News
Soldier killed in West Bank knife attack
Efrat Weiss
Published: 10.02.10, 17:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
99 Talkbacks for this article
1. Its his fault
Mike Van Harris ,   Antwerp Belgium   (02.10.10)
He should not be there from the first place. simply get out of there.
2. Why hide the attacked Israeli was a soldier??
m   (02.10.10)
3. Jewish residents of Palestine called "Israeli", but...
Nour ,   Palestine   (02.10.10)
Palestinian Arab residents of "Judea and Samaria" are not given Israeli citizenship. Naked Apartheid before your eyes! Just as I write this the BBC is interviewing Dr. Mustafa Barghouti the great Palestinian civil activist about this intolerable situation in Palestine... As we march further towards ONE state solution. Amen.
4. to #1 mike
Yitzchak ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (02.10.10)
Hey, Mike, I have a better solution. Let's remove all the Arabs from Israel and ship them off to the real Palesinean homeland of Jordan; and then the Jews who live in the Jewish Homeland will not be stabbed by "foreigners" who don't belong there in the first place.
5. We Need To Put Up More Checkpoints
Yishai Kohen ,   YeShA, Israel   (02.10.10)
And check each and every Arab passing thoroughly. If that inconveniences them, then tough luck.
6. #1 & # 4
Tel Aviv ,   Tel Aviv   (02.10.10)
Why dont we just send them all to Belgium where Mike lives and see how he likes living with them.
7. to #1 mmm so you tell people not to
ghostq   (02.10.10)
sit in their cars during traffic jams, I reckon in Belgium there r no traffic jams and people just teleport themselves, and if the do use a car they probably standing and not sitting. to belgium it's logical considering your country symbol. :P
8. to #3 actually it's your fault cause you don't want to
ghostq   (02.10.10)
be called Israelis, so stop complaining, if you did want to you probably did long time ago before the first intefada, arabs were called Israelis. all matter of choises, and since you refuse it it's not aparhide cause you got the mukata aka your own leaders. and Barguoti is mass murderer he planned sucide bombings that is y he is in jail for killing people on busses you know thee kind that return from work who got children elder people. those kind of people.
9. Kol ha'kavod
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.10.10)
Yossi Margalit! G-d bless you.
10. To #1 Do you have the same attitude to...
Truth Hertz ,   UK   (02.10.10)
Islamic settlers in Belgium (If that's really where you are from) or just to Jews who are in their national historical homeland?
11. How come terrorist jewish settlers are never caught?
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (02.10.10)
How come when a terrorist settler shoots and kill palestinians they ar enever caught?
12. What has P.M.and E.Barak have to say ?
Roland Seener ,   London England   (02.10.10)
13. #3 Nour, in Palestine, shows flawed logic!
Negev Girl ,   Israel   (02.10.10)
#3 Nour in Palestine: According to your reasoning, then the Palestinian Authority should give citizenship to ALL of the the Israeli Arabs (ooops, I mean Palestinians, as you say). That is almost a million and a half people, habibi, not counting all of the illegal Arabs from other countries that sneak into Israel every day for work BECAUSE IT IS SO BAD HERE! Yes, they are taking such good care of you guys in "Palestine" that is why Israeli Arabs are running to get Palestinian citizenship (NOT!)
14. B"H - Kol Hakavod Yossi, G-d bless you!
Ariel Ben Yochanan ,   Kfar Tapuah, Efraim,   (02.10.10)
15. attack
mohson   (02.10.10)
All the haaretz hype about peace comes down to this: a knife attack into the chest of an israeli in judea who was doing nobody any harm. All the spin in the world will not change this equation. Concession of land will not stop this terror. The only thing one can do is to manage it and reopen the balfour mandate for discussion of the land of jordan which was arbitrarily stolen by the Brits and given to the Jordanians. Arabs should leave the west bank and joon their kin in jordan. As for Gaza, UN should negotiate with egypt to take administrative control of gaza. Going back 3000 years, arabs and israelis do not get along, and contrary to history , have different traits. One looks westward, progressive, open, trades and educations and revers life. the other looks east, is regressive, closed minded, and revers death in cult like devotion. Arabs fight worse amongst themselves. Separation is required. Forget about any close 2-state arrangements. Educaiton programs have to be beamed to arabs that they stole original israeli land and that has to beam 24/7. Arabs do not want a state. They simply want to destroy Israel.
16. MORE CHECKPOINTS NEEDED
Yakov   (02.10.10)
The arabs have proved they never miss an oppurtunity to murder. Build dozens more roadblocks and settlements to deter this terrorism.
17. They will pay for it...!!!
Anat ,   Haderah, Israel   (02.10.10)
18. To: No. 3
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.10.10)
Exactly what is it you want, Nour? You could have had your own country in 1947. You rejected that, and chose to go to war instead. You lost. Twice since, a two-state solution has been offered, and rejected – including one which would have allowed you to claim East Jerusalem as your capital. There have been six wars, all of which were initiated by the Arabs and in all of which Israel emerged victorious. There have been over sixty years of unrelenting terror, not only against innocent Israeli civilians but against Jews throughout the Diaspora. You do not want peace. It is not so much a matter of what you SAY you want, but rather how you ACT. Peaceful people do not engage in war. Peaceful people do not engage in terror. For that matter, let us look at the charters of the various Palestinian organizations. Each of these charters call for the destruction of the State of Israel and the extermination and/or expulsion of the Jews. Is that your idea of peaceful? A good place to PROVE your peaceful intent would be to repudiate those charters and to acknowledge the right of the State of Israel to exist in its ancient homeland. Have you done that? No. That leads most people to understand that you are not interested in peaceful co-existence, nor are you interested in being good citizens of the State of Israel. You are correct in one regard -- yes, there will be one State of Israel, and it will include Judea and Samaria. Alas, Nour, you will not be a part of that state. Israel cannot and will not tolerate a violent and aggressive fifth column. Palestinians on the West Bank will have to leave. I know that you’ve been kicked out of Jordan, kicked out of Lebanon, kicked out of Tunisia, kicked out of Kuwait and kicked out of most of the Emirates. See what violence has brought you? Absolutely nothing but grief, yet you have not learned. We’ve had more than enough of your violence and hatred. Time for you to take it elsewhere. We care not where you go, chica. The farther away the better. Tick tock.
19. WHO IS RESPONSIBLE:(
Salma ,   Palestine   (02.10.10)
Every human being Israeli or Palestinian to die was because of the Zionist movement, we were living in peace and security, and we were simple people looking for a living and raising our children, untill the Zionist project came, which succeeded only in creating hatred in the hearts of human beings
20. #8 Marwan Bargouti is not Mustafa Barghouti
Nour ,   Palestine   (02.10.10)
Run a simple search. In any case, Marwan Barghouti is our freedom fighter and we're very proud of him. Your dungeons will never break his spirit. He's our Mandela.
21. Tresspassers: KEEP OUT, venture in at your own peril
Wael ,   Ramallah   (02.10.10)
Palestine is Arab, and does not belong to settlers from Russia, Poland, and Queens. GET OUT!!!!!!!
22. to #4 and #5
Gavriela ,   usa, usa   (02.10.10)
Amen! Too bad the terrorist's injuries weren't more than very mild.
23. two things
alexi   (02.10.10)
I have told you judeans and samarians is that you have to have your own defense and not rely on the idf. Carry your guns ready and deal with out suspected terrorists. US applies tons o fpressure for concessions going back to rogers of nixon's cabinet. Nothing has changed. IDF cannot babysit. Every israeli should have martial arts training and carry weapons to be ready. Enough already. Second, livni has revealed her true colors. it wasn't that she was led by olmert who all know is a wimp. She is a wimp. She says don't give golan tax breaks because we don't want to upset assad. I cannot change her. She is afraid. So how is she supposed to negotiate if she is afraid. It's one thing if you say, look we will give the golan eventually, so tax breaks are wishful thinking. Instead she says the situation is hot and we do not want to upset assad. How does israel get such people into politics. She is afraid and is a wimp. Its not about talking tough because talk is cheap. Its about steeling your nerves and staying strong. We all do not want war but fight we will for the right to be here. You tell golanis tax breaks and that's it. No she is a wimp, she is afraid, that is who she is and I don't condemn her. She should take a course in martial arts. I have never seen such weaklings as olmert and livni, unbelieveable that 2 of us could be so scared and weak.
24. #3 you wont stay here for long
ronen   (02.10.10)
do yourself a favor and buy a house somewhere in jordan
25. to #20 he still planned sucide bombings against
ghostq   (02.10.10)
elder civilians and people who waited for the buss, spirit of murder you worship, it shows, Nelson mandela never killed nobody his rebelation was by peacful way, he was the one to declare stop using weapons, and he got his lebaration from not shooting, however Bargouti murdered so many Israeli civilians he actually payed and designed the bombs(plural) on the busses a killer is a killer, he didn't protest he killed people, once you kill 70 year old people or mothers or grand mothers on the buses than stoping is hard. that is the truth. you glory mass murderer and that how people around the worl know him by the total innocent Israelis he kill, now if you will open dictionary the definition of terrorist is buls eye.
26. BHO & J Street Should Take Credit
Yishai ,   Israel & USA   (02.10.10)
This murder is a direct result of the pressure applied by B. Hussein Obama and those who support him such as J Street. All Arabs west of the Jordan River should be sent to Jordan (which is 80% "Palestinian"), or Belgium!
27. # 18
Birdi ,   Israel   (02.10.10)
INSHALLAH Sarah B.
28. # 21
Birdi ,   Israel   (02.10.10)
Wael, there is no country called Palestine. Deal with it.
29. # 8
Birdi ,   Israel   (02.10.10)
Mandela NEVER killed anyone so do us a favour & dont compare him to the killer called Marwan Barghouti.
30. to #19 zionist movment stop her activity
ghostq   (02.10.10)
when Israel was established by UN law that was legislated in 1948, you created the hatred, people can love or hate by self choice, just because someone hate me like you do it doesn't mean I hate you, I just think you r lake of different perspective, Jews live in Israel for many years and along they years sadly the people who conquer Israel documented that, in the Golan for example there is synagouge from the second temple era, or in much later years there is synagouge from the 17th century in jerusalem, Yavne Talmud Gmara ware also terms of jewish presence in Israel, sad to say that zion is a mountain in Jerusalem, it also mention in the old and new testaments, much like Muslim got special place and that is Mecca, Jews and chritians got Jerusalem, jews Got only Jerusalem and the place exist in almost every prayer, zionism is the love of Israel, people who chose to love the place and not to hate. so jews returned home from long years of exil, back to their home land a place they got history culture wise and religious wise.
Next talkbacks
Back to article