News
Report: Goldstone banned from grandson's bar-mitzvah
Aviel Magnezi
Published: 15.04.10, 14:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
81 Talkbacks for this article
31. What about Axelrod and Rahm Emmanuel ?
ariel ,   Toronto Canada   (04.15.10)
Good way to fight quislings - KHEREM.
32. #26
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (04.15.10)
Read the article carefully, it has nothing with "different view". Goldstone was paid to knowingly publish a false report to defame Israel. He knew that nothing he wrote had anything to do with reality, but a man has to make a living. He probably did not expect it to be such a "success" as to constitute incitement to genocide of the Jews. The Jews of SA even suffered attacks and abuse thanks to him. Next you will be surprised that Mandela never invited Eugene Terreblanche to tea because of a "different view".
33. Goldstone's spineless, but this is sad: private ceremony pls
Serge ,   Montreal, Canada   (04.15.10)
Let's be clear: Goldstone is a spineless, ambitious man who is only too pleased to conform his thinking to that of the bien-pensant London class to which he aspires. That said, I am very saddened by this. A grandfather should always be able to attend his grandson's bar mitzvah, and a grandson should always be able to have his grandfather there. Judge Goldstone is a millstone around the family's neck, but he is their millstone. The family ought to switch the bar mitzvah away from their synagogue to a small, private affair so that the family can be accommodated. Let them then celebrate separately with the community in whose eye the grandfather, to the family's great regret, has spit.
34. #3-Why would Jews want to live in NYC?
Joey Rose ,   Portland   (04.15.10)
Easily the most prominent target of Islamic nuclear terrorism.
35. Rahm Emmanuel the snake planning Bar Mitzvah at the Kotel
Joshua ,   Tel Aviv   (04.15.10)
I think he should reconsider, because that would make for one hell of a scene... Too bad we'll have to ruin his son's bar mitzvah, aval ma leasot? So be ready Israel, this summer, coming to the Kotel near you -- Rahm Emmanuel, the horse whisperer in Obama's ear telling him to break Israel's will to honor his leftist parents...
36. Serge #33 I agree
David Lev ,   Shilo Israel   (04.15.10)
37. Find him a bed next to Ariel Sharon.
Yosef Levy ,   Tel Aviv   (04.15.10)
38. # 3 Proud SA Jew
Vanessa ,   SA   (04.15.10)
Let me me remind you Esther that you have just noted your ignorance to all by writing what you did. The majority of SA citizens are not carcasian and therefore they would definitley not be upset bt ET's passing. Neither would most Jews as he was a Nazi and white supremisist. South Africa is a wonderful country that has one of the best and most pro-Zionist Jews in the world. You shouldn't make comments about things you know nothing about.
39. To: Max at No. 30
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.15.10)
B'ezrat Ha'Shem.
40. To: Serge at No. 33
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (04.15.10)
I respectfully disagree. Judge Goldstone's report was an uneven, unbalanced package of lies that has damaged Israel considerably. Judge Goldstone was a force for good during the days of apartheid. I guess he missed being in the limelight and at the ramparts, so to speak, so he took the opportunity to become -- literally -- a household name by villifying Israel falsely. He is no Jew, and has no role to play in the bar mitzvah of his grandson. I gather the child's parents don't mind, either.
41. A Bnei Mitzvah is about the community
steve from raleigh   (04.15.10)
It's not a private party. The community has spoken. If they wanted their own private affair they should have arranged one.
42. #30 Spinoza
Yossef ,   Rehovot, Israel   (04.15.10)
Spinoza had been banned from his synagogue, not excommunicated or "excluded from our religion". We have no clergy or pope who can excommunicate, don't confuse with catholics. It was a local (regrettable) decision. To be jewish is more like a citizenship than to be member of a "religion" (from "religare" - "relier"). Jews are just members of the one and unique jewish nation, and Spinoza is/was still a member of this nation, as well as the unfortunate Goldstone.
43. Re:Why would Jews want to live in SA anyway?
Marc ,   Modiin, Israel   (04.15.10)
Esther, don't be naive! Have you been to South Africa? Have you seen thank G-d what a thriving Jewish community there is in South Africa, that 95% of Jews went to a pesach seder, that 90% fast on Yom Kippur, far more than the USA I would imagine. Don't say things about a country if you do not have the evidence to back it up. Those people who supported Eugene Terreblanche are such a small minority, most people in the country found him to be a racist and most of the country, yes including the Jewish population as well as the majority of white and black people support the current governement, so Esther please think before saying something!
44. COLLABORATOR
YISHAI ,   ISRAEL/USA   (04.15.10)
If Goldstone was an Arab he would be executed for collaborating with the enemy (see article in today's YNET)
45. #33
mark ,   ca   (04.15.10)
"...and the bar-mitzvah boy's family concluded that the judge will be banned from attending the event". How difficult to understand ths his family (goldstone's) don't want him there?
46. #26 -"they ban..."
tanya ,   tel aviv israel   (04.15.10)
You are totally ignorant! "they" can"t ban. Accoding to Jewish law, every jew can be buried in Israel, even Goldstone,even you (if proved)
47. How does Goldstone have time...
Paul ,   USA   (04.15.10)
to go to a Bar Mitzvah ? He's desperately needed on the world scene, to locate those "phantom" scud missles, that Syria is sending to Hezbollah !
48. South African Jews get it!
Steve Klein   (04.15.10)
49. to #26 You think that SA is in Israel?
jason white ,   afula,israel   (04.15.10)
Your reading comprehension is terrible. The traitor was banned from a South African synagogue in Africa. Israel is in Asia. Look at the map, if you do not believe me. If you can read that is.01
50. Freedom of religion
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (04.15.10)
According to the anti-semites and extreme leftists only applies to Jews that hate Israel. What about the members of the Sandton synagogue and their freedom of religion? Oh wait they don't any rights do they? Well guess what stupid they do too. They built and maintain that synagogue not Goldblather and the leftists.
51. Poor kid.
Susan ,   Kfar Saba   (04.15.10)
I feel sorry for the kid who has to suffer because of his stupid grandfather. However, this is what Goldstone should have expected. I would not sit in a shul with him and I am sure most Jews feel that way. He has put himself in herem.
52. ONLY THE GOD KNOWS IF HE IS THE MAN OF HIS WORDS.
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (04.15.10)
HE DID GOOD JOB FOR GAZA. BUT ! MAYBE IT IS A PLANNED DEEP TACTICAL WORK BY DEEP STATE OF ISRAEL ON BEHALF OF TODAYS ISRAELI POLITICS. I PREFER TO DOUBT ABOUT HIS WORK. BUT I LIKE TO THANK HIM IF HE IS AS SEEN. *** HE IS DEPORTED FROM THE PLACE ! NO PROBLEM. HE HAS SO BIG PLACES IN COUNTLESS HEARTS TODAY BECAUSE OF THE REPORT. *** :)
53. Let him investigate the 3300 white
Eric..... ,   Israel...........   (04.15.10)
farmers who were killed by blacks in SA.South Africa will be like the rest of Africa in the next 10 years.Goldstone take your UN and check it out.We in Israel are very unhappy with you.
54. Goldstone's conscience
jo moor   (04.15.10)
Oy vey! If you dont have a conscience, are you unconscious? or just plain dead to the truth?
55. Goldstone spineless #33
jo moor   (04.15.10)
He should stop shaving and wrap a cloth around his head and wear a long white cotton dress (but no high heels!)
56. South African Jews - thanks. I love you.
Vardina   (04.15.10)
57. Goldstone is a judge who chose silver instead of the truth
Eyal ,   USA   (04.15.10)
One day we will all know, when we question him about how he has 10 million dollars in his Swiss bank account?
58. Sandton Shul is one of our mainShuls. They are quite right.
Alan ,   SA   (04.15.10)
Let him know our Kehilla DONT want him near us!
59. Worse than catholics, these rabbis ...
berlonski ,   berlin   (04.15.10)
60. south african Jews are the best in the world!!!
david ,   cape town   (04.15.10)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article