanon) we lost the war admitt it, the arabs in 48 is different now they know our capabilities but technology alone wont work!!! as we lack the committment and the true devotion, hizbullah and hamas members will and desire to be killed in the sake of their cause but we.....i doubt it
23. THE FM IS RIGHT !!!.
Arn. ,   SWEDEN.   (02.04.10)
Meretz chairman: Remove Lieberman from Foreign Ministry Published: 02.04.10, 12:56 / Israel News Meretz Chairman Chaim Oron called on the prime minister to reassign Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman following his harsh statements regarding Syria. "So long as Lieberman serves as foreign minister the prime minister's talk of peace is null and void," Oron said. (Attila Somfalvi) MK Cabel: PM must stop warmonger Lieberman Published: 02.04.10, 11:29 / Israel News Knesset Member Eitan Cabel (Labor) commented on the statements made by Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman regarding Syria and said that the prime minister must "stop this warmonger." He further noted, "It is impossible to have such a senseless man who does not appreciate the importance of peace with Syria and the danger of entering into war with it, in such a sensitive post." MK Talab El-Sana (United Arab List-Ta'al) said that Lieberman is "a dangerous blabbermouth who may drag the region into an unnecessary war. The prime minister must restrain him and if he is unable, than fire him." (Attila Somfalvi and Sharon Roffe-Ofir) WHAT KIND OF JERK ARE THOSE ???. THE FM IS NOT THE ONE WHO DECIDES, BUT THE GOVERNMENT . NATIONS DO NOT GO TO WAR, BECAUSE OF SO CALLED BLABBERMOUTHS. ARE THOSE CRITIZISING THE FM TOTALY BLIND TO THE INTENTIONS OF THE SOUROUNDING ENEMIES OF ISRAEL ???. Arn.
24. Libermam spoke the "arab language".
ROSENVALD ,   brasil   (02.04.10)
Is just this language them understend.
25. Lieberman is right, they lost that land in a war they waged
Potash Katiftof ,   Tzfat, Israel   (02.04.10)
While syria doesn't have to like it, they certainly understand that they lost that land in a war. They've given up other terrortory to other contries they've lost to, so they have to give it up for Israel too.
26. to sami the political system is very good give me a break !!
dovdevan ,   ashdod ,israel   (02.04.10)
the etnic puzzle in your country is a real mess this is what caused the civilian war ! for syria i advice them to stay very far from the conflict if it thinks iran will come to her aid in case of an israeli attack
27. Crimes
Majinder ,   UK   (02.04.10)
Israel is the last to talk about crime! Isreal is killing children and women since its creation. Issues with isrea is not political any more, israel preventing basic human rights and needs. Isreal created after stealing other people land. And still stealing the resources of the Palestinians. Isreal has the right to exist of course but not on other people land and by killing people and steasl thei homes The world is changing and the leaders of the war crimes in israel will be taken international courts soon
28. I LOVE LIEBERMAN!
Gershon ,   London UK   (02.04.10)
Avigdor - if you are reading this I can't tell you how much pleasure your plain, proud and fearless talking gives me - and I think millions of proud Jews in Israel & the world over. Finally, we have an honest, non-duplicitous top diplomat who knows how to put Israel's pathological (and pathetic) enemies in thier place. And to all the cringing and winging lefties, liberals etc, -wake up and smell the coffee! This is precisely how King David dealt with the scorning Goliath - he showed him he was unafraid of his threats he verbally owned him before cutting off his big fat head. (to be sure - David invoked (through his faith) Hashem's name to beat the Philistines. If , Mr Lieberman you did that - well to my mind you would become literally unasailable!)
29. gutless
alexi   (02.04.10)
Its okay for syira to threaten israeli cities and israelis are supposed to bow down and be quiet hoping syria doesn't do it. Instead rpoperly saying to syria if you try it, your regime will collapse, livni resorts to olmertism, hide, don't say it, it hurts, down't answer, gas chamber jewish mentality....maybe god will stop it. It is sickening, this weak kneed jewish response. Lieberman didn't war mong, he answered like a n ormal person. Livni is gutless as is the whole kadima and they are worthless to israel.
30. #2 Eitan, Qatzrin, Palestine
Marco ,   Spain   (02.04.10)
Eitan, the foreign minister of Syria was responding to threats issued by Barak. Even Livni had to scold Barak for his stupidity. In any case Eitan, 'could have, should have, would have does not constitute a war crime. Killing the children of Kana does! Why were you not barking Eitan, when Lieberman threatened to bomb the Aswan dam in Egypt, thereby drowning hundreds of thousands of innocent Egyptian villagers in the process?
Next talkbacks
Back to article