News
Case of Palestinian girl's death reopened
Aviad Glickman
Published: 29.03.10, 00:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
23 Talkbacks for this article
1. Umm, let's get this clear
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.29.10)
The border guards were Druze, right? So it was not Jewish on Arab violence, but rather Arab on Arab violence, correct? Nothing we haven't seen before. Just checking.
2. #1, border gurad is "Isreal Border Guard", isn't it?
Umm   (03.29.10)
So your analysis does not add up.
3. Sarah B , U.S.A, The so called Druze soldier
Bassem ,   Westbank   (03.29.10)
represents the occupation Army and its violent policies toward the Palestinians. So gee, which planet you live on!!!!????
4. Let our children live. :(
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.29.10)
their small bones could not bear the burden of life, death,and oppression that every Palestinian child here grows up with. I wonder where is the enlightened world?!!!
5. if palestinians had done this to a jewish child
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (03.29.10)
there would be celebrating, rank promotion and naming city squares after the killers. there's your qualitative difference between israel and barbarian palestinians. yes, give 'em their own state!
6. No. 4 Salma
NYC Girl   (03.29.10)
Everyone should let every child live. However, you and your people might want to start by not encouraging your children to become shaheeds and blowing themselves to Kingdom Come. In fact, your leaders should have set an example after that stomach-turning comment by Suha Arafat that if she had a son, she would have been proud if he became a "martyr." Apparently, she forgot that there are also female suicide bombers, so it looks as if she wasn't even willing to put her money where her mouth is. But, regardless of that, any mother encouraging the death of a child is about as depraved an act as human beings are capable of.
7. Shooting of Abir
Alice Krieger ,   Tel Aviv   (03.29.10)
this picture (I am on the right) was actually outside the court last year. I was so shocked by what happened that I went to Jslm to show support for the family. Had this been a Jewish Israeli girl shot by an Arab, there would probably be lynchings in the streets. May it be a Chug Sameach for all. Maybe after the Chug the P.M. can throw out Ishai and Lieberman, bring in Kadima an make some progress towards a Peace Agreement
8. To: No. 2
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.29.10)
Go to school and learn how to spell. It's "Israel." You're a fine one to worry about my analysis .....
9. @ Sarah B
Smith ,   TA, Israel   (03.29.10)
That's a pretty chilling comment you made initially. A girl was murdered. Does it matter who the perpetrators were? Are you so blinded by "love" of Israel you can not see injustice? I am Israeli. We don't need obsessive and crazy lovers like you. We need people who will tell us when we are wrong and prevent us from jumping off the cliff. And, you're a racist. You probably also think the same thing about African-American's..... "It was black on black crime, right? So no biggie"
10. Let our children live as well!
Ilana   (03.29.10)
11. To: No. 9
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.29.10)
Wrong, on all counts. Stupid comment, you made, actually, and certainly not worthy of a response. Chag Pesach sameach.
12. Sarah B. Most Jews are Arabs.
Scott Dearful ,   London UK   (03.29.10)
maybe you forgot that.
13. To: No. 9
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.29.10)
My dear you have a lot to learn, this wasn’t a little girl that was killed this was a budding terrorist that was dispatched. If you know anything about religious law you would know that this is quite permissible. Rabbis Shapira and Elitzur clearly states that children may harmed. “Hindrances—babies are found many times in this situation. They block the way to rescue by their presence and do so completely by force. Nevertheless, they may be killed because their presence aids murder. There is justification for killing babies if it is clear that they will grow up to harm us, and in such a situation they may be harmed deliberately, and not only during combat with adults.” “In religious law, we have found that non-Jews are generally suspected of shedding Jewish blood, and in war, this suspicion becomes a great deal stronger. One must consider killing even babies, who have not violated the seven Noahide laws, because of the future danger that will be caused if they are allowed to grow up to be as wicked as their parents.”
14. To: No. 12
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.29.10)
Ye gods and small fish. You are really not the sharpest knife in the drawer, are you? The fact that we are Jewish is what distinguishes us from the Arabs --- and anyone else, for that matter. Calling me an Arab is the second most insulting thing you could do. The first, of course, would be to accuse me of being British. I am Jewish, and the furthest thing from an Arab that is humanly possible. Please keep that in mind before you start tossing around stupid insults.
15. # 12
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.29.10)
You are WRONG. Jews are Jews & Araba are Arabs. There is no such thing as an Jewish Arab.
16. # 7
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.29.10)
Ms.Krrieger, you should know that Livni refuses to join the present government.
17. #1 Impersonation of SarahB
Cynthia ,   USA   (03.29.10)
That is not her post nor is it the talkback address she uses. Just an attempt to discredit a pro-Israel poster.
18. No. 7
NYC Girl   (03.29.10)
I'm absolutely appalled at your accusation that if an Arab shot a Jewish child, there would be lynchings in the streets. Let me recount just a few of the higher profile murders of Israeli children...after which there weren't any goddamn lynchings. There was the deliberate murder of 2 year-old Shalhevet Paz by a Palestinian sniper, as her father stood by helplessly? Then there were the Israeli children who were slaughtered by a Palestinian savage as they sat in the car with their pregnant mother, who was also murdered? And what about the young victim of Samir Kuntar, whose head was bashed against a rock until her brains seeped out of her skull? The fact that you're blissfully unaware of any of these atrocities might make one wonder if you've been living in some sort of parallel universe...or if you only give a damn when Arab children are the victims.
19. #17 You sure?
zionist forever   (03.29.10)
Sounds like a typical Sarah B hate-rant to me...
20. # 17
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.29.10)
Cynthia, the address of # 1 is the way Sarah B .ends her posts with as I was the one some months ago to suggest she change it from Savyon/New York. as not many here know where Savyon is. I am not saying this is or is not her post.
21. # 18
Birdi ,   Israel   (03.29.10)
Accurate & good post NYC Girl.
22. TO #1
SAM ,   USA   (03.29.10)
The soldiers were ISRAELI soldiers. Not PA cops, Hamas cops. This has nothign to do with religoin. They killed on behalf of the Israeli government.
23. Sarah (#1) - not all border police are Druze
Rick Berman ,   Karkur, Israel   (03.29.10)
Just so you know... and like you've been told, it does not matter. It is the responsibility of the state of Israel.
Back to article