News
US report: Iran's 1st priority is survival
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 21.04.10, 20:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
25 Talkbacks for this article
1. Query ?
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (04.21.10)
How many tanks, fighter aircraft and battleships does Iran have? And how about, do they have any submarines ?
2. US once again perpetuating false intelligence
Netanel ,   USA   (04.21.10)
Just like when they ignored Israel's warnings about Iran to pursue a pointless war in Iraq, the new US administration also wants to ignore the Iranian threat by spreading false intelligence downplaying Iran. As much as I detest the current Iranian administration, they are correct when they speak about the US being on the decline. Israel is a great and powerful nation, but it will go down with the US if it does not assert itself and its independence.
3. What planet are you living on?
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (04.21.10)
20 million soldiers???The Iranians are not just going to roll over and play dead. They fought with Iraq forever. Never underestimate your enemy. They will just keep installing roadside bombs and rocketing Israel for a decade or two. They already are doing so with their proxy states. Fighting Iran will be no cake walk for any country. Don't kid yourselves. You don't see Obama jumping into a war with them......He is a pacifist who doesn't want another long war. Obama has abandoned Israel. Israels nuclear arsenal is the only thing they can rely on now.
4. Is This a Joke?
Sherman ,   USA   (04.21.10)
Saddam's military was ineffective as well against the US, however the real dirty fighting didn't take place until American boots started to walk the beat in Iraqi cities and we eventually prevailed but the human and financial cost was staggering. We will be paying for the Iraq war for decades on. I don't believe Iran is next.
5. Large but inefficient...
Bernie ,   Brookly USA   (04.21.10)
and loud! Boy, them A-RABS love to boast about chopping the arms off attackers, erasing from history enemies. We saw how fierce the Iraqi "Mother-of-all" soldiers were. I am actually in awe of those Iranian Republican Guards, riding around masked on thier black motorcycles, hittin on civilians. Brave "men", as evidenced by thier mustaches (the men, that is). The clips we see of thier training on TV have them snaking down building clasping their dainty hands, and then, the ever-present "Ring of Fire!" that they hop thru...like Easter bunnies. Yeah, "inefficient" is not really the word.... Bernie
6. that's why american goverment is iaffraid of it
Mark Bernadiner ,   Pearland, USA   (04.21.10)
7. Bernie # 5: Iranians are not arabs
Rami of Nazareth ,   Israel   (04.21.10)
After reader your 1st sentence, it bocomes clear you don't know what u r talking about. Not only Iranians are not Arabs, historically Sunni Arabs and Shea' Iranians have been at odds and fought wars.
8. Bernie
Netanel ,   USA   (04.21.10)
You are confusing the Revolutionary Guard and the Basij. The Basij are little more than gangs under the control of the president. The Revolutionary Guard on the other hand are very well trained, and they answer directly to the Surpreme Religious Leader. There is no comparison between the two groups. One occupies itself beating down on helpless civilians, while the other is in fact a fighting machine. Are they good enough to defeated Israel or the US? We can only speculate. But the US is making a mistake trying to make them out to be weak. Especially if it were a ground invasion.
9. I always said Iran is puppet and don’t believe their bluffs
e.m.Jordan is Palest ,   S.F   (04.21.10)
And Russian is not that much stupid to mobilize those fanatic’s regime to nuclear bomb, yes it is true that the Russian building nuclear facilities for them but the Russian will not give any chance to Iranian to have nuclear bomb, but the Iranian army is enough strong to take over of the gulf nations .
10. No War
Yossef ,   Rehovot, Israel   (04.21.10)
I don't want any war with Iran, weak or strong, I don't care. I live in Israel, not in NYC. Who are these american playing with us like pawns in chess. You are not welcome here, in the middle-east. You are just good to jeopardize everything. Play in your sandbox and forget us.
11. #5 typical american stupidity....
Peter ,   Vienna-Austria   (04.21.10)
1- iranians are not arabs 2- the Vietnamese were even worse and were only armed with ak-47s and simple military hardware. But guess what,they kicked your A@# big time. 3- Wont be bad if you at least TRY to read a book or article about the middle east and get yourself educated. This way you wont be doing any harm to yourself and people around you. I know its hard,but you can at least try,right??
12. A report out of the lunatic asylum...
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.21.10)
Iran is a third grade military power, okay - but it needs no deterrence against any external foe, the mad mullahs are exclusively threatened from inside their terror state, they are threatened by the people of Iran and by nobody else...and so THEIR NUCLEAR PROGRAM IS ABSOLUTELY NO DETERRENCE, it is a means for the planned NUCLEAR HOLOCAUST...It must be taken out of their dirty hands BY FORCE !!! Stand not in the way Hussein Obama, You are already on Your way down...
13. #12 chris ROTTENmoser Cut the crap already.
Mark ,   Netherlands   (04.22.10)
There is going to be no war!!! PS: why don't you go live in israel when war breaks out??
14. Military strike against iran is foolish
Albert ,   US   (04.22.10)
No matter how strong presence the U.S. has they have to learn a lesson from previous two wars (Iraq & Afghanistan) Both the decisions were a utter failure of the U.S. Intelligence Buros, yes Iran is far weaker in military terms than the US but the amount of pain world would experience is simply beyond imagination. Those who favor war should think twice before going to war, neither you can exterminate Iran nor Iran can wipe out Israel from the globe but the consequential loss for the world community would be far greater. Please do keep sanctions working against them, one fine day they would knee down to the sanctions.
15. Contradictory US assesments of Iran by US administration
Joe ,   Canada   (04.22.10)
On several occasions high level US administration military & political leaders have brandished the potentially terrifying response of Iran to an attack on its nuclear production sites. Now we learn from an other branch of the administration that Iran is actually a paper tiger. Who are we to believe? It all looks like disinformation whose content is made to suit the current variations or vacillations of policy makers in Washington.
16. Barbara, don't worry, Iran is no threat, we say so...
Michael Hess ,   Charlotte, NC   (04.22.10)
...now that Israel has been informed that Iran is nothing but a paper tiger and only wants paper nukes as a deterrent, Bibi can get back to answering the United States on when Israel will be vacating the stolen land and making peace. You all wanted the US to deal with Iran. Now we have. They are no threat. get over it. Worry about the US Client State of Israel surviving without US largess. Make peace or find out. Time's up.
17. Whos Said Anything About A War
LeeVT ,   USA   (04.22.10)
The US has no interest in a war. But a strike or series of strikes against Iran is very possible. No nation building is required or boots on the ground. Air and Naval power will be sufficient for the task. If Iran chooses to attempt to strike back, it will give the US an excuse to deal a devasting blow on the Iranian Military.
18. I second #10. Here in Israel we don't seek no war.
Bat Zion ,   Centre, Israel   (04.22.10)
I still haven't figured what makes Iranians seek war with Israel (we don't even share a border), however we don't share their war ambitions. We have never attacked Iran, and never will. Can anyone explain their interest in us? Thank you.
19. #13- Oh, the mullahs have a friend in Holland..
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.22.10)
20. what a bunch of hooey. Iran will will keep coming
like the fish on ,   a hook, as they r   (04.22.10)
They may win a few battles but they will never win this war. The God of Israel has a trap laid for them and they have already fallen head long into it and there is no escape. Fear not those who can kill the flesh but fear Him who after he has killed you has the power to cast you into hell. Bring it on Iran, you have already lost...
21. Israel's 1st priority
Wespe ,   Canada   (04.22.10)
Israel and Iran are in a similar boat. Who's kidding who. If there weren't so many Jews in Congress, the US would have abandoned them long ago. Israel's strategic significance is on the decline. The war with extremist Islam is being lost due to Israel's inability make any concrete and public disclosures about its own future. The US is more insecure than it was prior to 911. I question if it wasn't a government lead set-up. Isn't bin Laden the target??? First it was Saddam, then the Taliban and now Iran. None of them flew planes into the WTC. The war just goes on.
22. We should better not rely on any report of
Vardina   (04.22.10)
this kind and defend our interests best we can.
23. Iran should not be spared : Time has come for action.
Ron B. ,   Lod   (04.22.10)
Iranian nuclearization remains an existential threat to Israel, it also remains authentically genocidal in the legal sense. It follows that Israel’s reliance upon its own nuclear strategy and nuclear deterrent will now necessarily expand. Israel shall soon have to make a long-postponed decision on preemption (anticipatory self-defense) against Iranian hard targets. If this decision should continue to be postponed, Israel will likely lose the chance to defend itself conventionally. More concerning the dangers of a nuclear Iran at : http://xrl.us/h8ydt
24. #11 To the ME expert
Cynthia ,   USA   (04.22.10)
Arabs were brought into Iran to beat-up the protesters. Can you explain why?
25. The Master and The slave
Eugene ,   US   (04.22.10)
Israel is the Master and US is the client. The Master says: Jump! and the US President says: How high?
Back to article