News
Foreign press slams new PR campaign
Tal Rabinovsky
Published: 26.02.10, 19:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
37 Talkbacks for this article
1. If they are in such an unfriendly atmosphere ...
EST ,   Miami USA   (02.26.10)
I suggest they set up camp in Egypt, Lybia, Lebanon, Iran, etc. rather than set their headqurters in Israel. They wouldn't dare as their reporting would be scrutinized and their lives would be in danger if their reports weren't a mouthpiece for the governing forces of those countries! They are idiots! lots of them "create" the news in Israel ... with the advance help and info. from their Palestinian friends...they fabricate the news for export purposes....
2. Many foreign journalists are naive or deceitful. Facts here.
Gilad ,   London UK   (02.26.10)
There is no doubt about it! Whether it's reporting France 2's false (proved false in court) Muhammad Al Dura story - which went on to be reported by reporters (including Israelis) worldwide and has become a symbol of the Palestinians, to the usage of false marches in what has been termed 'pallywood'. The stream of vids and pics we had in the early 2000s of "kids with stones against tanks", when those kids had gunmen behind them, or the usage of a blacked out Arafat compound (later Hamas meeting) when really electricity was flowing freely. We have PLENTY of reasons to think foreign journalists often either lie or mislead or are just ignorant. Then we can remember different journalists being 'professional' such as crying at a sick Arafat getting in to a chopper (BBC), falsely continuing to accuse Israel of a massacre in Jenin (Guardian), disproved by all including PA. We also have not forgotten about CNN being given grand tours by Hezbollah officials without any proof that the sites are true to the word of the Hezbollah official (not to mention edited photos in AP and reuters to make damage by Israeli strikes look worse than reality), or unverifiable reports by Al Jazeera about many events in the Gaza conflict. Then we move on to the worst, the purposeful liars. In the UK it's the independents reporter Fisk and Bowen, BBC mideast editor. Both outright mix opinion with (suspect) fact, avoid (or minimize) whereever possible the Israeli narrative and promote the Palestinian one at all costs, such as ONLY discussing the Naqba by Bowen when Israel turned 50. Do I really need to continue? We have so many reasons to doubt foreign journalists that it's unbelievable. Whether they are stupid, ignorant, lack understanding, are after ratings or other, the result is the same. The reporting is false, the opinion is meshed with facts, the facts themselves are often only rumors that cannot be verified and the images are often manipulated. The foreign press associations can complain and argue what they want, but their track record (as a group, not individually of course) is absolutely atrocious and deceitful. Satire or not those adverts depict the truth.
3. yss israil should make the foreign press angry
rashid ,   palistinian   (02.26.10)
because you know when they are angry believe me they report of a mascara in jenin that never was and thousands similar lies that the foreign press are experts in i am so glad the foreign press is working for us plistinians
4. Conny Mus does lack wisdom. Have seen his reports.
Ken Quinn ,   Amsterdam   (02.26.10)
5. #3 - Like being a loser?
Laurence ,   Tustin, USA   (02.26.10)
Until the Arabs accept Israel's right to exist, Arabs will continue to be on the losing side of history. So, #3, continue typing your infantile comments and throwing stones (or whatever it is you do) but remember, until you get right with your Israeli neighbors, you and your descendants will remain losers (much like your ancestors). Stop the cycle of self-destructive stupidity, if you can.
6. Truth is scary
Ellen ,   Israel/USA   (02.26.10)
The only thing the foreign press is scared of is that there may be less Israel's around to nod their head in agreement with their fabrications. Are they stupid?--NO!! Are they ignorant of the truth--most certainly! Israel, a tiny tiny country is loaded with all this foreign press working in what they consider to be inhospital circumstance. I don't see anyone holding them in Israel. They can publish lies from outside the country just as well. Only difference is being IN Israel adds credibility. Now, a new force is arising Don't like it--don't let the door hit you in the rear on your way out!
7. Its one thing to be ignorant, its quite another to attack ed
Jae ,   Lynn USA   (02.26.10)
education. The left is cooked. they even attack the education of Jews who know more about M & M than Moses. LEFTIST defense of Israeli's ignorance & losing hasbara war Its one thing to be ignorant, its quite another tyo attack education
8. complains, complains and more complains.
tiki ,   belgium   (02.26.10)
A man named Conny Mus, is like a woman called 'Johnboy. Can one take him serious? Of course not. Israel should learn NOT to take notice of all those Jew haters, because they will ALWAYS find some flaw.
9. Actually, the Israelis are being more than kind with the for
Ari ,   USA   (02.26.10)
They could state these facts: 1.)That the editors are the paid lackies of Arab interests and their anti-semitic OM's & CEO's. 2.) That Prince Alwaleed bin Talal of Saudi Arabia, who, finances terrorism, is buying up as much media, such as NewsCorp as he can. And, as in the case of MSNBC, Fox News, and others in the US and around the world, he can now influence the public: On his recent FOX purchase from Murdock, Prince Alwaleed said, “This is a qualitative leap not just for Rotana but for the whole Arab world.” Prince Alwaleed has publicly acknowledged that he has forced Fox News to edit its coverage he disliked. Conservative activists in the US have attacked the business partnership as “really dangerous for America.” Just think what he has in mind for Israel..... And, just as a side note, Prince Alwaleed owns a $4.3 billion dollar stake in Citigroup. Isn't it time to switch your credit cards to another company? 3.) That government controlled media outlets are bowing to the Arabs- just like Obama did ( ooopppps, I forgot, after all, he is a Moslem...), -for things like oil, and so that their own Moslem populations don't riot and destroy things in their own countries.....Jews have always made such nice scape-goats..... 4.) That their journalists are dishonest cowards, have no ethics, are too lazy to research the facts and history, and are often paid off by the arab interests. And, like the reporters at CNN, they are instructed not to run "certain items". So, to say they are stupid, and to ridicule these "professionals" is actually more than kind on Israel's part. It is an absolutely brilliant move. May Israel release many, many more of these ads. May the markets, world wide, be flooded with them!
10. #5 u don't understand great irony
Fan of Rashid ,   jewish   (02.26.10)
and sense of humor of rashid , palistinian. Think about and don't jump to conclusions too fast. Beleive me :-)) Rashid Rocks!
11. Over 80% of journalist are left and side with the underdog ,
redbourn ,   Tel Aviv   (02.26.10)
An internal poll of journalists last year showed over 80% to lean left and to always support the underdog which is pretty dumb. Why is it dumb? It's nice to stick up for the underdog, but you also need to ask why he's being beaten, which many journalists haven't often done.
12. #10 and #3 - Apologies
Laurence ,   Tustin, USA   (02.27.10)
I misread Rashid's comment and overlooked its obvious ironic tone. Still, I stand behind the substance of what I wrote which is that Israel's existence is a fact and fighting that fact is futile.
13. Rashid Ya Habibi - Ma Inta Mazbut
Ahmad Cohen ,   Ibn Mousa HaLevy   (02.27.10)
Rashid the Mascara, high heels, padded bras, and designer dresses was in Beit Hanoun non Jenin when the terrorist put on women's clothes to escape from the IDF seige around the mosque. Allah Hu Akhbar Wa'Mujadinhu Jemilaat (God is Great and his fighters are pretty)
14. Ignorant, yes; gulible, maybe; Antisemites, all the way
Jorge ,   Tegucigalpa   (02.27.10)
Foreign press, has a fixation on Israel, but not the right one, ignores that it is surrounded by mortal enemies, bent on destroying it as a Jewish homeland, receiving constant agression by all Muslim states, not just Arabs, Hammas, Hezbolah, Iran openly state they want to wipe Israel from the face of the earth, yet, that press is constantly branding Israel as an aggresor, 6 million Jews against more than a billion muslims, are foreing correspondents fair toward Israel, NO WAY.
15. Israel should be more honest in PR
Christopher ,   Boton, MASS   (02.27.10)
Instead of showing them as buffoons, they should what Reuters, the Telegraph, the BBC and the Guardian really are - Liars. The BBC paid 200000 British pounds to quash an internal report that proved it was biased against Jews; Reuters has repeatedly had to apologize when it was proved with great regularity that they doctored articles and photos to put Israel in a bad light; the Guardian makes no secret of its opposition to a Jewish State. Israel did not have to portray the FP as buffoons, they merely had to reiterate the proven obvious.
16. and why should we care about the largely hostile
soludo   (02.27.10)
foreign press? there is one little thing they forgot--this is OUR country, and we have every right to stand up to their distortions and outright lies.
17. my apologies
soludo   (02.27.10)
I forgot just how much ynet dwells on yellow sensationalism when posting my previous feedback. Just googled the Reuters article, and it's actually a pretty well written one, and by far more informative than this one.
18. Connie Mus
Hal ,   Usa   (02.27.10)
Like many journalists, Connjie is barking dog for the downtroddin no matter how loathsome or full of balony they are. Let's face it, they park in Israel cause, well, it's just better! No getting kidnapped or assaulted or worse.They know which side the bread is buttered on. Dog bites man is not news, Man bites dog is!
19. The Foreign Press
NYC Girl   (02.27.10)
First of all, there are more journalists in Israel than in virtually any place else in the world...except perhaps for Washington, D.C. Why is that? In part it's because it's a lot more enjoyable to sit and drink cocktails in a club in Tel Aviv, than to be stuck in some Middle Eastern hell hole, where you can't drink alcohol or have sex with a woman you aren't married to. But, unfortunately, for Israel, many of these reporters are more like proctologists...examining every nook and cranny of Israeli society, and it's highly doubtful that any country could withstand that sort of unrelenting scrutiny...especially when most of these reporters come to the job with an ideology that says that Israel's most vicious enemies are always the victims...regardless of whatever savage crimes they carry out against innocent Israelis.
20. :: Sudan will welcome them with open arms to go to Darfur
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (02.27.10)
21. :: Foreign journalists don't like it and complain? Tough!
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (02.27.10)
They give Israel the finger when it complains about their sloppy reporting. Now it is payback time and journalists prove to have a very thin skin.
22. :: Israel hosts the 2nd largest foreign media corps in world
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (02.27.10)
after USA. Do they expect to be tolerated without criticism?
23. #11.."REPORTERS " , UNDERDOGS, ..VERSUS TRUTH ..
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (02.27.10)
THE ARAB PALS ARE SEEN AS UNDERDOGS COMPARED TO THE ISRAELI ARMY FOR EXAMPLE. LOOK HOW THE MEDIA SHOWS A LITTLE ARAB KID STARING AT A BIG ISRAELI TANK AND THIS PICTURE TELLS A STORY THAT THE JOURLALISTS WANT TO PORTRAY. AN ELDERLY ARAB PAL MAN WALKING WITH A CANE BESIDE A GROUP OF ARMED ISRAELI SOLDIERS.. THIS PICTURE IS MEANT TO TELL A STORY BUT THE STORIES THE MEDIA IS TELLING IS NOT REALLY THE TRUTH. THE FOREIGN MEDIA CREATES AND PERPETUATES CONFLICTS, BECAUSE WITHOUT THEIR " MANIPULATION OF PHOTO-OPS, STAGED EVENTS " THEY WOULD NOT GET A GOOD STORY AND A GOOD PAYCHEQUE. THE FOREIGN MEDIA ARE VERY NUMEROUS IN ISRAEL, WHY ? IS ISRAEL HOSTILE TO THEM, SO WHY DON'T THEY GET OUT. THE TRUTH IS THAT THESE FOREIGN, " JOURNALISTS " WANT THE EASY " GOOD GUY, BAD GUY " STORY AND THEN THEY CAN GO BACK TO THEIR NICE ISRAELI HOTEL, HAVE A FEW DRINKS AND LIVE TO TELL THE NEXT " STORY ". CONTRASTED TO OTHER COUNTRIES WHERE THE JOURNALISTS ARE REALLY INTIMIDATED OR KIDNAPPED, ISRAEL IS " HEAVEN " FOR THESE COMPLAINING CHILDISH SO-CALLED JOURNALISTS. THEY ARE NOT PROFESSIONAL AT ALL. THEY CREATE STORIES THAT WILL SELL, THEY ARE SALESMEN OR "ORDER TAKERS ". THEY KNOW WHAT TYPE OF STORY THEIR EDITOR WANTS SO THEY GO ABOUT SKEWING ALL THE INFORMATION, OR DIS-INFORMATION INCLUDING PHOTOS AND ALWAYS COMES OUT AS BLATANT ANTI-ISRAEL " INFORMATION ". CONFLICT SELLS AND THEY KNOW THIS. AND IT GETS THEM THEIR PAYCHEQUES. I HAVE SEEN THIS TYPE OF SHODDY REPORTING FOR MANY YEARS NOW AGAINST ISRAEL.... IT IS NOT ANYTHING NEW !!
24. REPORTERS FLAUNT THEIR IGNORANCE & THEIR ANTI-ISRAEL BIAS..
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (02.27.10)
IF THE REPORTERS ARE COMING OUT WITH STORIES THAT MAKE THEM SEEM IGNORANT, THEN THEY SHOULD SMARTEN UP AND DO A BETTER JOB. FOR BEGINNERS, TELLING THE TRUTH MIGHT CONVINCE SOME PEOPLE THAT YOU ARE NOT IGNORANT OR STUPID OR BIASED. BUT TELLING THE REAL STORY, THE TRUTH THAT IS, DOES NOT MAKE FOR GOOD " COPY " AND IS NOT FINANCIALLY REWARDING. THEIR GLARING OMMISSIONS OF RELEVANT INFORMATION, THEIR HASTE TO BLAME ISRAEL BEFORE INVESTIGATING FULLY ETC. AND THEY CALL THEMSELVES " JOURNALISTS" ??.......... REALLY ?
25. Conny Mus, Dutch foreign correspondent
Goede Gouda ,   KaaskopCity   (02.27.10)
The Dutch lack any sense of humor. During World War II, Americans soldiers were instructed not to tell jokes to the Dutch as "they wouldn't appreciate it".
26. Gilad @ 2 :
MairiT ,   Glasgow   (02.27.10)
Absolutely spot on!
27. Probably ineffective, unless....
Hunt S. Cross ,   England   (02.27.10)
there is a sustained campaign to refute deceitful journalists' lies and expose their lack of balance. Deal with the negatives first.
28. Israel should not react defensively!
Ron B. ,   Lod   (02.27.10)
When interviewed on the international media, its spokesmen answer questions as if talking to their domestic media, instead of taking a pro-active, aggressive approach . They should see their job as educational, putting the facts out. Why don't we react to distortions of facts? Why don’t we denounce false and vulgar propaganda? Why don't we tell them simple basic truths such as that the Jews are the only ones who ever had a nation-state here, and that in 1920 the world recognized our national rights to this land, and that 800,000 Jews were expelled from Arab countries, etc. The answer is that Israel, believing it has no choice but to accept the world's position, allows itself to be boxed into a corner. We should defend our unquestionable, elementary, legitimate rights and tell the truth as presented at : http://xrl.us/berwte
29. Methinks they doth protest too much
Bernard Ross ,   st anns bay, jamaica   (02.27.10)
If the foreign journalists are not stupid then they are corrupt.
30. Members of the foreign press: When you obsess describing all
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (02.27.10)
the negative things about Israel and only the negative things about it - as if other countries don't have the same negative elements and as if Israel is only loaded with negative aspects, you make caricatures of yourselves, and caricatures as you know also sell well. Israel's government has chosen to emphasize the caricatures in which you star. Start dealing with Israel as you would with any tiny country - Israel's size is that of Wales, Slovenia, New Jersey with only 5.5. million Jews and no natural resources of which to speak, as you well know!! - and you will cease being the subject of laughter.
Next talkbacks
Back to article