News
Palestinian tries to stab soldier
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 12.02.10, 17:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. Israeli Occupation Soldiers are occupation soldiers
Noor ,   Coral Springs, USA   (02.12.10)
Israeli occupation is a crime. Every Israeli soldier on internationally-recognized Palestinian territory is a criminal. It would be more than foolish to be blaming the Palestinians for rightfully going after their legitimate national aspirations. Their obstacles are the Israeli occupation of their lands and suppression of their basic rights and liberties. But they are determined to go after their aspirations and resist, by all means, Israeli terror as opposed to abandoning their cause and becoming an all-to-see item at a museum in the future. Free Palestine.
2. Kol-Hakavod.............
Asher ,   NY,USA   (02.12.10)
3. Appetite
Sagi   (02.12.10)
is regained after tasting the first morsel.
4. Tresspassers, KEEP OUT
Paula   (02.12.10)
Well, you don`t belong there, in the West Bank ( Soldiers/settlers). Then, there won`t be another time either. Palestinians aren`t allowed to be in Israel, so why are Israelis in the West Bank?
5. Thats how you handle terror. Jordan is Palestine is a bigger
Jae ,   Lynn US   (02.12.10)
way to handle terror. Every cent of Foreign aid to palestinians contingent on education on Jews' history in the land, education in tolerance for other religions and peoples and their non Islamic sovereignty, is an EVEN BIGGER WAY to handle terror. The latter is actually the biggest way to handle terror. Otherwise its Lebanon/Iraq/Arab countries all over again with Muslims kicking jews and Christians out
6. They can keep their "personal motives" to themselves
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (02.12.10)
Funny that when Palestinian attackers "are not acting out of ideology, but rather personal motives" they more often than not seem to target Jews and Israelis. Maybe there's something to that ideology after all.
7. "ima!, they kidnap and stab at ease" said the soldier
observer   (02.12.10)
"boy!, that's legitimate resistance" said the mother.
8. to #1
Ellen Minaker ,   Israel/USA   (02.12.10)
Palestinian national territory??? Would you like to explain when the free state of Palestine EVER existed. Also, how come when Jordan was in control of the West Bank is was Jordanian territory? Do you mean to infer that Jordan and Palestine are one and the same? If so I don't see Abudullah running to create a Palestinian state in HIS country. In fact I don't see any Arab country welcoming in ANY refugee who claims to be Palestinian. Do you think maybe there is a problem with the so called Palestinians. --Inquiring minds want to know?
9. NOT for PUBLICATION
Ellen ,   Israel/USA   (02.12.10)
I just sent a talkback and inadvertently the computer auto-filled my last name. If that could be deleted I would really appreciate it. Thank you.
10. #1 noor
dov ,   canada   (02.12.10)
perhaps u should make ur way back to help free occupied palestine instead of you occupying Coral Spring USA
11. Palestinian State needed
Paula   (02.12.10)
This attack is a continuation of the vicious violent cycle involving illegal colonists and Palestinians lured into violence to express desperately their plight following 20 years of useless negotiations. This is a wake up call. The illegal settlements must be evacuated and a Palestinian state established. 500,000+ colonists can`t live freely on the expense of the indigenous population deprived of all forms of human rights.
12. Well done!
Johnny ,   Stockholm Sweden   (02.12.10)
13. Good shot..All soldiers must be trained
Al   (02.12.10)
in close quarter shoot to kill procedure. The days of wounding an attacker should be over.
14. Illegal arab settlers should be removed
jason white ,   afula,israel   (02.12.10)
with force from our Jewish land. Hebron is a holy Jewish city that the moslims took over. That is all they do is take over other people's religious sites.
15. Fayyad said he was sorry.....
Cynthia ,   USA   (02.12.10)
Until the next opportunity to commit a terror attack.
16. See Inglorious Bastards for Guidelines
Dav Lev ,   Burbank, CA   (02.12.10)
Hang em high. A Zionist right-wing US friend of mine says: convict Arab terrorists as appropriate of their crimes. When an attack, hang 10 of them in public, for all to see, rather than life terms. "Inglorious Bastards" may get an academy award. Many US Jews decry this movie as fantasy and absurd violence (Jews don't kill their enemies with bats). Hey fellow Jews, 500,000 Hungarian Jews were gassed, shot and otherwise killed in 6wks in Auschwitz. 3m Polish Jews were exterminated. 1.4m Jewish children were slaughtered (what did they ever do to Germany?). Barghouti is in a country club, while kuntar is in a terrorist group. Arab MKs go around the world, after demonizing Israel, with impunity. Goldstone wants to tie Israels IDF hand. The Russians knew how to deal with terrorists...Israel is afraid to bulldoze a terrorist's home for fear of PR, while some protest violently at the fence/weekly with little to worry about. ( 3 felonies in the USA and you get life, guys). Israel is the laughing stock of the world, and Fayyad is Fatah's clownish leader.
17. Given the Reverse, What Would They Do?
Dav Lev ,   Burbank. CAUSA   (02.12.10)
The problem is Israel's timid approach towards it's enemies, from Hamas to Hez, Syria to Iran, to Israeli-Arabs, to Fatah. I recommend every Jew see "Inglorious Bastards", the movie. It's a fantasy about Jews fighting back, and viciously., no mercy shown. But lets be honest, 6m Jews were slaughtered w/o mercy in 6yrs., many shot, gassed, hung/experimented on. The Arab goal since 1933, is to make Palestine Judenrein (get it, w/o Jews). They have not changed one iota. IF this guy had problems..why not kill one of his own? Israel has the might, but is reacting always. A 12.00 noose is all it needs..the Saudis and Sudanese flog their women..Israel gives out lollypops to it's enemies. Something has to change, and soon. Iran is out there threatening..some say, they are bluffing..some said Hitler was a clown.
18. Transfer all Palestinians to Jordan
Leon ,   Los Angeles, USA   (02.12.10)
There will be no peace until the last palestinian is gone. Israel belongs to the Jews. Palis - Get Out !!!
19. name the arab leader of palistine prior to 1948? A: there wa
me   (02.12.10)
name the arab leader of palistine prior to 1948? A: there was none
20. #19 - His name was Haj Amin Al Husseini
meir elazar   (02.12.10)
He met Hitler and was photographed with him. He supported the Nazi in the goal of exterminating the Jews. He set the policy which Hamas has incorporated about Destroying Israel and Murdering all Jews. While Husseini was the Grand Mufti, Palestine was a British mandate from 1917-1948 with the establishment of the State of Israel. Prior to that the Ottoman Empire ruled Palestine from 1517 to 1917. But formally, the Arabs never had a government in Palestine at any time during recorded history. They were largely nomads and squatters.
21. terroriet died
alan ,   texas   (02.12.10)
That's good. saved the Israeli public some shekels.
22. #1
alan ,   texas   (02.12.10)
There is no palestinian territory. Its ALL ISRAEL.!
23. # 19
Birdi ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
See folks, this is exactly what Israel is up against. The idiocy of people like Noor who are so full of hate. It is a crime to stab another human being, whether he is a soldier or a civilian. The same as its is a crime to kill another human being whether he is a soldier or a civilain. The greed for land has blindsighted you totally Noor.
24. # 4
Birdi ,   Israel   (02.12.10)
Paula, do us all a favour, go back to sleep.You dont know what you are talking about.
25. Lebanon
Lebanon ,   Lebanon   (02.12.10)
Lebanon,Lebanon..........
26. illogical
observer   (02.12.10)
they fire rockets on unseen soldiers, but attack clearly seen group of armed soldiers with knives. Soldiers fear not stabbing for they wear no bullet-proof, no stab-resistant vests, but are frightened of being kidnapped.
27. Paula and Noor
Eyal ,   USA   (02.13.10)
Your delusion of a state is going no where. Many leaders tried and failed again and again. You had your chance in 2000/2001 and 2003 with East Jerusalem as your capital, but I guess that wasn't good enough for you. Greedy greed will not get you anywhere. That's what you get when you change plans and wanting all of Israel. Now that we know what you want, your chances of getting even a small rock of the West Bank is just wishful thinking. You had your chance, it's too late and it's over, so get a life, start living it and shut your trap, cause again we know what you really want. Oh, by the way Nour, what happened? You told everyone you were living in Gaza? You lied to us again. I guess this is a Muslim thing ha? You never even stepped foot in Gaza didn't you? Too bad. hahaha hohohoho
28. # 26
Birdi ,   Israel   (02.13.10)
Wrong, they do wear bullet poof vests.
29. # 26
Israel Forever ,   Israel   (02.13.10)
I would love to know how you stab a bullet-proof vest?
30. Congrats
Yousef ,   Abu Dhabi - UAE   (02.13.10)
Congratulations, I hope you all feel better, You have one less Palestinian to worry about :S
Next talkbacks
Back to article