News
Former British MP Tonge: Probe claims of IDF organ theft in Haiti
Ynet
Published: 12.02.10, 09:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
100 Talkbacks for this article
61. Good because some people are heartless
Josh   (02.12.10)
I want a hatian heart to give to a would be suicide bomber killer of children. Something needs to be done about such heartlessness. After this we should call an investigation about the supposed earthquake macine, area 54 and the lock ness monster's contribution to the co2 polution (LOL). The idea of an investigation is not to counter unreputable lies but to take a prima facia case to the next level. Show some evidence first. Otherwise, drop in...just take a walk down the street and when you get to the bridge, drop in. Maybe I could sell the bridge first.
62. it's China
roly ,   miami beach, USA   (02.12.10)
just like in grade school rubber & glue... this goes way way way back to the Mongol invasions in the middle ages when the blood libels began. The communist rags are the biggest promoters of this deceit.
63. new stage of warfare
StevieT ,   USA   (02.12.10)
The big lie is back and is the current weapon of choice against Israel. This powerful crescendo is getting close to a critical mass. Realizing this trend and beginning a suave but strong counter campaign is essential to the fight for the 'hearts and minds" of the free world. I fear that the current coalition is not up to answering this kind of challenge. Assuming they can actually recognize the power of the new strategy in the first place.
64. This woman is one sick person
Mairi Tognin ,   Glasgow Scotland   (02.12.10)
I apologise for the behavior of this rabid female. Many in Britain are embaressed by her behaviour. The fact that she was made a Baroness is even more unsettling. I like many am grateful for the help given by Israel in Haiti but Tonge and the BBC are it is not taken for granted...........
65. Marco is no Spaniard; he just posts from
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (02.12.10)
Spain. He once posted that he was from "al-Andaluz" (the Arabic title) as opposed to "Andalusia". Marco is just another mideastern Moslem emigrant to western Europe without respect for the country he resides in.
66. Why?
Noor ,   Coral Springs, USA   (02.12.10)
Why should these allegations be labeled as "perverse to the extreme?" Israel has already admitted to harvesting Palestinian organs. It did so in the 1990s without family permission. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/dec/21/israeli-pathologists-harvested-organs This is appauling to the highest degree. No anti-semitism of the sort, either.
67. Matty is a Victim of Fraud
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (02.12.10)
If you are an avid follower of Matty like I am, you would know that the post no. 55 was not Matty's at all as the style of writing and the content are unlike his many fine previous postings. There is a possibility that you, too, are the victim of fraud (impostor). It has been occurring. I have written to the editors about this phenomenon and have received a reply. Assuming you have written your post in good faith, I hope you, too, contact the Ynet editors as the problem is becoming serious. Causing a brouhaha is one of the intents of the impostor.
68. Thank goodness that the Gazan "Palestine Telegraph" keeps a
AlexB ,   Toronto, Canada   (02.12.10)
a watchful eye. Nice going there, by the way, usurping a respectable newspaper name. Claims like these just makes one go on a rampage... :(
69. EVERY NEWS MEDIA , EVERY VIDEO CAMERA WAS RECORDING
..........DACON9   (02.12.10)
EVERY NEWS MEDIA , EVERY VIDEO CAMERA WAS RECORDING EVERY MINUTE DETAIL OF THE ISRAELIS AND ANYONE WHO OFFERED ASSISTANCE... its so strange that not one authority or other agency or any media recorded such things as organs stealing harvesting... OR ITS NOT STRANGE BECAUSE IT NEVER HAPPENED... NOT FROM A VICTIM NOT VIDEOED GOING ON A PLANE AND NOT VIDEOD GETTING OFF THE PLANE AND NOT VIDEOD BEING IN A HOSPITAL SUPER RUSH MORE FRAUD FROM JEW HATERS if anything, those that believe that Israel stole organs and those that repeat the lie... do infact need a brain transplant... there are some available from the local zoo
70. #46 SO YOU ARE FOR JEWS IF THEY DONT LIVE ON THEIR LAND.
.......DACON9   (02.12.10)
PIERRE..THERE WAS A TIME WHEN YOUR COUNTRY WAS VERY VERY INVITING TO JEWS.. you may be a lost jew.. you shoud be careful you might be insulting your great grandparents and they may have moved BACK TO ISRAEL YA DUMMY IF IT WASNT FOR ISRAEL YOU WOULD NOT HAVE A CELL PHONE CAMERA PHONE OR A COMPUTER AND MAYNOT BE ALIVE DUE TO THE DRUGS INVENTED AND CHEAPER GENERIC DRUGS.... YOU SHOULD BOW DOWN TO EVERY JEW YOU SEE BEING THANKFUL TO THEIR DISCOVERIES....
71. So now "damning evidence" is just a personal accusation?
William ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
So any nut apparently can go on to YouTube, make an outlandish accusation on anybody, and suddenly it's "damning evidence"?? Notice that the publication that first picked up the story per this video tirade was a "Palestinian" one, which hasn't even proven it's own false claims of organ theft. This "angry black man" is just looking for a scapegoat as "revolutionaries" do. He is no different than Malcolm X or Reverand White, who seemingly forget that while their Arab friends are busy persecuting blacks and making them second class workers, Jews/Israel rushed to the aid of many, most notably in Haiti, and Jewish Americans marched with Blacks demanding equal rights.
72. #65 Please enlighten us; how to show respect for the country
observer   (02.12.10)
by killing Gaza civilians or snatching Haitian organs?
73. SHE IS WELL KNOWN...
Maurice ,   Clichy, France   (02.12.10)
for ranting and raving against the "Jewish lobby". What is surprising is her praise of the Israeli Team...and the request is weird...does she ACTUALLY believe the slander ? Pathological hatred of people who do not yet see their enemy, Islam, is settling in their land...
74. Jenny Tonge
Sagi   (02.12.10)
is a "nasty piece of work". I do not need to do any searching and googling. She was an MP and was thrown out of her party by the party chairman, arbitrarily, for making an an anti semitic statement to the House. She is worthy of being "probed", with a red hot poker, you know where.
75. #26 - But you were silent to Iran's opposition
William ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
"where there is smoke there is fire" The Opposition in Iran has consistently reported abuse, rapes, assassinations, and torture in addition to the real ambitions of the Iranian nuke program. But despite the constant reports coming from different Iranian perspectives, you blow them off as propaganda....but they have the proof to that effect and you have...a guy in a YouTube video and a "palestinian" family who later admitted they made no such accusation. Is this the "fire" you were referring to? I think I understand why Spain's socialist State is falling apart and taking the EU with it.
76. #32 - It's not that the Islamic disinformation is problem
William ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
it's that there are so many people willing to believe the lies in order to support their own hateful agenda. Arabs lie - that's what they do, but the real problem is the movement of the West towards narrow-minded hateful positions, away from the open-minded thrist for knowledge positions centuries ago.
77. #54 - No flexibility in Israel morality
William ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
It's rock solid. Help those who are in need, punish those who seek violence and terrorism against us. It's just that simple. Keep in mind - Haitians are more poor, more destitute, and more abused than the "palestinians", yet the world hardly sends them money and they not once attempting to use terrorism or victimization to gain concessions or hurt other people. They didn't invade Dominican Republic to claim it as their own, nor do they blow up Red Cross or UN vehicles. I think this tragedy has shown the world one thing - we've all been focused for too long on the "palestinians" when real problems facing real people exist all over the world, and they need our help now! But one thing is for sure - the morality of "palestinians" does not waver...it doesn't seem to exist from the beginning.
78. #59 - I'm famous!! I have my own imposter!
William ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
I've joined the big leagues, everyone! I have my own imposter. #59 took a post I made about Matty over 10 days ago, changed a few words and re-posted it. I'd like to thank all the little people who helped make this possible.....
79. #66 - except that you ignore that many Pals were the recipie
William ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
Noor, please. You and your ilk do have a habit of taking talking points out of context and adding your own twist in order to push false conclusions. Here are the facts which you (and the Guardian) have conveniently ingored: 1) The doctor who took these organs did so for humanitarian reasons only. He did so to save lives of Jews and arabs alike. He took from Arab and Jewish bodies alike. 2) Israeli Arabs and "palestinians" were major recipients of these organs. Does it matter that a Jewish doctor saved someone's life if the organ went from Arab to Arab? 3) The doctor acted completely outside Israeli medical rules and was punished hard for it. This shows such a thing is not legal nor tolerated in Israel. Because of such action, Israel is re-thinking their policies on organ donations to fill the need for transplants. Equally, Iran is re-looking at their policies on organ donations for the same reason - even paying families to donate from their deceased relative (how sick!!).
80. #72 - respect is earned, not a privilage
William ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
Observer - those Gazans killed were involved in terrorist activities against Israel. That makes them military targets, not innocent civilians - no matter what clothes they wear. Hamas admitted they fed the death numbers (and high civilian toll) to Goldstone for his report. Not exactly credible, not to mention that 3rd party investigators already showed less than 32% were really civilians, and not totally at the hand of the IDF - as Hamas booby trapped homes, placed powerful IEDs in residential areas, etc. and the Haitain organ theft claim? Prove it. Every reporter and media venue in the world descended on Haiti, and many were in the israeli camp. Nothing revealed.
81. the nasties among us remind
Ilana   (02.12.10)
me of a pack of hyenas running to a dead corpse only to discover it is adummy. To save their pride they still swallow it!
82. i praise this type of ridicoulous comments
Federico ,   Argentina   (02.12.10)
People who make this type of statements helps us big time, I really mean that. Ridiculous deomonizing such as this theory is only beneficial for us, thank you Mrs Tongue
83. :: #55,56,57, you and your friends stop impersonating others
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (02.12.10)
or maybe you want to harvest their cyber identity? because I am mad like hell that someone is doing what I have been doing for a long time I am a certified nutty Antisemite and my hatred for Israel and Jews in general is unlimited by anything you do or you don't do. Eat your heart out impostors! (the main impostor too)
84. #7 Arab doctors have yet to master organ transplantation
observer   (02.12.10)
maybe they will or will not join the ball, thereafter.
85. #2 are you really going to create a superman ?
observer   (02.12.10)
86. No good deed goes unpunished
jason white ,   afula,israel   (02.12.10)
We should have kept out of Haiti. Whatever we do, we are condemned.
87. "observer" #72:
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (02.12.10)
You're incoherent, illogical and irrational. Try to speak to the subject of the post.
88. Re: Post #67: "Matty is a victim of fraud".
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (02.12.10)
An impostor sent this in. It is not mine. I will remind Ynet forthwith that an impostor posted it. I suppose it is "Matty" himself as he quotes the body of a previous post but changes the heading and we all know that that is "Matty's" peculiar style, what he is best at, to cut and paste.
89. What Israel really did in Haiti
Cynthia ,   USA   (02.12.10)
Treated 1,111 patients, performed 317 surgeries, delivered 16 babies. Bravo to Israel! That said and out of curiosity, is there any truth to allegations about Jenny Tonge's molestation of circus camels in Australia as posted on Wikipedia?
90. #54
(02.12.10)
big difference here. gaza and hamas lobbed 13,000 missiles at israel killing many jews in the period of 8 years. HAITI NEVER BOMBARDED ISRAEL WITH 13,000 MISSILES, KILLING 500 CIVILIANS (NOT A SINGLE ISRAELI SOLDIER OR MILITARY BASE WAS DESTROYED) FOR 8 LONG YEARS. THEREFORE, YES, WE HELPED THEM AND NOT GAZA.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article