Opinion
Goldstone, you’re welcome
Avraham Burg
Published: 21.04.10, 12:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
56 Talkbacks for this article
31. And hold hands singing Kumbaya
Alan ,   SA   (04.21.10)
32. I doubt in this
sam ,   colorado-USA   (04.21.10)
Judge Goldstone a fair and impartial man with all due respect, as a Jew does not mean that he is biased to Israel,do all the Jews in world side with Israel?no I doubt in this
33. NOT welcome
Leah ,   Israel   (04.21.10)
He is not welcome here in Israel just like he is not welcome at his grandson's Barmitvah. His grandson will grow up to resent him like all of us. Not just resent him but be disgusted by him.
34. Avraham Burg , Yossi Sarid II
Nora Tel Aviv   (04.21.10)
(End)
35. To #29 You mean like the "jews" of
jason white ,   afula,israel   (04.21.10)
today that collaborate with our enemies. Like burg, goldstone, falk, indyk, axelrod,kissenger, emmanuel and peres to name a few, plus n.g.o.s that receive money from enemies of Israel. Or j street that fight against our survival. Or kamm and blau. The hara-dim. These are enemy agents.
36. Goldstone welcome by Avraham Burg
Danny Schlesinger ,   canada   (04.21.10)
kol ha cavod ! this is the way Klal Yisroel operates as opposed to our enemies like Hamas and Hizbollah I liked the way Adon Burg argues this and his father would have been proud of what mensh his son turned out to be. ( probably did not agree with him but thats ok ) more of this attitude and we will not fall into the destruction trap
37. To #5 and #11
Dan ,   New York   (04.21.10)
Whether Burg is right or wrong, your magnanimous gesture of acceptance of Goldstone speaks volumes about how skewed the report was. As such, it's understandable how Israel and Jews feel about him.
38. #29, Clarification
Zachary ,   Baltimore, USA   (04.21.10)
I see your point, and possibly the rebellion of a united Jewish people could have succeeded. But Burg is complaining about Zealots who pursued the struggle against Rome, whereas you discuss collaborators who help the imperial enemy. It appears Burg is against the rebellion, not those who double-crossed Jews fighting for independence from Rome.
39. In principle, Burg is correct but
Robert Haymond ,   Canada/Israel   (04.21.10)
there are also limitations with respect to liberalized dialogue. For instance, we would invite Ahmadinehad to our table? Would we invite Simon Kuntar? At just what point does the liberal view of dialogue run its course? As for Goldstone, I think his grandson's congregation in South Africa has spoken regarding the limits of dialogue.
40. I PROMISE GOLDSTONE A WELCOME
MR. KUNG-FU ,   ISRAEL   (04.21.10)
He will not soon forget.
41. goldstone at bar mitzvah
meir samel ,   jerusalem Israel   (04.21.10)
mr. burg simply has nothing to write about. he says he would invite goldstone. So what? az mah? you cares.
42. I thought this dangerous cretin had moved to Paris for good
Nemesis   (04.21.10)
43. GOLDSTONE IS ABOUT AS WELCOME
TEL EM STRAIGHT ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (04.21.10)
As a fart in a spacesuit ,as a pork chop in a synagogue ,as a hole in a condom (Hashem forbid) ,as a turd in a bowl of chicken soup .Which part of PERSONA NON GRATA does Goldstone and Burg not understand?? (And Goldstone did it to himself ,by selling his own people and Israel down the river.)
44. judge of arpatheid
Freddy007 ,   Paris   (04.21.10)
From wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Goldstone As a judge on South Africa's Transvaal Supreme Court from 1980 until he was appointed judge of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in 1989, Goldstone enforced the draconian "emergency laws" of the Apartheid regime.[6][7] How such a guy could give lessons to anyone?
45. Mr. Bourg, I think that you have lost it long
Vardina   (04.22.10)
ago.
46. to 6 laura
nahla ,   ....   (04.22.10)
should move to ramalla .as fath and hamass is two faces of dhferent cultur lol..... i think this auther want to say something rather than different cultur , please tell it loudly but he is from the left use twisted point to be kept in their position in keneset or medis . so the differance is he is there and me is here . yes there is democracy in israil but sure it is tight one not free ..becouse there is always the jail or at least to be outside of israil .. why azmi bishara was outside if it is different culture it is square differance
47.  Abraham Burg says:Goldstone, you’re welcome
Yahli   (04.22.10)
Mr. Burg, I admire your way of thinking, but look in the backtalk comments, to find in which primitive and fanatic society you live.
48. To#46: You language is so poor that
Vardina   (04.22.10)
it is impossible to understand what you want to say. If your level is so low - better refreain from talkbacking.
49. #47: If one disagrees with you he is
Alexa   (04.22.10)
primitive. How convenient !
50. Burg...
Hertzel ,   Israel   (04.22.10)
I liked your father approche a little better than yours...this is not the jewish way you described, it is the Chrisian way of giving the other cheek to be slaped. Anyway, I hope your "Jewish" bretheren love will make this ass shed a tear or two for what he had done to Israel..but I dout it...
51. Birds of a feather
Yaron Shemtov ,   Ramat Gan Israel   (04.22.10)
Avraham Burg,The Guardian and it's posters, poster boy.Whenever these people want to smear Israel they quote Avraham Burg.He's very popular with them.They love him.
52. Burg should be ashamed of himself
Solly ,   Petach Tikva Israel   (04.22.10)
Burg's sainted father must be turning in his grave
53. barmy invite
Adi ,   Raanana   (04.22.10)
Thanks Burg for the invite, but I have another question, why didnt Goldstone himself invite his family to celebrate his grandsons barmy in the UK, or maybe he did and they chose not to, for whatever reason. Mazaltov to all concerned
54. Avram Burg is an traitor
Rosie   (04.22.10)
Burg should be banned from writing his BS in Ynet. His wonderful father must be turning in his grave.
55. ?????
Proud Israeli Jew ,   Israel   (04.23.10)
Where does Burg live nowadays anyway? Hope he's not back in Israel.
56. A perfect example of smug, delusional, liberal narcissism.
Scott ,   USA   (04.24.10)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article