News
10 Israel Prize winners: Let Gazans study in West Bank
Yaheli Moran Zelikovich
Published: 28.04.10, 14:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. Let Gilad ...
Leon ,   Melbourne, Australia   (04.28.10)
study in Hebrew University of Jerusalem!!!! No way should students be allowed to study in WB. Universities are known breeding and recruiting grounds for terrorist organization
2. Intellectuals lacking 'saykhel'
Dov   (04.28.10)
3. Israeli intellectual=neurotic leftist.
Yosef Levy ,   Tel Aviv   (04.28.10)
4. Leon #1
Resistor   (04.28.10)
You are a lunatic and a traitor to Australia. Get out and make aliyoop to Israel where you belong and are accepted. Gazans have a right to study in the WB without your stereotyping, and racism. BDS
5. that would be required some decency from the israeli gov
ezra   (04.28.10)
waist of time with these racists
6. 1,2&3 YOU TOOK THE WORDS OUTTA
GAL1 ,   ISRAEL   (04.28.10)
MY MOUTH.
7. :: #1 - Leon - Gilad
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (04.28.10)
I am sure that at this stage Gilad has learnt fluent Arabic, knows the Koran back the front and has an in-depth knowledge of Palestinian culture and history. All of which didn't cost him a shekel.
8. Resistor #4
Eyal ,   USA   (04.28.10)
Gazans are the enemy dummy, just like Iran and just like Syria. What don't you get? Can an Israeli go study in Iran? Also, the enemy are holding Gilad Schalit hostage...Let me repeat hostage, not prisoner. Why should Israel do any favors to any of you fools? Israel uses racial profiling and your race needs a lot of racial profiling. The US is starting to use it too (1st state - Arizona) and soon will spread. Israel will be the laughing stock if they let any person from Gaza enter the WB through Israel. So you can go to hell with you dumb posts.
9. Common sense
Philip ,   Afula, Israel   (04.28.10)
I am not a professor, but I would have thought that students from Gaza should seek their higher education in ,for example,Egypt. Then there is Gilad Shalit and many other obvious reasons to keep these people as far away from us as possible.
10. Arab students-Stay in own cantons.
Sivan ,   Jerusalem   (04.28.10)
11. Are You Prepared for Student Homicide Bombers?
emanon ,   USA   (04.28.10)
12. AS AN AMERICAN ,I AM CONFUSED WHERE TO VISIT
....DACON9   (04.28.10)
SHOULD I ASK THE TOURSIT AGENCY THAT: I want to go to the west bank or to JUDEA AND SAMEREA SHOULD I ASK THE TAXI DRIVER THAT I WANT TO GO TO: east jerusalem OR to the CITY OF PEACE JERUSALEM SHOULD I WALK ANYWHERE IN THE LAND THAT MOSES PRAYED TO SEE AND GD TOLD KING DAVID TO CAPTURE? OR should i worry i will be captured and hung or totured by arabs living on GDS HOLY LAND FOR THE JEWS? SHOULD I BUY A HOUSE AND RETIRE ONE DAY? OR will israel gov't remove me to be nice to sarkosy,obama or the un? I READ TORAH AND THE HEBREW PROPHETS AND CANT WAIT TO WALK GDs LAND WHERE ABRAHAM YITZHAQ AND YAACOB ONCE STOOD, WHERE KING DAVID JOSHUA ONCE LED ISRAEL, WHERE THE FRUIT IS SWEETER AND LARGER THEN ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD to walk where GD PROMISED WILL BE THE ETERNAL HOLY JEWISH LAND if we serve 'HIM" the way "HE" commanded us AND YOU KNOW WHAT I GET THE MOMENT I LAND? hey american.. are you a zionist or a religios zionist are you a orthodox or a secular are you a JEW or a buddist or a muslim or a xtian hey america do you want to march in the gay parade with us or do you want any drugs hey america we have it all here just like sodom and gemorah what pleasure you want today american friend? ya know what i answer? I tell them.. I CAME SEEKING THE 'ONE GD OF ISRAEL'' WHERES THE SHUL? ASHKANAZ OR SEPHARDI AS LONG AS ITS A TORAH ORTHODOX SHUL? WHERES THE KOSHER RESTURANT? WHERES THIS RABBI? THE taxi driver tells me.... OH I DONT KNOW ANY OF THAT STUFF...THIS IS THE STATE OF ISRAEL, WE DONT HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH THAT BIBLE STUFF..YOU MUST WANT DISNEY LAND.
13. They can study in Gaza as well as in all 22 Arab countries,
Anat ,   Hadera, Israel   (04.28.10)
so let them study there.
14. Why should Israel do so. Build a univeristy in Gaza
JO   (04.28.10)
they can join up with West Bank groups and have their Gaza extension school. Gilad sits imprisoned and cheered up by Gazans. University education is not a right, indeed it is a luxury and many Israelis can not afford one. Gaza is an enemy entity of Israel, not a friend. And those saying racism should know that in Palestine, it will be a Jew free state, `Israel on the other hand has over one million Israeli Arab citizens included. Racism can be seen in Hamas's charter , religious and ethnic.
15. I figured there would be enough shmucks
The Berlin Wall ,   Washington DC   (04.28.10)
To start saying, "oh my, on me, let Gilad Shalit go first, and then we'll talk." Well, it's the Israel government that is holding up the exchange, not the Palestinians. The Palestinians want thousands of their men, women and children released from Israeli prisons, most held with no other charge than resisting occupation. Shailit, on the other had, is a prisoner of war, a man who went to Gaza with the intent to kill. We're sick of hearing your whining self-serving comments while we pay your bills. As a jew, I'm disgusted with all of you. You do NOT speak for me and my family.
16. Barak The Great.....
Shalom ,   U.S.A.   (04.28.10)
Are jews allowed to live in palestian territories?
17. All due respect to these academics
Salma ,   Palestine   (04.28.10)
Since "Israel" declares Gaza "enemy entity, it denies Palestinians all of the democratic liberties it so proudly of, Including the right to education and freedom of movement and work etc This step of these brave academics give us hope
18. This is why Barak is not PM
Eyal ,   USA   (04.28.10)
19. STUDY
COLIM   (04.28.10)
tYPICAOL OF THIS LEFTEST yNET TO PRINT WHAT THE COWARDLY GROVELING WIMP bARAK REQUESTS. Barak hates jews,loves enemy arabs and from his talk has given away YEHUDA AND SHOMRON Gaza is a foreign state !!!Students can go to Egypt,Jordan.Saudi or Erope. Why do these terrorists want to be in Israel FUTURE ACTS OF TERROR ????? And the whimpering barak wants to help these killers banished from all arab countries.
20. #15 You're not smart enough to be a Jew
Janice Cohen ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (04.28.10)
21. Typically,
Noor ,   Palestine   (04.28.10)
the Palestinians who reside to blowing themselves up inside Israeli bakeries, buses, cafes, supermarkets, pizzerias, etc, are those Palestinians who were denied the basic rights and liberties that all people are legally entitled to, those Palestinians who have no means of healthy development due to limited income and below-average levels of education. Typically, those who blow themselves up are not affluent. They are not doctors, or lawyers, or engineers, or dentists... On the contrary, they are desperate individuals who occupy low-wage jobs or NO jobs at all. The higher the level of educational attainment, the higher the level of income. This is the case everywhere. I thought Israel's enemies were Hamas, Fatah,Islamic Jihad, the Al-Aqsa matrys. Not a bunch of hard-working Palestinians who seek to make the best out of their lives and who plan on feeding their families in the future. Denying a basic right like education is a crime. I assume Israel just prefers suicide bombers and Hamas fighters to educated individuals capable of transforming the Palestinian economy and the rest of its society for the benefit of all Palestinians.
22. Let them earn a degree in digging tunnels.
Shajan ,   India.   (04.28.10)
23. :: Let them study suicide bomber belt making in Gaza
Matty Groves aka BS ,   Fairport   (04.28.10)
They will end up doing this anyway after receiving "University" degrees. Matty Groves aka Michael Hess aka BS
24. LOL #21 Noor...are you so deluded.....
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (04.28.10)
.....that you honestly believe what you're posting??? We happen to know that your bombers are recruited by Mickey Mouse from a very tender age.....and made angry from inter-Arab aggression, which also starts at home
25. #21 do you really believe what you are posting?
israeli ,   israel   (04.28.10)
Yahie Ayash was educated alright. So were George Habash, and Abdel Aziz al-Rantizi.
26. Let those academics live in Sderot for a few years first
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (04.28.10)
27. To 15!!!!
doives   (04.28.10)
Gilat shalit was garding the border with Gaza! He wasn't going into Gaza. Terrorists crossed the border to Israel injured and killed fellow soldiers and kidnapped Gilat wounded. THEY CAME INTO ISRAEL! You obliviously have no idea what you're talking about. Galit didn't do anything, those arabs in the prisons on the other hand... most of them are in there for crimes for which every country would arrest people. And those ''children'' youre talking about are 16/17 year olds who can be as strong and as violent as any adult, if they act like adults, why not treat them like adults? No we don't speak for you, because you're one of those ignorant leftist people, who will always find something to blame Israel for, BUT ''you all love israel'' BULLSHIT, stay where you are and never come to Israel, we don't need people like you here.
28. #17 & #21 Mindless Liars
Hal ,   USA   (04.28.10)
There is a reason that you all have not gotten out of the ditch that your brother Arab countrymen of the 1948 war put you in. Your society such as it is was left to your it's devices as the Arab states that fought Israel literally moved on. 1967 and 1973 put 1948 far into your rear view mirror. Since then you have as a society been a group of waring gangs that pirated your future for personal benefit. Suha Arafat being maybe the most glaring example of where your society is. I never hear Erekat bemoaning the plundering of the welfare money that is your treasury, but I digress. Since 1948 as a people, you've been tossed around primarily by your Arab friends and even by your supposed leaders. What your society evolved into as a result is of your own making. All the money given by the world to you and the effort put forth by your leaders went into guerilla style commando bull shit tactics that only served to create a reality that worked against you, again, created by your leaders. So, you are now demanding from Israel that which your society for more than 60 years has never afforded you? You all cry for your rights, but never to your society or g-d forbid your leaders. Salma and Nour, you both know very well what would happen to either of you if you ever in public demanded you rights as human beings. Since you have in history never been an organised people gathered around a coheasive idea. This is a dilemma that is the result of asuming a false identity that doesn't suit you. Instead of calling yourselves Palestinians, go back to your roots that came from the very people that put you in the ditch you're in to begin with. Those countries surrounding Israel. Egypt, Lebanon, Syria,Yemen Iraq, Saudi Arabia and last but certainly not least Jordan. Since Jordan was and is the lion's share of the pre-1948 Palestine mandate and is ruled but an installed king from Arabia by the British ala the Pahlavi Peacock Throne in Iran, you can make a better case for a state that was denied you from the gang that got you in the dich in the first place. I guess you could call yourselves Jordanian as your brethren there do on a daily basis or not. That is your call, but your present strategy has been an abject failure on a massive scale. It is never too late to change course. Maybe a good start would be to begin demanding the fruits of a pluralistic society from your own leaders first before you make demands upon Israel. A house divided cannot stand. Get your house in order!!!!!!!!!!
29. they don't care about Schalit
bernard ross ,   st ans bay jamaica   (04.28.10)
30. Gazans should study in Gaza and Egypt, it being its mother
Omri ,   Kibbutz Reshafim   (04.29.10)
country, as was viewed by the United Nations Security Council and expressed in its resolution number 242.
Next talkbacks
Back to article