News
3D Hamas video shows Shalit in captivity as father ages
Ali Waked
Published: 25.04.10, 14:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
90 Talkbacks for this article
31. to #21 you gave the women and children speach
ghostq   (04.25.10)
and you added the dangons, you forgot dragons and the sleeping princese... where is my head that is Europene story, you try to top the 1001 arabian night stories, just to let you know Ali baba had 40 Arabian thieves. :)
32. Scary
Reb Mordechai ,   New York   (04.25.10)
I remember reading last week someone threatening Syria, to turn it back to the stone age. I think it is time to do it to Gaza.
33. Only one option
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (04.25.10)
Thanks to the failed Olmert/Barak regime, Israel has no military option to release Shalit. Now, Hamas has no motivation to release Shalit. The only way to release Shalit is to make Hamas appear to lose more then they gain by holding him. If Netanyahu were to start irrevocably annexing land in Judea and Samaria as an explicit response to Shalit's captivity, Hamas would release Shalit. Since Netanyahu refuses to annex land, the Hamas video will come true.
34. This is why I like HAMAS, true freedom fighter organization
Zionism is racism ,   America   (04.25.10)
35. # 21
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.25.10)
Collins English dictionary. "Honest" means, truthful & moral, open & sincere. All of which Hamas is most definately NOT. Before you imprison Israeli soldiers, you have to kidnapp them !! Threatening Israel wont work. The rest of your post is delusional as always.
36. # 18
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.25.10)
I call it utterly SICK.
37. #34-You seem like another crazy Muslim
Joe Dempsey ,   Portland, Or.   (04.25.10)
that endangers American society.
38. free shalit
here ,   gaza   (04.25.10)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wQbpt3wXgDs
39. Hamas, Listen to Naom Shalit
Yasir ,   MontrĂ©al, Canada   (04.25.10)
Instead of making videos.. maybe you should worry about providing food and security to the people in Gaza. That video was LAME.
40. May HAMAS leadership be cursed
ProphetS ,   USA   (04.25.10)
Calling all readers to call upon G_d's just curses on all HAMAS leadership, on their health, finances, mental state and their families. G_d has released such curses on Israel's enemies in the past and therefore I call on all people to curse HAMAS so that they may realize holding Shalit is going to be a greater liability than demanding their evil terrorists brothers from Israeli jails. There is a supernatural realm where real power comes from.
41. Hamas has no real intent to release Shalit
psalms83 ,   Selah   (04.25.10)
only to use him as a tool to needle and make fun of the israelis... if israel wants shalit it must take the risk and go get him...
42. DEAL: all prisoners from deal + declaration no more kidnappn
eporue ,   europe   (04.25.10)
IDEA: what if, all the prisoners from the mediator-deal are released and hamas signs a declaration, to not kidnapp any more soldiers, and if someone is hold somewhere, they will do everything to have him released without any payments(...), and also let israeli forces in to help with that. SO: all prisoners from the deal + barghouti + opening egyptian crossing --> plus hamas signs a statement that they refrain from future kidnapping and support israeli forces in case someone is supposed to be hold in gaza. its really difficult, when a country gets blackmailed with this. usually, they shouldnt agree.
43. Israels mistake
moti ,   rbs   (04.25.10)
was agreeing to a truce-- we shouldnt have stopped until gilad was handed to us on a silver platter, alive and healthy. i think the time is getting close that we go back in to get him
44. #27 Yeah like the whole Arab world being bird food
it is written....   (04.25.10)
45. American taxpayer
Christopher ,   Baltimore, Maryland   (04.25.10)
As an American taxpayer, after seeing this video, I am grateful that a portion of my hard work goes to support you guys. Please feel free to use this money to kill more Hamas terrorists. Do not EVER make a deal with these monsters. The US army never does.
46. Did you see the credits for video? It included Goldstone
Cynic ,   USA   (04.25.10)
47. unfortunate, that here is so much confusion why the deal
eporue ,   europe   (04.25.10)
failed in the end: it seems that, mediator + israel + hamas agreed on a deal. then NETANYAHU pulled out of it, refusing suddenly 5 prisoners to be released. hamas would still release gilad for this originally mediated deal. the prisoners are: pflp Secretary-General AHMAD SAADAT, head of Hamas' military wing in the West Bank IBRAHIM HAMED, one of the military wing's leaders in the West Bank ABDULLAH BARGHOUTI, one of the military wing's leaders in Gaza Hassan Salame, and Fatah activist AMNA MUNA.
48. WHEN ARE WE GOING TO REALIZE.....
SETTHERECORDSTRAIGHT   (04.25.10)
THAT THESE PEOPLE ARE A BUNCH OF EVIL BASTARDS? AND WHY IS YNET, AMONG OTHER ISRAELI MEDIA OUTLETS, GIVING THESE VERMIN A FORUM? SHAME ON THEM. TO NOAM SHALIT: ONLY OUR HEARTFELT PRAYERS, TEHILLIM AND LOVE WILL BRING BACK GILAD. AND G-D WILLING, ONE DAY SOON, THEY WILL. I AM AMAZED BY THE STRENGTH OF YOU AND YOUR WIFE. MAY YOU ONLY HEAR GOOD NEWS SOON. KEEP YOUR HEAD UP AND MAINTAIN THE PERSPECTIVE THAT YOU HAVE. WHAT YOU SAID IS TRUE: THIS IS ONLY PSYCHOLOGICAL WARFARE. DON'T LET THEM WIN. IF ALL ISRAELIS HAD YOUR STRENGTH, WHAT A COUNTRY THIS COULD BE. G-D BLESS THE SHALIT FAMILY AND KEEP THEM STRONG, BRING BACK GILAD AND GIVE THOSE ANIMALS WHAT THEY DESERVE. ONLY YOU KNOW WHAT THAT IS.
49. SALMA: I DON'T KNOW WHY I AM WASTING THIS POST ON YOU, BUT.
SETTHERECORDSTRAIGHT   (04.25.10)
...HOW COULD YOU COMPARE OUR GILAD SHALIT WITH YOUR SCUMMY 'PALESTINIAN' PRISONERS WHO HAVE JEWISH BLOOD ON THEIR HANDS?
50. Kahane Tzadak, Kahane Tzadak, Kahane Tzadak!
(04.25.10)
51. Thank you, Eddie - #17
(04.25.10)
52. Fulsome.
sunshine ,   Germany   (04.25.10)
Another proof of the lack of character among the Palestinians and espicially among the Hamas.
53. #5 look who's talking about blood on their hands
rachel ,   usa   (04.25.10)
a bunch of savages: http://www.youtube.com/watch#!v=JfEinAgwjlw&feature=related
54. # 47
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.25.10)
Eporue, dear, google all those names you provided in your post & see how much Jewish blood they have on their hands.Maybe then you will understand.
55. # 45
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.25.10)
Christopher, thanks. I wish we could kill more Hamas terrorists.
56. ABBAS..Has said.. NOTHING !..but..COULD !
Roland Seener ,   London England   (04.25.10)
57. Ynet, why?
Stella ,   Haifa   (04.25.10)
Why did you have to publish this video and offer a public stage for their shameless psychological warfare? Take your example from Channel 10 - they decided NOT to broadcast it Let's show the Hamas the cold shoulder they deserve and not give in to their cheap and ugly pressure. I'm sorry for the Shalit family whose son should have been at home a long, long time ago. Let's hope that there is a deal in the workings, and let's not disturb it by caving in to the Hamas psychologically.
58. Bring them to their knees...all of them !!
Poitcha ,   Kfar Saba, Israel   (04.25.10)
What a sick bunch of mother f........ Destroy them NOW !!!!!!!!!
59. time to change the game
tom ,   toronto, canada   (04.25.10)
gilad shalit will only be released when it is more urgent for hamas to release him than to continue holding him. such a time will come when israel turns up the media pressure about hamas' violation of the laws of war, and when israel begins a strategy of regular assasinations of hamas leaders, until the day he is released. until the rules of the game change, hamas will continue to bask in the media attention, and keep raising the "price", lest they look foolish in front of their followers.
60. does not care
sam ,   colorado   (04.25.10)
The video showed us that The Government of Israel does not care with their any Prisoners, as it say
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article