Opinion
Egypt isn’t our friend
Avi Trengo
Published: 07.05.10, 14:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
62 Talkbacks for this article
31. GAZA WONT LOSE.
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (05.07.10)
32. GAZA WILL WIN ! NO MATTER WHAT !
ATİLLA KARAGÖZOĞLU   (05.07.10)
33. To Marco number 21.
Peter ,   Uk   (05.07.10)
Every inch of Israel belongs to the Jewish people. In the bible it is stated that some land was payed in gold and silver. So get your facts right!
34. It's about time pressure was put on Egypt
Israel should stop ,   playing this game   (05.07.10)
Israel should announce that only Egypt and Hamas control Rafah! It would stop the incitement against Israel.
35. boo-freakin'-hoo
A passing Egyptian ,   Egypt   (05.08.10)
the author just realised how foreign relations work. "Cairo’s actions only based on Egyptian interests" lolwut?
36. Hahaha , thats sure dear :P
Samir Askar ,   Egypt - Cairo   (05.08.10)
Israel is the biggest enemy for EGYPT .. we will never be more than enemis . so go to hell lsrael
37. I am really Surprise
Mark ,   Los Angeles   (05.08.10)
First, when you can't solve a problem, do you give it to a friend! If you can't stand for gaza why do you wanna give it to egypt!! Solve your problem yourself!!! # 5) you should have kept WHAT? It's an Egyptian land. please rethink before you post anything!!!
38. :: Vardina and Jehudah
Matty Groves aka BS ,   Fairport   (05.08.10)
I am a woman of multiple personalities and when you think you debate with me you debate with Michael and vice versa. In the end it is all about my distaste of Jews and anything Jewish that drives my sick passion in life because I have no life. Matty Groves aka Michael Hess aka BS
39. The West planted & fabricated Israel? as friend in our area?
Araby Ibn Araby ,   Arab Land   (05.08.10)
40. egypt evaded its responsiblity of unpleasant gaza
eporue ,   europe   (05.08.10)
i agree with this.. and every option of a new pal-state is spoiled and doomed, as soon as gaza comes into play... egypt neglected this place and so it became what it is... they have to take it back. and its them, who have to bring gaza back to normality... its unfair, and also impossible, to expect israel, officially considered the "arch enemy" to do that. the egyptians get (in talkbacks etc) quite aggressive about their responsibility for gaza... maybe because they know, they will expect even more terrible fights than israel did... i honestly believe, gaza likes israel more than egypt... if people could choose, who to belong to - egypt or israel - what would they say ? when israel was inside gaza, they have done a lot to help gaza on its feet.. egypt never - in all its past ownership of gaza - did do so much (or anything at all) for them. maybe egypt isnt israels "friend", but between "friend" and "enemy" is a looong long way... you (all) often fall into those extreme views ? and further: your PM does everything, to not walk onto this way... (lieberman as FM...). err.. "friends": do you think austrians and germans are "friends" ? lol.
41. #36 - samir from egypt... have two questions...
eporue ,   europe   (05.08.10)
(1) can you please elaborate why israel is egypts biggest enemy... sorry, but other than religion i cant think of a reason... (2) who does hold ranks #2 and #3 of your biggest enemies ? tia
42. #36 samir... sorry (3): who is egypts best "friend" ?
eporue ,   europe   (05.08.10)
43. Egyptian government has no friends
Serge ,   Antwerp, Belgium   (05.08.10)
It is an Egyptian government policy to charge foreigners more for a visit at museums, temples and other tourist attractions.
44. to marco, nr. 21.
sjoerd van der velde ,   hoorn-the netherland   (05.08.10)
to marco, nr. 21, you are quite right. i reject zionism as well, as islam(ism). both mean racism, supression and exploitation and i am also against roman-catholisism, capitalism, neoliberalism, fascism, national-socialism. i prefer socialism.
45. #30
Yaron ,   USA   (05.08.10)
Did Vardina hit a soft spot blowhard? The reality is she is not far from the truth but it is not politically correct to say it in this backward world we live in. As for you and your ignorant and inflamatory remarks, the Haredim and "settlers" contribute much more than what your little mind can comprehend. The main difference however being that they are policed by the state when they mis-behave while the PA have all too often sat idly by as Israelis were being blown up on buses.....guess that never concerned your little mind did it?
46. #28 Vardina, for your good luck,
Salma ,   Palestine   (05.08.10)
I'm not good in "streets language skills " Which seems you've many of it ,only i can say to you try to think of things other than sex....you're sick
47. mubarak's phobias
tom ,   toronto, canada   (05.09.10)
mubarak's biggest fear is the moslem brotherhood (aka "hamas"), who murdered his predecessor, sadat. not an unreasonable fear, you might say. otherwise, regaining control of gaza would do little or nothing to egypt, since a few more hungry mouths would hardly be noticed, and gazans would have no more say in egyptian politics than the rest of egypt. but it would remove a thorn in israel's side, and a particular thorn invented and groomed by egypt. because the plo and yasser arafat were both invented by the egyptians, and served well to delegitimize israel. why a country supposedly at peace with israel needs to maintain a political weapon is the real question...
48. #41-eporue , europe
zezo ,   cairo- egypt   (05.09.10)
1- Israel is Egypt enemy because Israel occupying Arab land and the presence of Israel it self as a country interfere with Egypt Interests 2- rank 2 and 3 any other country support Israel 3-best friend Muslim and Arab people if Egypt take the right way finally it is a matter of time only your country will collapse and we just wait the chance and prepare the theater and remember that the Crusader occupation lasts in Palestine for more than 130 years and ended by the hand of Egyptian people and Egyptian army
49. #46 - salma
eporue ,   europe   (05.09.10)
ok, then lets assume the stork brings the babies to "palestine"... it doesnt change the point, one of your colleagues made about his "arab-demographics-plot" which wont work. or look at the haredim: why it works with them, but wont work for long anymore... tell me, why other rules apply on you ? interesting, that arafat said this with the "womb", and that this would be a solution... thats as stupid as he was...
50.  I think we can do the same
Egyptian ,   Egypt   (05.09.10)
I’m sure what is the objective of this article. Yes any government including the Israeli government has to look first for its own national interest. The writer ignores the facts that many Egyptians border guards have been killed on the borders and the number of guards on the border (limited number because of Camp David accord) cannot completely cut the smuggling under the border. Israel created all of this mess don’t blame us blame your government. Egypt now is under constant attack from Arabic media outlet because of the Gaza blockade. Also, regarding the other border, I don’t agree with our government stupid, inhuman and cruel policy of shooting African illegal immigrants on the border to stop them from crossing into Israel. When USA can stop Mexicans from crossing the border or smuggling drugs and weapons, I think we can do the same.
51. 47 Tom: I fully agree
Avi Trengo   (05.09.10)
52. To Egyptian Egypt #50
Avi Trengo   (05.09.10)
I think we are in agreement: Open up the Rafah border and end the Egyptian blockade on Gaza. Stop shooting African immigrants and instead give them UN refugee right - as Egypt should according to UNHCR regulations.
53. US-Mexico border: 4500 K'M. Egypt Gaza 12 K'M
to #50: look at map   (05.09.10)
54. to salma 10
salam ,   ramalla   (05.09.10)
in 72 i was there i had many egyption friends most of them said that egypt spend a lot for algeria then yemen then palastine i said no .. it was egypt fault as it liked to be the master of all but truly we remained friend becouse i do not like to be the master nor my friends like to be the master so we were friends all the time ... israil look to friend as if israil is the master .. it will not work with the arabs or with the americans .. salam salma
55. to 14
salam ,   rammalla   (05.09.10)
the fair is to return home with the help of arab
56. to vardinia 28
salam ,   ramalla   (05.09.10)
first i like your name but i do not know what it means ... do you think that israil will be existed forever by the money education and by immegration .... i know that israil was initiated by the three system but i do not think thede three is enough without the right of evry nation on this holy land
57. you too!!!!!!!!!!
esraa ,   cairo-egypt   (05.09.10)
i will tell you the summary of you article: israel was not our friend, and it is not our friend,so it will not be our friend forever. untill it leave palestinians and muslim and go back to our prophet Moses ten Commandments.
58. what a stupid article...
Jeff ,   Philadelphia   (05.10.10)
was it really supposed to be taken as some kind of a surprise that Egypt like all other countries bases its decisions on its national interests??.... what a stupid article...
59. To Jeff #58
Avi Trengo   (05.10.10)
Well thank you for the compliment. Of course it is not a surprise. Why do you think I wrote the article ? Because what is seem as obvious to the common folks is misunderstood by the leadership in DC and Jerusalem. Gaza is Egypt. In Arabic Masri is "Egyptian". The name of Hamas spoke person in Gaza is "al-Masri" (The Egyptian). Gaza has many Bedouin Hamulas that came from Egypt and Sinai. As soon as natural connection (broken in 1967) between Egypt and Gaza is re-established - we will move closer to Middle East peace.
60. to yousef
esraa ,   cairo-egypt   (05.10.10)
yes there are no friends of israel egypt is palestine faithful sister thank you
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article